National Insurance Company Limited v. Munni Devi And Others

  
     

 !"  "#$%$&' (

 !$& )&%*+ &#",- &./!0 
















 
*&&$ "1$ &0!2"+%
















   

 
       
 

!"#$% &$ 
((((

 !
) * 

# "  "%$+  &$ 
, ",%"

,  +"

- " ""

"

./
.0
01.2'

"34 $$%%," ,- ,3+ !  + ) , & &"$ 5 6*, $
7/22701.8!34  -$+ $&
.9!0.!/1/:7

3

"" %$-' ,$ $ , , ;8
<= ' +-&$- "

$&&, , ,-',,$,  ,> ,$$ % ! $

'' $3-$ $&"% "7 +, ?+-  , ,"$7 ,4 @ ! $  4"  '$"$
/ '$&$-  '$"3&$
$#!

"%$-' ,$$3$ $& -

$& % % 4&$%$ ," 
  "+- "

+"7

0A
1<
01.B!"% "7 +, ?+- 34,", $ , -$$%4%  3 ,  ,$$
 A/C7..A1 $, &$- , #,

$  $

$ $@ $'$&C  % '
 ",#, , -$$%4%  -$"  '"
D   % " E$  4$$"

$'!, - ,-!

", $% 3 ,  ,$$
 A/ 7901/% -&$-  ,"$& $

 $@ ,

,  -$$%4% $& +, ?+- 
 +$ %%,"! +  ,"  ,F+,  "  ,  -$$%4%   $  "

-

"
    %%," 

, "34C   $$&

,

- "$ ' $ '   '$
,  % $& 

%%,"$$@'

%$ %%$+$&

"  ",#, $& 3 $
 A/ 7901/34 '$"$
A7

 ,

! $, ",#$& " 
  &! G $
.B8"

"0/
1<
01.B

 , "
, % ,-"

',$$ %%,"!"% "7 +, ?+-  0A 4  $&

 ,
0/!111:7'-$ $@, '
 ",#!  $  "  , +  $&     ,"    

#  3  &$+"  F$, 4  "

# 4 , 3 $'

4 %$-' ,$$ 
'$$,%! '$" $
A "/ , " '$" $
.

"03&$   " "&, ",  -
 #"

,

$ %%,"$$@'

%"+$ %$& '$"$
. ,  ",#, ,"  "# ,% ,H+ ,$ &  4,-' ,% ", $ 3%$-' ,$
 '  ""

,& 4 , 3, ,4, $3& "! - 3& "+'$ + %$-'

4 ",#

#, # ,"",#,  ,%%

"# ,%  , +",  '$"$
A7 + %$-'

43&$ ,3+ - ,,  %$  $&    ',,$   ","  "  ' 4"  &$  , ", -, , %$ 

 '$"  $
A7 : + %  $-'

4  &, "  , -, #- 

 '$"$
. $

#, # ,"",#,

,%% " 

3#,$ -  "%$",,$ $& + % '$ ,%4
 ","

"  ,#$ #", %%,"  -

&  4,-'  "", , % $ 3%$-' ,$

 , $  $  $+"

-$ 4,%$-$& "% "

3&,I"
9!111:7'-$ ,  #4

 ," 3 !, $+ "

#3  "
<!/2B:7'-$ ,#,$&  # 

3 $,&,% $&

 $, -,,-+-

$ $@
, %$""

! $+

,

3 "

"% "

' $@, $'$&D7< "-$ 4

$&
0/!111:7

3, ,#$ ,-34 %$%"! ,%$ , 3$+

$%$"$ %$$3$ $ +3  ,  -! ","$&,I -$+% ,-"

-$ 4,%$- ,

&,I"
9!111:7'-$
$#!,#,$& >$,&,% ,$"

"1<
18
01.B! %$'4$&

3'$"+%"34 "%$+  &$  ,-$& !

-$ 4,%$- $+ "

#3
<!/2B:73,  -,7 @, " ,  # 3 &$ ,   ' $ 3 !,%$+ "

#3
<!8/B:7 ,  $"&$  @, "' $ 

' $,&,% $&

 +  4&,I"$&-,,-+-

 $& $@
  $ ,%  3 ,"   ,  +3-, ,$  ,  

  ,%     ,3+

", 3 ,#" H+ +-$&-$ 4-+ ,$ , % ,-"34 

3  "34D7<!, $+ "

# $", 3 ,#"

$@,  4  "! &$!,

$3' +-"

$@, , "  !,

!

 "! + !  # $,&,% ,$'# 

'$,$&,-

&$ '+'$ $&-,,-+-

"-, ,3 $ $@ ! $+ "

#3 '' ,"
," ,-3$& +- "# %"$3

&$& , $"$ 4$3F%"&$  $

%%,"

@'

%, 4 

" ,-, 

$@, , $'  4 
D7<

"-,"

"% " $@, , $' '
  4'$,, 

%$+ "

$'$"+% 4"$%+-$  3 , H+ +-$&-$ 4-+ ,$

3, ,#$ ,-3+

"$ - 

, $4

$3 ", 3 ,#"
$ %$ 4!$ ,

33$+

$%$"34 4$& #,"%$3

&$& 4$&  '$" ,% +", 7 + %

( $-'

4$ $

%+ 4$@,

$ 4

%$- &$ $-$ '+'$ , 4  "-, %%,"
 3 %$& ,"!  +3-, ,$- "$3

&$&

7 + %$-'

4

 ,-' 4$3F%" '%, 4    "

%$+  &$  "-,  ,-$& $&

 # '$,$&,-! -,,-+-

# 3 $ +% 4'$& -,7 @, "

' $$+ "3 $+"
9!111:7, $& 4 
 +%  ,+ ,$!, -4%$ ,""$',,$! -$ 4,%$-&,I"34 % $3& + "

,
  + ! !3, "#$,"$& 4-,!, ", -, "
$#! $+ "3$$" $%$ 
 )  *  C 00
1/
01.9 F

  ' @, : $"JE :$  '$ 3 J E :$