← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2343/2022allowed

Nesho Devi And ORS v. Ravinder And ORS

2025-12-23Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma13 pages

 

  

    

   



 !

" "# $% &

'(( !

" "# )*$ 

 !

" "#

+ ,

 +"

"""""))**$ % ,"

,

  +"

""""")  % -!

 ./ -+"

+  +

+-  

      

            

  ! "

#### +

+-

"

$ % 

 & 

'

(

   $* $$ +,+$    (!

(( (  ( $-- .

$/,  0(  $1** 2(  3$1** 45 &"

   ( (! %(&   ( 2(  3 %(& 45   ! ! ( '  

 6 (!

  

 $,*7,$*6

'

)( ( 

!



      !&( ('

 0( (   ,- ,1 +,$1 +   (  !( ( 

 ( (  :

!

! (

 &"

  %(& 

 (   (    (  :(  & 

( ;( (  ; &("

 +- ++  +  /   +/ 

  +

%    

 6 (!

   ! (

 &"

  %(& (  ) (

  &   / %   "  

 &

)

! (

 

 6 (!

 &  

  <        

  ! " ) !"

'  (



 

! ! (

 &"

= %(&  ('"

& '  

 6 (!

 %   "  (!( 

 -

        (

 )  (  SETTLED LAW ON COMPENSATION >4& !   Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 0123 +5) 6 5 % $  7 ( ) 

! ! (

   !





?30

                                      

                                         !"#$%           

   &$    !"#' %     '(    !"#) %      

*                  +       

 ),-                           .                !%     

/    0   

                  +         

                               

      

        ),-           ),-     

    

        

          

              

    

* * * * * *

 42.*                !'%            !   

   1   

 2         %

      "3!    ")&, &"&)  %         4 "5&($,   4 "($" $)   4 ")$(',   4 "''"')     4 "$'(),      

    4 "")"))   4 6)((,

  4 5("()   4 )((5,  

* >4& !  

National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 01 83 + 497  ((  ( $-- $-



$-*  0(  $1**  )('



!7% 8      9 !:% 1   9 !% 7     9 !8% ;        

                     

  9 !.% /       <       09           

  0    <

# ?52. 7    conventional heads 

    ; 0 =  +       ; &) ,,,         ;"

,, ,,,   ; "

,, ,,,       

       

; 0 1 

8                  

                

                   >                     

 7          

                 

       

  

     ?                      

             

                        

 

        +                          

                ; ") ,,,

4 ; ', ,,, ; ") ,,,

 

         :

      

*        

                ",-      *                        

@ @ @ @ @ 59.3 *     ),-                    0    ',     

  $,-       ',),   +       ),(,      ")- 7              

59.4 +      !%     

       ',-                     ',   7 &)-      ',),   ",-       ),(,

        

8   

        

59.5  /                             $,$&1  A B    

59.6.

      1  A C    '& 

59.7

          

59.8 ;        

           ;  ") ,,,  ;  ', ,,,    ;  ") ,,, 

         ",-   

>4& !   -$:6$   $*

5 $ ' 6)$ ;

/(6(%

,"

$ 5 $6 $*($ <5< $6  %<  0 91 93 + 7

 (('

+$ *$ , 6$ 15) $3

 $ $;

+%<( 1+5) $3  '

('

(!

   !

 



E21 7 :     1 =                  ?      +    F F           F  

9  F  F     F    F   F

      

                      

*                       

&"

"

Spousal consortium          

  

     F 



         0   F

&"

& Parental consortium            F   

    

         F

&"

$ Filial consortium                 7                     

                                     

                

40    

2     G                      4  0                               

          

        

4A 7        

    +                 

                     7 7                               

                    

                                      F F     1 = +                   ;', ,,,     

$,   (!'

 ) 

'   <

" 

(!

( @  !!



  AB  <   

'   </ " 

(!    $$

(  ((

 &"

>4& !  +5 (%$ ,"

,(

+( :< #

+ 44 )( >4& B   

& !

( (( ('

  "  (  ((&(( 



'  

  !!

 %   B  ! ( 



E""

                    ; 3"6# !;

/

 .

    H%               ; ", ,,,# !;

 

 %            

                 ; "$5# !;

/

 ?

 

 1%

                                       ; & ),,#  !;

   

   / 

%

             ; ($5#  !;

  1

 1

 

 1%      ; ,,,# !;

1

 %                 ')     4;       

                          "    $,

   ")                                     &)$,     

   "65,

4        

           4  ;

              "'    ')   *         1 !  %  ; ', ,,,# !;

/

 %      ",-      4  I +   J H  ; 

!&,"3%  "3  1  "$,                    

       K; '3 ,,,#   )L     ; & ', ,,,#  !;

  J   /

 %        D $+

 ()

&  

'!

'    !&( (' (

 (

</ " 

(!

( %   %(& ('"

( !(( $$

$

  

         &  ('

 +,,,,6

)( );('

=!

@ "

>)  ! "

(  &(('

 !"!  ('

   '

("

!"

 &   %(& :"   %(& ('"

  !((!!

'

;( );   ( (!  

 1,+/6

 ! % = %(& ('"

 (!  

%  ( (   ( '



$/ @

!

        B

 (!

(  ) (

  &   %

 :( (' ( 

   /+ 

$<

 () ( ) &"

>4& ! 

&  

'! 

 (

) %

   $* $$ +,+$   &"

   ( (! %(&   ( ( !((

('"

%

   (!



 (   

! ! ( !



  ( !

  

Sr. No.

Heads Compensation Awarded $ "

!

 1,+/6

+ @  $,9

 1,+6

21,+/ $,95 D( )   B( $6/

 +/*$6

211+- $6/5 / %

!

 7//<6

211+- +/*$5 < ((

$$ -  D"

 1*+7/,6

27//< $+ $$5 = A 

 $*$<,6

* @ AB

 $*$<,6

= (!

 $1 -,,6





/*/,,6 $  



 /*/,,6

$, ( AB

/ ,,6

$$

%$* 6) $%( " =4=2> $+  5'%(

! )  &"

%(& " =98= 9 > $

 <$ '

$65 % " =#2=2> 1 =4=2 =98= 93 $-  

(   ( 

 &"

>4& !  Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma  2   84

R.Valli and Others VS. Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation 13 # +5) 6 5 % $ 8=

!   

    "

 ( 

!

!

  (('

 (!

(( (    (E ( $7 %  

  ! "

( (  (  

!

'

)( (

 )( %(& )((

( ) ! !

  ( "

(

'! % %(& ( (  (& ! 

 

 (!

 ( & ;

 %

   (!



 (  ( ( & ;

  (  %(& $* ('

( ( (

"

  ( 1+

+-3



" "#  

G  ;('6  ;('



H6

G  &

 H