← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9454/2021disposed of

M/S Poonam Transport Company v. The Haryana State Federation Of Consumers Co-Operative Wholesale Stores

2021-08-17The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli3 pages

CWP No. 9454 of 2021 1 

      

!"#$#%&'&()* +, -' (!./!('0/".0!(1  2 #"&"&(#/  3#/'4' 5#!/1!(!6"!"# #$#/!"&(('4.#/'0#/!"&7#58#'!8#6"/#'     #'0($#("'  

         

  

  

/#'#(")* /!4/!750/!96/$7%!"#:&"5 /(4/!;50/!9$7%!"#9/"5#0#"&"&(#/   '654</!6&(;59$$8$7%!"##(#/!89!/1!(!9 /"5#/#'0($#("'

5# !/#'!&$ 0/#'#(%# &' <#&(; /#%/$#$ "5/4;5 7&$# %(#/#(%&(; '&(%# "5# 0/%##$&(;'!/#<#&(;%($4%"#$&(7&/"4!84/"  ====      /!8   5&'0#"&"&(5!'<##(&8#$<1"5#0#"&"&(#/<#&(;!;;/&#7#$ <1"5#/$#/0!''#$<1"5#/#'0($#("*!4"5/&"&#'$#%8!/&(;"5#0#"&"&(#/" <#"#%5(&%!881$&'>4!8&&#$&("#/.'0!/!*

%8!4'# 7&& "5#!/1!(! 6"!"# #$#/!"&(('4.#/'? 0#/!"&7# 58#'!8# 6"/#' @"$  "5# "#($#/#(>4&/1$!"#$  !:!/$&(;%("/!%"/"/!('0/"!"&(:/A /"5#0#/&$  "B B @#!/(#$ '#(&/ %4('#8 / "5# 0#"&"&(#/ '4<.&"' "5!" "5# 0#"&"&(#/ &/. 5!' <##( $&'>4!8&&#$ 4($#/ "5# '!&$ %8!4'# ( !%%4("  <#&(;<8!%A8&'"#$<1"5#/#'0($#("*!4"5/&"&#'#95:#7#/9'4<.&"'!<!/# 0#/4'!8  "5# !88#;#$ /$#/  <8!%A 8&'"&(; $!"#$ ((#C4/#

*D 9.!A#'&"!<4($!("81%8#!/"5!""5#0#"&"&(#/5!'("<##(<8!%A8&'"#$ <4"5!'(81<##(:!/(#$(""/#0#!"'4%5!%"&(4"4/#:&"5!'"&048!"&( "5!"&&"$#''9"5#0#"&"&(#/&/.:48$<#<8!%A8&'"#$!($"5#'#%4/&"1 '5!88<#/#&"#$

CWP No. 9454 of 2021 2 @#!/(#$ '#(&/ %4('#8 / "5# 0#"&"&(#/ 4/"5#/ '4<.&"' "5!" "5# 0#"&"&(#/ &/. 5!' &(!%" '4<.&""#$ !( !&$!7&" &$#("&%!881 &( '&.&8!/ "#/.'!'.#("&(#$&(0!/!*

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

/;#'9 "5#!4"5/&"&#'5!7#&''4#$!:!/(&(;""5#0#"&"&(#/"5!"&(%!'#'4%5!%" &' /#0#!"#$9 "5# 0#"&"&(#/ &/. :48$ <# <8!%A 8&'"#$ !($ "5# '#%4/&"1 $#0'&"#$<1&":48$<#/#&"#$ (<#&(;%(/("#$:&"5"5#!/#'!&$/$#/98#!/(#$%4('#8 !00#!/&(;/"5#/#'0($#("'!&/81'4<.&"'"5!""5#/$#/$!"

((#C4/# *D  $#' (" <8!%A 8&'" "5# 0#"&"&(#/?' &/. 4" 0#(!8"1 :!' &.0'#$40("5#0#"&"&(#/?'&/.:5&%5&(%84$#'!'4. ' 9-*!($ ((*0!1.#("  "/!('0/"!"&( %5!/;#'  7#5&%8#   D+**  

',-*:#7#/9'5#'4<.&"'"5!""5#0#"&"&(#/:!'$#%8!/#$"<#((* /#'0('&7#$4#"4/(&'5&(;:/(;!&$!7&"0#(!8"1/&'"/&%" !(&0!" ( "5# 8&;5"  "5# !<7# '"!"#.#("  8#!/(#$ %4('#8 / "5# /#'0($#("!':#88!'"5#04/0/"!($&.0/""5#/$#/$!"#$

((#C4/# *D 9 :# !/#  "5# %('&$#/#$ 0&(&( "5!" "5# !4"5/&"&#' !/#

CWP No. 9454 of 2021 3 /#>4&/#$"/#*#C!.&(#"5#&''4#"#%5(&%!87&!<&8&"1"5#0#"&"&(#/?'&/. &( "5# 8&;5"  "5# /$#/ $!"#$ ((#C4/# *D  !($ "5#/#!"#/ 0/%##$4/"5#/&("5#"#($#/0/%##$&(;' 5#0#"&"&(&8#$<1"5#0#"&"&(#/&'!%%/$&(;81$&'0'#$ $&/#%"&(; "5# /#'0($#("*!4"5/&"&#' " /#%('&$#/ "5# &''4#  "#%5(&%!8 7&!<&8&"1"5#0#"&"&(#/?'&/.&("#/.'0!/!*

%8!4'#*7&&"5#"#($#/ ("&%#!($"5#//#>4&/#.#("'"5#"#($#/:#7#/9&(7&#:"5#!%" "5!" "5&' 4/" <1 !( &("#/&. /$#/ 5!$ '"!1#$ 4/"5#/ 0/%##$&(;' &( "5# "#($#/9 "5# '!&$ !//!(;#.#(" :48$ %("&(4# "&88 "5# !4"5/&"&#' "!A# ! $#%&'&(("5#"#%5(&%!87&!<&8&"1"5#0#"&"&(#/?'&/.&(!%%/$!(%#:&"5 8!: " &' .!$# %8#!/ "5!" "5&' /$#/ '5!88 (" %('"&"4"# !(1 #C0/#''&(0&(&(("5#.#/&"'"5#%!'##&"5#/0!/"1  

36E      6



 @@   

+,