High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3402/2000dismissed

Bhajan Singh Etc v. Jatinder Singh

2019-11-25Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!" #

$$%% &#' (#" #'" %"% #

$ )#

* +, # $$%%

# -,#+, # #$

....

#%/+ # $%(# " %" +# %%0"# +$'# 1 1#'" '" !" +2 " + " 34 !0'#%(3'" # " + 5"$6#1/6/$

$##4"#4%%7

#"#" % 4'#" 5% 4#% 1" 87 # ' % 4'#" 5% 1#" 5 6 - 9+ 5 ' - + 5 #'41#7887 7 + 8 + +988 + 8 :

$#!41# /#

6 ;'% #% $#4 !' ##" #4 %" '%#4#" #"/5,#

$# ,# $%+ 4 # +4%/+4 <#0'#1"6# '% #"#4%% 46 47

#'4 9+8+#," 4' 4 "#4= $'%#>'#"#% 6 >

= 4 <# 0'# >$# :

#6 #1/ +6 # # %# #= $% %6/1#/6%%" $##4 $##= 4#6# >' %,'# $%"#"#+ # # / #% '%# #",# #" $%+ #,

'$ 1' #$%/ 4

2%%/+ $%1#'" ';'

""+ $$#%

!6#4" '/" ,#4 $%+# #" 4 <#0'##4 ! 6#$ '%%"6 # #% # # # $#$#/ %'" ' % 1 #1/ ;'% # 1'#% ' 4' - #"# 1 #,'#= '$#$#/% ,%%" ?#+6 $#%/6 %4 '$% @44+$'# 1= '%! #%1 %1#"5 #-

,/ <"

%= 1'$'# 1@,%<$%#% % #1/+ ## 4#5 ,%' $#$#/ +8$#4#%= 4 <#0'#64/ ' #6/# #%% '$#$#/ "#4%%'$1/ $%"'= 4# $%6;'6 4 <#0'# ," %!'# '%+4 <#0'#1" %%##'#%%"%/#$ $%= $##4 4 <#0'#6 %/ $ , 4 %%" >' "#4 $% 4" , 1 # '41 4$# 1%5 $$# ,# 4 "#4= "#4 ,%+ ''#% 6 ' /

# 46#'%#44 <# 0'#=4#4 <#0'# "#64%%/ $ /%%/65 6 ,""/" = 6 # #"%= % #"#46 $%= '% , % $#$#/ '4%,%' 9+8 $%6 4#5,%' % +8$#4#%= #% "#4#"#"%,#/$6# 6#"+%1%= ",#/#" % 6 '$#$#/ A + $#/#4% '

B $% % #$% #,#" %%" 6#46 ###" ,#4 $%

$%" $#+%%6"'6# #4 C #<#0'#">'"#4 %%7

,'# $%#$ 4' 9+8 %$#D ))

A'- $#,+6 #"#47

1"" $#D ))

C # $% %6/1#/ %% #/6%%"$##4 $# #D ))

C # "#4;'6 '# '1% #'%''%' #''% 4#$#+ %%"+ + 6 D )

A##$#, + $% "## 4)C1>4" %6" )C #! - + C## )C B $% % #,#'4

# + >4 !" C 0 @ C

A #1'% ,+ $% % >4 ' " +"#@%#5)C

# #" %#'%# $#+ #% @'#'- " $%,'# +'- ,'# " $% '%%/,!'"4#:

7 ' $%641/ #%@'#

2%"""#,1/ !'"4#+ $%%$$% @'##('"+'$"#+ 6 6"%#%#('"+'$"#+ 6 +,!'"4#

$ 4+ !'"4#$1/ #%@'##

7 '%1/ $%#$1/6/ $ $##4 "#4 %% 7

#" >' %,'# $%6 $# #4 +%"6 + $%8$$%%6'% " 4>' #'" @'# A +# #$#4!'6%"# $%##" #4 %" ' % # $# # #"/ #" #

"6 !'"4#$ 1/%#('"+'$"#+ ,% $##"'%#$$%1# @'#+6 6 ' #$$% + #'" %"% # $$# #'" '%

A , #%#'%# $#1"" #'" ##

B #% @'# %/ , ' 1#+ ##, %' $% 4#1%/ %$#, "#4E> )6>'1/4 <#0'# 6 # ,"56%"6 6"#1 # #66 '# B ##+6%"% '4'%1", @;'%/'%1/ $%64 <6,#+ 2#$$%%@'#6 #

9 ,6" "#4;'E> )6#11/ #!- +)C##= $##% "#4+ %# 9+8 1$= %6'# 4#""6 %5 4 44= #% "#4+ $6## ,1%,# $%8$$%% A6'# #1#, $%$$#" )C 1/45"4'$$# 4#% $" %'%1>' $'% %64#""6 %5 4 $'4 +8 %5 4 4+ ## %5 4 >'$6##/,'# <#1 !

" # $'#$4' #"#"#4$ )C%6" +"6 "#4 %$#,'>'$" '4 9+8 1$1/ $%4 <#0'# $#= #!

+$/#/1"E> )'# # $6##/#"#"$/44#""4/ %5 46 #+6 6"1/6 %5 4

@#" %% #'4+ 2# $$%% @'# #! $%#1/ <#0'#6 %/'#' $%8$$%%

: ,"65/" # '414$#4" ,1 1 1%5$$#+6 6#%#,# "#4%% A61#, "#46'%/>' '414$#4 <#0'#+ #6'" #%6%% 14#4 15 #$" "#4$"' 4$ $$# 1$'# 1/4 <#0'#= #/#"#"

$/4 4#"" 4/ 1/ 4 <# 0'# %5 4 6 # 5$%6 #"#/4#%/1' $%8$$%% ,+ 1 ## 6'% ,''' %'44 #"#/%%"1/

B $##/ #"##14#""4/ +86$ %5 4 4/"#4 %%6 ,#/+6 $' 4 <#0'# ,#/ 56%" " #4 4#""= !" 8$$%%4 <#0'# $$#"C '#" #>4 56 %6#47

B 2#$$%%@'#%' #$# !" <#0'#6$# 46#" #4$ '%7

"#4%% % 4 '46##11/

4)C## 6"$# !" 4 6 6>'+ ## #%@'# 44 ### %" 4 <#0'#6 ,"/$ , A 6 '# # 1#, # 6 , 4 <#0'#6 ,"65/" 64%%/ ' %%" #"##;',"'

/","$#$##"+ 2#$$%%@'# %' #4'6;' "#4 6 6 ' # E ,#/ $ #1/ #%@'#6 %4" ' $% 1$#$#%/%6 #!1/ 2#$$%%@'#

B !'"4$1/ 2#$$%%@'#6%%#+ 1$#$#$$#%,###$# %6 B #%%"%/#4/ #+6 4" , %%###1/ @'# # !'"4$1/ #%@'# 6$$%!''4'%/ 4$#$#%/,6#"#$#%6+ 6 #'%4##"!' B !'"4$1/ #%@'#6#" %/1/ 2#$$%%@'# 4' $% ''%%/$#, 4 <# 0'#4 #$### # %"%,%"#4%%E> )6 4+6 6 ## 1#/6%%"$##4

$##1' #'%4'#' 4"#6#$##4 #$# # >' %,'# $%" #"# B $%61%45'#"# $$##4 "#4%%#' $#4!' ,'#"

-'1%;'%6# $$%

B $$%4#"%/

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#