High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/16772/2024allowed

Neetu Rani v. Guru Nanak College Of Education And Others

2024-07-23Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil26 pages

-1-

!"#$ % #&##

# #' # (

) %* + , '

- ( (

! '

-.( (

# (((((((! , ++

##/

'# #'

(((( (

+#'

(((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

.( 2

/#'

(((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

( 2

/0'

(((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

-2-

3( .

#!#0 +

(((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( ( . .

"# $ +

(((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( ( .24

"#+!#0 + (((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( 2( .2

/# (((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( 4( .233

(((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

-3-

( . .

/# (((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( ( 24

#" /# (((((((! ,+

##/

'# #'

(

'#0" /# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

.( .

#"5'

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

( .4

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

+ 1(

-4-

3( 3.

'!0

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

( 2.

##!

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( ( 2

!#'

+ 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

2( 2 2

##"

1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( 4( 2 2

'/+# !#++

1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

-5-

( 23.

## #

1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( ( 2.

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

( 2

#",

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

.( 23

##!

1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

(

) %*

# #'

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

-6-

3( 2.

'#,'

+ #0#+ '

+ 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

( 2

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( ( 2

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

2( 4.3

##'

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( 4( ..

+/'

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

1( . ( 43

+ 1(!

-7-

/0 ,'&#!

& #'

+( 1(

"#+!

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

.( 24

1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

..( 2 2

1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

( . 4

"#+5'

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

.3( 3

+#'

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

-8-

"& 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

.( 2

/##0'

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

.2(

/##0"

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

.4( 44.

/# 1(! ,+

##/

'# #'

( 22

+ + #0

1(! ,+

/0 ,'&#!

& #'

#- 6$0

("+

+#'

-9-

! "

# ! $ $%&''($()(*%'(%($()(*+%'%%$ ()(*%',%)$()(*%,%**$()(*+%'*+$()(*+%',-$()(* +%,*($()(*+%,..$()(*+()+%$()(*()),-$()(*()%&*$ ()(*(+')($()(*(+-'&$()(*(.'+&$()(*(',+($()(* (,))($()(*(,)%,$()(*(,)(,$()(*(,(.+$()(*(,(&+$ ()(*(,*%&$()(*(,.)%$()(*%**,($()(*%&',%$()(* %,%(+$()(*%&',%$()(*%,)*&$()(*%-+.'$()(*%'++($ ()(*%'%&($()(*(%+)-$()(*(%.*&$()(*(%&%%$()(* (',*($()(*((*%%$()(* %-&-+$()(*

# ! $ $%',%)$()(*%,%**$()(*%,%(+$ ()(*%,)*&$()(*%-+.'$()(*%,(-'$()(* %,*(,$()(*

1 1 00 0!0 #234$5 + ! $ $%&''($()(*%',%)$()(* %'(%($()(*! $ $()),-$()(*! $ $()%&*$()(* ! $ $(+')($()(*! $ $(+-'&$()(* ! $ $(.'+&$()(*! $ $(',+($()(* ! $ $(,(.+$()(*! $ $%**,($()(* ! $ $%'%&($()(*! $ $%,(-'$()(* ! $ $%,*(,$()(*! $ $(%+)-$()(* ! $ $(%.*&$()(*! $ $(%&%%$()(* ! $ $(',*($()(*! $ $((*%%$()(* ! $ $%-&-+$()(* "

0!0 #5 +$234 ! $ $+%'%%$()(*+%'*+$()(* +%',-$()(*+%,*($()(*+%,..$()(*+()+%$()(*(,(&+$ ()(*(,)(,$()(*(,*%&$()(*(,)%,$()(* (,))($()(*

1 6

"4 6

#5 % ! $ $+%,..$()(*+%',-$()(* +%,*($()(*+%'*+$()(*+%'%%$()(*%,%**$()(*()),-$ ()(*()%&*$()(*(',+($()(*%-+.'$()(*%,%(+$()(* %,(-'$()(*%,*(,$()(*(%.*&$()(* %-&-+$()(*

-10-

// # ! $ $%-.'*$()(* ! $ $(),(,$()(*

+#'

0( "( 78 +9: %

4 007 # 00 #$

! $ $%&''($()(* ! $ $%'(%($()(* ! $ $ %',%)$()(* ! $ $%,%**$()(* ! $ $+%'%%$()(* ! $ $+%'*+$ ()(* ! $ $+%',-$()(* ! $ $+%,*($()(* ! $ $+%,..$()(* ! $ $+()+%$()(*! $ $()),-$()(*! $ $()%&*$()(*! $ $ (+')($()(* ! $ $(+-'&$()(* ! $ $(.'+&$()(* ! $ $(',+($ ()(* ! $ $(,))($()(* ! $ $(,)%,$()(* ! $ $(,)(,$()(* ! $ $(,(.+$()(*! $ $(,(&+$()(*! $ $(,*%&$()(*! $ $ (,.)%$()(* ! $ $%**,($()(* ! $ $%,%(+$()(* ! $ $%&',%$ ()(* ! $ $%,)*&$()(* ! $ $%-+.'$()(* ! $ $%'++($()(* ! $ $%-.'*$()(*! $ $%'%&($()(*! $ $%,(-'$()(*! $ $ %,*(,$()(* ! $ $(%+)-$()(* ! $ $(%.*&$()(* ! $ $(%&%%$ ()(*! $ $(',*($()(*! $ $((*%%$()(*! $ $%-&-+$()(* ! $ $(),(,$()(* 8 #0 9 0 00

(

# 7 /#! $ $ %&''($()(* +

# ! *,(#!# ! 0 %-'+ : # # ;!<= 7

/8 !0

0 7

-11-

# 0 %+,#5

704 %,,%:#;<=9 # 0 3# 8 $ 7# 7>

4!0 ?

;9 *

8 0# 7# !

@6 0

%+, # 5

70 4%,,%

# 00 #87

7$ !00 # 0

9 $ < .

0 # 0 7 7# 0!

B !# ()%'$()%-9 $!00

! 0 1 0 #0 9# 0 0 ( .0 &

0#9 0 / $!00 7

70 / 8

# $ 9 7 #

0 $9 # 9

900 / 0

#0 /9 90 #

0 # $ C9 0 0 # 7 $ ()%-$!00

-12-

/87 /# 9 9 00 0

0 %+,# 5

704%,,%

00# 8 4

900 7>

4!0 7 # # 8 # 0

900 78 8 00 ## ## #9 0 @

#!3 D*'*'D()(+:E$%'=9 ), )- ()(+:E$%,= ! $ 5 %&''(#()(*

= 8 '

4 77 0## 7 7# 0!

B !:()%'$ ()%-= $!00 0 : ## ; 0 <=#! 01 # 0!

72 #4

1# 700

00 9# 0 0 ( .

0 /

79 # 0 0

90 # 7 #$

0 0 0 9 % ?

/ 9 9

/ 780 ( .?

/ ()%+

F # 7 %% )'

())'

:E $+= 7 1 # 7 9 9

-13-

00 # $# 70# 0 7 #7 7 7 7 # 0 90# 7 0

9 0 0

# 7C #4 8

## # 7 # ,

$ # %) %( ()%(() )+ ()%+%.

)& ()%+ (( )'

()%* :E$'=9 9 0!

90 7

# 00 D D :1G 7=90 7# 0#$ :1 # 7= 7 #1#4

7 0

00# 700

9 00 D D

4 07 # 9 8

## # 7 #

9 E0 0 #907 71 71<" # 60# 0 :?5 +D'*D)' $%%= 00 # # 1 #

0 # 9 907 000

70 # 7 # 9

-14-

3 7 0# # 0

$!00 / 7 #

$70 /7 /8 90 # 0 9 0 := #0 00 09 #

#$00 4 #

8 8 3

7 $00 8 8 90 7 0 #7$00

#9 0 4

0 7# ! $00 E

7 7E0 70 /8 8 7

# E 0 7 9 $00 # 00$ 89 ₹

# %))))) )( )( ()(+ 7 / # 9 77 9 /90 # 9 0

00# 707

907 8 8 9 7 / 9 / @

= 8 %%

4 77 0## 5 % 7 # 0!

/ #

0 $00

C9 0

E# $

-15-

# 70 7 0

# D

/ ## 9 #

0 #97 0# 7 0 9 900

# 4 0 0 #97 0 7 / 00 7$ $!00 89

# 9 00 0 ##

7 / #

4 D # / ##

80 7 4 %+, %+-#! 0

# 9 # 8 # 9

!8070 9 7 %+, %+-# 077 ## !

# 8 7

7 := 00

99 0$ # # # 7 90 89 0 /

#$ C # 0# :=

-16-

? 0 # 5 +$2 # 4

" #

0> B9 0 00

07 1 2 ! 01 #

0 # E H! ?

0 ()%-$() ! ?

9 9 # 0 DF ! !0 1900

70# 00 # 7 780 0

19 / 9 0 7 7#

9 0 4 9 # ! 01 0 0 #

# # ()%&$ %' 0 #9 70

70 7#

D 0 0 7 00#7 7 7 7$ # 0 ()%'$%,()%,$%- ()%-$() 9 0 0 7 7

0 $

+)- (%! D 0#()()9 # $ 0 I %*) +&! 9 0 #! 0 # ()()$(%

# ()()$(%7! 01 7

0 ###7#

-17-

$ 0 )- )'

()()5 +

00 # 0

70 D 0 7 I #

C 0 0# %*

70 7 7

0 7# ! E 90 7 9 9 ## # ! 10 7

0 ()()9 $ 7 0

70# %+,# 5

704%,,%

# # 907

0 # %+,#

! " !

# $ %

& # % &

' #

&( # ) * %# ) #

% %&

704 9 %%,

70 9 # %+- 0# 8

0# /

-18-

%+, 6 %%,%+- %+,0 9 0 +

! # %# !#

+ % % +

! #+

% %'

0E # %+, 0 0 9

8 0

00 # 70 7 0

C9 $!00 7

8 # ()%' #

7 #0 9 %,

B # ()%'$%- # 00 0 0 ! 01 0 9 # 0!

1 0

070

0 9 0

71#4

()%) :E$%=7 09 # )% )'

()%) 7 #

0 0!

!0 4

9 ( .0 9 # ()%+$%*9 !0 $

009 7#0# 70#

-19-

D # 0

7/ 009 #

7/7 /# # #

0 009 #9 #0 #

%- 0# (( )'

()%*:E$'=

%( ), ()%.:E$,=# I# 1# 7$5 ( "

0 " #B :!00 = # 7 # 0 !

# # 0

70 0 !

9 # ())'$),

90 7 7 # 7 "

" # 60# 0 # %( ), ()%.

7 709 #$ , -

! !

% !

! # $

/ 0 /!

(($('+ !

! ! + #

-20-

% !

* ! # -

! % #

! 2 * ! ! # % 3 &

4 5 !

! ! % #

+ # ! %

! % ! % 6 % #

2 *,

# % ! * !

! #

2 *

! * ! ! # # % 3 ' % 3 .7 % # $().8

! ! -

()

# # (( )'

()%& :E$-=9 I 0 # 0 #

-21-

60# # 1#

9 $ 94&.4

4 5 + !

! ! +

3 % ! % !

% 4# # 3 % *

! * ! ! # # 3 % 4' 4

:4 !

! ! - + # ! !

* ! ## # &(,! %4% ! !

+ ! % !

% 3 % ;. ! % % ! !

< 7"%#

< =

%% + -

:- + > -

:- <

* ! +

,% +

3 % ! % !

% *

+ ?

! !

# !!

" %

-22-

4,6,).

% ! ! %= @ >

% !

4,6,$. % ,

$(8.$(A B

+ ! + " + + ! + + #+ !1 + "

# - 4 :-

: #

#+ # % +

# - 4 :-

: !

% > (%

# #

D # /

7 0 0 # 7 # $00 900 "

" #B :!00 =## !907

B 9

## 7$ 00 9 0

9 # / 9

#9 9 7 7 7 1

-23-

((

F 74 ## 9 # 7 0 ! 01 0 # 0!

0 / 9 0

070

B 9 ()%'$%- 70 /8

#9 #07 # $0 $9 #! 1 1

E# 7 9 #0

4 0 # 0

%+,#5

704 7# 0 ()(+ 8 8 9

/ 0 ()(+ #

# ()%'

9 # #$00 # 00

89 # E

0 0 #7 ()%-9 72

#0 9 # %+,# 5

704%,,% 879 9 9 0 0

7# #

0#0# 0 900 4 79 089

# 970 / 0 # 007$00 0# 7

# $

-24-

# 7 # #

$ /9 7

#$00 0 # 0

0 # 0 # 9 (*

# 7 / $9 70

7E / # #8#07## #

9 ! !"! #"!

$ %&

!'!"! $ ()*))+ +,-./ %% %) ()(( 7 0

7 # $ D 0 # $ &(

;

(i) For the commission of an offence under Section 138, the cheque that is dishonoured must represent a legally enforceable debt on the date of maturity or presentation; (ii) If the drawer of the cheque pays a part or whole of the sum between the period when the cheque is drawn and when it is encashed upon maturity, then the legally enforceable debt on the date of maturity would not be the sum represented on the cheque;

(iii) When a part or whole of the sum represented on the cheque is paid by the drawer of the cheque, it must be endorsed on the cheque as prescribed in Section 56 of the Act. The cheque endorsed with the payment made may be used to negotiate the balance, if any. If the cheque that is endorsed is dishonoured when it is sought to be encashed

-25-

upon maturity, then the offence under Section 138 will stand attracted;

(iv) The first respondent has made part-payments after the debt was incurred and before the cheque was encashed upon maturity. The sum of rupees twenty lakhs represented on the cheque was not the 'legally enforceable debt' on the date of maturity. Thus, the first respondent cannot be deemed to have committed an offence under Section 138 of the Act when the cheque was dishonoured for insufficient funds; and (v) The notice demanding the payment of the 'said amount of money' has been interpreted by judgments of this Court to mean the cheque amount."

(& 47# ! 0

# 0

# ! 01 0 # (( )'

()%-:E$-=$ 0

7 #9 07

8 7 7

/ # ()(+ ('

4# 0

B ! ()%- # $00 00 ##

# :E $-= # 8 # 0 0 . #$!00 9 70 7##0

4# # $ 9 #

07# ! 00 7 0

7 0 / #

-26-

%+,#5

704%,,% 7 7 907

# 900

4 9# 7

009 0

%+,#5

70 4 %,,% 0 9 0 9 78 78

3 0

.( (

)+#'

0* ! "'

3 % * !:

;

3 6 % ;