The Lodhiwala Cass Ltd. v. State Of Punjab
!!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
-(% !!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
.
* !!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
- !!"# ###$"
%
&%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
.
* !!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ ###', "
/ !!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
$++ !!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
-(% !!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
.
* !!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
- *% !!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
!!"# ###$"
% &%'('
!"" )$(*+ "%'
###', "'
! "! # $
%&$ ' ' $ $%'"0 %# %(%1 2 3" %","
% # %#$%,!
4 %,(%1 2 3"
%","
% ' %5 43''# '#!5 6 %16 71$(*+# %#%(!"1 2 3") % %#!(5 "8 1 2 3" %"%', " -9:6# ;;;;
' $( .<" ' %%1=' ', ' )
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
) +<,"
%'#
1
1
1
1
1
1
) % >(' 4 ) 3 5, "'1 '(55 4 %% '(+'>(",% 3 4'% 4"%)% 5, ""% (%"2 +) +<,"
% '?33('@ #'
"<# A%'
1
1
2+) +<" ,"
% ' 4 '" " 5,(4 %% " ## ,'' +<
%"% (%" '5 ''
4" %,, 3"
') % '3%4# .% ) <'""1"3 )3"' )"3''1 3% 3''%<) %"3
)","
' %"""!"" "% (4 ) 4% 3( "(% )) 3%1( +% (4""3 5, "'
(%!3"
)"9%"
B% "% %% % )"% %)%%"
'"
,( '+ (%!3"
)" :''"
' 3"1 % )"%%)%%"
'
" 4"
'""33('@ #%
,# 4% 3( "(%!%2 3!
"
'
"" '"% +("
))%"
B%""C' ?33('@ #
'C '5()3"(% 4( ") %5()3"(% 6 $@D$D %', '
+ ) %"5()3"(% 4C' 4C'"
3/ 4 '"% +("
))% 4) %' $(*+!""""& '($%'(?
33('@ # '",%'
%', '
+ (% (' ) "%
%%) %"3 (3" )+('
''>( "< ),% (3 )5()3"(%%
+ ) ) 5 3 9%"
B%'""" 6 $ '
'(,, "% (4 ( -9:6 .%31 84% ( %3" <)% 5"/$
" )"3 5,<"
" ''
"<""" ,% 5%<4% 3( "(% 3
,#!
"
'+E5,")% 5 +" " 3'' ) )%"
B%'1 ' '(3 33(' @ # '
"
' + %', '
+ ) %" '"% +("
)
>( "< )6 $)%"
B%""
33('@ '# %%', '
+ ) %5()3"(% 4C' 4C'"
3/ '"% +("
4'(+'"%)%"
B% ) 6 $(%" "%
%%1 "" <133('2
"",%
' ) ('
)" "% %%'
3"'5, ' ) 6 $@D$D
.(5,%1 3+% +<"3 5,"" )) 3%',% %( ' %"'""
) 4% 3( "(% )) 3%1( 1+ ( "33 % 4"
',3 3"
' )" "% %%',% <'
%, %"'# )"%%3 ," )%'( " )"'5, '1'
3('' 3'
%'%2"
33('@ #?'
"
'13 , ' ) <'
'%, %"' )" '5, '+'""
""'
"
'#!
3(' 3' %'%2 (, -9:6.%3184% 6 '"% 3"4% -9:61 ( #!
% <1'
3(' 3
"3 , ' )" <'
%, %"' %'""
33('@ '# #, ' %%3 21 3
% ") ("
+'"
')3"
%<1"%) %13 5, "' %) " (%"#
,%'""
)"3 5, "'+<"3 5, " " (%"1) 44
'()) "4% ('"
,% 3)(%"%4 '"" 33(') %3 ""
))3(%!3"
)" 3"133(' %
%%"
+'(55 #,%'
,,%3 )"3 5, "
'E5,""
)(%"% %%' ',%5 """
,,%"% (4
$(+ 3$% '3("
%#
< 33(' @ # ,(" ,,%3 " (%"1
%'"3'/,"+ 4* (%) %,% 3(% 4'%2 3 )%5 33('"
5"
"
5#="5 1",%'","
' %) 1 3 )"'5 % ''("
"%', "1 ,(" ,,%3 "% (43 (' # =2% %3 (' ) %",%"
'+'
'4
"% (4"%3 %# 6(% 4 ,3< ) " ,%'" ,"
'1 % %4(5"' ## 1 % ".3 )" ' (%" +'%2 '(%0 6(% 4"3 (%' )% 41 "'"%', %""'5, )%"
B% ",%'"3' '"/)% 5"53 '"
"3+4' ",%'3 ),"
%' '5 )" "< # #
+<' 3"
4+4' (" )" ' 5"% "% 51',
" (" ,% )"%, <) +<6%#* %!
4$%1 ) 4% 3( "(% )) 3%1 ( # = ,% ) " 5,(4 3 5, " " # #
E(%$) +<" ) 4% 3( "(%
)) 3%1( 1 " ' 4"" " ) +4' )" )%"
B% >('"
' '(,, "
" '
"< ) " ,"
%"% (4C'%/)184% #F
2%1%/)
'5 "" < ""33(' ",%'"3 5, "#&
%%" ##
,''+<" % )8( 4 '"%"1( 1 %%" )%%'" % ''(4 '"
33(' '# 5()3"(%% "% (4 " 3 3% !(,% "" )$
3#A33(' '# % %%'"13 3% %%" )%%'" )33(' '#
5()3"(%%
" ""% ''""
"3 3% !(,% "" )$
32 %%"##
,'' +<" % )8( 4 '"%"1( #% (' ) %",%"
'% 5""5()3"(%%1 < 3'1
( +"5 33('# =2 )"+ 21!
%!(,% "" )$
31 (
''
% ) $
31 ( %3""
) '
)) 2 " %+) %"E"" % 4
"3"
"/%, %"',3 )< 4'"
"/ )'",' %"/"
%%'"33(' '# 1
3 5, 3 )"+ 2' %%,''+<" %
)8( 4 '"%"1( #F' '
E, "" )"33('3 ( "+%%'"1 " %" %'
') % "%%'"
4"33('(% 4 " ' ,%
)5 %"<%'# %3 (' ) %"!""1 '"%(3"
')% !#7(%,!
41 4% 3( "(% 62 ,5" )) 3%1
) 4% 3( "(% )) 3%1( 1',
" ("""'
,%" )) 3 55( 3"
" # #
''(+< " .%3 4%1 %/)1 84% 1 "
" ) 4% 3( "(% )) 3%1( )%"
B%('"
+,(%3' +<"'"" 2 ,(%3'3 ""3 5,% )6 %3"
%1 4% 3( "(% 1 $(*+1 !3%"%<1
,%"
1 $(*+1 4 '"%%1
,%"
2 !
"
'1 $(*+ 4 %3"
%1%/)1 4%# =2 )"+ 214 46 %3"
%1%/)1 4%1 ' %3""
) '
)) 2 " %+) % "E"" )% 41E, 4'"
5(3,%
'%+<"%/) ,(%3'
4")%"
B%)% " 5()3"(%% ' 4 " ) % % "
))%"
,%"
2'
"
' /",%'","
%'
"< "
!"" )$(*+#F' '
E, '"
"/ 5'(%'('"
+ ,"+<%/)"
'(%>( "< "% )")%"
B%('"
+,(%3'+<%/) )% 5"5()3"(%%1) %",(%, ' ) %'(,, <1 "% (4' 1"
))%"3
,%"
2'
"
' "!"" $(*+# ) 4% 3( "(% )) 3%1 ( 3 5, " %3""
) '
)) 2 "E, 4"" 3',% "2%5"'"/ ,% )"3 5, " "' )1" )%"
B% >('"
''(,, "
","
%'
"< "% (4%/)"'5, "% ) '"/)% 5" 53 '"
"3+4'+<' 3"
4+4' (" )" ' 5"% "% 51 <"%/) ' "5 "33('"% (4 "'4 46 %3"
% %"3 3%
)) 3%# )) 2 " )4 46 %3"
%1 -9:6 ') " (%" %', '"%"
#% 2",%" ) ')) 2 "%''
(%0 # %/) ' ,E
,%"
2!
"<#%/)'
+''
4"
%%4C,% 3(%5" ))%"
B%'',%" ,
3< )"!""7 2%5""% (4"6,%"5"
,%"
) %"'5
" '"% +("
2 +
"< " )%"
B% "
5 ) % " )%5%' ) " !""# %/) '
'(%,(%3' )'"
3/') % '"% +("
")%"
B%")%"
B%'%+ 4%%4+<5/ "23,<5""
"'(,, %' "%'" "'5
' + % +< %/)# '"+ '5" 3 '" ) " ',3 < 3"
%/) %3 ' '
+ %+<%/)# # " ) % + ''
" <%
7 + %' + ) ) !"" 2 9%"
B% $(%3' "" % 2 "+<%/)) %",(%3' )6 $ 9%"
B%# ,< ) " $% 3 4' ) " $(%3' "" 'E) *3 ,< )". 3'"
'E') "*# # " " %3 55"
) " !"" 2 ""$(%3' %% ', 3) %",(%3' 6 $ )% 5
'" "% ## C' 5 3 ' 9%"
B% """4%,% 3
""3%" "%5'
'#
# "'%4%'1",% "%)% 5"9%"
B% 3"
"<3 3%1 ',%"+ 3'" ',%,%
"%4%"
")%"
B%'(,, +<C' 5 3 '
9%"
B% "#F
2%',%"+ 3'") % "<%
5 (" )## 3% %' '%'
,% " )% 5 " "
% 3"
"< ) '(,, < ) )%"
B% +< %/) "!"" )$(*+ 33 5,% '' )6 $1 G%1H 31 $@$-)%"
B%) %+ "+ -% !'
'# " " ,% " '
" + 3 '" E3 ('
2 ) " "%'" 3(%% " ) " )%"
B%3"
"<'"+ '5"3%4'# # "',%"3 ('@ # )""%I'"%5'
'"',3 3"
' )")%"
B%' %,%'3% +
E(%) * )""%5' 3
'#=" ')(%"%
3 %, %" 3 ('@ # 6"""5()3"(%%C' % ' +%', '
+ ) %">( "< )6 $'"
3/' "%5' ',3 3"
' )%"
B%3 "% %%) %" "3"
+4'"
" % ', ' +<"43<C+(<%+,-) .*# # " " !"" 2 )%"
B% $(%3' "" %3 55 " ,(%3' ) " )%"
B%
" "
'"
,( "
'"""'(,, %
'(,, <)%''"
3/ )4
>( "< '
( '"% ,3/ 4 2 4 ( %5 4%( ' ) 3
(%+'
'',%"J9%"
B% "%
%%K',3 3"
'# ="%'"
4 <1" -9:6' "+ 5, ' 33('+<"3 5, "# 33('@ #?'
"
'*('"+ '"% +("
4")%"
B%1'(,, "
"+<" -9:615()3"(% +<%', "'@ # '"
"3+4'1"
3 ( "<+ , B) % 4,
%>( "< )")%"
B%#@ 2 %'
"" %4% ' + 4 2 " 3 5, "' '
% < % 4 '"%"'5'"
2,''" %%'
"%4%"
%', "
@ # 53 3 5%
" ("(,, 3"
)5 #)3"
'"
+"/ "
3 '
%"
"","
%'?'
"
'% 44 ' )")%"
B%+(" "' '"% +("
5 4"55+%' "'
"<)(%"%5 %"'5, '+% )% 5' +4'
' '(,, +< " 5()3"(%% "% (4 -9:6# %) %1
3% +
"<3 ( +)'"(, 33('@ # +'3 )< 3" % ''
" %,%"'1 35 4"2%'( " "%
%"
)>( "< ))%"
B%# +
"< ) -9:6 '5(35 %" "" ),"
%@ #'
3 " ' -9:61 3,% 3(%"
)%"
B%1'(,, < ""
,"
%'
"
'15") % '"% +("
5 " %55+%' ,' %)( " ",%" )","
%'?
"
'3 5' (""
+"%1 35 4"2""%3",% 5)3 ''
)<'(3 ))3 " %,%"# % 3 (' ) % " ,"
%' ' %)%% "
%% ,''+< % ".3 )" ' (%" )
"
% %)%% 4 "
(" % "<
!
"#1 3 "'+ +'%2'(%0 '5, )3"" ) ') ("
+'(+'"%# '5 '"/)% 5'"
"3+4# ' (%" ', ' +'%2"""33('1 ' %13 "+ 4( "<#9(%"%1 "3' )$ %
& '(() * !
*'1"33(' ,(%3'+4')%"
B%)% 5@"
9%"
B% " /," " '5 % ) %5
" (" < "5,% 4# !5, )% 5+4') ("
+'(+'"%# ' (%" "" "3 ( "+' ""33('<3( ,+ 5" '"") %3 ""
))3) %5()3"(% 4)3"1
33('3 "+ %', '
+ # %3 (' ) %","
%'')(%"%%)%%"
%%,''+< % ".3 )" ' (%"
"
" % !+
3 ## % +'%2 4"""%% 4"
'""'"
"3 +4' %"5,%
"""" 3 5, 3 )"'(+'"%1 " 13 <+""% +(""
"5()3"(%% ""
","
%1
5 "" <,(%3'C4 "'(,, "+4')% 5 '"% +("
%) %5# =",%'"3' '
1"%% 4"
' )"5,%
)"+4'# %3 (' ) %","
%'')(%"%%)%%"
(" % "<7( *% ,# 4% #!%2 3!
"<"#&%'('!"" $(*+1 ### 1 % " ' + +'%2 "" " ,(%, ' )4% 3( "(% '
"
' '"
3 3"
2 <,(%3')%"
B%)% "5%/""
'"% +(""'55 "'55+%'"% '
' %"%')% ),% ,%"< 2 2+"
"'
"< "'55+%' )(%"%,% 5%<'
"
'% '
)(3"
4'4"' )" %55+%'
" ,% 3 , '
"< "
'"% +(" " )%"
B% "" "% '
5" )' "%')% 2 2"'
"
'% "%>( %"
+%4 '"%(%"9%"
B%' "% %%1# %) %1=) "" "' + ") "'' )" 4'1 ,% ,%1,,% ,% ""
,%2"+(' ),% 3'' ) 1 )
1
1
1
1
1
1
%
#
%%33 % 4 <#3 5, "'
"'(55
%%' 3 %<,% 3 4'>(","
%'%>(' "',"
'# !
3
1
1
1
1
1
1
'"
1
1
1
2 +3 5 )%(3"( ('% ', ' )33 % 4 <# # # / ' $0 .% * 122--34567
4 122--5-89 4