High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/297/2021dismissed

Vijay v. State Of Haryana And Another

2025-04-21Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda11 pages

! ""##

$% &''( )*!+++ '*( ",

! ! "

! #

-$ $.$&/.0,1, $ 2$3&/.0,1$.""#""## $4$050*$6 77777 # $

'.""#""##08..9$.$.,,0 2/ #1 ""# / . :%,/3 . $# %$ ,, ; 8.$96$",+.9<%,9$/) + ,,; $/$,%,$ & ;=>

?=> - -#&#8 '.9$3,$3."#,/.$. ; #".3/8$1,$3-5&0.2. "#$/$,/.,.:%8$",+.2 96 %3/ " . $30 . 1// $ #/ 8."##$.,-5&.2$$$,/.3'. 3"# :6&%#&/.$=1##/4.$/$$,, . 3 . . . $, 91 , ,,$ ,

,/"$1:9'.6$89$.$0#,$+$:,..6%/$ ,:%8.$08.,,.,6-5&0.2* ,..6"$$3,.3$$/.$:%8.$", +.2 : 4%3$

> @ "$ *,% $ , $3,/1,8$696,.$"6$3,6. 3$$/0$",+$,,3,/3$6#,$,9/ :%,.$/.$,#,#2/.$ .0.62:% .1##/4.$09%18.3"$3.".60. ,,8.$3$3#.3*81$08.3. ,/.,,.$3$3#.30+$:#,$9$.$. 3"# $1, #". ## $3 . .$#8 :% . :%.%3,"%%9,2,.32.$92 .$.3'..69$%/.:%.$"$#.31##/ 4.$A..6<%$,9%.3$3:%0.#,.3. ..$#.%3,"0$.$0.

$#8,.%9,.2 .1$9#6,3$,".$"$.3"#0.3.$ #80$3.$#80$",+.2 .%9,,&%3 /.9$2##,.$:%96,3$/".$ .

?=> -8$/$,-#&#80$ , > '."$% B3, 36 8 , $#, %" (B- (B- &%9<%#60 . "%9# "$%$ #, . "$%1,08.$.%,"#,,/%#6,#3, .1 9 ##6 3"#,C .81$0 . %, #, . ,

1, 96 B3/ 8 8 A , A , #, . 1,'.%,D38$$,,8.."$ &>>$-08.$.,,.##/#1##,/.3 96."$%,"#,,.#3"#."$

'.A0.303"%,$ #0&,, A0 08. /.9%$ . %,0 8$ B3, , 8 ?, . 1, "$,0 . %,=$", 8 <%, ; 96 . #$, ,,# & %,/0 ,0 8...3"#.8.##/,.$%/.."$""#

'.#$,%#$.""##,..$#%$ ,,""$.1,"$,%,96."$%,<%,. %,=$", 9, :%$ , %$3 '. 3$# 8 ., ,%#6 %""$, . "$% 1$0 8.. ., 9 9:1#6 ,$, "$"$ "$"1 '. $# %$0 .81$0 $$%#6"$,,<%.%,=$",./$%,.. "$%#,9#../.$",=%,96, . .,8 $9# ,%9 *0 .$$0 , . #1 9 /$,#""#/.$",D<%# @ A .1 .$, #$, %# $ . ""#=""## , .1$18,.E8$%$$$,

'. # <% 9$ . %$ 8..$ . 3"%/, :%,/3<%#,,; $<%$$$$"$%# .3"%/,:%,/3,.1,"#,$$, ; '. "$%# 3"%/, :%,/3 .8 . "$ . >

3 (B- 3"# :60 . ##/ 3, / . %, 8$ . 3$$/ . $ 8 #3F, 8. $", +.2

> @ "$*,% $ ,$30 8.$ $ 3,63$$/0$",+,3,,,8$6,$,9/ .$ :%,,'.$$0.62.$.$1##/ 4.$9%18.3"$3.".60.,, 892.$3$3#.309%8.3.,/. ,, .$ 3$3# .30 . #,$ 9$.$ +$: $1, #". ## $3 : 4%3$0 .$#8 . $0 8.$3,.:%%3,"%%9,2,.3 2.$.$.3'.$$0.69$%/..$.$"$#.3 ,8..6<%$,9%.3$3.$0..#,..$ #8 , .%9, .1 $9#6 ,3$, " .$ "$ . 3"#0 3.$#80 $ 3.$#80 .%9, , &%3

,1$2##,.$$,/#60."#$$,,.3(B - $0 . #$, $# %$ 9$1, . -A :6

9$.$,,.B3.,",..86 -5&0.208..6<%$,$3.$$/$,/.$ %3 "% %9 96 .$ . . $"#, . . ,, %3"%%996.$#0$.$08$9#6,3$, .$ 96 .$ .%9,0 3.$#80 $ .$ 3.$#8 , .$ ,1$09%-A+$: .$9$.$,,.B3 .,",..62,.$%3/"$3:%

.%08.$0-A> .$,,.$B3, ..,%/.$,#,9%."/,9$.809% -A@.9$,..86.$"$#.303.$,, 2,.$,%/.$9%.,'.$$0.$$$, . 3 . 8 $1$0 -A . $B3 ,...,3"#/$",+C-A.$ B3 , . . %, ,, ,3, 6 ,8$6 9$ . 3$$/$.33$$/ '.#$,$#%$#9$1,..$,9#6-A -A>83".,,%.$308## .3"$133,96.308..%//..%,# 9#., 96 .

"$% 8$ 9#., 96, $9# ,%9 )%$.$0 $ $18/ . 3"%/, :%,/3 8## . 1, 3$# 8 3, .$0 8 # .$ . 3 18.$3#0./%#.%,3%9"$1,96, $9# ,%9 '.$ .%#, 9 .$ "9# $ . 8## 9 2B"./%#.%,08..$.$%3. "$ '.%$##/....3.$. ,,.9,8,"...,, ,#, . , .$0 8.$0 .$ . ,, %#, .1 9.98"$1.1#13.%,09%.$. .9,8$..

9B3,.$8.%$ )%$.$0.3"#.3(B-.#3,. $",+ .%9,0&% 3.$#80&.

,&%3 ,1$:%$9#6,3$,".$09%,%$/ 1/ B" $", +0 ## 8$ %, %$/ . $#0""#%,$&> $-831,$%33/ &%0&.#,&%3,,#%,09%.,""#8 $:, 96 . $# %$0 1, $,$ ,, , .$ . "$%.#,6""#$$1/.,$,$

E$,$#%$9$1,.0A0/.9$ .,,:%,.20,.%$..%"#., .""63$$/,.$8,"%98.3&.#3, . :% ., .$, .$ $ 8. .$ 9% .$ 9$.$ :6D ,8..20.%$/,.$/,1$0B"$/. 8.$$/,$3$$/$.$'2/D36 %0.$#%$9$1,.."$%$36.1$9%, .,,D%,#6 3.$.$3$$/ > $,/.3,#$$,3,.:%,/3 . $# %$0 . ,, ", 86 $3 // #%3%3 ".".,0#$$$,#".0%""$,963$3-A @0$-2:480,..

3#"$(B-; %$/ $B30 -A0 :60 , . . #,$ 9$.$.,$1,".##$3:4%3$0.%,D.$ 0 8. $3, .3 . :% ,, ., %3, "%,2,.32.$.$.%'.6$%$,.38. .$$:%$%,@-*#3,.:%#,.

-.3.,",.$&.82.3 @

3$6#0 8.$ . $, 8. .3 , ""$, #3 )%$.$3$0-A0+$:4%3$0.,9$.$0,..$1, ##$3:4%3$$%,> - 0,.6$.,. 1##/$%,>-0$1#/.$3$6#,$6/.$ $G 3$3# .3 $ 9% .# .%$0 :% ., # 8. .$ 9$.$ :6 .$ 3$6# -A>0 &%#0 $3, ,%$/ . $B3 . . :%$6 $3 . 1##/ .$ .3 2 $%/.#6.%$963$6# '.$#%$,..3-A0-A0, -A>08..,..,.,,:%8$3#C ..,$%9#"2/9%H.%$9$.$,.)%$.$0. ,, 8 $"$, $3 .

$ #8D .% 8 .$ "$D .3.1##/5.63$6#'.%$9$1,. :%.,/,".$#8D.%0.8%#,.19 9#$1#3$9#6.3$6#%$/$B30-A @0$-2:4.8028#,/,.#%3%3"."., /0 8.. #%, 1$ 9%$/ " . 3%.0 .$0 , 3.013/3B,8.9#,,6" 9$.#0$","%#0 %9$3#3"$%$01%#0#$,0,1%#,. *$3,.#%3%3".".,G$,963. .6,$.#$,8.3%"."./,",9$9, .9,6*B"#,."$8./#%3%3".".

,8%#, #2#699#$1#3$9#63$6#$1,.8/ 63"3*%$.$,,.8.%3,#$$1$ .

..%$11#,$/#6-A@#,.%$11# 96, .%$$/3"$99#0,."9#6/ #"..9%

3,/.$1//. =; 9$%#,% @ '.$#%$,.83,3$,. :%82.$"$#.3963$6#0..,%3, " .$ #8D $,0 .8 %#, . .1 $1##, .%$ 96 3$6#8.%6%I,,##60$,/.$9$.$, .$0 .6 8$ $3, 96 : 4%3$ 9% :%D "/ 0 $%, > - , $%$, .$ .% $ "2/ %" :% $%, @ -0 %/// . . ., /, #%3%3 ".".,.%,D.% )%$.$0 . ,,0 :%0 $"$,#6 %3, " ,82 -5& .2 ; 3 $,/.,E/#"$ E(B- "$1,,96-A ". $30:%831,-5&; 08.$.",86

.3,6:%/, ".$3$#.3 ,.$3#6#$,. @

- . ,60 $ . <% 8.6 . 8 $$$, ."#33,#6,9/#1$/.'.$#%$%$.$ ,."$.3.-A.68$8$."/ @

- 06 .6,, 2 .$. ."#%#. ##8/ 3$/ ' %""$ . %0 A 8 3,08.#3,..83,#"$#9%$.$ ;

3"%,$ * , . 8. . 8 . #,6 %, . #0 . $%,$.$,,1,.3/#8.$$$*,, "$1, 6 $ , $,/ -A & 9$ &/.0 . 1/ $1#, . . ,, 8 ,3, -5& .2 8.%$1/$3$36.$."#9$,3'. 8$3,96-A 08.,..,,,,$16 $3.$#6"$$9/,3,-5&.2 ; $$18/."#,/,.3"%/,:%,/308 9#1 . . B3 "$% 8 , 3. . ##//.$",=%,0,.1,"#,$$, ,%""$%.##/'.$$0.,/$$,,96.

$# %$ , %$ $3 ##/#6 $ "$1$6 $3# 3$0 8.1$,%9%"."$%D0.%,#, .9%.,%9$B3/.,"."$% ,,80.$#%$.#,.."$%.,#, "$1..$/#1##,/.%,,<%,.3 ""##,/<%#0.""##%$3% B3 8..$ . ,/ . %$ $ "$1$ , "$3 ##/# .""##%$,../$%,8...:%,/3 9,$,"$1,0.".""##,/<%# #3,0,$/..$#%$D,/%$.$$/..#/# "$%3" . %,D .

"0 3"$1 ,$.,.*D9#&%"$3%$.

0 8.$ . 9 9$1,

##8

( &3#$#60.

"# $ % &0.*D9#&%"$3%$$$,.318, .$#1B$.,:%,/3$,##8

( '.%0.:%,/3<%#9$$,8.#6$ 3"##/,%9#$.3"%/,:%,/3#$#6 %$9#0 8%#, 9 3"##/ $ $ $$ 9% 8.$ .$"$1$6.,/.3"%/,:%,/3<%#0. ""##%$3%2,$18#69%.$18 "9# '. 9% . $# %$ . . "$1#/ / . ,3%$8,0.$$0,3%9%". 9$/,=$3"##//$%, 18.9108,,6##/#6$"$1$6 .,/$$,,96.$#%$'.$$0.""#2/ /$#1""#,,3,,#1""#,#,

! "

% &

A..$&"2/=, !=+ A..$"$9# !=+