High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8935/2022allowed

Pawan Kumar Verma And Another v. State Of Haryana And Others

2022-12-21Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj30 pages

! " #

$%$&'$ ( ) #**# # "+$ (, "$-.%.() *#* # #

!" &/0$ 1# $%&' '()$*+'),&

$ '-.')*+')

$ '/'011','()*+''

$0&'2')*+') 3& 4&& $

$ *0%&'-&')($$5$'/'') %6789:6 ; $

$. 1& '1)5)-<'4) %678=86 ; $ >>>>

2 "

3# " #

?'+-('

'14&'(33& '' &' ' ' +22 @- 3 (', ' 3 2' & '

)&+)4&&+'+'4+4/'+22$ & 3'+ ' 41 A'+ 32 ( ' B4 506& 2$&6 (+7$& 2%# 3++$ (, &1 (+7$&%$C "3(/ -22'D) & 3'+ 3 & +' ' &' &

' & + 3 & %2 '/ '2(/ .- -( *' ?2 &'3 3 ' E.-F ' '+& 5' "(1 *' ?2 &'3 3 ' E'+&F$ & ' %2 ' &' - '*2 & , '

& /' ; *1 '

(+' ' 3 '((2 3 5' %/( '(& ' 3 '4(&1 5' 1+&'3-<'4''/''$ --' & ' *' 3 '((2 3 '(& G4-& 3 & +2 ') *'( '

(+' , +* 4/ & %2 '$ 3 +-/ 3 & '

(+' ' - + 3 @- (+ 3 ' ,(( ' +-/ ) & +2 ' - +3+' 3 '(& *'- '

(+'$ . '* &' & +2 ' &'* * &-1 '2- 3 1 - ' 3 '((1 4(1 (' '+ & +-/ ' 4' (+G 2 32 *'-'-/'-&3 ('' -'') '&/''&'' ?-&''-<'4$&%2 '''&'*,0'3'+/ ,&&'(G4-',(('&+-2)&,*)-3'(( & +- + & ''( 2'0) 4+'2 +22+'((/ -*'4( 3 & +2 ' 33 '2 + * '( 4/ & 5*2-4D+2 '$'++-3+&'1&5*2

(+/)&+2 '+-( *&1'+/('&-4D ' 1*1 - 4, & +2 ' ' & 4- '1' + +' & ?5 5'G63((1 +&'1 +$ & '(G4-3- '/&+''2-&+/(' +'/ ,& & %2 '$ '- .

,& '(2 +'( '((1' , (1 *'- + & ' 3 -<'4 ' '/''3+22333+-+=;H)= ;' ;6"3 &.''(%$ & )'-:; .

' 1 43*'-(,%-3-<'4''/''$%$789:6 ; &' 43(4/& '1& .

1&'3 '/'',&(%$78=86 ; &'43(,& +&*'-

&'&'41&'3-<'4$ & &'* '/ &' & '( 1 43 *'-'(%-'1-3&' .

& +*'2'/ 4+(-441&'%-'3-'2'(1&$$&1&(3 ' '((4/3& 41*('-2-(-3 '(3+1& 2&' :'/'2&'

'1 %-'&$.'*&'&-33'+'01(( & (/ &/+'((/'2'((/4-'(3'+'((/$&

' @- '

' 33 %- & '2 ') (' & -421 '

(+' 3 01 A2 $ . 3-&A & &'&+'++* '0 '1'&2+-& + 1'($.3-&'* & &'&'((1'(*((& .

'+'($$&' '((1'1'1 '/232/'1132 $ :;G6 $;;;G6 &'*1 4 ' ' '

(+' 3 ' 3 &'*1 & '2-

'11 4, $ ('+ $: ('+ ,' (++ 3) $ ('+ '

+1 3) $I ('+ ' +-/ 3 ' 1'1 ' '2- '11 32 $:('+ $ :('+''*'+3'((23&5'%/( ,&+&&'- -(/4'((-4@-(/$ &'(3&*'-+'1&'3-<'4 ''/''',(('&'-'4-(''-#6 3

! 3#

(# ".%++# 3#

(# 8% .9 7&/$ 3+/$ (,

$-$+

3++0% +.99

*# # "

37$$+$ "+$

. 99G= = ;G=;H ?? 6 $ $I 9;$;8$ ;:

+- *+

''+ @- ;=6;76 ; $$ ? .

. IHGH = ;G=;HG9= ?? 6 G=G7 $ $ ;I +- *+

''+ @- ;=6;76 ; $$

;7G:

= ;G=;HG:;H ?? 6HG8GI $;$ ;=

''+ 3+ 99%% '2

''+ @- ;96;96 ; $$%.

;IG:

= ;G=;HG:;H ?? 6:G7GI $;$ ;= +- *+

''+ @- ;96;96 ; $$%.

H9:GH = ;G=;HG:;HG ;"G ; ?? 6 G8GI H$;$ ;7

''+ 3+&'1 3'2 "- :$;=$ ;

$$" . 9;7G:

= ;G=;HG ;"

?? 6 GIGI :$;H$ ;H +- *+

''+ @- 7$;9$ ;

$$%. .

I !!!

=7G:

= ;G=;HG9=G ;"

?? 6 G G7 8$$ ;I +- *+ "- 7$;9$ ;

$$!!!

!!!

89G:

= ;G=;H ?? 6:G:G7 :$;=$ ;7 +- *+ 7 6 H$;=$ ;

$$? %%' . H;G= = ;G=;HG ;"

?? 68G9G7 I$;I$ ;I

''+ 3+&'1 3'2

''+ @- ;$;:$ ;

$G$ ;

. I6-1 =;HG= ;G ;"

?? 6 G=G7 $;=$ ;I +- *+ "- ;:$;8$ ;

$$. %.

. 77G= = ;G=;HG ;"

?? 6 G G7 :$;8$ ;I +- *+

''+ @- ;:$;$ ;

$$ ?.

!. = ;G=;H ?? 67G7G7 +- *+

''+ @- 7$;9$ ;

9 . IGH =;HG= ;G=HIG =H7G=I ?? 6:G GI H$;I$ ;I +- *+ "- 9$;:$ ;

$$. 9 7G= = ;G=;HG ;"G ; ?? 6IG9G7 =$;8$ ;I +- *+

''+ @- $;=$ ;

= . $$. %.

. 7 8G:

= ;G=;HG ;"G ; ?? 6IG9G7 =$;8$ ;I +- *+ "- :$;=$ ;

$$%. . H

:IGH =;HG= ;G=8 ?? 6 9G:G7 I$;=$ ;7

''+ 3+&'1 3'2

''+ @- ;:$ $ ;

$$%.

GI = ;G=;H ?? 67G GI ;7$;$ ;I

'( '1-2

''+ @- I$;8$ ;

$$ ? 7 % ? I6 ' = ;G=;HG ;"

?? 6 7G9G7 ;7$;$ ;I +- *+

''+ @- 8$;=$ ;

$$.! I6!-( = ;G=;HG ;"

?? 69GIG7 ;$;=$ ;7

''+ 3+&'1 3'2 8 ?

''+ @- 7$;9$ ;

$$ " ;

!!!

9=:G:

= ;G=;HG ;"

?? 6HGIG7 ;H$;:$ ;7

''+ 3+&'1 3'2

''+ @- =$;:$ ;

$$%. "

5 ??

9I7GI = ;G=;H ?? 6G;G7 ;I$$ ;7

''+ 3+&'1 3'2

''+ @- ;7$;=$ ;

$$%. ??

." =GI = ;G=;H ?? 6IGG8 9$;$ ;7 +- *+ "- $;=$ ;

$$ "??"5 . ;HG7 = ;G=;HG ;"

?? 6 IG G8 =$;$ ;8

''+ 3+&'1 3'2

''+ @- 8$;9$ ;8 $$" ? = ?

9 ;G:

= ;

?? ?.6 G G8)& 9G7G ;I 9$;:$ ;I

''+ 3 '2 +99 %% "- ;=$;I$ ;

$$%. ? :

"..

I6 4 = ;G=;H ?? 6 :G G ;7 =$; $ ;7

''+ 3+&'1 3'2 "- 7$;9$ ;

$$".. %.

.??. "..

I6!- = ;G=;HG=HIG =H7G=I ?? 6 :G G ;7 =$; $ ;7

''+ 3+&'1 3'2

''+ @- 7$;=$ ;

$$".. %.

.??. 8=G I

= ;G=;HG ;"G ; ?? 6 G;9G ; H$;$ ;7

''+ 3+&'1 3'2 +(' 7$$ ; 7$;=$ ;

$$ 7$ $I !. ;G:

= ;G=;HG=HIG =;7G=H7G=I ?? 6;G;=G7 ;$; $ ;I +- *+ ?'

-/ '

'$ $;=$ ;

$$? ?

I9G:

= ;G=;H ?? 6 ;9G;=G ;7 9$;:$ ;I

''+ 3 '2 +99 %% "- 8$;=$ ;

$$?. 9;

9=IG ;:

.% ?? 6;G;=G ;

7$$ ;:

''+ "- 9

8:G= = ;G=;HG9= ;H$;:$ ;

$$ ?.

;G:

= ;G=;HG ;"

+ '/"'( ((, 6 .? $$% 98G= = ;G=;H 6

." $$ "??"5 3

3# (# ".%++# 3#

(# 3$-+.(% .9 7&/$ 3+/$ (, %$ "

37$$+$ "+$

5 =7G= = ;G=;H ((,'6 9G8G7 G GI "- $;=$ ;

$$ .

H9G:

= ;

((,'6 IG G7 GG7

'(<-12 ',' ;:$;:$ ;

$$%.

:G= = ;G=;HG ;" ((,'6 HG GI +- *+ 7$;=$ ;

$$J.

= .? :9G= = ;G=;H ((,'6 =G7G7 HGG:

''+3 <-12 8$;=$ ;

$$%. :

9I:G= = ;.% ((,'6 8G7G7 G GI +3+&'1 3'21 ;=$;:$ ;

$$%.

.??.

97G= = ;.% ((,4- '*'('4( G GI +' '

''+3 +&'13'2 7$;9$ ;

$$ 5?

I .

9HG= = ;G=;HG =;8G ;"

((,'6 =G:G7 "'('4(,'' - :$;=$ ;

=79G= = ;.% ((,'6 ;G;G7 G GI +' '

''+3 +&'13'2 ;=$;:$ ;

$$%.

.??. .? HIG= = ;

((,'6 =GG8 :G;G7

''+3 +&'13'2 :$;=$ ;

$$5

;

"? 7G:

= ;G=;H ((,'6 HGG7 IGG ;7

''+3 +&'13'2 ;=$;$ ;

$$%.

.??. "? .? 9G7 = ;G=;H ((,'6 GG8 IGG ;7 ?'

-/ '

''+3 +&'13'2 8$;9$ ;

$$ . . .?

:G:

= ;G=;HG ;" ((,'6 =G G ;I

''+ @- ;7$;H$ ;

$$J.

77G:

= ;G=;HG ((,'6 IG G ;7 "- 9$;9$ ;

G9G ; ;

$$%.

= !?

7GH = ;G ;"

((,'6 G9G ; ; IGG ;7

''+3 +&'13'2 H$;=$ ;

$$". "? ?

9H:G= = ;

1&1& +- 7GIG ;7

''+ @-- +21' :$;=$ ;

$$ H

=9G:

= ;G=;H .% ((,'6 GIG7 8GG ;7

''+ $$ ?5 I

77G= = ;G=;H ((,'6 GIG7 9G G ;I

''+ I$;=$ ;

$$". .

7 ;IGH =;HG= ;G ;" ((,'6 G G7 ;G9G ;7

''+ $$ 5 8

:HGH I= ((,

''+ ;=$;:$ ;

$$"? %.

.??. .'*&'&+'4'3 ('+'*

<-+'&'& & ''33&2'

-/ '

'(/3&2(*$ --' & + -) (/ 4/ ,'/ 3 '33'* 3 - 3 (+) !&'<<' 4&'(3 3 $9 7 &' 43(,&,''*&'& '/2'4/& 2++*'&'&+(-4413& .

2 24(-& % 3 %2'( +- 3 & &'3 3 ' %$$%$ ++ 8%$$%$+2 ('+(-4413'2'A2-2-243 &+'+22,&' 3/',&(+ ;%$$%)$

*3'+22'(3333+++1& 32 '3&'2''+$& &'- ('1-24 3*&'3-<'4''/'''33''+ , +22 ' 33 ('+$ -('(/) .

&'* 4 1&(/

1'&' ('+'+&'3-<'4''/''$. '('*&'& '&*+24-'& '3 +2$&,'*+2'33 ('+&'*4A'2' ,-(4 4(++(-&'(' '++'& .

' +(-44 1&$ . ,' '( - &' & '- 3 & +' 33 + %- ' '' ' &' 2'/ 4 A +&'4*'+'4+(-441&$

'- '- G ( , 3( 4/ & +* $$ (+ 33+'( % $7H=86 ; ,& &/ &' 1* '( 3 *'- +' 1 ,& & <-+ ' & '-3&'($&(1'(-'&33+-(1'1+(-4413 +' , 2(' & 4<+ ' 4/ & ' 3 '/'' &'&'*'('/43'4*''41' '* '3&'034*/$ ?'+-('

'13& &''1-&'&

&' &'* 4 1 '1' & ' & '++-

&' 33 '- & ' 3 -<'4 ' '/'' &-1& +'( '((1' 1'1 & '- 3 33+) & 2' 3 & '((1+223&33+' 3& G' +'($ 2-+& ) & +2 ('' &'* &2(* ' *'-

&'&/+'20,&'& .

&'*'(414/ &'( 2 1&2(1&+2 ('311& .

1$ ++- & .

' '( '2 ' '

' 32 & +2 ('' ' 32'( , 4 A'2) * '(( & 2''( ,'*+2'&'2$+&'1&'3''( '1'( '3+( 3&%-3.''&'&'4*

'1&3& 413'4/-4<+1& '

' ' ('1 -24 3 '( ' 33 ('+$ 2-+& ) &

' @- '

'2-('-(/ '33 ('+ & '2 ' 3 &'1 ,&+& '2- -&1 &2 +-'((/ * &-1&&+2/42$.&'4+22 4(3&

''+&'*/'3&'1'33 ('+' &' +)&'((3'41('/$&''(*&2(/ '1-&''&33+-(/,&+&'&'&'('33 ('+ (' +'+/ <-12 4/ & %-$ &' -42 &' &

, +*+ 4/ & %- ' -'2 * <-12 ' ;=$ $ ;8,&'&/&'*4'+@-4/&%-'& '&1'& '&4*<-12' :$;$ ; $3-&'1-&'&<-12 3'+@-'(&'4 '4/&(,%-'3+1&'&-

(/ &' 4

- 3(-+-' & + 3 +- ( & .''( '0$ * & '( %- ' ''( &' '+@- &

;= +' & '4* 1-$ + &' & (/ -414<+'4/& 1'1&+*+ +'-&+2 ('''&,'&'&&'4<+ +' -+& +*+ '0 +' 3 ' 3 & '( @- ' '3-4@-&+13&*+3&+2 ('' '-4<+& 41A2 32 '('

''+$ +&'& &'((3-&&@--'0143& ++%-'14<+&*+41+& '4+ ' & + 3 & +-( 2 3 & 2'' 3 + ;:%$$%$

%*1 & '1-2 '*'+ 4/ & (' +-( 3& )&(''+-(&'*'1-&'& '/2' 4/ & (0(/ +'- +*+ ' &'& & +2 ('' ' ,(( ' & ,$ &/ 3-& + &' +*+3&'++-+'*&3&*+2' ,(('&,,&''

'43 +*%- $ & ' , +' 4 2' '*( '/ & ('+ ,& & +'2'/4'3$&/3-&-42&'& &'*-1& '3 3 & +') &,*) & ++ ' *6K6* & +2 (''& +*+'&'*42 ('' ''-+&)& *4236<3 +'/ '$ . '('1-&'&1*'+3& ('1(/ '++- 3 & '4(/ ' '(( ' 43 & +*.(('@-' '1''&'&/+''+-'((/2*''

(+' 301A2 32 '('

''+-+ ;:%$$%$ ''-+&)&+*++('24-334/& +' 4-(/$ ?'+-(3& &''1-&' +'/ 3 & 2 ('& +* +2 ('' &+''' '/6 & '& &'*4<+&+'41'3'3&+2 (''' &+-+'(,'A'2'& +* ('+,&&'( '+-(/ 1'G,&& +*.(('@-' '1'$") & +-1'1+/&+'&''&+2 ('',& ' (/ ' & ' *1 +'$ + & ' 41

4/' +-1'1+/)&3-&+/2 (' &' $ . &'* &' & (' +-( '

'1 4&'(3 3 & +* ''&'*'(1&-1&&+-2'

,& &' ,&&'4(''+$ "3 +13-&&2'),-(4'

' 2'0 ' 3+ & '- 3 & +' 1 '1' &

$-22'/3-+&+'4'1 .

$H9:' ;$ $ ;H 1'(+')&'&4')+ --0&')3+22 333+-+= ;):;H'9=.%A'+'-#6

!"# #!

" $%

#& ! '&&(# & )

! + ! ,-. + .(# / /) /

" / .# 0

#12

3 ) %" 0 ) +# 1 + 4 & ! #0&+ # + # 1 2

+ 3 +

+ &

+ ! 52 # - #&

"* %#

2 &.% !#.

! 6& 789 '

+ '&&(# 9.1+

2 ( ## ( 0

'&&(# %# #

( "! + # " &+& # # 1 2

+ 3

+ 3 1 0 & # # 6 #

& + # " # & '& "#!& #!" # ) '& 1 + "# # - +! #

& '&&(# 7%# 7

" ## # +# ! 2# #&. !/

+'# 0

' #

&) '&4& '& '&&(# "# #

& + ! & # +

0 # !## %#

&!& #

# & # . : ! # & & ! "# # 3 ,.: 4 &

!. ! "# # & "

+ ( & "# # "&

# %# #

4# . :9 , ! 4 .: " 3 !

& !

" !.%1;267<::=

#" #> 8 %# # + " # #

4 # =

#" #> # #

&( #

# +" 6 #

+ &

+&!. :%# #

4# &! . :

" ! .%1 ; 6 <7::84. .%1; 6 8<

& ! #&+# 2 ( 2? '&&(# %#

& #

" # !: %# #

## # 4

!9.1+

%# 5

@.:9 5

"# # + " .8:9 5

)

"# # # + )& # A & A + !& # & !.89!5

%# # 3 &

# 5

# BA

3 "# # ! & + # +

+ ! 5

# C# #

D& 4+ #!! ! ! #&? # #

# # 0

40! "# E & " # & # # + #

4 # # (

# #& &

! & + # +

+3 #

!& + #+

!& " # #

4 +

& <%# #

!&" # & ! # +

# %# ! # + # + + ,-. +

& # ! "# #

# !

#01 6 52 # # ! "# # & ! +

& + #

! C ! 6 E

6+# 5& "# # 6 E

6+# & # &

# 5 2 # ! # # + " # ! " #

#" #6 #&

# ,-. + +

& # + # + &

#&+# 52 #-"& # (!& &F & .

' '( 2(' & '((1' A+ 3 & *''+&'2- 4/&2$+)3''&'-3 '((1' ++) & '2 ' +'($ . &' '( 1 -+* &' & &'* 4 '+@- 4/ & %- *'-+'+(-1&+2'(%'$ 783 ;I4/&%-3 2 -2'5*)'(%&3!-+'( '1') --0&'* <-12 ' 7$;$ ; ' ,(( ' *'- +' ' ''( '

'&1'&'&4$&'22)&&'4'<-123+*+ - 2(' 3 '((1' 4/ & +2'( %- ' -'2$ . '( * 32 & -'( 3 & +&'1 &' & ' @- '

''*'- ('+&'2'3&'1$&23'1-1 ,' - &' & + 3 & @- &

+14&( 8$$ ; '''/''',+''

' -<'4 ' '& , +' ' 2'$ 2('(/) &

, @- 2' ' 5-' - ' 2' -<'4',((' ,''/'';$ $ ; $&/,'(@- 2' ' &'0 '/'' ' ' ''(' -<'4 ;:$ $ ; $2('(/)&/,@-4 '"&,'',((' '(,'('/''I$ $ ; $&(31&'4*'') + &' &' 4+2 2 4( 3 & 2'

&/+'((/ '(( & %- +'((/ ,& & + @-&'2''&'4'('4(,''G -+,''' ,(( ' +('2' +1 ' 41 +2 (' '1' &

& '4+ & +1 41 ,((3-( ' *(-'/'2''32+2 -(*++-2'+((-''4*&' '4/&+(3& $ . ,-( '( 4 +'/ 2'0 3+ +'

*3&%3%2'(+-&'&'*24'1&

+'$&'2' -+'-#6

=>C# + && # !# " # #

! #

& #

=>2& #+ D& + + # # + ! # +

! #

& ! ! & #

# # !

=>C#

&!!! # ! # (

" # # ! " #! # ! # !& #!! "# #

! #

# #+" # ! & ! # A + # =>?!! ! #( "# # & #

" #

#& ! & # & #

! # - 5! "* !

# ! # & ! #

& #

<7 ! # - 5=8: ! >#

!! ! #( !! & #

! # 5 =8: ! > # !! & #

! # 5 ! " #

!! ! # (

& # !! "# & #

=>-! !

+ # ! #

!! #

# # #+" # ! & #!! => C# #+ " # !! !

# ! & #

=>!

=> !

& !

+ ! #

& ! ! + + # ! # !! #!! !! !! ! !

& # #+ " # ! & #!! =>-! #

+ & !! !

+" # " ! ! " ! ! # +

"# #!! ! & # #

& ! # #+" # ! #! & #!! =8>-!

!"# # # "&

! # & !! & "# !! !! #

& ! # #+ " # ! #!! &

& #

"# ! !! &

!& #

=:> # + #

#- 5=8:!> #$! % &

=>C#

#6+#5& => # ! D& # 5 5& & # = > # D& ! " ! & && !! &

(

= > # & #

! # 5 "

# + ! #

" A ! # ! )&

=> # !! D&

5& D& !&

<< := #

&> & #

D& & #!! G => # &

!!5 5& & & #

#& #5 5& !D& & )&

G => # &

! 5& ! G => # &

! ! => %# 6+# 5&

# # ! # " 5& #

" * !

# 6+# 5& !

! + ! 5 5& # 5 5& # &

! & # ! # # H&+ )

# => B

! & &

=> #

"# ##

"# #

# 1 ! # &

!! !! =8> C# & #

& # 6+#5&

# A & " #" #& & ! # ! "# # #6+# 5& "& &

=<> =:>B

& ( +& #

# &

& " + ! #

+ #" #

! #+& "# # G

# ! #

!&#&# " #+ +!& # ## +! #

=>C# #

! # !!

! & 5& #6+#5& ! !

# # !)& #

+ # ! #

# + # & 5& #

& # # 6+# 5& # (! * !

# & # #

#& 5& E

"! &

7 =<>C#

! & &

=> # 6+# 5& ! ! # #

" ! & A & #

" ! "##

& #& A + #& & # & ! # => C# # 6+# 5& & &

=> #

!! 5& ! ! ! #

& # # & "# # # 5& "& # ! # # ! =7> # + #

! 1 &

7<F .*32& -'(3&'4*' *&' + ;: %$$%$ 2 , ' '1' ,& & '( '

''+3''++-' 2&2'

'&-1&& ('$ + 8%$$%$ 2&33+3'04+&'1,&' 4'('+ ;%$$%$'(,&'(3'3

'+ ++ 1& ' 32 & '2 ''+$ + =;I %$$%$) *3&1'( ,3&1&%-+'33 +' 3-&'+ 3 ' 3' ' 2 ''( @-/ '( ' G 3 & 1'(+*+3& ',,&A 3& 3<-+$ & - 43 & %- &' '( 4 A'2 4/ & F4( - 2 %- & 2' 3 ' '

( "

( )*

,& - . ////#0 $.&'+')& &'-1&'33H+2'(+' 1'1'&23-33 ' %- -24'$ * & ' +') & '((1' *(* '- '++- +2 '/ '2(/ G 2 ' ?2 ,&+&,''((1&'*41'1&4-3+0)+-) "01 ' '1 '& '((1' ,&'&/ &' *'(''+'(1,&&5*2+-'&'&' (&'+-,&-'/'-&D'$ -&)&5*2 +-,'((*,&2'&2/'&4/ &' 4 2'

' 4/ & '++- &$ * '

(+'4&'(33'

(+'41'+'/' '/&' '(4-42$&F4(- 2%-+&'2-( ( .

&'*41'1'& -2('3'((1' ('12-( ('(43*'-+-33'$ 3& , , +22 ' & &'& 3 & '++- ' ,(( ' & ,'&'143*'-%-,'('1--('/ ' &-1 A $ & F4( - 2 %- '((, & '3 3

& +' 32 33 ' -24'$ & (*' A'+ 3 & <-12 -+'-#6 , & ! #!

,-. #

#,-. # ! #

# (

& ,& # # ,-.

# ) +"

AAA AAA AAA - " ! # !+ + & + #

+ + #

,-. + + #!"# #

+ !

% 5& !& -!

# # # ! )& ! #

"%#! #

! !!" # #!

" +

* >%# ! =

&=> =A>> ! ##

!! # & "# # + # & ! H&+ 2 5

5 5& , & 8 ## G

> # H&+

+ # !

#5& & #)&

# 6

+ ! # # & ! G

> !& #

# # ! & #

# ! #

H&+ 2 5

5 5& , & 8 "# ##& # !G

& # #

# H&+ 2 5

5 5& , & 8G > + ! # # 5& =>

# #5& =>#

! # #+ " # ! " #! # !

& + ! #

& ! G

& A &

# " - # # A ! #"

# 5& =>

#& & )&

&F 2('(/)&2'3(

( 1

2 ( 3! 4

,& -.

$ +1&+('3'(( .

)&F4(- 2 %-+&2'3+(-4413&' .

''3& '( ' ('+$ 2'/ ' 7 .

&' 4 1 '1' &

&$ & '++- +3 & (3 +(-441 3 & 2-( ( .

' ('+' ('+('+&<-12&2' 35

6" 2 3 7

, - (&&

& .

, 4 +('$ . ,' '( &( &' 2-( (+/3 +1,-(4'('1 -4(+$ .&2'3( 8"2 (8*

,#-8&8,& - $/)&F4(- 2%-+'33 +2 ('G+'G'( 1 ' 33 ('+ & %- 3 %&3 !-+'( '1')''$ +&+-(3& &'1*- +&'((1 &+(-441G213'(( .

'+3& '/(/'33

&'(' ('+'3'((&'(41+''+&' 3 '/'' ' -<'4 +'1 & '*( '(( -+&

('+)&1*'+('1(/+*4/&'4*<-12$ 2('(/) & 2'3 5%

3 7 +

,0-(&&

0)&F4( - 2 %- + & '3 3 +2'( +' 1 '1' &

&33'(%-%-$(&2'3 8 ( 2 ( %

,& - .$ + ) & F4( - 2 %- ++(-4413& .

1 '1'& 33

(+'$&(*'A'+3&<-12'&-#6 ,

" + #A ! #5& 5

6" "

3 7 9 :

+ , - (&& + "

A ! " &

8 ! # 5 & !-

#,-. "# #

+ #! !

" ! # # &

! # +"

# + &

C # #

# )

! +" #& # %#,-. ! ! !! &

# - 5 !

+ ,-. <9 # ,-.%#,-.+ & D&

# !% + # =A

! 6 # # ## > #

" # # ,-. <9 &

! # 5 ! 5 & %# + + !!

+!,-.<9"

! ! &

#+ # !

+ #,-. "# #

! # - # #- + +?!! #,-.#

! # &

< ! # 5 ! 5 & ! # 5& #

5& # ( + I #! # ,-. "& ! +9

+" # +!,-.<9

" #

" # "%# + + !! # = > "

! ! &

#+ # # !

& + + ! #,-. + # ,-. + # # +

# ! ,-. + #

G # + ,-. # #

9+ " # # ,-.9

& +" #

#- + +?!!

" # # ,-. ! &

#+# !

# # # !! !

# 5& &

# 3+ - # "

# ! 6 "

" # ,-. :9 7 + " # 0

, #

5& , # =6 >

+! #,-.! #!! ! # !# #"

" # ,-. 797 :7 + " #

& # 5

& # J

5& & #=# #> # ! ## # "

" #,-. 89 + " # 5# + . 0

0#& J

5& 0#& =## >F

2(' -' ,' '( - +' 43 & F4( - 2 %- & 2' 3 ;

2 ( .& 6

4!,& -.$ $,&2-( ( .

&'41'1'&'++- 3 1 *'- ,$ & (*' A'+ 3 & ' <-12 -+'-#6 B: ! # !

# # ! )& #

+ # 0 # !

# # "

+ !! # ,-. # " & )

+ # & 5 D&

# "& D& #&

! &

+ " ! # & ! + ! # !

" #

+ &!

! # "# # # !

# & # -

# ,-. ! "

" ,-. " + #

& + # !! &

F &, ,'&'3'((, ''3+1 &'33&+2'(+'&%-'''('-$ . * 32 ' -'( 3 & '4* ' <-+'(

-+23&F4(- 2%-&' ,-+=;H %$$%$ &' 4 A+ 4/ & F4( - 2 %- '(1 ,& &

, - +( = 3 & %- 3 .' + '3 3

+'' ('+'33+1&'++-A&'-&2(32'((/)

&/+'((/',(('3'+'((/'1 +1'33 ('+$ &'2'3+2'(<-+/2'

(+'4(& +-/'' -2 3++3''++--(& * 1-(/$& +3+2'('2'3<-++'4 (/ ' ' 2' 3 3(+1 + ' * 43 & 33+

*) 4/ -4<+1 &2 ' '-- +-'( @-2$ . & 2' 1'1 & +22+'( ''+ 'G '(& G4-& ,0) 2('/ 3 '((1' ' *+ '1'+22'++-,-(4('1(/ *'(1*'('1-243 +-24'G4-& ,0'G&''+&'2'/&'* 4-'04/& '-1&+-34-$ 1'3 2-( ( .

' 33 ('+ 4/ 33 2'/ 4/ (3 4 '

-&2 4/ & + 3 (',$ . &' '(( & +'((1 3 '1 ' '++- 3 & -+ ' &'(&$ -&2) 4/ -4<+1 &2 2-( ((1''33 ('+)+2 (&21'1(',/)3'+ 33+-(''113-)2'0'@-''*(''123 33'''('4'&'+-'('G++- '(/2'

--&'3(1'('-+&'1'&2$-+&' (3' *'''(3 --3'3''('

'32+'+&1 1& +-+( 3&%-3.'$&-+ 3(*(&2'/43+4'4'3'&*+-' ('* -+ 3$ '((/) & 4(2 '( ' '++-3+ '+&<-12&'' '4/*'-+- &'23'((1''2('*+$&-(+3(+1 <-12) * ' + ' '$ %+/ 3

& *, ' ' 3 (',) & 2'/ 3-' 3 ' '+/'2'3+2'(<-+'- &(1*1/ 3-(3(',$*1 ' '1*+3- (/ & 2 3 & ( *(* & '( 4- '( & '++-','&23&1'( -4(+$&'2&- & - 2'+/ 3 (', ' (' 3+ &' @- & '2'3 +2'( <-+$. ,' (/ '4(&++/ &'

+ (3 '/ &'*4 @-'' +31- 1& &

'(&2&'2'2$ &4<+4&2''1++/+('','/& ++-2'+ ,&+& 1 - + ' - 3 ' %- /1 ' +2'(+'' 23(13+3+&'2'3 <-+$&'2)&,*)&-(43(+''-24/'/

'/ +3 '/ '( <-+ '/ '+-(' %- +2 2' '+/)3'&)+3+4(3&'2'3 <-+&- 2'+/3&-(3(',$ +=;I%$$%$2 ,&1&%-'3+' ' ,(( ' '

'( (/ 3 & 1'( +*+ 3 & ' ,4-'(3A 3&3<-+$'6<'+0 32-('1'( + (+'4(',',&'+'4+- ++*'+*+3& 'A 3&3<-+$ '' +&'4+4/&1&%-323'+3'+&+' 4-1&43$ .- -& +'&'&+3(+1<-12 &'* 4 ' - 2(' 3 '((1' ,& & , ' ('1(/ & '2 ' & 2''( +-2 3 ' ' +-

,-(4+'(+(-1&3+3&'++-$&(/2''( ,,&2'/*'/'+&+'&+2 (''$A+3-+&' -',-(4-'4((/32& +*3& ' 4-'(32&*, 3'2'3<-+$&'22) '(40 2&'2+*+3''++-2'/4& (+''&'&+*+3&,'(@- 4 ,1& 2$ +'( 3+ +' 4 1* & 2 +*+ 3 & '++- '2 & +*+ 3 & +2 (''',(($ &+-&''('0+'& '/2'4/ &('%-(&'&+'2'/4'3'/+- & +*''&'&&'4<+&*&'3 3 & +' '0 ('+ '3 & 2''( , ' A'2 4/ & ++.

(('@-' '1''&+'4'3&'3' 4*'&&'& G+*+3&+2 (''',(('&& 2''( ,$ '( -42 &' & &' 4<+ 3 & '('*) & *+ 3 & , 4 + &-1& & * +3+1 2 'G '/ & ,'/ ' A & %-$ .

('G+-('& ('+3&'(<-+$&'2&- '0 +' 3 & +*+G&'& 3 & +2 ('' ' 2'0 @-'4(,&(4'('+1& +3&1&3& 3 +-1'3''(''(-1++/&<-12$

&F4(- 2%-&2'38 6"

2 .

-0(&&# + &'&(&'*/+'2''32'&-2''+22+'( 4(2 '%-2-2'0'-'*-(*& 4(2,&& 3'2,03(',''++'+,&&,((( + (3(', '<-+$&'-/3'2,0*-'(D2-( (+/3(1'' &+/ 3 +(-441 3& +' ' & '($ ,*) & +'''(1&*''+$& +('23&'& +' 4 +(-44 1& ' 4 ' ) '& & '/

2'(/ &' & '( 4 '3 ('+ 3 & 3'( '<-+' &' & ++/ & *, ' +3(+1 <-12+'4'*,&(22D1&&'& 3& +*

'''*'+1&3<-+'&'22$ '01+')&++-2'++'4*)& 2('/ 3 '((1') & '- 3 *+) & -24 3 +') & '- 3 & '( ' '(&1-1 + ( & +=;I %$$%$) & * 4 '((, ,& & 3((,1 +#6 & +2'( +' 1 ' *'- ('+ & ' 3 '/'' ' 4 '3 & %- 3 %&3 !-+'( '1') '+&0-(' ,&( & +' 1 & ' 3 -<'4 ' 4 '3 & %- 3 %&3!-+'( '1')$$$'1') &'($ & + 3 '3 3 & +'G'(G+2 (' &'(( 4 -'0 '3 & +2 (''G2''( , '

A'243& +*.(('@-' '1'G'(%- A+1&'(<-+$ & +*'(%-2'/+&*+3&' 2''( ,G+2 ('' ,&- 1 - &

+ 3 & ' & 3(1 ' '

(+' 3 01 A2 ' '( 3-&1 ' -'01 & +* %- +*/1 & 4<+&*+41+&'4+' & +3& ('G'*+'$& &'(('( ''/ -@-'&+3&*+2(/ '++-3&'241+,&-& +$ * & %&3 !-+'( '1' 3 & +* %- & ',&&+'&'*44'3&'(( 4 ' (4/ '1 & ' +' '/ 3 & +2 %--'&<-+''(4/'1& +'33%-,&&'2'(<-+$ * &'3%-&'(('3&+2 (+3& +++''(1,&&*++)2' '3')&'3%-$ * & &'(( +- '

' 43 & '3 %- $$ & %- 3 %&3 !-+'( '1' '+&0-(' 'G$$$'1') &'()'&+'2'/4'G33 %-,&+&&+'''1'3'3$ * A'2' 3 & , '(( & +' 4 + ''(/4/&++%-&'+'-'/

<-+'/3& '$

"&& ''++1(/'((,$ "$-$6:$& *;

(VINOD S. BHARDWAJ)

* "

7$+7$& %<$=./8&$%($

) !$%8(

7$+7$& &$<(&+:9$

) !$%8(