High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5019/2003allowed

National Ins.Co.Ltd. v. Jai Singh

2017-12-11Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat14 pages

!"# #$%& '("$')$*+,'$! -(# .. ))'$( / ,*+* '"0"$12'$# ,* *.$# $(*

'("$')$*+,'$! -(# .. ))'$( / ,*+* 03('42('5',"'$# ,* *.$# $(*

03('42('5',"

.. ))'$( / ,*+* #2 '7'$# ,* *.$# $(*

'"0"$12 .. ))'$( / ,*+* #2 '7'$# ,* *.$# $(*

'7''$'$# .. ))'$( / ,*+* #2 '7'$# ,* *.$# $(* % 8-

0 0 9

, * $(%

!% &

% ! '

"! !"

% %

# % &

"! $ :::

0 9;

- ")'&"

"" !

! *

-" .&, # ! /0 12

' ' 3 .

&" ( 4 "

5 .(56 7 '" ""

"& ,! $ ! $ $! $

&"*

& &" 3 & " 8

& !

-" .&, + " " 2 9 )!

3"' '(8+ ' ' " ! /0 12 '3 : % '

" # ),% '

" " 8 )! 3" & 8 ;

, +,""< " !' 40)"

6 8 + ' ' " ! !9=19 2&

& " " + ' +, " > 0) " "

% ' 8)!3 3" ' 8! /0 128 " 8 ? & " /3 8+ ' ' " ! =9=19 2" 8' " " 8 / 3" & '

' ' 8 +

' " ! =9=19 24

' 6 - " # ),% '

8 ) ! ? / "3 3&

& & '

&" # ),% '

8+ ' ' " ! /0 12: % '

" 8 ) "

" & "

& '&" ) "

- &

+,)! "

" &, ( 8 ! /0 12 3" & " , " ) ! 3"

" 8 - & "

+,: % '

& # ),% '

-" .&, " 83"

& 3 '

' " & 3" "

' ' "

' @ + '' "" & "

" 3 "& "

-" .&, 8+ ' ' " ! /0 12

$ '

' " 8

& "

" &,

"&8 ' & ,+) "

& " +

" 3 3 "3

" 3

" &, -3" &

3" ' 7 " "" 3"+ '

&" " " , 3

" "& & ' 8

' ' &"

&"& "3 " -3"

' " "' " )! 3"

' 3" '

' " ' "

" "

+8"" + ,'

'+, + "

" ' +, * '+ "+'

'3" 8 + ' ' " ! /0 12 &)! " ' 8)"& "+ / + "+'

' + ,+3 3 "+,A

' ' " ' + , " '

' " &, 8+ ' ' " ! /0

12+ ' +,)! "

' " '+,

' "

;

' ' "

" &, ""+& "' , " ' ' ' ' + , '

' - " ""+& "" & ,+" & '

" "

3 " &" & 3"'

' %

" "+& "" "' +,

" " ' ,& "

" " ' + ,'

' " / "

"+& +, & " ' "+"" " " &,

' ""+& ' " ,+

+, (

- " " "+& "" + , '

' " ""

3+, -0 "+ ' " ' " "

' / ' " " ". "

" "+& "" &+, "

" &," "" ,+" & '

" "

3 "

" &,"& 3" , " + ,'

' - "& 8 " 8 ? & " 8

- "& 8 8"

" +" 3" "

, " + +, " &,

' 8 B

' 8 " + ?& +, " &, "" / "

" &, " '

' / "& "+ "' +, ' + ,'

" ' , & " "+,& " " "" +,, ' %*+,,&" ' +, * ' ' + ,'

' "

" &,*+"" ' +, ' ' + ,'

' """ '

" &, "+"

+ ,&8 ,&

& "3 " , + ,&8 ,& 3 & " ? " &,

' @ - -" .&, < "

" &, "+& " " 3 , " &+ 1 &" +, &

,+ "+ " &"

""+& "" " + " &,+ ,+8 &3 3"

" +,

" &,* , & %

+ ,

&, " + + -" .&,

' "

, &+ "

&, ? "" & "

,+ & ( & ' " &

-" ,"

+ +,

( + & ,+ &"

& -" &,

' 3 + "

6 - "

3 3& " # ),% '

3" & "3" 2, " ' ( "3 & 0"

11C 3 ' & ( " """" & " + 0"

"& "+ "

?""" "3"&

D ' 3 ' " & 1 3" =" " &

C3"' ?""

' ' "

" &"C

""+& & " "+ """" 3 " - " ""+& "" & " + "" ""3

"+& " ""

" 0"

C " " -" &,"+& "" " +& A %

" '

+ "" " / ' " " " '

3 + "" " ". " " 3 ""+, .(" "+& % " & " " "& "+8

=,,&"" "3"3 8 '" 8 +, & &&" 3 +' '

C ' '"3 "7 / & " "80"

C - &" )'& /5+ % & . &" " &" ? $A &

"" " / ' "" & "&"0"

C &

& " """""0 C &

" " " A "+ " )'&

/5+ % &. 0',)'< ,3' ,*/* )2",'$*.,(,.

$, =0/ &

, "" , &"&"0"

1C &

& 1 " , +

, "" , &3 +0"

1C41? ?16 =" " & 3 ?"" " " 3 " " " )'& /5+ % &. " ! -" 4" 6 &3 " "+ 0"

1C /3 """ 3 " , & " & & 0"

C "3 "

0" , & " "

&" 0"

21C ( " & " "& "3"3 +,

- 3 + 3 ""+, "

& +?7 "

66 - " & " ) : % '

+ ' ' " ! /0 12 - "" "+ ,* ) , "" * "+ +1A & ) " ""

& & "+80"

C (8 ' ""1A "" &

, & "+"""" 0"

C( & "+ ?"" "

+, 0"

C =" "&"

' "+3 0"

C ' ' " " "

"+& " """

3" +"

"" ) , "& + , *" " &" + "+ , & "+8"A

"+ , %

" "+& " &"""" +, 0"

C " 3 " ( "

"+& " & "+3 ""

& &

3 & =" " " "+& " &3 "

' " 3 " !& "+3 "" & " ""

?, ." ," & & "'

" " " " )'& /5+ % &. 6

" >'/"('<* .'4 ,* " " " &, ""+& &" " ,+

3 " "3

"" / ' " " " '

3 + "" " ". " " "" "+ , & " ' ' " ) , " &&83 ' " '"

) ,3 + "

/ "+ , & "+8

A =. " ,

' ,3 """"& & & ( "& " ,+""""+,

C &

& " " ,+ +, &" )'& /5+ % &. '

, &" +3 &

"" &3 +& 0"

$C4 ? ?6 %

8 ' 3 ) , &8 +, & " ,+

3 ++

& " , "" ?& ( " ""

" , " ?& '

, "3 & 0"

2C4 ?96 & ?"" " ,+ 3 +, ( 0"

C /3 &" 3 "

' "'

, 7 ""

& " ) , "" "+3 %

&" ""

?, " "+3 8 '

3 )'& /5+ % &. " D 4" 6 '

, & "3 & 0"

C "

' & 0"

"" & ""

& 0"

?, &" +" )'& /5+ % &. - 3 + & " "

&" 0"

292C 0, 3+$(

* <"" & $C <""

& 2C

?""

C $ "

C <"" & "

C <""

?, C (

?;=?;@A - " " " & "+ "& "3"3 +,

- 3 + 3 " "

& +?

6 " "

) )!3 3" '

! /0 12 & "8 "+ ,"A" " = '" & +& 3 &+ & & "" "+""""0"

C 1 "

+ +, ( " " ( & ?""

C "+3 %

"+3 & 0"

C "

!& "+3 "" & " ""

"" ""+& &3" & - " "& +" "

" , &3" "' ' &, , +" "

, & ) "+8 " 0"

$C &

""+& +, & & "

+3 ""

& '

& ( " "+& " &" "+ 3 &" "" & " ""

?, & 3 "

" "+ " " " &, " & + "" 3 +8 ' 3 ' ) ( "

, & 1 - ""+& +, " . 8 " &" $0

" " ,&& +,

"+& " & ) " ,+"""" '

" & "

"" / ' " " ". " " & " "

& & "+8 0"

$C "8 &0"

C /3 "

&& " " &, ,+" "

( +,,&" & &3 + ? & ,0"

$C &

" " " ", ' "3 '

, & 1 D ' 3 ' & )'& /5+ % &. & " + + "" '

, &"

+ &"

1 C4$? ?6 "" & =" " &8+, & " ' "

& &3

3 + " , ' "" ?& '

, " " & 0"

$4$?96 ""

& & ?"" , + 3 +, 0"

C = &3 "

' " 3 " "& "+ 8 ' 3 &"

', &

' & , ' & "+ '"

=" " " " ' 3 ' 3 3 ' , &" "" & " ""

?, '

, & "" " 0"

C "

'0"

C ""

& "0"

?, % "& + '" &

+ & ( " + + " 3 +

7 ' "" " 3 "

B" " """"& &3 + " '0"

C & " " /

+ & 0"

1C4? ?6

$ '"

- 3 + &

" &" 0"

11C " "' + 3E 0, 3+$(

* <"" & 1 C <""

& $C

?""

9 C $ "

C <"" & "

C <""

?, C .

1C (

*;&&;@A " "& " "& "

3 +,

% + ,'

' &

"+""

" &, " " "& " +"" 0" , 3

+ &"3 +

& -" .&,

'# - 3 +

3 ( 3 .( "& ?& +

" (2 ! 3B ,;& C 0 9D

92 (2 ,*. '4"$1@, '*$ # % *@ 92 (2 ,, .,('B) % *@