Haryana Public Service Commission v. Anshul And Another
LPA-404-2022 ( O&M ) -1-
! "#$$ %%&& ' ( ( %)& # ) *+,- )./!01#-2!!*314 #01*2#1-5./!01#- *+,- !./!01#-10,*-).1
& 6(74"4 (&&
!8 4! "48(
!#((4"4 &*9
&7, 4 "2 4
4 &* ::::
9 0(
! " #$$ ( 4 ;( #$$< ( = ( >? & ( != .
= #39@AB ( 8 & & *9( 48( 8 (#$$ $( $(8 (&* 0( = 48 (8 ((8 8 C$ ( (2 =
4( #$$8 & & & &
( D
LPA-404-2022 ( O&M ) -2-
$$(!2" $48(& 8$( $ ( ( 8 & && ( 8( & ( 4 ( 8 D & 7& $ ( ( ( $ 8( ( && C& ( $
(& & E8 7& F (&& #$$("($ = ( & (
#" ! " -C " , ( ! " ( ! " #$$G#$ -C$ 4 ( 4 ;( < 4 &&$ 8 4 8( 8 & (8= ( C$4 & 8((( $8 $$ (#$$0(4 (4 ( ;8= < 8 ( ( C $ $$ $ (#$$ &&$ "G&" " ( " & !( $ ( ( $4 ( ( ( != .
=H 14 = 4 ( H= 8 &&4 8 $
4(8( (8 8 (& = (( 88= & $ 4( ( ( H ? (8 I &*94 (( (4( $((&8= (8 $ & ( H = ( ( $ & " ( )=( 1 $4@ C
B 4(=?>&&4 8(H ($( D C(& H=4 ( ( &&4 $ !( *7 H4 ( H (
LPA-404-2022 ( O&M ) -3- & $4 8( &&$ ( 8( 8 1 $(8( ( =G "4( 4( &8= 8 & =(&&48(( = "48( (8 8 = (& 8((H) & &! ?
( 48(( & ( != .
=4& ( ( (8 ( && &&$ " " ( " & 4 ( " (( &8( 0((!(8= 8& & ( #$$( ( ( 8(
== 4( && I#$$8" 4$(8"&(" 0(&& I#$$ ((
$$ & & (8= 4 (2" $( ($48(
=($$ 9@B9 ?9994( 4(#$$&& @ != .
=((( 4 ?>(4(2 =
(
J>B$ 7( 8(J>9$ 78C ) ( &
&(&C#
!
" # !
$ !
"8( 8( ( H= 4(" &
$ 4 ( 4 ( & 8=
=(&
=( =$ =((& && =( &
LPA-404-2022 ( O&M ) -4B ) & &(H =$%&
'!
"(!) * + !, 48( (&C#
( ( =( & ( $ 4 8( 8 = &&$( = & $$((H ) & && = &(999(H =$48((
! "
#
$ % & ' (
! "
))*)+
, $
- (
..)+ (-
/01 2
' ' '
! " ' '
, ( 3
- $ %&
(
'
# (
$
( -
#
- ( '
$ % & '
(
(
-
#
LPA-404-2022 ( O&M ) -5-
(
(
'$ %&
, '
(
(-
'
- , 3 '
'
- '
(
3 '
'
' (
$ 4 '
'
-
' ( '
3'
' (
(
-
'
(
! " ' '
'
- 5
$ %&
' '
$
% '
'
'-
( $ %& '
'
! "
))*)+ $ '
6
$ - '
( ' ))*)+ (
- '
$ % &
))*)+
- '
7
3 %
'
(-
LPA-404-2022 ( O&M ) -6- )8+) 4 ( '
'
9 -)+$ %& '
(
- 6
'
'
(6 -(
-$ '
( 6
(
-
: J 1"8( "48 ( &( ( ( != .
= $ $ 4 ( =(& (&$=((" 8 (C ((& 8 (8= 0(&8= 8 $& 8( &&$ (H4 ( & 4(&( $1 ( $((8= (8 (" & 1 (8= ( & & 4(#$$8 (" H ((8 (" =(("==( =(( C ("= 8 & $ 3 = 8( &&$& 8($ =
( 178((
=& & = $ ( $$4 ( " $ 4 $7= $ $& 7 = 4 ("= = ( =( ( 8( C 1(& 4(" $( 9@0(
8 9A(H=7& 1 ( $(( != .
=( 8(8 & (D (C((8 ( ( (D & $ (( ($4C& ($
(& & E8 7 & F
LPA-404-2022 ( O&M ) -7- > ) 4( $ (& && $ $ A = 4 (&=&& & 2!!*31 #01*2#1-5./!01#- 10,*-).1 5
4 ./2- H 3(( &7=G K 3(( & *