← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/131/2021dismissed

Charanjit Kaur v. Jagtar Singh

2021-03-16Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill5 pages



     



  !"!#$%$&' (#)*+ )(&,$ -.( //!00&  1!(%.% 2 ($&2)  !%/&"!&    '3  45

 555

(!%!& '

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

%++A3 (6 )! /0$& $ &" /(6$%!"  (! .(& )! %6! & "!6&" 0&2>$ )$& !(!%   )!( !C/!(6& ) $%.( )!(/0!"!" ) //!00& @ "!!&"& !D!#. !"/(& !&"(!#!$/ " !"*B>)$#)>%%#($9!"9= )!

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

00>$&2$%%.!%>!(!(6!"& )!9%$% )!/0!"$&2%'3  E)! )!( )!/0$& $$%!& $ 0!"  )!(!0$!(!#7!(=%/(=!" (H

  E)! )!( )!6.& /(& !&"(!#!$/ $%0$90! 9!"!#0(!" .&0>.0&"7$"H   E)! )!( )! 6.&   /(& ! &" (!#!$/  &" $ % (&%# $& "!!  )! /(7$%$&%  !# $&   )! &"$& & (#  # H

 B E)! )!(/0$& $)%& #6!  )!#.( >$ )#0!&)&"%H  G E)! )!( )!%.$ /0$& $)%& 9!!&/(/!(0=70.!"H  * !0$! 7$"!&#!>%0!"9=9 ) )!/( $!% 5!(&!" ($0 #.(   !( #&%$"!($&2 )! # %+ #$(#.6% &#!% &" !7$"!&#!&(!#("#&#0."!" )  )!/0$& $)"/(7!")$%#%!D!#. $& )! /(& ! &" (!#!$/ + $  $% 9%!(7!"+ >% "6$ !" &" "!!&"&  @ //!00&  $0!" /(7!&=(."(6$%(!/(!%!&  $&  )!)&"% )!/0$& $ 0$& $ >%+ ).%+)!0"!& $ 0!" (!#7!(%.6 %++A3>$ )$& !(!%   )!( !

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

0$& $ )% %/!#$$#00= %  !" )  )! 6.&  $& F.!% $& >% 9((>!"9="!!&"& @//!00& ".! )!((!F.$(!6!& ("6!% $#/.(/%!%

0$& $".0= !% $$!"9!(! )!0!(&!" ($0.( % E&">%% !"% $& )$% !% $6&=#($9! )!/(& !&" )!(!#!$/ @ E%7!!($&2))%0% !% $$!"(!2("$&2!D!#. $& )!%6!9= )!"!!&"& @//!00& $&7.( )!/0$& $ !("6$ $&2 )!#& !& % )!%6! 9! (.!/!#$$#!& (=$& (!%/!#   )!(!#!$/ &"/(& !)%9!!&/(7!"$& )!(!2$% !(6$& $&!"9=

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

$/  " !" *B &"   )! %6! $6! %)! )% "!&$!" )!( %$2& .(!%& )!%$""#.6!& % !0$&#!)%9!!&%.2)  9!/0#!"& )! (!#!$/ %D D*$! )!(!#!$/ %%  !" )7!9!!&$%%.!"9= )!/0$& $  !((!#!$7$&2%.6 %G+A3 )%9!!&!D/0$&!"9= E+/0$& $ )  %$"(!#!$/ %>!(!$%%.!"9= )!/0$& $$&7.($9$&2)%&%)>( $&2) $! ).%9&"  )! //!00&  @ )(&,$  -.( $& (!%/!#    %.

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

%G+A3&0=  )!/0$& $$& )!$(/(!%!&#!&G&" )!=>!(!&  >(!$&=90&#!6.& >%(!/$" !!(!&#!  !% $6&=E&"> $%  & 7$0  )! //!00&  5!(&!" #.( % 9!0> )7! (! .(&!" #&#.((!&  $&"$&2%# +9%!"./&/(/!(//(!#$ $& )!!7$"!&#!&(!#(" -!!/$&2$&7$!> )!# %&"#$(#.6% &#!%+ )!(!$%&F.!% $& 0>+6.#)0!%%%.9% & $0F.!% $&0>+>)$#)$%$&707!"(#&%$"!( $&$& )$%(!2.0(%!#&"//!0  )!((2.6!& )%9!!&""(!%%!" 5!(&!"#.&%!0( )!//!00& $%.&90! /$& . &=$00!20$ =+ $&$(6$ =(/!(7!(%$ =$&$6/.2&!",."26!& &""!#(!!" !"<</%%!" 9= )!0!(&!"$7$0."2!.&$($7$%$& 2%>!00%,."26!& &""!#(!! " !" ? /%%!" 9= 0!(&!" $% ($#  ."2!+ 2+ >)$#) #00% ( &= $& !(!(!&#!9= )$%.( $&%!#&"//!0 ##("$&20=+ )$%//!0$%"$%6$%%!">$ )&("!(% #% % 5$%$00

(#)*+ ."2!

% E)! )!(%/!:$&2A(!%&!" '!%A E)! )!((!/( 90! '!%A