Sher Singh And ANR. v. State Of Haryana



         #

,-., #$ %  &'&% /)0)1 





;  /"


   





















$  MR. JUSTICE HARP PREET SINGH BRAR

  

  

 
"0  
 
  



 



  
 

 







  
#
   

1
HARPREET SI

 INGH BRAR()*+


 





 
<"

22+,22+




2+,22+
  
 


 
 
!"


3 "
%  

!   


 

##$
% .

, 24 556
 
7'$
%

-

,224 556
 
 -6
-5
+,+
+,.
+2 28

'  
 
(


642
&


'( ()

 



 
! 

 

 :  
 :



 *"


 





  

!

" ,

$ "
'



$.229:
 


=






+,+
 



'(
"


 "

+-




 
$ "
'



$.229:



 




"

+,.
 



'(

"







 

+-

,






"  


  

,224 556
'
$  



< <"
! 
 
&>+)

(
 
!  










 


"   



" " 
 


  


  



 



 



A
,224 556

22
 
 

 
 " 

 
 

 


! 
 &>+)
 
 

 
$ <
?"


& >4)

 
 
?"

&>8)



 
  




" :  


 

 





" :

$

 
 






: "
$ <
? 
 

 




 
<




  
> 

 

  "
" 


  
" : 


 "0

! 
@

 





" :  


 













$ <
? 
 "0
$ <
?"




 




"
  <
?"



$ <


$


 
?"

&>8)


 
*" 
"


  
  <"

 



<"
 
 0


  
A

   
7'$
 
 
  
"  
 


  
 
 
 
 
 : 

7'$
%

- -

,224 556







"" 
  
"9
8+
( ((
 


  
  







 


( 


+




 
  
 (

  
 
<"

2+,22+




 
  


(

-
B  "

  


 
 
 





7'$

 

:


 




  
  
 
 
 "
  
 

< 






"
*"

 
 

  

  

  
 
 


 





C=
##
 


  
  


$ <
? 

" 

 



 
" 
  
+28
'(
 
   


  
  

 





  
 
 "
<" 

 





 
D"

 

 



 




 

.





7" 



 


 

" 
 : :
 
 





>+
!

! 
 

$





 

 






<"
 




  

 


"


 
 







> >-
#
 0
 




B$
C=
(
<"
 .
  
 

>+
! 
 
B 
  "
 
  


  0







  





"

 




"


 "


  <"


  
  



 
'

  
  
 

 



 
 



<"





  

"


 
 




" :  


 




 
 
 
 " 






 0

 

"




"
4




 



 


"



 



  "



"


 



 
(
 
  


  

"
 


(



   8   
 
  "





"





 
  



 
 


"



 
 " 


7'$



##$
 








 
  
 

"








 
,8
  6

+

-




A


 5.6
&





@ 
 E)




(

 

 
  



"




 

  



+42

+4


((

 
(

 






"



 

"



 


!"


D


 E 
" 
(




   




 0

 "
!" 
D D

 
 


:

 
   
   

 



   
    

 
 



 
         

     

  
 
 
  

 

 
   
   
       

    
  
 

  
 
       
 
  
  
  
 



!"


D


 E 
" 
(

#$ & 

  !

"
  0
 "
!" 
 < 
? 
? "
 
 :

 )  
'   
  ,
     
  & -

 




   

   
           




 0 
         +
  
 


!"


D

  !
    * + 

-
    

    . 

 
     

  
 

/  
  
 
 


   '   +   
 

 








7"


 E 
" 
( #$ %# $  &  ' ( ( 

!

!
 



 
  #"

'

 

 & 
5
   ) 


 
   !   "  !   #"

 
    

           


 ' 

   (
  

   
 !   $ % &    
    
  
   ! !  1        %&

   
 
 '  
  /   +  
    

 
   

            

  !   #"    (  $ %& ( 

       

' 

  $" 
' 
  

 
  
 
 @ 
" 
(

*  
   

    )

*+,- -!.

. ./
 
 










(


 

 




 
+42

((








"

" 
 
  


 


 


 


 "
 


 
< 


  
 
 
 
-

4


 
+42


+4

((


"



-







= 




 
 
     " 
 



  
<"

 
"



2
'




"




 

  

 




 
:

)




<"

22+ +,22+
 


 

 
 
!"


3 "
%  

!   





" ,)







2+,22+
 

 


 
 !"


3 "
%  
!   





= =

  
 




" +)




  
 

   





 

$ 22229:
 
" "





"

"

0

0

  



  "






 




  ( 


"
0
-)



  
 
 
" 
"





A



"

 



'


 


 
 
  

 


"

0


( 
 

 
"

 
 



"


 
( 2"&3/(1 














*



,

+


> 
 09 
 > 
  39% 39%