← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9236/2019dismissed

Resham Singh v. The Financial Commissioner Punjab, Chandigarh

2019-04-05Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih9 pages

 

      

 !"!

#$% &'(!)*

"&+,!#-& 

& !## !) ++!""!

# (* .#/01

& ("



 2$ 342 5 , , 2,         

     , 2, *5   ! "  #$#%&#'( )*   +,- 

  .        

+

+/

.



0!!1!2

1%".   /  !  3 4!/  )/

- '5(6 )          7'5(6   7-        

  .

1,8     9  .!"!  !

   

 

            '$#8&#'$  )*   +8-

. 

  !/   !2

1&

!

.    

+

+ /

.  

    0!  !  1!    

 #8'&&#'$  )*   +6- 

  .    :   

 )  -   3  2  

  1'   

!       

.  & ;      

! 

     

+

+ /

. 

0!!1!                         #$#%&#'()* +,-.!   

"! " 

!    9      "!+

 . 

!

 !     <

     .     '$$&   

   ; 

    

   

3 !     = 1'#8'$ '55, 7!(+) 6!7"5, 

(8#1

& ("7  #%#(&#', =1555 '55% 72 &!#9 ( ,!#-&1

& ("7"5& !## !) ++!""!

# (:''

)";* .#/01

& ("7 #,#&&#'8"  

 "!+ ! ." 

 9   

!   

  '#'' <

  . '$$& 



 

!  !    

     % <       .

 !! #%#%'55%'#'#'555       4       .              *

!  

.  



     !   

.   *

 > !





 ! 

  

  

!      " "

!    , ;   



 . 

 "

  ! ! 

  8 0 .   /  !"   

! %' 4  ''  

4"1'%%41%,,? 1%#99%# 1)(+''-'#)$+#-'')$+#-&&)$+#-3  .  '55#+5'       !  9?!!  <     /  1"  3  9   '#

'5(6 "   . 

1,8 ! " " 

"  / !#%#%'55%  !4 '# / !2

1, "  *

 "" 

  / !.@  ; / !

 ! "0 !2

18 '#'#'555 ,4  '$####9+

 "  " "  *

 "  

  / !.@  6 ;

   *

! 

"

./ !!  

" "

 

.  A !)A / -0!! 1!""  

"

 .

=

 

" !./ !

 3 " .

    

 1,    8  !     0<       1'#69&#'6:!1&##'$9&#'%#('#&#'% !/  ! )  -  !.



! 

<  

 ! "  

! 

 ,')-    '5(% > 



.

  ! " "



*

3  .

. 

!!  

""   

.".  '%#8&##%)* +&-

  / ! "

! 

 ! #%#%&##%

 '#'#'555!! 

."

    

 . '()'-  <

  . '$$&"  

 .!   *

"! ./ !   .  "

 !!  





 ! ;  4! 

 

   (    9  "  .

1,  8          

+

+/

. 

    '# '5(6  !    "  

 ! .

/   !  "        

      !!  "

"  " 9

 ". .. .  * .

&#.  

"   

    . !

 <

  

.    

+

+ /

. 

   0!  ! 1!     #$#%&#'()* +,-!   ./ !" " 

  ! #%#%'55%'#'#'555 " .!

 

 

1,8"  .  



./ !  "   

.!

  



   

" 

 . 

" !3 

  *

! ! 

    

 3 ! &''&&#'6)* +%-:

  < +

+ 

  '

 @0!&'#8&#'8" "   !  "! > " "

"/ !/ !2

1,0 !2

18 "   

      

      "       

 

"   / !   

  ! /   ! 



. /

.  

+

+     

    0! !1! '$#8&#'$)* +8-"   

.:  

)  - 3 $ < . "  4.  

    " 

 "   

 

 >   

   

! 3 !

.     

   )

-

 .

3 !  

 "     

  5 ;    7    )

-    >   "    

/ "  

      <3 !"      "    .   ,+ 5,(0/!

<.(#94 "

&!#9 ("!# 9

"

9#9

& ("7"52 &!#9 (,!#-&1#

& ( &##$),-   )  -,8$"  ! 3 4! /  )/

- '5(6 " ""

  "  "  4       !!

      .  '56&  

 " " 

   """

.

  3    !!.  #''&&##$ ! 

% 

 '# '5(6     '#.  '# ;      

       )

-    "

.    

 

  " 

 . !    

     "  

4 ! 

  3 !   

  ! ."   '' <   

 

 "   .!

  "   . <  "  " "  3 ! " "     .

  ".     

"

 >   " 4      

.@    "   

    

 /  !" "!       



.'55# ! *  / !    "  #6#6'55#   !  . / ! #%#%'55% 4'# "/ !2

1,!

  ".!

'#'#'555 ,4 !"



0 !2

18"    

" 

'%#8&##%< "

 

"

    ! "

   

  " .

.'%#8&##%"  )* +&-" 

 

 ! .   '&   :   

  )  -   3  

!.   

      "     > 

."   " !"!   

"   !  "  

"  *

   

"    " .  

 

 3 !&''&&#'6)* +%- "           

    .  /   !  

 

  !      

      

    

.> 

 

*

 ! !"

     B> .

    .  . '% ; "   ! "

    

 : , 2,;

&'(!)*     &

& ("'

=!#->( "

# 9$  ">

&

& (

'

( 0) $  ">