← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/18105/2022dismissed

Anita Kapoor v. State Of Haryana

2023-03-15Mr. Justice Namit Kumar21 pages



          

   

    



     !"

#

 $  %  & 

'( 

    









!) *(&"+&"

! +,"

- #-$ &")-+! +

  .)  # +!!.+'( &# -/"+! + &-(!- +! +



/" 



  0-" -* "/*(  & 1 $ 2")  ""

( *"/ "  34 5 66  

1   &  1 + 17+ 176+ 17+  8 4$ &  17+ 176+ 17+  8 4$ ,  /  + )"    $ /" & &

1+.

) +" "

.

) 

 

8" 

- - -*   34 ,)"  $&&

1+.

) "

 



*( -9:+.

)  ; 7 $

/"

"/ *(

/"   /( '" &")- )"  !"

#

+  %"#

! -#

 

+ ") -" -

/" *   < " ,"

--

-

 -/ 1(4(

7+ -   

-

/"

 -/

 (*")5 !=17+.,

"

(+&

1 +.

)   ")1 &< 0-

/" )

- -"

 (

1+ ++;"

," - )" (,"//*  

 6 0-

/" " - 



  ++; 7 7*(,(

, -< 

 92-- *") 5  67   677   7 7 ! - #



  ")"/-"

/

 ("< 

/"  0- ) 

 // , >

 * ,

 " 7 7 0-      

/"

-

 ("  // *0-

/" "

- 



    92- *( ,(

,  -<   

17 7 *")   661  66    17 7 '

- "      7 7   1  92-

67 7 0- " (   , 2 ,/) *( -  

 *( ,(

 2 ,/)  "

 0- +

/"

"

/



+ ++;

-   9 +      "")

/"   > 



-,))");/")") ->

/0- +

/" "  " 7 6+- ,+ < 

- + - 

>

&/,



  68

 "//+ -(/") - 

   > 

- 9  +

/"

 

*/" 

"   

6  "  " 0- 0" 

 4" ,  -

       -   "

 ) 

 //      ,"

-   &"

 "  ?  < "(+

/"

-

 -  ") ) "))

" ,"

-

/" + -   - * "/ 

7 

;!"

(8"/3"

(0-

/"   

- %"#

+- ,+- - 

/"

/"



"

/" ")-" " /4 -",(+ - 

 - 

/"  , )

// 



  

/"   " 

 

"

+ 

 

   7 

 *( ,(

 

""

 !  @+ !"  ""



$ /"+&+.

) +-* "/+,-""

-*      

  

      





 

      !   

 "#   !#

 $

   !  !"     

  

%

   !   !!   

  !     

 & '   

 "#   ! !     $  (

       " !!  

1

 )*( )(

 "   !#

    

       " !!   + + 

,  " !-!! .

  /   0

 /          " !!   + + 

+* " 0  /  0

 / .

1 /  

0 2

 

  %

"  #    !1  #   !

 '    

  

     #    !  +  ! 

 



  !!  

"# 3 4

5

! 

   

+



(

  

&   

 5     !  

   

    !!   

 "# 0  3 

! 

   # 

( 

    

&   

      "  



      #    6 !    !#

 4

 

 !! .

 / 0

 /    ,

, "   # " 7  + !  .

  /   0

 /  ""

6   

       #      !  "   #    !#

     ! &   

   (,   (,, " 7   81  !  * ,

,   ! &  

  ((+  (("7  (81 !    ,

, 4  "    7    !

!  !!   !

 "  #     !! .

 / 0

/    #    ! !1     !-!!  0 /  1   #   #.

 / 0

/%

  '  

" #  5"  

&   !#

  + )

,  "   !!   

  1    " 7  + )

9- !

  

+ 7 

9-

  

,

 

 7 

*

9-

    

( "#   4

5

! !#   

 "7 (!

  

("#0 3 5

!  :# 4  ! !   "! "#  !#

 " " "   #   #      !#

   !!  

  

  #       

&   7

 

;!

"    !

  "7 ,* !    #  1

  !  

   "  

    "#     "   !!    

( 

    !#



  

     #

          #    !!    "            ( ,

) 

    !!   

         !  "   !#

  "!    

"      !-!!  



"# 

 

 "       !     #    !  !#

 ! + , +,( +,*

-3 <:    

  

 ! 

+

 , !! # .

 /    ,

 $  0  -

    

   1    #      1      ! 

  0;!



 !

7:":   !   47- ,-=8-         " 7 

9-     !   

    !   #     1

  !  

    :   !      1



"#!! .

 /

   !  # #   ,

 $  >      <

!8=   !  "#   !    #   1



  ! # #   ,

   

!    #  " .

  /    !   

   #     



7

 !##

 " 

 ""

!      

  " 

 / %

   '   0 /                           

          

      

                    ? 9 &"



/

    -

""  -* //("

/" "  5

" 

& 1 +17+176+17+ 8 4$ )"   4  "

-   - 

"

"-")-/( */"*/ 

"( ,

/  (- )



  



 (,-"-"/(")

)),"

-*2;

""/"

,"

-

") ")"/ /   '

-  * "

 -   ""/   *") 5      A1 

  "

" 

 

 ) 

 // " /(

") *

 - 

 / ""/ :

) :

"

 """

+ .

) + -""/"

-*)" -" "/ /



/ 34 - * )"  )"   4  "

-

  - "

" /"(

->

34 5 A   7   &  1A!+ 17 4$+ )"    $ /" &  ? " .+ /-"  4  "

-  * "

 -  

"/"  )

"< "4 "/  * "

 -   ("

*

  <  !   9 & 

/+ "  *( /

/



/"  * "

 -   -*

*(

-  ,"

-

/" *( ")"

6

 ) 

 //   7 7

 

/ "

1   

 ,-"-     - * " *(

/"

   -" (  - *  /( 2 ,/) *(     " !> 

6 -" -/ * "

*(

  " -" /( 67 A

-/)/ 

"

*(

/"     A+/ 

,-"-"    @A !

 

 B

 !    $ 

        # "  



0 #  C    1         

    !#  "       6 !            "   +

 6 6 6

     

 

    !"!#"$$"$$$%&'   (     ) *  +,       -   

 .

(     0  

"  !

     B  "      

   !# ! "     ! #    

 

   

     

  /01$/$12              

     #    "   

C      "        

              3    

 34   . ? -

-*   - 

/(  - *

,"

-

/" *

,"

-

-  + /(+ &"

" ?,"

-,- ) 

//   -



*   "

  "

 7    ")

(

) 

//  7 7 -"  -

"

AA/

/ ),"

-

-   9& 

/-   -    1 

&"

 "  ?  - - * '" - 

 0 -    &  7 $  !  *     +

      &"

 "  ? - - "

 ("  // * / >"  -"

 (  3 -+   - *

 ,"

- "

 *2;

""/ "

 ,-

 ( - * ))

"   )"  /  - * 2 *(    4 "

-   - 

""/"

  /(!"

(8"/3"9  ,- -/ ,"*(

  )" - 

 (-

-

-" 

 *( "/") B$ 5 1



A =!"

( 8"/ 3" 9" "

  " "

 )"  + .

)  

- 2") ,"

# #

-")  -("/

"

 * "/

 ( " $/

 5 17+ 8/ 2!+ " "/  / ( 2 , . B

 "

(+ .

) + - *"

    A  *( " "

)"  +.

)  & 1

-C& "

"D   

 3""/ !   E

 

 & "

( 4   !

+  F -"

  

  C - &!3!E&4 !

F+ ,-"-,// ,*("""

8-

-"

"?

)   7  " ," 

-" "

)"  + .

) 

   - -("/

"

 ( "

A

<   " - 

- 

- "D 

 =

"

( ,"

-"  ,2  0- /

- " ?

)  "    

   "

   0 !  ,"  :

  "        "

!





  !

"

   !

"    <D+, 3!1-0 7  : 1   > C:

 >#   # 

   "!    

     ! + "    ! E   7 !

!  " 5

!

 0

   = "! #  "  !      0!

 %"  F  0!F'    

 ! ;

  >#  

) %0

6  <-'

   !! " "" 

 " , ,

) (,9-    (

)     D 

     "    D+-;9  /! =  

     D,* 

!  

    ! 

 "   #              0     ! #

 !           "       #  "   7 !      !

(%+0'" 0!$ !! "   

  6 !   !        5

!

 

  !



!# 

: 6 6 6 6 + 

     !      )

       ! "

  ""



"   D -

 ! ;

 >#   D -D      

" 

     1

 !

  !! "  "!  !   # #   

     ! + "   0!  

) %0

6  <-'   # #          







 ! "   !1     1   "   !  

    "  !1  $

*

    ! " :       

  #  

    :

 : >#

 

          

  " "

#-  D     D,  *       !  "#  # #  "  

 !  1

)0!!

 

:      !                 !        

   "#1



"   

& :

"      #     1           

" "  ""



 

   6    )

$ 

          1   #   !        

!     "

  :;-

+ -:C<-

   !     "   !  "  ! 7   "    *

     G- C   # 

1 

 ! 

!    

 !           

     

 "    

1    

" 0750= 0!   "  

 :

 "   !

   

  

  

     :

 2  %2

 

'

>



   

     

"#1



"   

 &      "   "   " 

:   !

  

 "     F #        

"



  "   !

 

 

     

  ""



 "" ! "

   #  "  ! ! " 1

 " ) $! 

 "  

:

#

 !     !    

 #    "

  ""



   "" !  !!

  

   1 F #  !       

 "   #         

 

!  

 !

 :;-

+ -:C<-

   

 "0!"

 

  !  

  D   ?  0     "        ,

  !

   

    D 

  !# !  "       *

  ! 

      "   " *

 0  #   

 (

           !

!    :;-

( -:C<-

  !  "  !      

 "  

    #  

   

"    #  

      

 "#  # #   "  #  "    

   " 7 ( *) (

*9-   #  " , 

9-   0 #      #  "   !" ! 

    ! (% '"   0!  "       7 !    -       "  

 

"  "     #  !       "  #      !#    ,$  ,

 :

 3 !" 

!  

           !

 "           !  # " 

:       D     !! 9  

  

   1



 

 ! 

      *

7     1  #   #     1   #   #      !#       1

 5 

 !      

       G- 0" 

  

   !       

 !  "    !

 "   



          -  D   " #    9   D  *    #

    :  

   !  ! 

 "   !  

  ""          ! ! "   

!

   9

     D  *

  

     #    !

 "

 # 

 "

  0 

    



     !

#

! ! "   

   "     

   #  # 

# #

      



) 

 

 ! ;

 >#   ! +" 0750=0! 4     #  6 

     

 

!

  9  D  *  

     "   !    

      ! "     ! 

"   #  "



+

"" !

  ? ( $

+

    D  *   "

   #         ! "       ! 

 "   #      ""



"  D B,  "

  

6   "  

   !  

  , +

$     # 



#  1 "      3 1" !! 

   #  

    #       1

 

 !  " "     D  *     

!  

"  $ ) +



: 

 8<

   

+

 "

  !!

! 

    "   " * +

 0!!##    1        !!  "   "!  !  

 " 

  +

 "   0 6: *



  0 6: 

 !    +

     !    # " 7  !        ;9  /! =  



   # "7 , 

9-0 

   

     7   !   " 

  3 1   6#

  "   #  !

!      #    (

   ! 5 !   

!  # "7  !

    

    !

        

#

     +

%0

6 0-

' 

8< D ,)) , * "

   ;9 /!=  

B  .

0  5

! 8 #     F     G-  

 

 

  !

   

      #  "   1       -:# "# 

7  -0   5

!  8 #   

 

      #    

   



(

!!

 !        &          #  #  " , 

9- %7 6 !    1 '  *

      #  

1

     7 ( *) (

*9- %7

! 

1

  "

       '      #   # " # "7 , !   # "    #      -:#     # "7 !  !#     !   " #  " "    ; 01 /#     !

  

 "       # 

 #       -:# 

 

 # "   !    1 "     " 

  "  #     #1   "    "  #  "     ! #   !

     

 7   ;   

   !

  

" 

7   #  

" "!           #    (

   

           

  4 

 #  

!

 "  



    1""   !   " 

   -5

!  :#         !

      "

 # " 

" " "!  !

!#  !

   

  " 

 !

            !  

 !

     -:#       1 " " 7   !     

 7       " 

      "    "

 #  " 

         !

   

 7   #  !  6    

  "  

   " 1 "# "



" ! ! 

 

"  

  

 !

     - :#          1 " " 7   !      " 

 

 !

        

#

 C    "  !

    !

       

 " <

  ! % '

"    

 "? ) 0    "   !##

!    , )

%0

6 0- '    D  ""     #  " " 7



9- %7  ! '  "    3   ! !!

    !!   #  "#  !     * )

%0

6  0-'  !##

!

  #   " "

# 

"# # #  

 / 



   



        # 

  " "



"

   1

  "  

 : 

  "    0 6:D" 

 ! 

      !! "  #  

 !

 

 

           "   7 * !        1 

   

"   "    !    -"

!



     #  # 

"  #     

     #  !

 >#

 0!!

    

  

 

  "    !

       D -

 ! ;

 ># 

      ! 

 "    

 &

          E    "       

  1 "#   

"# 

      

7

D 

  

 !;

  1      !        #  " 

      ! 

 "    

 &      E     "        "

!



   #     "  

           !            "  # ! 

      

        !

     

   #  ? -

-*)  - / ),"

-  



)( -(-  

)

 

 ("<  ,-"-,- ,

/" ,// 

 &"

 "  ?  ,- ,-"/ 2") /   "

 *2;

""/"

+ ,

"

,"

- - 9 & 

/

-  * "

 - 

"/ "  )

 " < "

  (

 

  " -  -  "

 //)  )"  -

")

)(   





0-

+-"

 /

)

 ""

( *"/ 4 --/

/

  "   

-  3 -*  +"

"( //"D 

" $  / ) ,"

-     "

  ) 

//  

7 7 ,"

-

/" '" &")- ,"

- )

 ( " $/

 5 17+ 8/ 2!+ " "/ / ( 2 ,  . B

 "

(+ .

) +  ")1 <(



/ "

6

1   +

 ,-"-     "   

/"  )"    2 ,/)    0- " )   ,

 * >

 *(

 6      ,

- >  ( " 

/  >  /" ()

0-"

"

 -* "

*( 

  " -"  /(   67 A

/)/

"

*(

/"  

  A

"" !

- ) 

 //      - * >

 *(     %"#

G%"#

,"

-&"

"  ?+  ") (

 ) 

 //   7 7

""" $    ))

 (" <    - 2 /   C4" 8 //F = 1+A + +;" -( 1+ ++;"

- ( 7+  ++ +; " - ( 6 0-( - / * "  /   !"

( 8"/ 3"9" "

" -( 6



6 &" -"

 ,

 "*(

   + !"

( 8"/ 3" 9" "

 

- -" 

 *( ,(

 B$



1



A

 2") -("/

"

 (""



" $-("/

"

 ("<  - * 2 *( !"

( 8"/ 3" 9" "



 / ) ,"

-

-   ,-  , 

 5  

6" -  ")"  

 """

 8- ?

) 

-" 

   7   -*"

  A

 & 1

-&!3!E&4!

*( " "

)"  +.

) + !  /

- ,

/

-- , - - 

-

 ( "<   , /( )),"

- 4"8 //+ -"

//( "

-) 

//,"

-

/" +*((") -

 ("  //  *+

>  ( -" 0- ,"

-

-

  -   "

 ) 

 // ,"

- &"

 "  *<  /(2 ,")

//( - -(,

/)//(



  + "

 ( , )) ,"

- ""/

(  ) 

//

"

 (-/(* 2 /,"

-

/" 0- 

/ ),"

-

-   "  *"

+ ,-"-  *  " *( *   *( '

F*/ """

 8- " - 

 B$ 5 1



A  

 * +  -( - * /   *

" 

 "

/ ") -"  2") *

 -" 

  ,//  '

F*/ &

 

4 "

  - -   - +

)

A



  - * 

 //

 ( " < 

 > 

(  ! ""/ 

  "

" 

 

) 

 //   7 7 "/ *(

/"  " /

")*

 "/

 .

)   " /

   - -   ! - #

 , )   ""

( *"/ *( / !"

/ &"

 :

)+.

) +"   7 9  +& 17+ 176+17 84$,0-

+! -#

    2")  ""

( *"/ *

 - / !"

/ &"

 :

)+ .

) + ,-"- , " " "   

 0-

+-  *

 -"

"

 16

"17   + - , " " 



*

(

-"

- ;  0-

  / 

 "

 0- '

F*/ &

  

 " .   5-      4   6

- 7      '1892, / .(( !:0+ - -/ 

    !##





"  ! # ! ""

    

   ! # "        10# # !##  

   " ##    

 

   0  ! # ! ""

! 

!##     ! !!                     "

  

 "   !

& !     !##

 0

  "  

   "   !##

 !    #

       !  " ""

      " " !##



   ##

  ! 



-  #

 " "! !

#"#

 

  &    !

    ! ! #      #

   #

" "   #       ! #  

  ? 4@&6

4  

  (;

'/$1!,2.(( 0!8+ -'

F*/&

 

-/  +=! # !""

!

!

 !

   

      ""   !

   #  "     ! # ! ""

!

  

  -  !

 !



   

"  ! "  

    !

    ""

!

"" !

  ! #" !      

    "

!

 "  !  C  

   ! 1 

#

 

  " !! 

     "

! 

   "

  

 "   

#   ! !

!        !!  "   !!  !

!#  !

 !    !     !!     

   " !

   

!  "   !!             

 "   



#      

  "   !9    # !

 

? /"

-* /

-'

F*/&

 

"

"7. 3 7

 .  ; 

  "/$/1'0, ( '(,#89 .    (   6    7            5  

 " '/$/$,18 . (  (   !:0 ,-*( - '

F*/ !

>

-" "

 ""

(*"/"",

-)"

(

 



 

4",

/" "  

- 

/ 

"

/,*( -'

F*/&

 

+ -"" 

 

)  ""

(*"/

0-" # "!

)" 0-//) "

"

  2 ") " ", 

  ,//   "/

  

 "

*"/ "



+

"-  -

+

"*"/"

(

- "),"

- 

""

-/ *"/+/"2/"-



- /"),(

-?

""

-

 

 ( "+  *" < "

 -

-  -" #   

 ,-"-



"/"  )

"(

-

" -*)  !

")/(+ "" "

-")   -" *  -// *     > "

""

- "



-



!

"#     & B- - 2");   @;5 B- -

*/  @;5