High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/29719/2017dismissed

Sanjeev Malhotra v. Kushargra Malhotra

2019-08-13Mr. Justice Hari Pal Verma10 pages

!"#$"%&

" '''( ) *&" ""%&

"+ &&+

& " "&""%&

" '',

!"#$"%&

" '''( ) *&" ""%&

"+ &&+

& " "&""%&

" '',

----- ./!&! "

$ "

%"%" %

!"#$" " ! $ "

0 & #"/!&(" +"

$ "

& , 1& &"%%,

+ , "

&"+&"$. % ! 23 (./, !"#$ "%&

""" &+ *&" ""%&

&", "/

"%%

%./ & , ! 5 ( ." 6 57 7 2"

%" !"#$%$##&"

'$# ($! !)$#*+((,#&"

'$#,.

%" 8"% " %" *"%9"

("&9%""0%%"

:"&

5 ,"./%" " 0& ./ &",,%"

;2 ; % ./ & , ! (

"%%

< " "&""%&

& &" .+ !+%" %/ "

& , -

, &" , "/

"%%

& "

" , ! 5 ( %./ & , "0%%"

:"&

5 ,"./%" " 0& ./ &",,%"

;2 ; % ./ & , 9 , +

"+ ",,%"

;2 ; ! (" &",,%"

3 ; 9 " 7"++ & ",,%"

;2 ;

0 +./%" " > 0$

$ " %" / "% . ,"

? %/ , *&" ""%&

%"+&+% "+

&" %", ! 5 (

+" " & & +

& " "&" "%

0& 0

& ,/

& "

" , 9 +" " &" %"",,%"

! (

"%%

< " "&" "%&

& "

, & "%

& + " "%".% "

"$ 4

&+",

+" " %./ &+

&""% " &

. % "%," "" :

. % "%," "

&+ ./6 "% "/ " # 1&, &

% 0$

$ + " ""%

< " "&" "%&

" " & + ./ ="+& "" @" %

& , &" .+

< " "&" "%&

. ,"% 9 0%

& " + A +" ""% 0" :

% &"+ &+"

%%/ . " &

& &" "% & "+ ./ $ "% $ 1& , 0"

="+ < ""

"% / +"% , ./& " &0$ &

.% +"%", "%

&" ." &. % "% ," "

+ , 1& +,% " . $"$ ,%""+. & +

<"&&" "% &$ "% " 0&&

.%" !&

. ="+

& +

&"$"+" "

1& .+

./<

% "

&" " $.%

&"9/<&%+ &" /"

%" + "%, @(" %"

"/&".+"%%.%

"% "

, !+%" %/ =, "

%$ / .%"9 0&&$ /"%4 %

..%"9 @(&".

&" 4 &+" &&" "% &"

, !+%" %/

+ "%&

/&". "+,

+"9 %

9%9 7B B

# / +,

+"% @" %

& , &" & " < " "&" "%&

0& % & , ! 5 ( .&"%

+ *&" " "%&

" >" /"" C $ + "%

0 & . " "% + " " " &

& :

+" "& + , ,

& +1& ""%

& , " $ / +" . %" " &"

$ %

9 & ".% /7 "% /

0&& "%

" # " " :" +

+" "

&+ 1& +

5 2& &""& + "= & 0"

& /" " 2 "

4 & +" & &" "% & + $

+ "+

+ &" %"9& &/" 2!+%" %/ ", "%"

+ &" %"9&

&/" "$& "%" / +&"

. & %/, # ! & , &" %

& , "

&" +," +

& $$ +" +

&((D" 1& %

+ ./ < " "&" "%&

" 0 % %"

+" "

%/ $ /

+ &"

<$ / "%

&"" &&"

% & + @" %

& , &" & " , $

! (

%. "%" & +, 0

++ +"

"% 0 ="+ , , & , ! ("/ +"/ "

"/ "

"/: / "%

& , & ++ "/, ""0 ="+"/ , "

" &

++ " " 0 "%% " ="+"/, "% "/="+1& +, 0

++ "/, ""0 "

"/ "

: / "%

& , &7& $",,"

. "%

&"4 & " " &0 &" %", ! 5 (

+" "

& + " &

& $ ""

& " & "%

"4 "

+ "9 &,"

& %

<0"

, , %/ ="+ & :

"%% &

& & %

&"$.%4,,

& %" %

& , &" % , #" &

#.$

($! !)$$/0# 12342$/5/*#&46

& &" %" %

& , &""

&&".

+ $&%9",,%"

%/ " & +" & &" " & , 0 " +

"$ & , .% /

,"/+" " $ "% &" "%% 0 %/ " /+.

% +" "

& + $ &

&"%% ./0"/

, , 4&"$&" %" %

&,"

" + %" %

, &" " & " + : & % +"/

*&" " "%&

" !

" " %+

+" " $

" %% +"

&% & ,= ) 7"'#$ #"#* ($! ! "#55(8 9#$

: ;24 2$/5/*#&4 -1 &" &% " , !

& 4" E$

" , 0" .

"$"%+" ". 0&+

& ""/+" 0 & 3"/"

% " &+

& +"+" &"%%.

"9" %$,

& &% +"

+" % ".& 0 &,"

&+" "&" "

& "

"/ +0&& %&"$..

!+%" %/ */'# #<"=#"# #*8 '"($! ($! ! */& #<"=#"# 32342$/5/*#&4;- > A.%!, + &"&%

&, ! 5 (++" /"

" ,

" /

" " "

0& 0" " &+ "%

&+"

+ "%, . 0 &&." "0

1&>& "

& "

, . 0 &,"

$ "#.#*/$#!#8(*#($! ! *,(* $(<$('#$0 $/!!#'#'( 55/!!/ *

$> 5(*#*8#* '"($ 2342/,/&41- > A.%!, + 0&% %/, " % #+ #57#*0#

#/($! ! "#$#'$#5

2342/,/&4;13&" . $ &>& 0"

# "%% 0 &",,%"

&% & & 0%%., .% /

&,"

&60" " 0"

+ +

& 0".

&0% 9

&,"

D & & %$"

. $"

+" ," " ",& 6 " 2

"#.#*/$#!#8 (*# ! <#!(2! ?$#4 ""

! %

! !

" #

% & ' (

)

+ #

- .% - .

!" (

% !

/0!

! 1! ,

1!,

$ ! !

1! ,

1!,

F E &+,&"0"+"./%" %

: &% +"/

&&% & 0$ &%&

&#+ ".

$ &

$ "/ ++ " , &" +/

"$"% %"0 !

" " &" +

%" %

& " " & +

< " "&""%&

"" &". +" /

& ="+& + %/

." + + &"$ + &9 0%",

, "

"%"

"%% 0

"%% &" 0 0& &" "% "/ . ="+ "% 4 "

0&"

"%% &"0

& 0"

" " +

& , 0 " ," &+"% + &. % "%," "

&&% 4 %/ & , &" % ! 5 ( 9 +" " & /"

0& " & ",,%"

9 "%%

< " "&" "%&

& & ="+"

0" %./ ;2 ;"

0 "/ . " "% < " "&" "%&

" &" &

"$ & ="+"

& " & "

&" 0" =

D + 0"%

& 2 "& +" 0 .

& %% 5 2 0& & ="+"

0" "%%/ % (" " ",&6 2

&+, "

5 ," ./%" " +"9 %" "

"",

/" 52 5 & ",,%"

"%%

& 0 ! (0"+ $./ ( "%

&",,%"

& & 0

& ,

& .

& , !+%" %/ &+"% 0&&0",

<0""% "/ ,,%

& , "

& "

<A $

, $

$ ,,

="+& ,%" & "

" " & +

"%% 0

"%%<

& % . " "

./ + +"

"%4

&" +. ,

, $&"./ "%%, .".% 1& " "/ & +

<0 % "

& ,

""$" " "

"%"#"

! 5 ( & &"%% & " &$,"

",,%"

%./ , & &, % &""+"

&" "

& , , =

& 1&

& & + &, , " &"+" " %/ + (&

& .,%" %

& "

" G"

<& & ,"97 " G <& & ,

".%