High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/29842/2018allowed

Gurbachan Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2018-09-05Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal7 pages

!"# $%&%!'(

( )*+ +,

! "#$ %&'" (& ! ) &

"*" ""+$ $ *",

"$ %&'" (& )& &- +,-.*/ !

) & ' & ./- &( ! & &( &' !" , ( + (& 1 "!

&( &23- " 4546-42.

' & 7-6$ 7-.$ 7-7$ 7. &( ! " "+ & 8(& !& 9! 9:$ " &+ ' " & !""0;& ' & " " "++ '&1 "+ )&' " !(&0$ & ! ," &( '&0)&0 " % " ,< ! )" & " 2/45-42/$ ! )" < ' & "))" ,(& ! +" "+ & = ++"1"

"$ (& ! "0 '&> " & !

&( ! '&0)&0 '&0)+ "' !&($ )& &( &"+ '

& $ & "$ " 4?4/-42/$

!" , ' %$ <! $ !" , & ' !" ! )" !"% + ! ) "0 '",+# < !& "# (+ '$ '&'

& & ) " & &( ! "''

!"% , '+" " )&'+"

0 &(( ! + 0" "

0$ &,*' % " &"+ &( " + "+ #0 & '&'

+ ! &'

"+ '&(+ ' @"< 1

&+# & !" )&)+ & & !"% & ( ! < ! "'! &! * & )&' ! ! & )&)#$ ! & + ( " + ,# " &! ! '

& !0 ,# ! + "+ #0 ! '

% + ) " ! '&(+ ' ,< <& )" $ !"% + &%& (& ! &'

"+ &$ &'

"+ !"0&# & ! &'

# " '! ' ",&+ (&0 % & ! )" & + ! ) ,# '&0)&0 $ &( '& $ '&0 < ! '"

+ "+ '&1 ' " <++ &<%$ ! ' ) & & '" +# ' !0+% & &+# <& )" & ! ) 0 &( ! '&)$ '&1 ' " ((' ! ' "' & '" ! ((' " '&1 ' % )& ! &'

# " +" !(&$ ! +"< )' , ) !0$ % ) !0 " ! A0 ) !0$ '+

"! )"+# (& ' "+ "' &<%$ 0& &( ! & ! '

% + ) & B '&(+ ' &( <& )" "(&0 !0+% & ' "+ ")' !(&$ ! + "+ #0 )+"# 0) & &+% ! '&(+ ' ,< <& )" > < ! ! " "; &( !" ! "% 0)"' &( ) " &'

# " +" 0 C ++ ! '& "

& &+% !

0 '&(+ ' ,< <& ,# ) & !(&$ % ! ' +"< 1

& % " & ! < ! &( ! )" & ) '& !

) '

)+ &+#$ ! " + "+ #0 "+& )&% (& '& ! '&0)&0 ,< <& &( " ' )

' & 7-4 " A) )&% & !

" !

' & & &+# )&% (& '&0)& ! "+$ , )0 '&0)& % " "))++" & % &"+ " &<% ,# %# " " '&)$

' & 7-4 '"& , ! &+ )& &#> <! ! '& & & " '&0)&0 ,< ! )" !"%> '" +#> & , '&( !

' & +" &+# & ! &((' )' , ! " "+ & ! " " +& 0& &((' )' , & % & ! &((' A ! < 0 & " " (&0 0 & 0$ 0";

! A &((' & , + ! & " % < 0&"+ &( )&&( &( &((' " , '& % < &( '!&+& '"+ "%"'0 !

' " " 1

! (& +&&;

,#& ' & 7-4 & '& ! '&0)&0 ,< ! )" & ) & 0"

! "' # &( ! )&' )' , (& ' "+ "+> ! "+ & '"& , )0 & "%+ ,#& ! '&) )' , !" )&' ' ! (& %&;

' & ./- ,# ! !

& $ " &,% ",&%$ ! < ! &( &+# )" & !

' ) <& + & "+<"# , (( '

& 0 " " ' "+ "+

% < &( ! )"$ +" & ,+ (('> ! '& ' <& + !"% +( " ! &'

# " +" !(& ! &(' '&00 ,# )&

%&+% &%"' & "0 " & (& "'1

&(( '

"+ )&< & <!

+ A'

&(( ' )&< '"& , )0 & , '&0)&0 @ ;< $ % ! &((' %&+% &+# <& ) %" )&$ , (+' )"% # &( '!""' & %&+% '"

&"+ +& &( + ( & '"

&"+ +& &( )&)# ,# A !" &( +& &( + (> '"& , )0 & , '&0)&0 A') ! ",&%B 0 & "% &(('$ ! %# "& !" "++ &! &((' !& + , )0 & , '&0)&0 ,# ! &

' ! )&&( &( &((' ,(& ! & $ " "

<& + %&+% ! '& ' &( ! )" &

) $ !(& ( ! & & & )0 ! "0 & , '&0)&0 ! ! )" <& + & )+"# '; )& ! & & ! "'1

"+ &( "''

,# ,% ! "0 " & &( ' "+ * ' % ! &( "0 " & &( ' "+ * ' & (&' ! '

C & +" " "&) ! '; & , )+"# )& & & ,% ! * ' #0 & <& + "+<"# , ! &( * '

+(> !" ! '&0)&0 ,< ! )" '& C " ! '

C 0"

0&& " '&00 & ! "+ &( ! #0 &( "0 " & &( * '$ " +"$ 1 " !& &(('$ <!

'! ! &(

# & & )0 & , '&0)&0 &9,+ !

)0 & !" "0)+# '+" ( ! + "+ )& & & '& '&0)&0 ! '" &(

!"" !" &,% "

! "

%&'

(

)*+ ,

(

!("

( - "

(

.- -

(

(-(

1 0

(

( *

(

- -

(

( -

(

# "

(

+ ,

! ) '" & & ("++ "#& &( ! A') & % " ",&% '$ % < &( ! )& &( &"+ '

& $ & "$ " 4?4/-42/ 0" ) "' &( ! & " 2/45-42/ )" ,# !

& $ ! & (+ !" & ( + ) )& <& + , % ,# ;) ! )&' "+ % < ++ , !

&( * '$ ( ! +0 "'! ,< ! )" "'') ''& +#$ ! ) ) & "++&< &23- " 4546-42. ' & 7-6$ 7-.$ 7-7$ 7. &( ! " "+ & 8(& !& 9! 9:$ " &+ ' " & !""0;& ' & "

" "++ '&1 "+ )&' " !(&0$ & ! ," &( '&0)&0 " % " ,< ! )" " !,# 1 "! 1 " ! ) ) & . +,/

" D!! )";

= "& E & D!! )&",+ E &