← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/136/2021dismissed

Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. And Others v. Kartar Singh @ Kartara

2021-09-03Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia9 pages

    

      



!"#$%&% '( ")!

*+ +"#$%,%      !" #$%&  """'%#%&

%&(& ) $*) """%&+#!% $  -./%  /%% 0. '%&%, """ # -!.#/%&0#$%++%&"

1$%+#/%%! &%2% /#!(/%!$#( $.!%# /#0%%/ -&+%&(/#&"  %%'#!1'2'3+'

 4 %   1$%++%&!%0%!&%% (%/#!++% & $%  /#/(%  0! &  #0  $%  3.  3#(    )$  !%!  4" "

5 6$%%2$%&(#0$%+00%&+#!%6&!%/%%!! &$% !%/&##0$% #6%++%%3#(!%!5" "

.!%6$/$$% ++%6&&#!&&&%!" 3#(&%0#$%++%&$&.%$%%&(2%!$$% 3#(&2%#66%%%#!%/%% $%&(&$%(&!/##0$% 3.  3#(  6&  2%!  !  $%  +#/%%! &  (!%  %/#  7  #0  $% 8%///-

 0#&$#-$%9/9$!2%%%! &$% %&+#!%/#&(%"

+%(&#0$%%/#!-$&3#(&#0$%#+#$# &(2&:(%&##06&%&0#/#&!%#$%+%&%% ( %/#!++%"

  1$% 0/&  6#(!  #  #  #  &$#6 $ 0#  /$%/; !#%  # 7"

<"

=-$%#/%$!2%%&&(%!&%%//&&%&&%/$ %&0# &" - = >!&"=

>&/#+#(! 0%%&#$%/#+#(! #0$% % %!$%0"%6%%/$% %!2$%+00#$% #(!$# #++#(#0$% 6& .%#$!$%%%6&&%!#(&!% $%  +%&%&  #0  $%  +00  !  $%  $!  %!  &%!  &#  %%  %:(+%$&+%&%&!$%6&(& &#%% "

1$%!%0%/%#0$%+%&%++%&6&$#/$%/; - 6&0#(!$$%#!&$#6996&( $#( $$%%%!#!

&$#6996&/#%/%!!%/2+&& $%%%!$(&-$%# /#%/%!#!#099!996&"=5=)? &$%&/#%!#!#0

"7

)?"1$%+00$!%0(&%!#+($&& (%&(+#$%/$%/;

%+# !%&(-2#$!%!&6%%&&(%!!%%$!&# 2%%6%#$% -@ '-A!0##!

 $%B@ &$%+00 0#(& $%%%//!&$#%&2/# !%/$%0"

$%0 #0$%&&(%&-$%13#(.%&(/// %C%!$%+#.&#&#0$%/#/%#$%/#/(&#$%/#  ##%$!!$%+#.&#&#0%/#7%!&/!!00%% !#+%%!00%%0%!&!$.%#/##+%&%6"%/% 6& $+/%!(+#$%(!

%#0$%+%C3#( 1 /5 *6(+

/#7+#

'#"(1 8 %9 +

('':+* +33  &"

1$%%%.+##&#0$%(!

%%!&(!%, D7"+#$%+%! -$%;!00%%/%&$%/#%& #0%/#& !7#0$%

/%#2.#(&"1$%% !&/!!00%%+#.&#&6$/$#+%%!00%%0%!& !$.%#/##+%&%6"?%$.%%!#/%!

 $%/#& ! <#0$%

/%!# %$%/#&(%   /#+%%  /#!%    $%&%.%&  /#.%    %%. /#&!%#&0#+&& #0#!%#0&&%&&%/&%& 6$/$!##0(!%%/#7#0$%

/"%/#7 #0$%

/0&(!%'E@ % #F#00%/%&!

+%%&9!%#0$%%/#&F$%0#0%%//9"1$% %/##+%&6$$%6#!&F6$#%.%-!&$#%&9!#%&# #0$%/&&+%/0%!(!%/(&%& # %#0(2&%/#  #0%/#7#0$%

/&#&#2&/#/#&(%#(&% %%//&$2%+(&$2%0#+&#%0#%6$/$ %C%!#$%%%&#6$0%#6$2#$"%&!%& +#&##0+(&$%&&+%/0%!(!%$%&%+#.&#&# $%+#.&#$%%#-(2&%/# #0%/#7#0$%

 /+#.!%&$6$#(+%(!/%#$%+#.&#&#0$%

 /-$%/%&%%#&(++%-&$%/&%2%-$#( $#00/% #0;($#G%!$&2%$02$%++#+%/#&&#- %!%!&/#%/$%&(++#0%%//!%.% ;%#$%%&(%&%(%%!(!%(2&%/#& # 4#0 $%&!%/#"1$%0%6$/$2%+#&%!(!%%/# 7 #0$%

/&!%/+#+###$%(2%#0 /#./#&!&&#!%+%!%#$%%C%#0#!2&/%!" @/#!&/##$%&%+#.&#&-%/# #0$%

 /6#(!2%++/2%#$%/&%&6$%%$%%&#$%0#0 %%//2($%%%//&2% /#&(%!.###0$% %&!/#!#&#0&(++%! #+//%&6$/$ &:(%  0  6$  $%  %C+%&&#  F(($#G%!  (&%  #0 %%//9"1$&&&%&&%>+#/%%! &6#(!/#%/%6$ $%  &+%/#  #0  $%  +%&%&  2    &&%&&  #00/%  !

%/#! #00! $&(/$/#&(%&!(   F($#G%!(&%#0%%//9"1$%$%&&%&& #00/%&$ +#.&#&&%&&-#$%2%&#0$&(!

%-$%%%// /$ %&+2%2&(/$/#&(%-&6%&+&&+#.&# &&%&&%#!%%&#0%/#  #0$%

/"1$% #00/%&&#(!%#2 ##&%.%#/%%&#0 %/#  #0$%

/(+#&(/$/#&(%%:(

4 $  #  0%  $&  #2%/#&-  0  -   &  $%  +#.&# &&%&&%2%0#%0#!%#0&&%&&%&+&&%!6$ $!&0#$%!%#0&%./%#0&(/$#!%#0+#.&# &&%&&%"  1$%%0%-    +%&#  &%.%!  6$  $%  #!%  #0 +#.&#&&%&&%//%+&(/$&&%&&%!!%+#& $%#(6$$%/%&%%6$&%.%!&#0&%./%#0&(/$ +#.&#&&%&&%#!%(+#$#+%0%++% & $%%&(0#!%(!%%/# <#0$%

/"1$% #!%#0&&%&&%(!%%/# !$%+%#!0#6$/$ &(/$#!%6#(!2%+&&%!$&#2%%&#0(2&%/#& 7 ! #0 %/#  #0$%

/"1$%8C+## %/#  &#0&#%& 0//%-6$/$6%&$!%6$ &$# $%%0%" %/#    #0  $% 

  /  0&  (!% 3$+%E@@!%%&#.%& #!%0#/%%!

%+#6%&$%&&%&& #00/%#+&&#!%#0&&%&&%" "%/#7#0$%

/!%&6$#00%/%#0$%0#0 %%//!$%+%$/2%+#&%!0#&(/$$%0"1$& &:(%0&6$$%!%&#&#03A(&+(!%/% !%&%&#%#0$%%%.0/#&0#0! /&%#0 $%0" $%/#-%/# #0$%

/!#%&#&+%;

#0/%!%!&+/#!%%! .2%(!%$%/.6"@!#%&#$.%0%(%&#%%%& 6$/$%/%2%#$%//#/%+#0%&%" <"1$(&-6#(!2%/%$$%%C+%&&#F(($#G%!(&% #0%%//9(!%%/# #0$%

/!%&6$/&%& #0(($#G%!(&%-%.%2&%/%#0%#"1$%&%/&%& 6#(!/%2%!00%%0#/&%&6$%%$%%&!&$#%& 2&/##0%%//2#0$%%$#!&%&%!(!% %/#7#0$%

/"/%%C+%6#(!2%-6$%% /#&(%$&(&%!%C/%&&.%#!& &$%&%!#!

&+/%!$%%&.###0$%%&!/#!#&#0 &(++-$%-$%/&%6#(!0(!%%/# #0$%

 /" $%#$%$!-6$%%/#&(%-2#0$%%& !%$#!&&&+%/0%!(!%%/#&7 #7 %#0$%

/-$&2&/%!%% 6$!&$#%&%#!

7 6$#(  ($#G#-  ;%  +#.!  0#    !%/  /#%/# 2+&&  $%  &%!  %%"  1$%%0#%-  $%%  &    /% !&/#2%6%%$%/&%&$6#(!0(!%%/# #0 $%

/#$%#%$!!%/#7#0$%

/# $%#$%"1$%%&#/##2%6%%$%6"1$% #+%%!00%%!!&/0%!&"1$%&&%&& #00/%$& 2%%.%&%!6$$%+#6%&#+&&+#.&#!0#!%#0 &&%&&%/&%&#0(($#G%!(&%#0%%//!/&%&#0 /#&(+##0%%//2%#!/#/%!#!6&:(% 0(!%&(/$+#6%"1$%% &.%%#&#/#.%$% /&%&#0+//%&!(($#G%!(&%#0%%//!$% $%06$/$& #.%%!2$%+#.&#&#0%/#7#0$%

/" =" %/#7 #0$%

/& 0/(&%&$%6#!& F6$#%.%-!&$#%&9!#%&#0$%&%!/#&&#&# 2&/#/#&(%%%//6#(!2%+(&$%!//#!/% 6$$%+#.&#&#0$%

/"FH&$#%&9&&%#0 !6$/$$&#2%&$#6#%C&2%0#%+%&#/2% +(&$%!(!%$%+#.&#&#0$%/#"I )%%+ .%6$%+/+%#06&%%!2$%+%C3#(- $%13#($&/#%#$%/#/(&#$##%$!-$%++%& 6%%+#&%/( $%/#&(%0#$%0#0%%//!#$%#$%$!- 6%%&#&&%&& 0#$%(($#G%!(&%#0%%//" /%$%0$!

2%%% %!2$%H%+%-$%&&%&& >($#G%! 00/%6&# /#+%%#+&&#!%!%! &+%/0/#(&$%2 #0$%/#&(%-6$/$/#(!$.%#2%%!%%%!2$%+%/ 3#("@6&&##/%!$$%& (%&#0$%+006%%##$% +( %!#/%!$%%6&#%+#&#6$%$%$%&!#/%&6%% &%.%! (+# $%+00" @ 6& &# #/%! $ $%#00/& #0 $% ++%&-&+%$%&%//(-6%%&(++#&%!# 00C/#+#0$%

 /$%/; %+##(&!%$%+%&%&#0$%%&+#!%!;%+/(%" //#! -;%%+ .%6$%0/$$%!!#%&##$%+#/%!(% +%&/2%!-$%!%!&&&%!.!%8C&"H  H#$%#(%#0 &"4- = >$!2%%!%/%!% -(!.#!" 1$%H&/A(!

%-6$%(+$#! $%&!%&# -&# #/%!$#$%2&&#0$%%:(%&&%#$%++%&-#$ 6& 2#( $#%/#!$$%B@6&% &%%! &$%%&+#!%"1$% #00/&$!0%!#+##(&#6$&(2&%:(%&+%!+#&$% %%>%:(%&#$%+#/%#%/+#/%%! &" @6&&# #/%!$.!%# +$/#(!$.%2%%!#%6$/$6#(!$.%$%+%!$% +#/%.%& #!$%+#.&#&#0%/# #0$%/$!&# #2%%0##6%!&$%%6&#+#.&##!%#0&&%&&%&%.%! (+#$%/#&(%!$%%0#%-+&& #0$%0#!%#0&&%&&%& +#.!%!(!%%/# 6&#&(&2%"%&(-0! 6& %/#!%!$$%++%&$!/%!% !&&(%!%#&!%$#&$% &(#+#.&#&#0$%/!$%%0#%-$%(&!/##0$%3. 3#(6& $.#;%!!$%#2%/#$$%3.3#($!# (&!/#-/#(!#2%&(&%!"%&(-$%++%6&!&&&%!2 +/ %/%(+#$%(!

%#0$&3#(';

1+#'<'#'+=3+ 8+('# +7':.(!%"(1

8 % '

2'#(> '+?+@ .AB"

+%(&#0$%%/#!6#(!&# ###&$#6$#$% /$%/; %+#-$%%!#&%%6&$%%$$%/#&(%$!%0(&%!# & 2(#& (%&#0$%6%&&$!2%%;%% ! $%&!

%0(&"-$%#/%!%! 7"

<"

=6#(! ###&$#6$$% #!%#0&&%&&%#0$%/%/%%#0$%0#0%%//(!%%/#7

< $!&&%&&%!$%#(+2%&&" - = "(-6&&#%#%! $/#+$!2%%0%!2$%($#G%! 00/%#$%+#/%0# ; /# G/%#0$%$%0#0%%//"&#/%#0%.%!% 6&&#&&(%!0#/#+#(! $%#00%/%&(!%%/#&7!7 #0 $%/6$%%2$%/#+#(! #(6&%#%!&&"=

>"1$% ++%&$!!%#%00##+#&%/(%$%/#&(%2%0#%$%+%/ 3#(% ! $%$%02($.%&%! #%/#.%$%#(-6$/$ $&%!#$%0 #0$%3.(" %/#7+#.!%&$%+#/%!(%% ! $%#00%/%&!

+%%&6$/$%$%/#;#0/+#/%%! &"1$%%%// /#%/#  6&  #  2%  !&/#%/%!  &  +%  $%  +#.&#&  !  %.%   /#+6&#2%#!

%!#$%'#/%#$. (&!/#6$ 4$#(&0#$%%#0&(/$!&/#%/#"@&++%$#&(/$ !&/#%/#6&!#%2(&&%&&%#0$%#(!(%6&!#%-6$#( ; %&##$%+#.&#&#0%/# "B#$%%##0$%&( 6$/$6&0%!# "

="

=-0%#$-6#(!2%/%$$% +00$!&#( $$$%!%0%!&2%%&%!0#%/#.% $% #(!##!&/#%/$%%%//&(++" %$%6&$%&!

#0$%++%&$$%%%///#%/#$!2%%!&/#%/%!&+% $%+#.&#&#0%/#7"$%$%&!$%6%&%%&$ $%  +00  6&  .#!  +%  #0  $%  &&%&&%!  #(  !  $% /#+#(! #(" @&-$(&-++%$$%3#(&2%#66%% /#%/#$%%C%$2%&# #$%+#/%!(%+%&/2%!0#/ +#/%%! &-$%&&%&&%6&2% !#%-0#6$/$&%+%+#/%!(% $!#2%0##6%!&(/$&+#.&#&&%&&%6&#2%!#%

= (!%%/#  #0$%/!(!%(2/(&% -$% $#00

#2%/#&$!#2% .%0%00#! %&#2%#++#(#0$%

2%0#%+&& #0$%0#!%"1$%&!#!%6#(!&#2%++%2% (!%%/# <!$%%0#%-$%3#(&2%#6$.% $/#%#$% /#/(&#$$%+#/%!(%0##6%!2$%++%&%%#$%#% +%&/2%!$%&(%" @A&6*A2 &(+-6$/$6&&#/&%#0$%0#0 %%//6$%%2$%/#&(%$!2%%/:(%!2$%33#(- $%&!&&(%6&!%2%!(+#!%.%(-/#/(&#6&.%! $#/%+#/%%! &(!%%/#76%%%!-$%&&%&&  00/% $!#($##+&&#!%% ! $%2!+%"@/&% &&#!#%-6&$%!$$%/#&(%/#2%%0%%!%&&!$% /  .#;%  $%  (&!/#  #0  $%  3.  3#("  %%.  +##  #0  $% (!

%%!&&(!%,  /&% $% !%+%&>#00/%&>/%&%%>&(++%& #0 $% #+#$/#&(%$&/#%!$%0&!%0%!(!%$% /-!$%>$%%+#/%%! &0#$%0(!%%/#7#0 $%/-$%$%&&%&& #00/%$&#($##+&& #!%  % !  &&%&&%  #0  2  !  +%   &   /#&(%"@0&(/$#!%#0&&%&&%>+%&+&&%!! +(+#%!  #  2%  %0#/%!   &    /#&(%  2  $% !%+%>/%&%%>&(++%$%$%/#&(%$&%.% $# .$%%%!#0/.&(2/$%  &(/$#!%>!%!

&%!2$%!%+%>/%&%%>&(++%"@&(/$&(#-$% (&!/##0$% /./#(&$#2%2%!2.(%#0 %/#47#0$%/"

@0(($#&%!#!%#0&&%&&%>+%&+&&%!2$% !%+%>/%&%%>&(++%-!%&+%$. % %!!%!

+#/%%! &#0$%0J$%$%/#&(%/#2%&!#$.%

5 %.%%%!%&(!%%/# <#0$%/"1$%%0#%-$% /#2%!%%!$% $#00 $%/.&( &&(/$ % &&%&&%>!%!>+%#/%#$% #(!$$%/ .%.%%%!#0++%(!%%/# <#0$%/"

/%$%+%/3#(/#2%%!$%&/%#0$% /#&(%!$%/.2&!%%%!2$%+%/3#(& $&2%%%&/%!#2%!%%%!# &$%/#&(%!

# 0# $%  #&&>! %&  /(&%!  #  $%  !%+%  !  %.% 6$#(0##6 $%+#/%!(%#0/./#(-$%%0#%-%% %C&%/%#0$%+%/3#(!#%&#-2+/#-%C/(!%$% (&!/#  #0  $%  /.  /#(-      /&%  6$%%  $%  &&%&&

#00/%>/%&%%>&(++%$&+&&%!% #(($#&%!#!% #0!%!!%&+%$. %0%%!$%%#$%+#/%#$% +%/3#(0#!%%##0$%&%"I )%%+ .%6$%2#.%-$&3#(&#0$%#+#$$%% &#% #0$%#!%&+&&%!2$%3#(&2%#66$/$ 6#(!  6  %0%%/%  2 $&  3#(      % (  %/#!  ++%"

%&(-$%+%&%++%&!&&&%!%"  C( :?

4  %%'#!1'2'3+'

'+3

  6!7  ?$%$%&+%; >%&#%!, K%&> # ?$%$%%+#2%, K%&> #