Rakesh Mahajan And Others v. Narinder Singh And Others
!
""## ! $% & & '
!
"
!
"(
()* + ,-*.
-(/0 (*
"((-2, ( ,* 3+(((34222,
3- --(0346 ,*(2(, 072-6 8/+ 34, ()0, 2-/
2( 0/"* -9 ,346 ,*(( ,0 72-6 8 :/+ 34, ( , (
2-/ +2(* , ++,, *(2(, * (* ++ -* *( (49*9 2,(+5 -*,, 6 2(- ;
,6 (, (3 * +, 2 $,, - - ,/ !*, "* -9 * +2 <8++(+(4,*6 ++,, (+5 +2(* +(+(4(6 < 8 * ++ *( * !*
(,4 6 ;9* (+5 * , 2 :
< 88* ,,--*0 ,4 , < 3*
88=234 -*3-*( (4 * ,2-* + , 6 2(- ;
, 6 (, / (( - (+5 <8(6 , -(( ((-(( - 4* (- 0(*, (2-*(2(+5 * , =2, 6 2(-;
, 6 (, 6+, - +( (+5 8
& ( * ( -*
!* 6 >2( 6;9* *6*
4 :* ,,42,34(+5 9 634, ()0, 2-?
2( 0@/"* -9 072-6
( 8
2 : < 88 +((( 34 - 72-6 ( 8
/(+5 * , ,9**9
+3472-6 ( 8
9 *,*
(4 -** (-*,,*+(+(4 ,
889( !* -((34, (A(++,, )2(9 (6072-6
/+ 34* -* )2( :
:
2(*(#" 8 <
9 , 6 <
2 9 (( +/+(02 ,- 6 * & ( * 9( ,9 4 ( 32* * +(+(4 ( ((* 6+( +((
,-*(2& (* 9** 0( (20(*2+(+(4 (+ 2,+*2 +(+(4& (* (* 3+ (- (-+*4 , + ,4 , 02((+5 <8 * 03 9**9(27, !*9 (( + 7 ( * 36+,6(02((0 + <<
2* ( 2,,4 & ( *
( +2(* (9*2;9,- 4,- 9(+ (* +(02 ,- 34 (+5 (-,4/72-6 8
/+ 34, (A( ++,, )2( 02((+5 3- 2+*(-* (-,4/2(, * 72-6 ( 8
3- * (-*
9 +((( +5 * *234 ;-263(+(,6 (4379*(- (6 3,4 6(9 (* (+5 * =2+9(
(4 02((+5 ((-* *3-
(4(+5 =2+9( (4 02(
-*!2, -*!* (49 0*7, *(>2 ,+ (/*90(/+9( (4=* 2*(4 * ,*, ,,- ,,4(+5 <8(-,4/ * , 2, B ((-* $ -*C (D9**9 2,4(34, (A(++,,
: )2( 9 2+*, 34 * -* )2( E3, 2+(6 )2( (-,4/(02 2*(* 2 <8/ /:
/ </ / /:
/ :/
8 < ( ,,- , 8 / : / :/8 / / / 8/</ & ,
(* +, * 36+,6 2*( 2,,4 6 , 2 9 +( 4 ( +5 ,* ,,-6 3,42 +( 4(6 ,2 : A,,9-29(( 6(6*+, -+ ( ?@ F**(*+, (,(, +( 4 (G ""
?@ F**( * +, ( , ( * (, +(6 72/ +( 4(G ""
?@ F**(*26 3,*+((6G "
?0@ F**(*+, * -,2 ( 2
,*+(2G "
?0@ F**(*+, * ,*(2 6 ( , (6* E3,)2(/4/G "
?0@ , .**)2(3,92 02( - 2 9( - (+5 3-+(/ (-,4/ 2 ( ,3*9(634)2(A(& A( ++,, )2(
* +( ( +2 6,4/ ( 9( 2 +(+(4 *
=2 +9( (4 02( -* 9* 3- (+(*(2-**#(+5 -* 62-* +9( (4=2 , < 3* 889**9(* ,,-34,-2 :
< 88!*2+(((34(+5 9 634*)2(( 072-6 8
--(0346 ,*(2(+5
,( ,3 (-
!* ,9
+ 34 , ( A( ++,, )2( * 2 9 (-,4 (!*-, (A(++,, )2(9(2(*( (634 *)2(072-6
:
:
0 * #" 8 <
<
- 72-6 + 34 , (A(++,, )2( -*)2(2,2 9 634 E3,2+(6)2( < ( 2*(4,,, 34 -*2(+9(
(4234(+5 (/ 6*
,4 , (,46 2* -** 2*(4 =2 ,340(2+9( (4=2* 02( *,* -** 2*(4=2* ,/ *,, 934(+5 0(0 *23>2+2(* (!*((/*23>2+2(* ((0( +( (+5 <89*9(
,+ (4+(02,- 9(*,* 0-,((-*0(*2 +(+(4
"( ( , 6- *( (-* *(2-* <8(69*6*4* +2(* *2 +(+(4# (2,( * * +(02 29 (2,( 2 3( *(9 ,,239 -*9** ++3 ( ,2,(+5 , * 3+, 2+*,,9-72-62++(* (-26( 34, ( 2,( ?@
"#$%& '&'( #)&)*#&+ ,-.,-&'#,) /$ /#01&) %(2#*&+ )"3$'-#($4 -$ ?@ # H ?@ /#$%)3/&-"%&)5/#$%)3-&"%&)/$%('&'(,6 ''&- -&"($%4 -$ ? @"#8 8 !*( 3072-623F*( 72-6 ( *93(2,( 2 3( /* 6 0(49,,3* ,,-34*+ ( --(0
90(/+( =+(( , (* 72-6 ( + 34 , ( A( ++,, )2( 8
02( 9 (2,( 2 3( / ( ,0* 3+, 3(*)2( +( 3* , (,4 3 2 -* 9 2, 92,32*9,,2 39 -* & /
*(+, * 0+, * 72-6 8
9 (2,( 2/(-(4( 3(
< & 3 40(- (-,,239 -* * 72-6 ( 3 349 4( 2/ 3( (6(+( + ( * ,,-*72-6 8
9*** ,4&0972-6
/ + 34"27 3
(4 -*)2( 72-6 <
/ + 34 E3,2+(6)2(/*(-*+ ( (4 ,,I34 72-6 8
0( * 0(-*0(*2+(+(4/*42,* 0+ 4(-*
34 ,23>2,4=288 02(
*(>2, 9 * 3( "( (-2, ( ,9*2 46(/*6 "- 6,, 2 ++, ?@/ 4/ , ?@ + (-,4
7
8 *( 70
F**(+ ;-5( J F**((+( 3, J5