High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/32281/2013dismissed

Central Excise Commissioneate v. Deepak Gupta

2016-05-26Mr. Justice Krishna Murari12 pages

!"!#$ %&' & # )* !"++!""!#(

' ,

- .

!#( /" 0 -10

. "0#2# $ 34 55

("# $ (51#!",!#2)!",'26

( ,0 !

!#( (55,-,

'26

( ,("0#2# ,!"!" 0 !

!#1#2(5 !#89:;( ("

!#< "!2

,(2(<( !#<= !) ("0#2# =%5""!#"1( ' ,

-#1<1"

9' !#0( 2!#<"1#2(5 !#9 ,# )* !" '988'( ",( > , 3' ) !+!#<

, ("0#2# 7 (("

2 # 1<1"

' !# ,! 01#!", =)1#2(5 !#9 , #27 "0(21 2 =( ,#1<1"

8' 7 "(+ #22 ?12! !

) 1"

!))1<1"

' ,= !) 00)!

!#7 "2 )!#2=%'6!2(2(

21<1"

' #2?12! !

)(+ #27 "* #22 !))50 +=(8' ,("0#2# +62 ,5""!#"1( ' ,

-(<( = !)!# 7,! ,# ! 7 "!""12(1<1"

@' 0)%7 "!)2!# ,= !)

00)!

!#6#7(!

#"1=+!""!#"7(+ 2!# 00)!

!#, 5""!#"12<6!2(2( ##*1( , 2<( 2= !) , # ))

!#= !), "=#0( %2(# ,<(1#2

,!#6"

!#7 "0#2!#<

,?1# 1(7,#= !)7 "<( # #1+=( 0("#" 7( # ?!#!#< !#A1!(!" 2"0!

"1++#" 1#2( !#8 , ,1( 2!2# 00( !

,+ <#!

12 ( 12 ++!

2,5""!#"1( 2!2# 00( !

,# 7 01#!", =)10 @% ("B ,("0#2# 7 "!#6)62!# "(!1" #+! # B ) (< #1+=( !#A1!(!" ( "

!)) 0#2!#<

(1 !

) "

<B ("0#2# !" )!-)%

+0( 7!

, , 6!2# B , 5""!#" 12< 7(#<)% 00)!2 ,(

! ,?12<+# !

2=%= , ,0 !" (51#!",!#2)!",' 1#")( ,0 !

!#(, (<12

,# 1#2( ,# )* !" , "=#+ 2##= =)=%7 % +#2+# 7,! , +!# 7 % ' ,?12<+#

,0*1( !#

' :@&;4:5;', ,)2

# "1#2(* !"7(## <#!C =)'= =) #271)2= 0(

!60("0 !6)% 7 "1(<2

+#2+# !"# +()% 0( 21( ) , #< (

,( "

+ 7 , "1="

!6 ) 7 6!2 7,! , # 7 " + 2 <#!C =) #2 ##= =) " "1 , , #

1( # ## = , #<2= =) 7 "1(<2

,= !) 1)2# =

<( "=% # +#2+# ,# 7 "2 ) (2##= =)4 (#2 1#")( ,0 !

!#(, "1(<2

,#)%<(!6 # ,0 !

!#( !"

,="(6

!#"+ 2=% ,5""!#"1( !")!-)% ,( ""!#7,! , ,0 !

!#(!" +0) !# 4 (#2 1#")( !

!#(, ""1=+!

,!#2!#< ,5""!#"12<!#(2(2

1<1"

9' ,)2!#<

,("0#2# 71)2=<6(#2=% ,)2 0(6!"!#"0(!( % ' '",1)2="

"!2 ,0( 21() 7

# = + 2 0(

!6 ( ("0 !6)% , + !# # !# ) (#2 1#")( ,0 !

!#(!"

+#2+# 7,! ,7 "+ 26!2!)) @ + -!#< ,# ##= =)'",1)2= #"

(12 = ("0 !6 !# #

1( #2 !

",1)2 = ,)2

("0#2# 71)2 = 2+2 = # 1"2 !# ##= =) # 2"0!

# ++!

2=%,!+7 "0(!( % ' ' ,21 %6 "!#

))<2!# " !" (+ #1 (% 0(!) #2 21 % * 2"

"D ) " , # !#") (#2 1#")( ,0 !

!#(, 6=#

#"7(2 =% , ) (#2 5""!#" 12< =% + -!#< , ))7!#< ="(6

!#"$ ED # ,!#"

"'=%7 % !# # +#2+# !# @'7,! , +!# # D ' # 7,! ,7 "## <#!C =) #2= =), "=# + 2 <#!C =) #2##= =)! ,6 "!#21 % * 2" "D

) "

! & ,((' 0(!( +#2+# 7,! , + !# # D ' , (!<, 1"2

00)!

7 = #) (<2 # = !) # 1# # =!#<= =)!##

1( ( +#2+#

,# , "=#+ 2##= =) ""1 , )1 =)(!<, 1"2F 00)!

=() "2 #= !)=% ,(("

!#<! (, "=#!#(!#<2 "1 , +#2+# 6!2 @ ## ="

!2 =

0( 21( ) +#2+# (

,( ,"

+, )1 =)(!<, 1"2 00)!

@ ,#3=)0*1( !#,!( + ) !,+!

)" 4!+!

23" ":"10( ;, "2 ) 7!

, ,"1="

!6 0( 21( ) ) 7 #2 , " + , ))7!#< # )1"!#$

$ # % &

( # ) * +,-.

-/0

# ! '

1 2+,.-3 ## 5/0 6 '

$& ) *

1 ) * 2+,,/3 /

## 1" # (

9 ) * 2+,,,3 ## +78 )

: ) 2400+3 ## 4/

;

,((' "!# , #3=) 0* 1( !# +

(- ",3" " :"10( ; , " ,)2

, # = =)#

1('=1 +#2!#<!)) @ , 2!6"

1"2 00)!

,!"(!<, =() "2 #= !)=% ,(("

!#<! (=%+ -!#< ,# ##= =)!##

1( ""1 , ,"

+!")!

=) = #"

(12 "0("0 !6!##

1( !" 0( !## +# !# ,(

,( !" # "

6!#< ) 1"!# ,#7)% +#220(6!"!#"( ,(!" # + #!"

!# !#

+#2+# 7,! , + !# 71)20(

( ("0 !6 ""1 ,!

=,)2

+# 7,! , +!# 7 0("0 !6 !# #

1( #2 # ( ("0 !6 " "1 ,

1"2 00)!

71)2 = <6(#2 =% , )2 0(6!"!#"!0(!( D G # 6!7 =6 ="(6

!#"' , ("0#2# , 2 =# <( , # ""!#= !) , 6 #"!2(2 =6"

!2="(6

!#"

-!#<!# #"!2(

!# , # !#") (#2 1#")( ,0 !

!#('2# !#2 #% !#!(+!

% !# , ="(6

!#" + 2 =% , 5""!#" 12< !#

00)%!#< ,0(!# !0)0("0 !6!

%!# ,+

(!# (0(

!# #

+#2+# 6# ! ( , "

- (<1+# "' !

!" 0("1+2

# A1 ,("0#2# !"##= =) #2 <#!C =)' ,(!"#= ((

1( <( # ""!# = !) !# ## <#!C =) # ' " 0( 0(6!"!#" ,( 5 !#8@( ( 2" "))7"$ E8@H,# = !) + % =

-# !# " ## = =) # I:; H,# #% 0("# 1"2 ' ( "1"0 2 ' , ++!""!# #% ## = =) # !" (("

2 ( 2

!#2 7!

,1 7 (( =% # ! ( !# , (< 0)! "

!# ( (" ( !" =(1<, =( 1( ,( # , !<, 1( ( 1( 5""!#',+ %=() "2#= !)'=1 :!; "1 ,0("#", ))# ="() "2! ,( ( "# =)<(1#2"(=)!6!#<

,, "=#<1!) %

## 01#!", =)7!

,(!+0(!"#+# ( )!B :!!; "1 ,0("#", ))# ="() "2!"1 ,# !" <#!C =) # #2 , , 2 =# 0(6!1")% #6!

2 # # 01#!", =) 7!

, 2

,' !+0(!"#+# ()!(!+0(!"#+# ("6#% ("( +(' ( , , 2 =# 0(6!1")% #6!

2 # 7 ( +( "!#" <#!C =)# 01#!", =)7!

, !+0(!"#+# ( ,( % ( ( +( =1 # )"" # "6#% ("$

(6!22

,1( + %2!(

0("#(((2

!# ) 1":!;( ) 1":!!;=() "2#= !)!

"1 , 0("#!"1#2( <"!* #% ("(!" 7+ #( !""! -(!#!(+$

(6!22 1( ,(

, 1( + % )" 2!(

0("#(((2 !# ) 1":!!;=() "2#= !)!!

!" "

!"!2

!"?1"

#20(0(" 2( #% ,( "0 !

)( "#$

(6!22 )"

,+(

# 1"20("# + %=(A1!(2(=!#<!2# !!2=%7!

#"""21(!#< !#6"

!#", ))# ="1! !# <(1#2((1"!#< <( = !)!,!" ,(7!"# !

)2 =() "2#= !)

#2<!6" #1#2(

-!#<

,", )) +0)%7!

,"1 , 2!( !#" "+ %=<!6#=% ,1(

(6!22 )"

#0("#", ))'! ,# ))<2

, 6=# ++!

2=%,!+!"01#!", =)7!

,' !+0(!"#+# ()!''(!+0(!"#+# ("6#% (" (+('=() "2#= !)=% ,1( 1#2( ,!""1= "

!# 7!

,1 <!6!#< # 00( 1#!

% , (!#<

1=)! (" 1 ( :; !

(" "1 ,! ((1(

#%"

,!#6"

!#'!#A1!(%( (!

)' "+ %='

,( ( # ( "# =) <(1#2" ( =)!6!#<

1"2, " ++!

##= =)# '=1

,( ( "1! !# <(1#2" ( 1( ,( !#A1!(% !# ,!"<1!) 1"2", ))'"1=?

,0(6!"!#" "

!# 88& #2 0#2!#<"1 ,!#A1!(%' = () "2 # = !)J(

,2!" ( !#"1 ,! ((1( '# * 1 !# =% ,!+ =#2 7!

,1 "1( !" ( ,!"

# ",(!# (0(6!22 :; H,# 0("# 1"2 ( "1"0 2 ++!""!# ## 01#!", =)7!

,!+0(!"#+# 7,! , + % * "6# % (" ( +( ( # # 1#2(, (/', (K/(, (K/ ,#2!

# )2( = +# '( #"0!( %(

+0 ++!

' #%"1 ,# '!"() "2#= !) 1#2( "1= "

!# :;' , 1( ", )) !+0" #% #2!

!#F :

;

"1 , 0("# ", ))

#2 !# (2 # 7!

, #2!

!#" ,=#2* 1 21#2( ,!", (' :=;

"1 , 0("# ", )) # ++!

# # "!+!) ( , # 7,! ,, !" 1"2( ++!""!#7,! ,,!""1"0 2' : ;

"1 , 0("# ", )) # 2!( )% ( !#2!( )% + - #% !#21 +# ' ,(

( 0(+!" #% 0("#

A1 !# 2 7!

, ,

" " " 2!""1 2 ,!+ (+ 2!" )"!#< "1 ,

, 1( ( #% 0)! ! ((

+0(7!

, ,6!2# ' #2 + % )" !+0"' !# , !# ("

?1"

! ' "1 , ,( #2!

!#" "!

#"!2("# ""

(% :8; #! (( 1( () "!#< #%0("##= !) 1#2("1="

!#:;("1="

!#:;'", ))( (2!# 7(!

!#< ,!" ( !

" L( "#" ( "0 !

) "

"#"J ( " 2!#< :D; #% 1( 7,! , , " () "2 0("# # = !) 1#2( "1= "

!# :; ( "1= "

!# :;' + %' ! !

#"!2("!

# ""

(%" 2'2!(

"1 ,0("#=

(("

#2 ++!

,!+ 1"

:&; '!# #% " (!

=)=% <!"

' (!

) 0("# 1"2 #% ## = =) # !" # # )122 7!

,!# 0(!2 "!* % 2 %" (+ , !("

!*2 (

-!#< 6!2# !# "' "1 , 0("# ", ))' ! , !" !# 1"

2% 21(!#< , 7,) , "

!2 0(!2' = () "2 # = !) , "

!# <!"

'1#)""(( "#" =( (22!#7(!

!#<'

, <!"

,(7!"2!( " :@; '

#% !+ ( , # )1"!# (!

) 0("# 1"2 ## = =) # #2 =( ?12<+# !"2)!6(2' ,1( !"0!#!#

(( "# =)<(1#2"(=)!6!#<

1"2!" # <1!) % #% "1 , # ' !

", )) () "

1"2'!,!"!# 1"

2%'# ,* 1 !#=%,!+ =#2 7!

,1 "1( !" ( ,!" # , ( ?12<+# 2)!6(2G 0(1"

) =6"

!20(6!"!#"!#2!

6#!!

!" 0("1+2( ,"

- (<1+#

# A1 ,("0#2# !"## = =)' ,) (#2 <!"

( ,5""!#"1( 1)2, 6(2(2 () " #%0("##= !)1#2("1="

!#":;(:;5 !#8@ ( =% ( (2!#< !# 7(!

!#< , ( "#" ( 2!#< " , ) (#2 5""!#"12<, "*( !"2?1(!"2!

!#!# (2 # 7!

,) 7,( 2" # ( = #% ( "# !# (( !# , (2( 0 ""2 =%

5""!#"1( ,(2"# ( = #%(A1!(+# 2?12!

# , A1"

!# ( !"2 =% 1#") ( , 0 !

!#(

# 1#2( !# 9 , ",1)2 = ,)2 ##= =) #2 <#!C =) 7!

, ("0 !6 7!

, #=?

!6 + !#

!#"

(!#<# %<( = !)" !## "1#2( ,* !" ,07( *( !"2!" ( !#!### = =)# "!"<1!22=% ,0(6!"!#") 7 12! !

) ! (!" (A1!(2 =?

!6)% #"!2( , !( 1+"

# " #"!2(7, ,( 2!" ( !#= !)!" =*( !"2!###= =)# !# 0 ! 1) (

"(# #6!7 =6 !( 1+"

# "'#<(1#2!"+ 21

# ) ,= !)<( ("0#2# !"+!""2 %&' & :5; "