State Bank Of India And Another v. Presiding Officer And Another





   
  

  
     

   !  "

 " #"$ "% "& "' ( )"* !$"'

+",$'-$*-., $"-!& /%"/  "

     
 
 "   /$ 2'& 3)   " "

$ ($1& 3)   " "1




/''%  / 1" 1  / , " % 5"  

6
37$" 6  ""  8

6
37$"  +/ 1 " 1"2  " $  5"  " ""  %  37$" 6  

3 ," , "

 /   / "1

&  *1'

2  1 " , 5 /"%/  "1  "' /"%& '  1" 6  / 1   '$  1'"2 1"

%& / $/ "2 ) ""  9 6 *1  1'2 *' "

* ") 5/ $   '  1"

% 5"  ,2 / 3 ., ** "
"' ,$  $'   , '$

 '  '* 1  $"

  3
 / !$"' 1$ 3& 6 :

+/ +",$' ) "" 

 69 "* $  "  ;$"2

6 1

5"  

6
37$" 6 / '% /    / /"% 71 /"%

6  1"

) % "1

*  1$/*  *'  *1$' "2 ""* 5/ ''

;$' ,

" "1

 "  1"'*"2 ,< ;$ <$"  /  $"&    ""  

3 "') 7" /""

*& "   ''

5- =1  "

$ ($1& '"  $'  "1  

 /)% "  1"'*"2 ,<  / <$"  /  $"  " / *"  )5  /  / / 1 " ,  ' "1  

 " $''2 '

>"%  ?*/' "/& 5/ / *" /)% ,  ,2 / !$"' +",$'& /%"/& '2 ,$ / +",$' $  "

* /%"/&
/)% <$" )" /  $<,& ?"2  ?*/' "/  ' / = + /%"/& " 2'& '"  "&  / /"

/ "' $1  <$%*  / $"  '

/ /2 "/ ?%/  $"&     !   /" ) ' %/  /" 8 3!0
  & =

 0  +"1 "  "1 "  ) #  @$*" 
6

 668& =

(/  " A ) ( & ($<" 3*,$< * ) . 
6  9:& *  " "B ' ) ,' * .
? * .   "

3!0 6

 669& > @$$* !%   3''

2 . )

=  !   /" :
 00
)'  

 /2 "/ ) 1 /"*
.5 C"  ! D 69988

"

($1  / /" / $,* / *   / <$%* /) , $'2  " ,2  )

/  $"   

  &   2 :& 6

" '"  " / 1"  % /"

$%/ / <$%*  '   " "%$* /""& < $" 

$'  " "1

 5 $' "%$ / !$"'

+",$'-$*-., $"-!& /%"/ 7" <$"  ;$

 $<,& ?*/' "/  =  +"" "2  /%"/ !  "%$ / *"'2 ,$ /  / ,  ,2 / !$"' +",$'-$*-., $"-!& /%"/& / *    $ 

" 5" <$"  $1  /  $"  /%"/ !  "%$ / "1

 "* 1   /  ?*/' "/E ") 5/ /"%/ /"  ""

 *' 5 1 ,2  *1 "2  / !  )/*'2 "%$ /  '' / 1" % "% "

* 1"'*"2 ;$"2 '' $'*  1'"2 1"

% 5"  $  /  ?*/' "/  ) / 1 " /) /"

  /  ?*/' "/& /  $" '  ""    /  5" 1 ! $11 " /  & / / /)'2 "' $1  / ) /  $" ()&''

( - "../01"#211/$'3!$'$" 241521.1

"&  /  ""2& 5 $' "%$ / )   "  $    / "$ 5/ / <$" /  $"& / 5" 1  / "%/'2 , ' , " /  $" " / 1$"1 & / / "' $1  <$%*  ?

B,' / $" 6(

+(+7
8"%(9

":(%$)( $

21142

!;!

<21 $' 5 $' "%$ / / $%/ / ) $"  &''

*  +,% $  "%&'

((  3 ('  (+,

 /   / <$%*  6(+(+7
8"%(9

 ,$ /      1"   / <$%*& "  $"- /  ""& / 5)"&  1 ,2   $" +",$'

"  7$) $/ "2 5//" $" 1"

) 

  $ /"5&  1"  $    "  / 1' A)   %) & 5/ / "%' $/ "2  $   1'  / 11'' $/ "2  $   /"&  5" 1  5 $' , *,'  , / / 1' ! /" 5 "  ""

 / 11'' "2  $  1"  $   &  5" 1 $' , *,'  / ?%/  $" 5/ 5/  <$"    $ /)% "%"  /  / / ""

 / 11'' $/ "2  ' ";$"  ,     / ""

 / "%' $/ "2 *"% 5/ /  / 11'' $/ "2

/ / "' $1  <$%*  '/ ?%/  $"  !(&%!

3&""

"# %'(!8 9'3& "

"8:)(& !

,'

(" ' %

"

$"#

!

7'

%!#!3 %!"  $

21..=2 !;!

<05

!1$'2& / " 1"

% / $'*  ""

*'

 "1

 5"  $  /  ?*/'

"/ +/ 1 " " ' /)% /"

  / ?*/' "/

   "  " @%" 5/ /  ?*/' "/ +/"   ' /  $  

"$ 5/ / <$"  /  $" 71 / / 1$ 5  ,2 / !$"' +",$'-$*-., $"-!& /%"/ / / <$" )"

 $<,& ?*/' "/  = +"" "2  /%"/

3 *'" $ * $1  "   , " / ) /  /  $"  &''

((3

! / & / =  ! )  5" <$"  /  $" $"

3"' 9  /  $  /''%% ""  6



37$" 6 /" 1 ,2 / "' 3*") +",$'
F@ "$& /%"/ /  /%"/  '  $,*  * ,2  " / 1" 5/'  "% <$%*

 ?

B,' / $" 6(+(+7
8"%(9

(+,

7>!3 
$+(% !'()("77!((!" '

"#' %

?3!('211< @<@0 :

%$)( A '

(9

%!'()'(('

) %+ '

?, '((211@=.11 )  '/ ?%/ $" 6('A"

!B" (%$)(  
.004'

&!.2@  5 /' / / ?%/  $"  /%"/ /  ""

)" / $,< *" "  / 1

" /  $%/  "%$ /   &''

((3

 / )      1"   <$%*  ?

B,' /

$"  6(+(+7
8"%(9

/ <$%*   , "  / %) "$* +/ 

" ,2  "  '' $  /    "$'

 1"   / <$%*  6(+(+7
8"%(9

(+,

"1"

$ /", " ')  *"

  $, /  5 /' /"&  / "%' $/ "2   $   1'  / 11'' "2   $   /"&  5" 1  5 $' , *,'  , / / 1' " / '   $   /   /" / "%' $/ "2 " / 11'' $/ "2  $  /%"/ " 5/ / <$"  $<,  ?"2 ?%/  $"  )" /   $" 1"   /  " <$%* + %   / ) $"  &''

((3

& / 1 "   ") 2 )%  /"   "

* / <$%*   %' /  '/ ?%/  $"   !(&%!  3&""

 "#   %  '(!8  9 '3& "

"8:(3

! / )5  / *"& /"   1 "

*  '$  / /  "" )" / $,< *" "  / 1 3 "%'2& / 5" 1 " " "'%  )  <$"  /  *1  $"&   " 5/ '5

" 1   *  /  " "*


   



  //" "1 ",' G >