The Oriental Insurance Company Limited v. Shakuntla Devi And Another
" #$%$ & '
(#) *
+ ,
+
-----.. //
0 (%1%
,2+ 0
---- %. &" &
' 3+
,- ,
+, ++
( % & '
(--- 1.
"4 #
+, ++*
-
)$%
7 $&8
9 & 1.
($&8
)( 18) 4$"
# &! ( &#$&8
7(
&" 6$#* 0 :-
)$%
..
!$/ "
# 6.
#) // &8$&8
--* %% "
##$" &
/ $6% /*
21(19%)
) ( $& ( ! (( "
/=-
($ !
& # %% (;
">1"$#
1&" ( , #
0 )$#/ % # :??* !$/ "
$6$&8
## 1&
% & <) $6 "
"$ "
($&8
A@*
- / !$/ "
% 9$&8
%-@ 9)%- # $6 "
% &
(&$&8
%16
%- A*C . ( )- # &
%-
// <$&8 $%%1 % < ( !( 6 "
%$%
"$&8
$ %'
- D)
( %1/ $&8
& 8/$8 &#
<)$/
($&8
A@E
- !
$%%1
.( 4 "*
<)
6 1&
!( 6 <) 6*
- D)
4$ /
# &"$ $ &%
. /$#;
/$
$ &E
@- /$ !-
# &%$" ($&8
4$" &# # &#/1" "
"$ "
$&>1($ % ( # $4 "
)$6
($&8
A@*
-
<)$/ # &%$" ($&8
1&%9$// "
7 1( (*
%% %% "
$&# 6
%-FC . (
(" "
%16 %-?*?*C
%*
$/ "
1&" ('
&&1 $&# 6
: *C
-
1 1(
.( %. #
AG
$- -
: *H*?I
* @*C
-
AG " "1#
("% . (% & /$4$&8
J. &% % $- - * @*CI
AF*C
@-
1/ $./$ (
" .
@
A-
+ %%
A*C
-
1& ( J. &% %
A*C
F-
?*?*C
4 ) 6 &
(81 %
$" &
7/$%) "
% -
%176$
&# //
%176$
. /$#
) ($ $ % AA
-@-
J-@- !1( ( ! (%
6 #) &$#
?-A-
J-:
%176$
. (
$"
" &
! 1&"
$&%. #
(* .( 4 "
$"
$&4 /4 "
)1%* /$
&&
! $%
!1( %176$
61/ $./$ ( @ <( &8/;
../$ "- %
6
7 1
F (%
8 *
) ( ! ( 61/ $./$ ( %) 1/"
../$ "-
)1% .( ; "
.( % &
..
// < "-
8 &
)( 18)
!$/
< //
# .;
6 #) &$#
" #16 &
! (6
7 ! (
/* ( ! (( "
"1($&8
# 1(% ($&8-
"6$
"/;*
!$/ "
1&" ( , #
#
% 9$&8
## 1&
% &* 6 /;
-@- - #16 &
(;
4$" &#
.( 4 % - ;
<$ & %%
,1( > )
$!$ "
D-
" &;
J-@
( "
$- - -@- - D ,1( > )
%. #$!$# //;
6 & $ & "
4 //$&8
/ &8<$ 7(
% "
(#;#/ 7 $&8 "($4 &
% "- D 8$4 &
$/%
K1 %
%1##$&#
&& (- 8$%
&167 (
%. #$!$# //;
6 & $ & "
- D (/;
1&# (
K1 %
% / /;
4 )$#/ - D #( %% J 6$&
!/ "
!( 6
%.
9 &
&# //
%176$
$&/;
%$% 6 #) &$#
J-:* <) ( $&
" &
#- ! 1&"
($8) 7% (4 "
.( .
( "
?-A- <) (
9 &
) ( ! ( * . %%$7$/$
4$&8 ( .
$( "
<$ )$&
7 1
;% &&
(1/ "
( 4 (*
%166 & "
($ 1(
4$"
(" (
-- :
J-
($ /-
.($&#$.
.( # "$&8% 1&" (
#
.( 4
1#)% .( . &" ( .( 7 $ %
.( 4
7 ; &"
% & " 17 ! ( &#
( 8 $&!1//;
>1"86 &
&=7/ ,1.( 6 1(
!" "- &
.( % &
% *
$&" "
%1## %%!1//;
.( 4 "
1#)% .( . &" (
.( 7 $ %- %%1
# (( # " #$" "
!$&"$&8
( %. #
1.) /"- ) ( "$%.1
( 8 ("$&8
"1/;
$&%1( "
# 6.
4$ /
# &"$ $ &%
. /$#;-
(816 &
$% "
61/ $./$ (
@ $&# (( #
../$ "
7/ * ) &# ( > # "-
@A (%
61/ $./$ ( @ %*
)1%* # (( #
../$ "
>1"86 &
&=7/ ,1(. 6 1(
:
$4$/ FF-
. %$
61/ $./$ (
../$ "
<$ ( ! ( &#
<$ ( ! ( &#
! ( &#
( 8 $&!1//;
>1"86 &
&=7/ ,1.( 6 1(
#$ ! % "! &'(- //
$%%1 % # (( # " #$" "
/* 7( 9
(! ( &# -
. $&
$// 8 /$ ;*
. (4 (%$ $&!$(6$
$6.18& "
--* %% "
##$" & / $6% /* 21(19%) //%
(! ( &#
1(
$&%
$&%1( # 6.
&;-
(816 &
""( %% "-
..
## ("$&8/;
"$%6$%% "
<$ (" (
# % %-
+$%
$//
(#) *
1"8
D) %.
9$&8C( % & "
'
%C
D)
'
%C