Charan Singh And ORS v. State Of Punjab And Others
!#$
%&
!"#$%&'" #"%
( #
'
()#& *&+,
"
()-!
-!
.** !#$) ()))-&*&+,
"
%&
)/0) #"%
( ##)*
%
$
".
& !& 23/ ) %4 " 5! " )/6 &
& 7)2)/8/8
& !&
0/0*0/2*027*689*02 :
0/9 && &.
;
., *&-%! .*
, -%! . )6/&
7)2)/8/8
& !& 26/* 0/0* 0/2* 0/6* 723* 72<
& ., *&-%! .*
, -%! .. ..
%,
"> $ "
,>%>
&
&0)2)/8//: ?! 0;) 5!
=
&$4,>%.
%&
)/ & +
,>> & ) = + * =
+ "
% $.
*"..4
+ &
.+
&
*=, %% "> ,>%>
)
>
+@ %= "
! $4%4 ,
=!.&$ "!
.
,
&$!
"%,
!
5!
&..
">>4$ 5! &
"#!
+& & &
&/3)2)/8//&
%% $ " . ! A..5 (
" ,&
* ,
& $ " ! & . ! A..5 (
= .
&
&
% %! !, > * .
& (* -%! .
% &
&/)9)/8//&.
,%.(
**-%! .
% &
&/<)B)/8// )C % &
&/)9)/8//.
(*-%! . .
% ,%
"#
"
,>%. >@ & $# & #
"
,,!
&A%
& ,& &/2)6)/8//) >..4*.
,%.(
**-%! .
% ,%
",>%. >@*=
$# *,,!
$#
D $ ,& &7<)6)/8//.=
" !& ,& &08)6)/8//)
*.
&(*-%! .&.
,%.(
* *-%! .+ ,,.!& & % %%
+
& ,>%>
+.! .4& ,,!
&
A,,!
&+ $
,. ,.> & ""
+ &.
&,!
."
*% !
,& & %
$4.
&(*-%! .&.
,%.
(
**-%! .) $ !
."
4%+ 23/) ))=!.&
= ! >4>@ !,& * >4$
4
+ ""
4& !& & % + $!
"4! =
,! "#!
) 0/8) 5!..4 + ", & *=,%
,$
&! " ,>%!&" ""
!& &
.& -
%+ = ! """
..
&.4,>>
& ", $
+ >,$.4
&
, ",>.%
,!
=!.&$ "!
.
,
) E$.
!% !>$ ",
,.!&
B.S.Joshi and others + State of Haryana +,)-%./)0.) "..= &$4 !.. ,,
"2.*3+)%4,+ ,)5%6.78+,)9 + & .
%% +.+ &
.=) "
*E$.
!% Gian Singh :State of Punjab and another %./)0.) "! & .
. .=
&$4 !% "5! " State of Haryana :Bhajan Lal9
%.// %)
97" #!&> & !& '
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
-
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
($
(- (
. 0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 %%.4 .=
&$4E$.
!% %.
"#!&>
! * %% =
+
& ,>%>
,
=!.&$
.4$!
"%,
&$4..=&,, %
%4 "
$45! =!.&$
,! "
#!
* =, %>.4 $# .
. ! , !& 23/) .
!%
""
!& 0/9 4
&
+.
&!%
4+
&
,! ,, %
#!
, % "
$ &*% , &>4$
=
!.
"&
& 5! .4"..
>$ &%>
&$4#!&,.%
& * )/6&
&7)2)/8/8
&!&
0/0*0/2*027*689*02 :
0/9 && &.
; ., *&-%! .*
, -%! . )6/&
&7)2)/8/8
&!&
26/* 0/0* 0/2* 0/6* 723* 72<
& ., * & -%! .*
, -%! .&..
"> 5! &5!
,>%>
&.
4 %
.. >$!& $4
> & ,& ,>%>
,& &$ " ,!
$ .=)
& ..= &) #"%
( # #$ ;"
.!,@4 C
% @A &'
A C
% $.
'
A