Union Of India v. Rup Chand
#1#
! "#$# %&'()')
%# % !%*#
+,- %* & ./ ) 0
1 0// 2/ ) 000
!!! 003) " # # $%&'$( ) * + * ,* #- ./0../.0
)12*# * . # #3 1./0% # # ) * 0400./0% " ,* #- 3 # ./0../.0" + 3 ./.$ * 1 /%1 * # $ " #
# # 5# # 6' 7568( *
#2# ) # # 5# # 6 * # 9 :%./ ;* + )* * 5 </.0=4$ 6 9
3
1" *$=> ?
"
?
; " 6 @ < 6 * *$=> ?
, * ?
; " 6 @ < 0400./0%" # # 3 * " 6 * /%/A ./0& + * 5 0..=?./0& * 5 AA?./0& 3
" 5@
* 3 # +# + ,* 0=00./0: " 1? # # 3 * )* 9:%./* " 6 *
* ## " + 1
3 3 * # 4% 5@# 0:&A)
+;5 #
#+ 3 1#;
?
; 6 <#
0:00./0% +; 5 * 3 56 " # +* ; 6 < *3 ## " 3 1 ## ) 6 # * " ## "
9:%./;* 3 # # '
(?
"
; ) 1# ) " # < # 3 3 # 3
" ## " ?
* 1 #
# 9
#3# " ?## 3 , + * * # # 4% 5@ # 1* * B# ;3" +* "
;
3 # 3 # )) )1 ) - 1
3 0//4./0: " ) 9 ## 3 CD * 1 + ./00./0% EB 9 ) 3 #+ CD * + B 5 CD'(?&$?<>?$=?./0&?0=% $//0./0& +
3* CD'(?&$?<> ?$=?./0&?.0A0 04/../0&+ 4A/& /A/../0& * 3 +# * B # " + +)1 CD# ) 9 ## 19* 3 * ) "E..A.3 65D
@&::0A0A/=$0$0=/%:00/ 9 ## " ; 0F0 # +1# # +
3 ))&&:=//&.04" +)1CD B 3 ) @ '; 56 5 %A./0% < :%./;* E
E@ DE @" 5D> ( " # ?
4A6 E+## 3 # 1 # ; *3 EB # ? * * +)1CD*5 0.0/0..$$A:$0/.00/00. )0*5 0=F00 )0# + ## " ' 1 @<>$=./0& @0<>$=./0& 0 )0* 1@<>$=./0&@0<>$=./0&0
* (
#4# ) - 1 #
@+ 3+ + #
# #
+ * * ?## # # &./.%.: 5@ # 0:&A3 = C* ## # .:3 # ./ 5@ # 0:&A # * 3 ## *1 * 3 # * 1# '
) - 1 # *3 1( A
+ #
# BG0 , *# # G . , * *# # G$* )12 *# #G=<<< GA
;G4@ G%@)1# 6 6CD * G& , G:;, # " ; * G0/ +; 5
*# # 56 * # ) 56*+G@+)*3 +)1 ## 1#
# +# 4 #
*
# +# # $0$ 3 # 3 # * ## # 3 3 # # < ) 1 # 1 " < #3
+3 * + # <
1 ) #
;)1 56 # # +1 ) # % 6 +# ## 3 #- )1 # 2* # * + ,*
#5# ./0../.0 &
,* 3 # # * # : " # ? # ,* #- )
) # ,#
"
# ) *
)1
) ) " ##
# #1 ## " 3 +# # +# ## 3 # +13 # )* # # # 3 ## " # 4% 5@ # ## 3 3 *1 )+ # " # +# ## 1 # # 3 ) )1
) ) + ) * * #- ## 0/ G + # # ? + * * 3 # 00 1 1 # +# * ?## EBG.?E*1 )1 56 0//4./0:" +*) 56
)+# )# * #1 ,*
" + * # ) 3 H
!"#
!$
$!%%
% & ' (
)' ((
)* + , + ($ -. + /+ ( -. + +. 0 + ') ( '') 1!
#6# , & ( #% -.
'
& '
') $ ( (#% ( '
' ' 2I
, (') * 345 ( (( -. + +(
1 ( )
( ''
1 ' 6 -. 345 #% -. ' -.7 0. * +# # # ) 3 " '## ( ### * ) # # +# # B * ) # 1 # # + " < 8) , <*
!"
#$ %#$& "
) '
0 '
) ( ( 9 ( ( '
'( ( 9 ( ( ' ' '
' '
8( 9 ( '( 9 ( ) )( (
( ( ' ')
'
: ' )
(
' '
(
( ') ; )3 4
' '
'
) 6(9 ((
#7# '
7 0$ 1 # +# * # +1 3
+ 3 # 3 3 C )
1 +# 1 * # ) 0= 3 * ,* #- ) 3 < 8) '() *%
) +
, -& H" , < (
(& (
:') (& ( 8(
< (
' ( ')
( = '
( 6 '
'
:(
)' ( '
5
(
'
' )'> ( J 0A
+3 #
;*+3 3 3'() *%
!
(3
3 3
,* #-
)1 2*# *" # ;** +
00
1 0// '()')
1 .
!" /
/ .
!
/