Gurbrinder Singh Dhillon v. State Of Haryana And Another
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND
HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
!
""
#
$
% &'
(
)* *
("
#
$
% &'
(
+ ), ,
# -
) ,
.- & /0123 673 ./7 &.
1.6.
Mr. Neeraj Poswal, AAG, Haryana.
./7 &.
1.6.8 4
! " #$%
! & &" &
" '( ) ) *+,+#$%
-(./
/0 1 2 .
.'/3'4( 5/3$) 67+ , + + + # %0 1 .
8 #$%&++ & &"
8 + ++ + 7 7 + 9 + : & + / /(
/ 5 * 7 + & + ! + : + 9 7 9;
+ "+ + 9 + &++" $ + &
* 6 + /( /5
/ 4 & + % 5 <* /5
/ 4 77 ! $+& &+ & = * " " *+ 1 1 +
& """+ " + & * " & &" '
+ '
/ & 7 9 + =
% + "+ 9% + 6;7$ *+ " % + 6; 7 979; + , !" " + &" 7 + & +)" !
1 &" "+ " * " + " + !
,
" + " *+ + '
.
.'/3 '4( 5/3 $) + $+ + ! + & 6+ + + + & + % +6;7 &979; + 7 & "+ -.) ) ) + % + 6; 7 , & + " -.0(2) ) &* + &," /.
/(
&" ) ) & + 6&)&& !++ ! & &" +&+&""&" ! " + #$% + '4( $) &" &++"
'4( $) > + + .
.'/3 5/3$)" +&
+$ -
/ - &*
)
$&+#$% > + +#$% 9 #$%,&+& &" 8 +1 " $ + " & & % 5<* + & &" & " 9 % 5 <* + + ! ""
/0 1 32&"))) < )" + & " ?
6.5. ?
6( 5 $"+ ++#$%$+ % 5<* - <+ &* + ; & + 6 & ) )#1)"0 1 -2 &
&% <* > " &" ) ) <)"&" ;" """ & &; @ + $ & " + & /(
&"+&")) < )" + 1 > & & "* ;) ;& ++#$%7& ) +&++ #$% " (( ) ) = && +&" & + #$% & ,, (
&"
++ & " ," + + + &" 9 7 9; + & ,% +6;7& ) &
*
+*&") );&"1&) + && + 6 , $ ) /.
/(
&)+& & $ + &; + " $ (() ) "" $+&" )&"
+ + = & +& , +#$% +&& $& ++"
&&* &)@ '( ) ) ; 9@& ) 9+ ) ! 1 '( ) ) 9+)1 ":&&9+) ! " ; & ) * " "&"+")
9
&1&) !9@&
) + +&" " & 1
'( ) ) &") ;+) &
9@& ) + '( ) ) & 1 & ;&+ +& &"""": 1& + + + 1 "*&1 !
550 2)B 0.2=+ #$% " *+B
0'2 = + #$% +:& & " +:& + &" +
550 2)B 052=+ #$% &" &&& ; +++B 032=1+&+" ) 0 +2 + ) + + ++"B 0-2= + " + " *+ + ++ C
% & ! "
# $%&&
& 9@& )& 9+),+ #$% 1 ; + + .
/ ) $ " & & 1 + +:B02;02 &") %&
'
( ( "
# ) ( % && * + ,# -.. 1 ) 1+; '( ) ) 9+) " &* ," , & & &)
$ 1 '( ) ) ,+1 $/ ) 01#* ( "
( % &&- -
2- 1 ) ; '( ) ) + & 1 +"""1;&" " & + ,+ + 1 ! &" ;9+)+ .
9+ &" ) +,+#$% + & " &; " " 1 &+ " " $ &*+#$% &" "
, , + + & & " + & 9 & + + & &* & .
.'/3'4( 5/3$) '4( $) " &"& &" + $ & +" +1"+ '4( $) $ * ;+ 9D& )'
1#* " ( % &.-
2 & " '4( $) &; & & 9 '4( $)+:& &&& + &" + ! " + & ! " + & ":+ # &""+ &+ *
'
;&
'4( $) E'4(
=&+& & &; "& " 1 " && E !D>1D" 02 "*" +;"+ & " B 02 + " " " " & " &"" !+
&
&&;"
.
)" & 02 " *" B & +;"+ & "B 02 0 2 " & " 0 2
&"" 02 &; " &" 0 2 & 0 2 " & F++#$%+&"
$ & & &) " & '4( $) $ + & + 6 * / /(
/ 57 +& + +:+97 9; + !#$%,&+&" &" *++ + 1 &++ " $ " "&" G> & &" ! " +$ !+ $ + $ #$% 1 2 0 1 2 +&;+ " "
++ + &++" "*"
,
++ '4( $) ! + ++"+" "*" " + ;" + & " % + + & ? + $ + &" " "&; " ++ '4(
$)++ + & &, -
+ *+ .
.'/35/3$)++ &" B"" " &" " " &"
+ " * '
/ & &," & & #$% ! ) & * #$%
)
, "
! .
.'/35/3$) ( ! *+ + + & &" &++ "& % 5<*+ &" /5
/ 4 & & !#$% & &"1" +& ! +&""+ &""+ *&" % 5<*+ & " ; & & ) & /5
/ 4 0 1 .2 +&+ % 5<* 77 979; +& & +6 77 9 ; ! & &
&* + ; & ) ) #1 )" 1 -2 &% <* +&" "+ *+" % 5<*&" "+ &$ & + + & )
+ ++#$% ++ &+ 8 ""+ "&&"))<)" /(
0 1 42+ +& &&
1 4" )" && " && ! " &
$, "
&& 3 3 * --- 9@& 1 ) & #$%
'4( $) + + + " &" + &*+&& ;" #$%+ )&;,++ ! " "$*;
*
+& 4" &
& ) 8 ) & + & , % + & 4 ! ( "
# $ ( &&.3 3 * .5 (# ! ( "
# $ ( && 3 *
++#$% + * & " *"+ 6 7 8 9) ( "9 :/ ( %&&-3 3 *
5 /" ( ( " ( %&&205 &&"9@& )+ #$%++" ++ )+
" $ + &" +"" * + + ++ ;)1 '( ) ) , #$% ,++&;
9
+" #$% -( ./
/ 1 2 .
.'/3'4( 5/3$)
67,++ &,,"
.
02"
'
< " &
) , (MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes Whether reportable Yes