Charan Pal Singh v. Financia Commissioner (Appeals) Punjab,And Others


 

         

 

 !"

#$

 % & '"

((

)!!"* &+,  

.!-

         



# / #$ #, * )-0*

11111     





 !"

"-  &- ) "

2 
& 3-*

*
4$ & &    $ -  -

 5

 !-
"" * 8&-9  - 5 

  !-
(( * " 0* "  -

5 !- '"

(( *

)!!"* &+,

; "7* -( #  ;4/ #$* ! 0&

< "

$ 7 8&-9 ! -$ ""$ &!

- 07 /  -* / &!*

 !"

/  --

= ="- * .4 #&,

0"

$ * .4 ((-- --& 

!!( ! ( /  / --
"" * 8&-

= -  "0 (  -(  --* &-

(  &," --  -$"7* 0-  -

 5

 !!- ( 8&-

'"$ $$ 0- $  -  -

 5

* !  -  !!"

, 
(( * " 0* "* / / -(- 0-  - 5 

 

#""

$$ 0-* !  - 0

.

.

 : ,  '"

((

)!!"* &+,* / , -(- 0-  -

5

 (-  &(* , "- , 
& * 4$ "  -  ,0

? -

; 
& * &"

- "7   $&(  0& &  ,"/ 6-- 7 ,   / !!- # , 
"" &(!&7
(( * 8&- 0-  -   

:

3 --  "$ 

 

 * &- <0 ( &+,* /" (4$ / !!( @& -


4  -  6!  $- /7 # , 

- -  -  -  ," &"

! * &  7  0 ;
&  




 

  



! "-  $ $ !   --  ,   & -- / 4- # ,  8(, - 9  (& $0 !    - 7 "(* / " -7 , "- ,




& 3- 0 ;
&   "

  #

$ 

 % &!'()*+ ',



A0  /* 0   - 

 

  , - - $0$ !   -- 0$ 6!  # ,  8(, - * (7 - - 0/* - !    , $0 "7   (  $ --   "( ("

*  -!&- , 
&   !!- --  

7&$ $ 

/ ,&  7  $

3 -!&-  "- (  "-"-$ 0 ( / ((-- "/ 0& &  !!( !



= ! * -  "0 (  -(  --* &-

&," --  -$"7 !!- ( 8&-



3 "- !  ( !!(

8(, - *  , "$"7   - /* 0  / 0/   !,"9 &"   7 ! ""$"7  ! 0 7  

$ -*    , (- +&-$( - - 0 ;
&  8)

 "- - . /  

 01  * ---    , 0- &-


 








 

 



 

 

 











 


 










  
 






 
  

















  
 












2

3

/  

  4 ( 5 

!  "

 4 #/ 6 %

   4 !!)*+(7# 

$  &$  -  !- )!!"" .0"

)& 7 -  ""$"7  ! 0 7  

.&""7* " (  -$"7 -(-



)""

!-$ !!" *  7* ""

- "-

!"!# !

"     

-   

 !4$2 -

B2>

 ! ," B2>