High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/8802/2004dismissed

M/S Hisar Metal Industries Ltd. v. State Of Hry. & ORS.

2026-01-09Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill,Mr. Justice Parmod Goyal20 pages

!"# $"% &

( )* +!!")'

% ,-

.()!()/0$ /*) "

)/1)!

!$/ " &

( )* +!!")'

,2-

.(!"' #))/1)!

!$/ " &

( )* +!!")'

")! 40)5

6,78 )!)#!0 ")! 4!# +27- 4 9$ (%(

$ ( $$

9$ %(

! " #$

! &# "' ()) ()*+,,-

$ #

$ # .

/ "0)),+0+,,(

$ 1! #%# 1

2222 $ ( $$7% " ' )),+ +,,(# ()) ()* +,,- 3 # 4

54 7

+)" 8 9 % $ :7 #*;<. =>8%$: ?/ 1

@A + &

=$ B 9 <*** +*** B 9# **# 4 1 3 1 B C

? .BC / 1 1$

BC + "0 ())0+,,- 7 0."9/ 1 . 7 0< "0())0+,,-/

$ 8 9 7 7 9 ,,(+,,, B

,,(+,,,'

0 6/ D B E 1/ 1 4 E

E / +9

A ( B 1 '# 7 0< 1 4 9 9 93 1 91 7 9117 # 9 1 7 91 < : # +-,-+,,,

19 1 #C7 :7 "

#8 9 "

? $ :7 ++,-+,,,# $

7 B $ # ,,+,,, 8 9 #,,(+,,, ' 1 .

- ' +),;+,,,

1 9 1 57 5

<,+,, +)" 8%$:

0 6% : 0)!0 )!7 0 )* !"# 7 1

)" !" )'

0)!")!%( 0)!80./"

7 91 11 1B #

.+/ 7

1 9 7

0& +<0 ./

" #

7 4 #00 ./F F 8 9 % $ :7#*; .+,*;/ " $ :7#*<-.;( *<-/E .1/ F

F 9 .

/ .

/ 1

# # 7 9 #7 +<G7 .

13/ 1

) 0:71

1 1

/ 1

)

7 1 #

7 # 9 1 30 71

/F1 F 0 / 3 7

# 57 5

0 ./ # E ./ 3 $ " % G E ./ $ BH

9 $ ./ 9 9 7 1 8 9 % $ :7#*; " $ :7#*<- 1 E ./ 1 3 # 4 # : " 9 D

8 "9 1 : " 9 D

./ E , #+,,, 9 19%

)

:19 1 198 " 19 8 I $ " : 8 "58 I $ " 1 .BB/ +)0 +)0&# 1

1 1 91 91

E .BBB/ 3 . /E / F F $:;+0&19 D 9C7 :7 "

E /F7 F 1

E / F7 F 9 #

/ 1 7 7 9 # # 7 9 # 7 +<G 7 .

13/ 1 7

) 640 :7 1 7 1 1

7 9 9

9 7 #: 13 7

7 7 7 7 7 7 .

13/7

)

71 #

7 #

9 1 30 71

7 777 777 777

$ 6;

< !"# #! "0 $ 7

+<G 7 C7 :7

$ 5 ,,G 7 * 9

*9 <,G ,,G 7 , 9

9 ),G + 9 -,G (;9 <,G )9 (,G *9 ,G , 9 +,G " <,G 7 & +<G 7 +<G 7 9

9 ),G + 9 -,G (;9 <,G )9 (,G *9 ,G , 9 +,G :&ICBB / C7

" C7 :7

$ 5 $ 7

#& "

<9 <,G ,,G

< 9

;

+)" 8%$: <,+,,&9 +)"./# ./ . /

0 6./F F ,

#+,,,#

0 / D B E /

19 9 # # E /

E / + 9

1 9# +,,+A

) +)"8%$: <,+,, <*** *

+,++,, 119 !J #

9 #D1 " 1 " 8 I$ "

AB #+ 1 19

5 '(

# 1 1 3

:5 "

9 # # 7 B#BB 5 9 : # 4 1 B +)" 8%$: 19C7 :7 D # # 1 C7 :7 "

C7 :7 D ,<,<+,,( 4 1 $ B

.$B/# 9 B 3 19$B# 1 1 #

# # 1 D B 19 1 , B 13 #1

)% ,)*- ./ 1 1 I " 9

" # *<- = " 9 1

9 $ I +,,)**

+-,**( ?

$ $ " I 9

),*** ?

$ $I " I ./ B 1

# BC 1 19 $B#

9B 9#% B ,+,**(. 7 0+/" 1 8 I$ ".8I$"/ ( ,-,-**; 9 1 BC "

$ :7

-;-),3 ,,G 7 ; 9

1 # 1 1 +)8%$: C19

++,;**; 7

+)"8%$: % # D B " #% +,++,,

1 . 7 0</ % 8 9 11 9 7 9' 7 7

,,(+,,, B 19 % ,,(+,,,B 1 ,,(+,,, 1 $ 1 ./ = 9 1

++,++,, $: ;,& 1

' < 7

7 7 +)"8%$:

" 5 #

9 8 # (,++,,- . 7 0-/# " 9 1 BC 7 ,+,-+,,; ,,(+,,,# # '1 K +)"././B BC 1 ,+,-+,,, ,+,**(# # 1 4 ,+,-+,,, 9 3 ,+,**(B 1

3 9 4 1 # "0())0+,,- # # ./ 1

'( 9

./ 1 1 I 9

" #*<-

B 9 ,,** 9),, 9 D B 8 9

7 3 ** 9 19 ),, -,, 9 B 9 7 #

7 9 7B 9 # ,,G 7 9 7 1 *9

$ 7 3 **- 9 -,,, 9 ,,G7 9 7B 9 ***# 7 9)(,, I 1

4 1 B 4 3 D

3 7 7

4 > ? +)"8%$: 8 #$8 9 9 7 # 9% ?

D B " +-,(+,,, 1 ,,(+,,, # #3 1 ,,(+,,, $ 9D

,,,50

9 1 BC % B

,,<+,,,3 BC ,<,<+,,, 19

" 7 ,,;+,, 1

,,)+,, 3 7 9 7 1 <,G 7 1 9

' <

1 +,,+ ?

7 198 I$ " ,*,-+,,

7 BC ,<,<+,,,

> 1 ? : 9 #

19 1 :

1 #

+,,(+,,( # ./ 1

'+# < 9

1 9 ,2- ./ 1 1 I 9

" # *<- 1

B1 BC $B# 9B # % B -,<**; = 9 1

++,+,, 1 $:;,& 7

+)"8%$: "

9 1B 9

# 3 8I$ "

10" 7 ' 5BC 7 1 1 1 19 9 1 3 ?

198I$ "

1 5BC 7 B :# # ./ 1

' +# < B 0K 1 BC 7 % B +<** 1

198 I$ " +; +),**< $ 7 7 7 9

,**+ C19

+<,<**< 1

+) 8%$: 7

$ I3 D I .

D /# 0BB

# & % = K 1 BC 7 91

% B -,<**; 1 3 51

# 1

3 & 7 9

++,**** +,++,,) 1 3

: # 4 19 = 7 7

+)& +)" 8%$: 1 7 1

+,-<3 1 = 1 +,++,,) 1 8 I $ " ;; +<5+-,++,,+ "

19" 1 4 1

1 19 DC:" 1

19DC:" +)"8%$: ./ B 9 +,,# 0K

$:;,& 7

+;,+,, +)"8%$: ./ 1

./ 11 % #

'+(#$ #B : #% $10" 7 ' 9 1 5BC 7 B : 19 1 3

1 8 I $ "

(,++,,- D

# #

I "0)),+0+,,( 9

4 BC # 1 # "0)),+0+,,(# 1 #

D B 49 + I

"' ()) ()* +,,- 9 # 4 5

BC # 3 # # 1 4

9 13

# 1# 9 1 4 B 9

1 9

4 B # #

9 9B 1 19 9 ,,(+,,,

BC 3 B # # 9

1 9 I

77 +)" 8%$: $ 1 1 9 C1

9 #

9 3 1 7 4 91 947 9& 7 4 7 1 19

1 D

( 9 < B

0 4 1 1 9

**#**(# **;$ 77 #

1 #1 9

' +),;+,,,

1 1 9 57 5

C1 9

+)"./././8%$:

,,(+,,, 9 19% $1 4 9# <,+,,# ./ +)"./ 19 > ? 9 $ ./

9 > ? ,,(+,,,

D B #

19 9 # # #

1 ,,<+,,+ - B "0())0+,,-# BC 7 1 ,+,-+,,, 7 #

+)"8%$: +,++,, BC ,+,-+,,, 1

# 1 9 +-,,,, 1

# 7 7 9((,,,, 1

9+;,,,,, 1

= 1 BC 7 ,+,-+,,, 19 ; B "0)),+0+,,(# 9 1 $$B % # D B " # 8 ,-,-*)<:

1 77

1 +-**

1 ,,**

7 <,**I I$ " 1 7 7 1 1

B 7

7 # ?

19I I $ " +*+**

19 198I$ " ,),+**< 1 I I$ "

,,G 7 19 9 7

77 +*,<**- =

$$B 1 BC % B ,,(**< B

7 7 9

19 (,**; .

19 / 1 9# 9 7

1 57 5

) $ "0)),+0+,,( 9

+)"

+,,)+,, = 1 BC ,<,<+,,,

D ?

,;+,, 9# 1 BC ,<,<+,,, 1 4 B 1 # 19 = K : 9

19 8 I $ " ,*,-+,,1 & 9# BC 9 1 ,<+,,, ,,(+,,, * B "0()*0+,,-# 9 77 +) 8%$: 7 ' # 8$BD" B C % #% -,**(8 I $ " +),**<

19 7 7

)() 3 7 ,; 9

,**+ C19

+<,<**< 1

+) 8%$: $ 7

7 $ I3 D I .

D /# 0BB D

#& % ++,(*** +)& 1

1 BC 7 9 1 3 # 1

# 1

3 3 -,<**; . 7 0/

C19

(,+,,, +)&8%$: ?

4 77

+)&

+)" 1 71 1

= 1 +,++,,)

198I$" 1 4 1 7

119DC:" +, B "0()*0+,,-

$:;,& 7

++,+,, +)" 1

11 ' +( $ # B :

#% B 19

1 9 BC -,<**; 1 3 # 1

# 1 #

3 91 119 = BB D

#& % 8I$"

7 +)& B 4

'+(#$ B : 9 ; 9 1 1

D 19

9 # ?

1 5BC 7 : 19 9 & 3 : # 9# # BC

1 + : 19

9BC 7 57 4 9 13

1 9 9B 19

+)" 947 B # 1 BC

H 9

: 1 1

4 1 6/ D B E 1/ 1 4 E /

E / +9

A ++

19 "0)),+0 +,,( 7 1

BC 1

+ 9#

1 1 1

7 1 B #

9 1

1 9 9#

9 9 3 19

# +( ! 1# 9

7 ++-" B +< '

+- # 9#

1 9 +;

# 9#

9 =$ ( $$; = $; !# +27-

3 5 L 5' 1 L 5' Uploaded on : 12.01.2026