High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/112/1998dismissed

M/S Vidulesh Kumar Arun Kumar And ORS. v. National Ins. Co. Ltd. And ORS.

2019-09-23Mrs. Justice Rekha Mittal9 pages

!" # $% % # $% "%

&&!! % '" ! ( % )

* "%

& +% %," # "-. / % " &&!!

% $ 0. / % ". / % %&

)"!!2 " &% &&! " , % 2 3 2$ %

5 & ,6 " % 0 2.

$%% 7"%,6 &&! 2 " 3 2$ %

& ,6 " %! ) % 7 & ! ,6 " &&!! % /%6 7 $

% " &% % " % % /%6 " &% &&! %/ !/ % $,!6 " ,6 " %$ !" # $% % # $% % 7 ! # $%. " &%% ,2 " %2% &%% " %$ " &$,%.

'" %! ) % %$

9. % " :

;""% " &! %2% %$ % # $%

&%% "% <++ ;""% " $,! 2

<+ '" %! ) % 7% , " " % / " &&!! &! &%!6 % " = % /%6

: 7" &% & % % > 9? &% $ % $ " !2 " !! %!@ " $ 2

$!6 ! ( % ) $&6 *

'" &&! ! ,6 " % % $&6 7 !!

7 ,6 " % &&!! ) '" % &&!! ) % ,6 -2

% " $%6 /. %%% &%

" 3 2$ " %& &&!! "% &%

"% . % % ,%/ &%

! " 2 " %! )

9 %/% " ! , $

%!/ A% % $ &%

" 3 2$ = " :

%$ C)C DA "

7 " %2% " %$

8 &6 %$ CC DA % " !"

# $% " 3 " %$

, &%% " %$

% # $% + % 7 " &%% " %$

! # $% " , "

7 &%% % $

'" !% !

% " %& " ,$ " 7" ! # $% " , "

7 &%% " %$

. , " " 7 $,! E " !%

! 2 2 %6 " , ,! $ " % ,6 " !% % " &&!! '" &6 %$ C)C % " " &&! % %2% " %$ 7 $ /

8 "2 " " %$ % " '%% +% &%6 7 2/

5 '" . /!6 " " "2 " %$ " , 2/ $ % " "% 6% % " " '" !2! &

" & % /%6 = A&! % 7 F2"

% " ,%/ !

" #$ %& ' ()*+ $%, -./" " $ " !! " &%% $ "/ , "

7 &%% " %2% %$ " %& , %$ / & ! '" " , !!

1$2

, "!

%&'2!3 "

()+/ $%, -.56 ( " %&. %% $6 ! , $ " &A ) % %& % 7"

1 0% %83 '

20'% " "0% !

% %& '2!3 " ()9)$# 313'$ 2(5+)'" ,%/ "% * %"& &% 9 " 3 2$ $6 , %&% %:

( " &% " ! ,6 " &&!! !%!6 " ,6 " &% / ,: 9 " +%%"& . " 7" " 7 !. $ " &%% "

7 &%% &% " %!/ % " 2% B%$ 7% . . &%%

7 &%% " $ 7 $ % " , $ " , " &%%"& %$ %2%2 7"" 7 2/ " 2%% B%$ '" . " &% 2. $!6. " %% &%%

" " 7% "

7 &%% " 2% B%$ '" % ! " " 7 $,! /7 " &% / ,: 9 " +%%"& " /7 - ,6

" '%! ) % %$ ,6 " F2"

% " %% !"

2" " &! 7 $ !% " / " % " , $ $ " 3 2$ " '%! ) %G "

7/%. 7 %6 %%

6 "$ " & !7.

& . !% &! %2 ,:

9 " +%%"&

$!%!6. && % , %7 % $ !

2! $"2 "34 :

'());040 '$ 2 "3"((63

%% #''

0<3 " %& 3%3

3" " $%'& = 0<3 " %&3%3

3"()); "3"

*+)

'" !% % " %& "

7/% - && % % $ 7"$ > "" :

, "7"

3323!

! %2

1 ()*) $%, -*;6 E " "

%6 &&!,! " " &%

;" " , ,%/ "% " "

&%%.

%" %2% % & %& 9 %6 ". " 3 2$ "!& " %& '" . 7" ! # $% 7 "

7 &%% " %2% %$ " 7" " 7 . " $ ! , $ '" .

$2 " 2 " %! )

" " %$ !6 %2%. " 2

9 %/% " " ! , $

% " &&!! " & " %2!!6 " %$ !" # $% % # $% 7 " 6%

" &%%"& $ A

/ &%%"& DA +;

" $. " %$ 7 ,6 !" # $% % # $% !" # $% %% % $ " &%%"&

DA +

. ! # $% % # $% %$ % " $ $ 6! !" # $% % # $%. H % # "!.

$%% " $ DA + '" %$ " % /%6 &$,%.

8 7"% !" # $% 7 $&!

2" " " %% % $ " %$ " 6% .

"% %. 7 &%% " %$ " $ " ( ! & & " " " %$ 7 %2%

8 7" " 2%% B%$. / ,6 %$ C)C $%- DA % " &&!! " & " % # $% %2% &%% " %$ &% %$ CC $%- DA

! # $%. " &%% 7"

,$ &%% " %$ 7

7 %2% &%% " %$ "% " $ %2% " %$

8 % " $ "

'" % &&!! ) % ,6 %!62 & 3 2$ " % %%% &% " F C,! " &A ) % 7"

1 0% %83'

20'%"8 "3"$#

" "! " 7" !

# $% 7 "

7 &%% " 2% B%$ " 7" " 7 . " $ ! , $ %2!6 2 " %! )

9 %/%

% " &&!! " ,$ " 2 " % &&!! ) % %/%2 2 " %! )

, & %% &&% & !7 7" %2%

$&! 9 '" ( +%%"& .

C" C % " & %& . " " &! %! "/!6 & 3 2$ C,! " &%$ ) % !

& "

%2 '2 : "

1%0:

?& ())9( 040 ;//. 3 2$ E $,6 F2"

#8!

18!

%& %&' "3!

%>0 ,0'1 %,0!0%'= ()/6'1- =.*5. 3 2$ + 3, F2" ) % !

" #$ %&' ()*+ $%, -./ / E" 3 2$

H 3% F2" ) % $,

2@ $## = %&3?3

>3'

& %&!0% >

" $%&

& " $:$1

1 !04 %0 ())( $,

2(56 % " %&

" && % " 3 2$ % & ,6 " ) % &&! ,6 %!62 & 3 2$ F C,! " &%$ ) % 7" !

1 0% %83 '

20'%"8 "3"$#

"% ,$ $ ,6 ! " " $ $ !" # $% %% % $ " &%%"& %$ !" # $% % # $%. "% 7 &%%"& %$ " %$ A ". %" &%%"& %$ 7 %= % , 7" ! # $% & %& %!6 3 &%% 7" % # $% % " & %& . " " %%% 8 " 3 2$ F C,! " &A ) % '110""0'%3 'A%8'13 B &!=

&3"! >#$ %&!

>#$ "32!'40%&

"()++ ./ '!& 0C$0&&0% %& %'2!3 "

3400"

&3 &-= " %&'2!3 " 040 +95 ( "/ "% % " &%. &% " &&% ,

- % % , A&% $6 ,!6 & " &&!!

% % 7" 2 " &&!! ) % % % &%

%&% "%, %

% " &&!! & $- 6 /2 %2 $ "

7 " 3 2$ 7"!

1 0% %83 '

20'%"8 "3"$#

%! & ,6 " &&!! ) % &&!,! " " " " %%6. " 3 2$ %! & ,6 % " &&!! "/ ,%2 "

" " 7% ,6 " ) % /7 & !% % $ / !/ "% ( !

& "

%2 '2 :" 8 "3 "$#

. " &A ) % " "!. % " :

; % ! $&% ,6 " %2 $ " !% % " &&!! " " 8 &&! 9 " ! " $

!! &%% &! " 2% B%$ . " ! ,6 " +! , '" " " %$ 7 %2% +!C $ &! " 2% B%$ % & . '" $ " 7!6 % &%%.

%. &! " 2% B%$ '" $ " &% 7"

$ &! " 2% B%$ $6 % % ,! " 7!! ,! " &! &% " 2 " %$. 7"" 7 %2% 2 " &% 7"

$ &! " 2% B%$ ; % !! & 7" % " ,! " &% .

$ &! " 2% %$

% " & %& 9. " &%%"& %$ 7!!

$ " %$ " % %2% " &%% " %2% %$ $ &% % ! B %$ CHC '" &% ,2 ! ,6 " &%%. 7"

$ $!6 &! " 2% B%$ !

27" " $ !! " &&!!. " %= %$ 9 % 8 " ! $&! 7"

% " !$ & %&

&! , % ! %2 " % A% !/

$% , " " %$ 7 %2% &!C $ 7 !

"% " %2% %$ '" $ 7!6 % &%% &! " %2% %$ , " . "% 7% $ % " &%% 7"

$ 7 " %2% %$ $ &% % ! B %$ CHC "

% $. 7 "! " "% * %"& 7% !! & 7" % ,! " &% 7"

$ &! " %2%% %$ % " &&!! " ! & " %%% "

%6. 6 " %

" , ! 7 " / &% %2% &%% %2% %$ " &% 7"

"/ %

&%%"& 7" " %2% &%% &! " %2% %$. !! " %2% %$ $ "% 2" %2% &%%

" , !,!6 % % % 7" " "% &%6 '"

"% 3 2$ %! & ,6 " &&!! !6 7 6 "

&% & !7. / %,! " &&!! ! 2 " %

&&!! ) ( " /7 " $%. " &&!! %/ 6 /2 "% % $ " %%% "

(& ,!6. " &% . 7 &%%"& %$ 7 % 7" ! # $% % &%%"& 7" % # $% % !" # $% %% % $ " %$ ( " 2/ % . "%

& " &%%"& %$ % " $ !" # $% % # $% 7 A % $ " 6%

7% 7"% % # $% ! # $% 7% " &%% , " %$ 7 %2% " 6% 8 !6 % # $% 7 " %2% &%% " %$ ! # $% 7 %2% "

'" ,2 . % ,6 % " %& ,6 %%%2 8

" 3 2$ %!/ " A " %!/ 7" " % % /%6

( /7 7" " , "%, %. 2

$%. " &&! ! %2!6 $ !/2 " &%

,% "% 7

# ;""% %& %,! I