High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/633/1998disposed of

Ram Singh & Others v. State Of Haryana

2026-01-12Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja3 pages

$ &" $# &" $# &" $# &" $# A$#665- .

A$#665- .

A$#665- . 2**$! 2**$! 2**$! 2**$!< < < < = = = = <=<

<=<

<=<A

'' ((&!"

'$!4 !"

'$!4 !"-.

!" #$

&* &D&%%9((+4?$2&" "% &'' ((&!"

)%*!&%&*!+ +&,&!

!& FFFF + - &(.

+ - &(.

/0 , 1&, $# ' !" &'' &(-.+ 2%&( (( !3 %& ) ! (&*4 "$ "% 1 1&4 4&" 45 66 67'& 4),"% ( &! 444( *"*2"943 + &*"%&(-% *!& #" "$) # 4& &"% 8 # !2 $9":. 1% ), B&D " ?&(9 $#"% (&!4 1 1*"% ===>E' &2 ' 2""$&2;9* *"*$!1& !%&!2 4"$ <+<=+= /<0 * #(,"&"*!3+*!"% ' !"2& + +(&!4B &9*!3 =&2 *"9& &" 4 1*"%*!"% ? !

!9 "&" $#?*((&3 %&!4+ % %*(&!4*"*2" &*"%&(2&B "$ $) &2;9* 4?*4 $"*#*2&"*$!4&" 4 =5 66@&!

!4=C < 66@*9 49!4 2"* $! @A$#"% &!

!42;9**"*$!2"+56@-#$% %$""% 856@2":. ' 2"*? (, #$ "% '9)(*2'9'$ $ !&B (,#$2$!"92"*$!$# 1%&!4, E'&+#$(($1 4 4), &! 1&4 '& 4 ), "% &!4 2;9**"*$! $(( 2"$ -#$ %$" 8"% :.

$! = = 66C "% ), 4 " B*!*!3 "% B&D " ?&(9 $# "% &2;9* 4 (&!4 &

+<=+===>E'

&2 ) *4 &1&4$#&(($"% "&"9"$,) ! #*" /@0 3 33* ? 4 "% $#+ "% &'' ((&!

!"E(&!4$1! *!?$D 4 # !2 9!4 2"*$! 5$#"% 56@2"+1%*2%2&B "$) '&"(,&(($1 4),"% ( &!

! 4

# !2 $9 "?*4 *"&1&44&" 45 6 667+1%*( 3&!"*!3"% B !%&!

2 4 2$B' !&"*$! G G <+<=+===>E ' &2 ) * *4 &1&4*!3 &(( $"% "&"9"

"$, ) ! #*">*!" " *!"% *#&?$99!4 "% 56@ 2"

*E&"*#* 41*"%"% 1 1&4 '& 4 ), "% ( ( &! 4 # !2 $9"+ "% '

!" &'' &( 1& ' # 4 &" "% B !"

*!"&!2 $#(&!4$ $1! D*!3#9"% !%&!2 B /C0 % %&? % &4 ( &! 4 2$9! ( #$ "% '&"* &!4 3$! "%$93% "% '&' )$$D&1 1 ((& 2$4$#"% 2& -.

#*!49)"&!2 *!"% 9)B** $! B&4 $!) %&(# $#"% &'' ((&!">(&!4$1!

/A0 '

' 9&( $# "% *B'93! 4 &1&4 4 %$1 "%&" "% B&D " ?&(9 1 1& & 4),"%

1%*( (,*!39'$!

& $ 66>6A"*"( 48 D* &B& &!4 $"% "&"

:-H

E@.4 2*4 4$!5 =6 6 667+1% ),"% B&D "?&(9 1 1& & 4G < <+<=+===>E' &2 /70 "* &B&"" $# 2$4"%&""% '

'$!4 !">"&" 4*4!$"2%&(( !3 "% *B'93! 41& 44&" 45 667'& 4),"% % ( &! 4 # !2 $9"

"% *" %& ) ! '$* *!" 4 $9" "%&" "% 1&4 4&" 4 4 5 =6 667 '& 4 *!

& $ 66>6A-H

E@.&( &4,"&!4B$4*#* 4), "%*$9"?*4 *"4 2**$!4& &" 4 <=<C'& 4*!

$ <=7=$#665

$ <=7=$#665"*"( 48 DD* &B- 2 DD* &B- 2 DD* &B- 2 DD* &B- 2 & 4."%$9 4."%$9 4."%$9 4."%$9 $93% 93% $93% 93%

&!4

&!4 $ $ $ $ "&" $# &,&!& "&" $# &,&!& "&" $# &,&!& "&" $# &,&!&: &!4 "% B&D " ?&(9 "&!4 & 4 G

+<=+===>E'

&2 &$!"% 4&" $#!$"*#*2 2&"*$!9!4 2"*$!@$#"% 5 56@ 2"'9)(*% 4$!

!=A =6 66@ /50 !?

?* 1"% $#+"% ' !"&'' &( *4*'$ 4$#*!"% &B " B $# 4 2**$!4&" 4 <=<C'& 4*! DD* &B DD* &B DD* &B DD* &B B- 2 & 4."%$93%

&!4 B- 2 & 4."%$93%

&!4

: 2& -9'&.&!4 4"% B&D "?&(9 *!"% ' !

!"2& &1 ((*+"%9& 4 4G

+<=+===>E '

&2 *! #&?$9 $# "% &'' ( ((&!">(&!4$1! ! &44*"*$!+ "% (&!4$1! %&( ((&($) !"*"( 4#$&1&4$#& &(("&"9"$,) ! #*"&!4*!" "

'$?*4 4 9!4 "% '$?**$! $# "% 56@ 2" -&B !4 4 9'"$ "$ 4&" .

% (&!4$1! %&( (( &($ ) !"*"( 4 #$$(&"*9B G =I ) *4 &1&4 $#*!"

" "% 9'$!&1 (( /60 J% % ? "% (&!4$1! -. %&>% %&? 9!#$"9!&" (, H'* 4 *! "% &'' &(-.>2$E$ $)K 2"*$!-.&#" #*(*!3"% $# &!4"% ( 3&(% *%&? !$") ! *B'( &4 4+ "% , , %&(( ) &" (*) ", "$ D H 29"*$! $# "% ' !" 4 2**$! ), B$?*!3&''$'

*&" &''(*2&"*$!-.) #$ "% ( & &! 4H 29"*!3$9"

/=0 * '$ 4 $# $! "% &)$? " B (( ' !4*!3 &''(*2&"*$!-.+ *# & &!,+ %&((&($"&!44 4*'$ 4$#

. &!9&, &!9&, &!9&, &!9&,< < < <++++<= <= <= <=< "*D - - - - A J% J% % "% ' &D*!3> &$! 4 % "% '$"&)( >$ >$