Satbir Singh v. Chand Kaur











 





 








   










 




  !"#$
%&'($
$) (''#    

 ! "## $%&"%""'  ! "# *****
$) (''#+% (" '

 !  &!)*%   " !   "

+ *

!, "
'%#-"% .""%  * ."'   ("   /  !
") + +  #    " " * !%%   # "# ("## ! '

*"

' &# 
'%#

!

% 011 12 

 &  *"3
'%#+"

!"+  + "+ 122

1&%#'

 

 "% + !  &4 "     (" ##

 !

 %   5 

1! '

*"

' & 
#." &  *" 3
'%# +"

!"!!2

#! " % +#  % "##(+###+

* "  ! &4"%*" "
'%# ""&4"
'%#("### &4%*" "
' %# + + "+ &% ##

 &4 "
' %# +

&4" /  !6%* 
")(" % +

 &4 "' /   ." $%  %*"   "
' %#    " 7%*'  !  2

1  8  " ' 

"'/ +%!)

'"4 #

&%"% + #!%&4."$% ."$%!"*"!2

  " + **%,  
("## '" 4&*  * +4 * &  ! *  " " &4 %  %## * '  ! ' " .%  .

 % 01112 

"+ *"   " ## +"  " # "

'   & # 
'%# 


 '

4 ' &+ " ##  "
' %# " ) #! (" ## " 

!  " * '

4 '   +" +  & &  &4 "
' %#   %   "

##9 '42)  * !%%"
' %# +" +  & *  #   " '#%* !  *

  % 


("##+ 

"!%  #'

 

"% "&! &4" .%  
(" ##   !  ! %  + " * 

 *   # % !

 %  011  12 

 * * " ' ##4   

".%! *"

#4) *#'

 

 "%   
.   "
' %# + &  &4 )# * "

'%!

'!!

:

!+  #%  
(" # +  ' &%

 *   %  5   2

 #  !   20 

("##'" '* " 

!     %& 6%* 
")  "

' +* "#

 


(" .%   6;6 
")   # ' " % +"##++

 #! + " %   5 + "% !"!) * '4 #* *# % *  (" ##

 " +  '    # '

4 &7!   #!   '  &  4  !%    # " *  ##!" " .% + " ! "   ' * "& +" "!2

1+ %*"  &   +    <    " %  +

 &4 + * & *# 
'%#&4 ! *4 &%"

#  "

#&+"# "

 !:   )
' %# * !

' =' !"

"  "   + "
'%#("9# ' *+4 #

+

!%&4"+ * :"&# '

*"

%  #  %

(" #;#

 # !   !  " # '

4&7!  ") "#  (" .% ' + * % '

 , 
>"" " 7%*'  !  2

#&4"
8)" ""6 
") .

% & * 5;

* %   & *%#" *" "#

? 
< %   #   +"" " #

   "# "% ? 1
>"" " %   '  &  " #

'?/



   (# "! "#9'


'%#>,  /4""%&4>, 
7  *"

"   @ ' :

*" !" >,1  .%  " #   !!%'A90  (&% ! "# "##9'

 %" $%'  .) 
!
'

   .% 
") />, '7 4 "##/>, %& *"/>,1 /"'#
.

6%* /

 
")/>,

B' *"/>, 0 : *"!% "#  " *" '   !  "   .% '

 %    *  " #;#

% 1  %   " ##;    %4"% + + "! ! 7%*'  52 

C  (" ## #  &4 %%!! % #;#

++&4" /  !6%* 
")

 !  7%*'  

'#%*  " # ##("##.% + &  ' # + ! !!% " + *

!, 

4 !! * '  ! * * " # %  *  "##"#4 %".% & " '#%*! 
(" 9# +"+"! 4 + "+ *" % *  % * " % "'!% ! 4  4 "% # ! "  ##&  *" 1

' %# + % %!   &   *" '

 *"

! ' !

%  5 2

+"

!"" '#%*!"&#


# &  *"  ! %4 #!

! %"



!"& '! ' &4 " #   "%  " 9 !   #   A9/1> A9/  % &  *"* &9!%&4
'%# "%*""'"& #!

!4 &4
'%#+"

## * " + &9>, *%* * 4 " '#%*!/ &  *""

' "## "+ &9!"%&  &%  '4   >,
' %# ("%  , ##!   &   *"  " +  &9    *  !* "

'"

!%! 0
. "##+ "*!% ." $% 

 " %  7! "  "

%*" 
'%#

" '#%*!"  & #  " +  )4  %!!  " ##4 
'%#+"" % *#!4 "%  5
 #!

! # " &   &4 "   " %  & &4 # !

#    7% !  D%   ! " & %!  %&  #    7% ! C
(" ##

 &4 ." $%  "' / *  '#%* ! +  '  &  !" ! *%  (" ##  
' %# + 

  !" ! *%  & * & &4  '

   %  &!   *  * *

%!!

!


.

 %   5   

1 + & %  1
%  ". .

!%  " E..F&%&  *"

" % &4!! * " !%' * * + "+   "

 # % % 011




! " '#%* 7%*'  ! 

  # "% +     * + 
'%#+"+    "    %    " %  "% #  !%  &    " #



 '  
' %#     ! & #    #   %   " #

 ## " ("*"  !
'%#+ &

 

*'4 ) *# % #+ .%  " ## +% *% " ! 

1+#"&  !* &4"
'%# +"

"'

+ '" '' & ".%'

 *! ' "###

" + " * '

4'&+"# 
'%#

.

 ##12

1* 7%*'!2

1&% " ' +  &4 "   /  ! 6%* 
")  !  7%*'  C20

 "   " '#%* ! 2

1'* "!C20

%!"" !2

'&!"*+ "%!"* * !C20

 "%&'

 '&4!% " 

"
' %#"4*  !* "!!2

" 4'4  &"

'+

### ## ! &  " .%&%"   ### '4 !!!+ " +  <  "'4 *% "

 "
' %# "

'  !%  '    # %     !  2

#;#

."$%%*" "
'%#"  !%'  "% !"* *!2

1 .%+%*%"."$% "!&4  *! * %+ "*  # %% 011  12 

  7!    #'

  

  " % !!' "# % *  %  5;

1< *%" "#;#

"  !

4+" 

% "

&

  " #    1
% ..   ! " & #  " ! %  " ' +% &  , "&!%  "# %% , !% "  !  " %&D% %   < %" *% " 4 %!" &7! + "*!% & *'  &!!%

  % !%& 4&4"
'%# ! "     4 %!" &7!   '%  +   " 

* ".% ##""## *% 4 #4 * % %#".%!&+%  "%&'

 '&4!% "#  "#"' 
'%#+& &4)# *"

'% %% !

'  !!

  "

 ! +    #%< *%"
'%#  %!" % " &4

 *## ! & ".%"#"!&4   * ###  '4   &  +  " !"* " '#%* !&4

 *% < %"*%"
'%### " + &9 + **% "

''& ".% &4  ** * "

*

! ".%"

!" &!!#&4".% ## # 1 " 7%*'  !! *  !%   '4  
' %#     %

!

%& # "#" ""+)#

*!

'"

!! !

%  5;

" % %% %!;!!

!< %"*%"#" #  + #4) * !;" *%  %  D%   #   ! ! % * % !'# !+ ""#  5
% ..# " ') ! '

!"*&4"+ &%&<

%&'

 " # " '

&4    !"* " * & * & "4 %& *#4&4"## "  " '#%*!  &&  .%# *"#;#

"!4 " %## "

*  " &  +"  " ## .%  "7%*'!#&4" .%!!# ! ' "#;#

* *!)* "7%*' !  2

1 # *  "
' %#  !

 %  5;

1  <  %&'

 "  " !  2

 " % %  ""##!&"4"# " !% "!" '#%*7%*'!&  "! %  4"

*!& &4

%!&   !#! * <" "!% "#  #%"##,&)   *  ! %     + !

 %  011  

 5

1 ("D% "  !  , 
>"""!2

"%

%#4%#"
'%#? 
>"""!2

1!&  &"% %"## !'#4 + ""#  C
%7 .. "

 " %&D% %   5   

1 #  "

# %% 011

"&  + "+#'

 

 "% " &7!?

2 1
>""."$%""!%   % "%  % *

 ' "
'%#?




>"""!2

" % %#4%#"
'%#? ("#;#

"*"! "
' %#+& &4)# *"

'%!

'!!

:

!+ #% 5
% "..+ "# !%&*  +"!4 9!" '

 +, G<! +"

!""#4# * 4 '

#  % &!" % +  % %  %% %!     " !  +"

!" # !% '4 & !4 &4 %!"   9'#

  " '  

 # !% + "   '

 !4 " &   " # *H (" # *  " # !  !# !%%4   + "*"# !%D% &*  !'# !+ ""   # ("

# "!& " % &# ) ! '

!"* !

!+ (" D%   4   '

   +"" " #;#

"&&##    %    " ! !  2

1 # *  "
' %# " "


'%#+ +"% +

"&" " +' %*"'4 "'/ ."$%("'

"' /  + %!) 

   52C

5 # &4 "  .%% ! %"&" ."$%."$% " ## "+ &9& ""*  

 " #  &% 9'

 " "%& & *  4 ("   9# '%!"* & '"#

)#" +4 ' " +  &9  "      !   &  & + *  " #;#

 :+  
' %# ##  " + &9%##!% "

%*"""! "% %% %! < 9'

   !"



 "

 '  :

 &%  A* "

 +, G999   " &  * '4 "%'& '#  &4 %% %!)9 *") ' 7') "') )<

"%    " 6%* &    " "  '4 %#  )

'*)"&" &%< "<' *"&  " 6%* " "  ' 4 #* "   "

*%"%& ))")< " 6%* " '4  *% "  & & 

!

&4  % %% %! 7&  ) "')<+* '4<'*    &4 '4 %*" <    "

 ' +" & "''%+4H    9! ' "

 ! 9'

    

+,

 G>"& *+%#"7 '"

+

&"% 7 '<"&*  *+

 & ''4  &%   * * " #%# +  

  ') '4   ("4 4 + " '  + 4("!"%& "+ <+  * B "!  "+%& #  '4 
222;022;, %

!

  '4 ' ! <   +  *  '4   4&4H (" ## .% "  !!#  !! "
' %#''& "6%*" "" +*  "   "

  *% "  & &  % %  %%

%!!A "+ 

!%!!#"

  *" !4%!" !"#

*

! "

' +%   & !  ("

 #  "
' %#  

  ## !  &  " .% !!    !!   "

'!2

1# * !!"& "  4 "


' %#

 " ## *  " 7%*' 2

1 4  '"&%"'+  &""D%  '

 ' 7! *""!

&4 %  #  &% ! %  *      9! ' ! 9'

   
' %#      & !!%  "
' %# 4%!%! +

 &  # * " !   "   " !!! " 4   "

9'

  !"

 + "! ! ! "

%*"+ **%

1   " ! :+   '  
' %# ')     ! ""+# ".%+""

'+!  2

1   '    ' &4
' %# 9'

  !"



!&!!#&44!" '*  

!%  !!# #   " #;#

 " ! 

"% !!

 &4 %!! *4 "   D%  +* "#;#

 
,>""."$%"!%   %"%  % *

 ' "
'%#? (" ''  !    " #;#

 " ! 

 &4 % #4 %#
' %#  7!  "

%"."$%!%

%  "!% *

 '  
'%#%'* *

!!("##.%  " ""

" '#%*!"&# ."$% + )4%!!"##4 
'%#+"" % * #!4 "% "' ' "&""#  !%& "#



 ' 
'%# !&# # "#

 ("!% ! !% 

"% "   % % ("' !"

"!  " ##4' %+"

# "
'%# "'+% !  *"%#" !"*"!% *

 ' + +" ' #    "

 ##4 ' # !%4  " !

!%'!""#

! '

*4 # *" " % ##4""

% &" 
'%#<"

+ "'

* "##.%+ "*!% ."



$%  '   " %   *4 %4  "%  ! %  =%"'  !  ! ! " & #  " &   ' 
'%#! ".% "4'4"!% &  &4"
'%#+

## ! & ".% !!+ "+ '"

 '!)"! *%   &  + &    !  2

1 + !"* ##&4"
'%#&%  *4  "  

 4"!2

1"'* "! #&4.% ##"' " 

 4  
' %#+!'#!"*"!2

1+ "% !"* * " !  C20

 # &4 " .%  ## 4 '4* ."$%+!'#'  " #% 


 ,>"""!2

1!&    & " %  %  " ##   !'#4 + " " #  C
%7 ..

"%&D%%  5 

1# "

# %% 011

"&  + "+#'

 

 "% "&7!? < #%&4 "## !'#4+ ""#     C
% 7   ..  "   ! &% # % % 011

"% " % '4  "% + "+ '

4 " !%' 7! "

#4

 " % +&%*"! C
%..+ "# !%&!  # .%7 .%  C
%..+   %7&  :4  ." *" +  021

 .%  "

0 #;#

 "    #  % 4 #   +   #!"

 *"  !'#4+ "D% '  C
%.%7 '%#4 * %%#".%< "

+   " '

!%  

'

*   " ## .%" !"## !'#4+ ""#  .% 7 C
% ..

" *% 4 #4 * %%#".%  7! #4 "##

 "% +"

 + "+ * # % %  011   

  122

 "   %  5

1!% &7! ""%  '  && *&% 1
% ..&% !"    4 %!" &7!   ! & !% " " +  

 "

 *"     * &7!  D% '  &  4   " %  A  " .% ##""" '#%*! !!% + "+ "# %% 7! #'

 

 " % 
" "&""""

!& ! .

%  5   

 " .% '

*"  "  # " ! 

1("

# "% "!%'

 "!

 "!% ! "&#+ "" + * * , G("#

! "' * "   #"'& "'  "     *"* !%% #%&% "     ' " "   &%* 

!"""'%#"

'

 +4 " %*"4!"* "' "#

12

1:!"

% H

5
'%#

+ ' "*  !  # 0 "# &%"' '#4" ! ! &#  % "#

" ! * "#

&+ #  " * !%% "  (" +  ' +

 &4 "

' "%*" " ")
"  !(" "

*!%**  " !"
'%#  4! * "")
"  !

 * * "

 "%'& '#  +*4 '%!"  % %%

%!"+ ' '

 *"* !  #1 "# '

 * # *!  % &  *"4"


'%#''2

'

 *! ' "###

" + 

&4 "")
"  !("' 
'%# "# ! !# !%%4 " """)
"  !+  ** &4 "

'  +  '

 &4 " ")
"  !"

&" '

 *! ' "##+ %*" &+ "+4*%+" 
'%# !" % 4*% * !%

* "##.%"

'#%*! & &4"##&4#4 * %%#" .%*4% &!! *4 ("## .%  '4 !  #  * +4 &4 4'#" ! !    "!2

1("

.% +   " 

'    !  2

1 +% #  " #  "  & *    ##9 '4 ;

 ! +"

!" "4 !% " "&  %%!! ""  "! %

C &+"  "



:+  "

! %*" '  "7%*' ##.%

  # * + " " 7%*'  #   '  ""

.% "#  '  ""4!    ' &% '  %%!! % (" .%      '

!&'&%"#    " 

 < + +""& !%" &  "## +("7%*'!

 " "   .%   (" %

 &4 " #;#

 *"# &" +!



 
!"
# #














$ %
&'(
E/@% F

















 
>""#) *;  4; >""#&  4;