Harpreet Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab





    
   


   



 ! "#$$  % !!&& ' ( ")(*+ % !      

      
 )   , - ./  $!!&&

   )$0.&  , .)(*+

  &2  .      $      !  ! ( /  $



.!&! 2 3)&" "(&4.  3   $  +2  "(+5!  6 &!  "#$

$          $  5/##   75

  4 !     + #    &    $       -    "#$   4$! &&#.4$3!&*-(3 3

 $ #$3  .#$ $.$ 5$4 6# .8 8 .3   (# +(    &        &   0  &#  4$  $  $  3$
$ 
$40#&"#$9$$2. 4$$4"(2.$+ $ :4&! 4$$3 $$ $ +(! 3$24 4 0#$ 9 +(  ;7;

 !

.  ++(    "00.      ,(** !( 

33!( .3  . & 04$3 $$ 9$2 4 3!+2$ ! 04$3!&  $$  & .$(#$$2(&2$3$4 $39 $#$ "000:$$4(&+(#$ & &&4#$3 2$#(2+# 3$#  3 09++( & 32# 
  

      

9 2#$++((#$$&: 3$0&  +#$39"000(  4$$4$/# $ !#4&0  3$(+#/ +&44$$3$:. (&&2: 3($&&4.$$$ !   ! "#$ (#$$&3+ 0& 0+&&2#$ #/ +&44$$3$! :94$&:4&2# 4.$#&!$$3$49$  #$(  23!  3 +2$!3$ 9$$& ! 3$!&#4$$  !/4!

 5$3.$3!&( $ $ & &#$4$!&( $  ( 4+2$3$$  3$
$ 9$   ## /$&.$2$ 3/:"$ ,( ( 3
$ +&!&. 34$ $4  ,( ( 60 /!&9$*(  40 $ . $4/  $#$3&(.$4& + (#$9$ +2:4&,( (60/!&.3  . $  $3!&4  3#$!&$ 42$3 $!&! 2#$3  

8$3/ $4$3!($ 0!&+4:"00/ $&# #  #(2+#$# 3 0 $  "00.++($ !  ! "#$$3(  :

8$5/##    3<= ): $3!&$!!$ 3<= ):7+&4 .# (>$!&.$+4$$ 3& ?5<= ):7 4  $!& 8$!&! 2 3!+2$3!&4,( (60/$!&. 3  (+2:+!&$3 ( 2 $$!& !$+2:. ( >(! #.! ! # ! <= )
$ #  $ ! !   *( 2  !   <= )?  &    #  $  !3 3 =3($+2:+2!(#$

 !&&#$(& 8$5/##   (!! 8$+&4!! ( &2#$ 4/ ! &.4$$4&+2$

 4$  $  &  $/#  &  @6"@      4  0   !/ / 233<= ) (#$!&<= )6 $!&( 4! !  "344   

  ;

.  $  (  4      +2  $ 5/##   3!& 
$408 &0B*,$

(  "*/  -(3  C  "00  4   #  +2  $ 5/##  .4$( &( 3# $  $  $ $  0! &     $ &(   (&2!(  $ &42&!!$&&$3$ 6# $(&#$3 /  ($3 <= ) ( " D$</4  .4$$ 4  #  +2  (      +2  "5  "3  "#$

8$  .$(4$&!&(2!( ( $&( 33+2$3# /  3 $  &  !&  8$  5/##    ! !   (#$ 0$$ / 0$3! /33<= ) 7 +2"5"3"#$ (#$!& <= ) 7$!& / 24! !   (  $!&.$5/##  !$! & 4$&4$
$!&

A

  



.  $  &$    $    4  ! (+ $5/##  +2:
:+$"#$ 8$ 4 &/ $! &&4$&5

$/#&@6"@4 0!/ / 2 33<= )   3!&/#$  3&. $&&#$(4! ! &$
( 
$B(&# .3 

  !     $&&    $ 
(    
$ B(&# . 3  . $(!!& !(3 &(!$$&&&&$( ! / ( " D
)
8$#$( " 5)
=&(/&2 +&+2$
( ".& 
$B(&# .3  /$   ;

 33  $      $ 
(     &   "  B(#. 3 

E$$4 /$
( &  "B(#.3  .$#$! 3$ # $ ( " 5)
#("*/-(3   $( "  4$"5)
# (  ++(    "(  4  &.  $ #$  $3  #&2.4$$.$2!&#(&2&3 &

8$4$= /$! (

( #  $  (       /.  $  ! (

F =3324  )E (0$$ 4*.

)E  ,( 3*.)E
+&,( 3"#$.)E
+&  " 4  "#$.  )EA 
+&   (  -(3 .  )EF
+&B# )&.)ED*-(3 .)E; 3$
$ . )E 5! 6 &!"#$)E $$!&"#$

E$$$! (/&

"3$(4   ( " 
)
.4$$&&$ 3# (3!! # #  ($  (  4   !(    $3  +(  $2    $ &&##$$2 $+&&2 3!&$ 4/ .$(&2/ 

  $ #   #(3.  &    & 
(   / *(#3 

/("*/-(3 & "00 $( " 5)
('*2 -(3 &++( ! "#$C"(C$+ $   (  "      4$  "    5)
  $3(

63( G " "4  "*/-(3 C "00 5)
53! 3 &!2    .

7      (&   !23        ( $  ( # # (3! 3 !  =3$

'*2-(3 C 7 53! 3 &!2

D ++(  ! "#$ C"(C$+ 5)
 .

7$(& !23        ( $  ( # # (3! 3 !  =3$$

8$*(#3  &$(7/ ## /$2$/&$! !!&.4$$ 4#/$"

E  $/  $   &   (&    $  !!&& (/& &/, & $ ")(*++##$ (#$$    E$! !("*/-(3 C "00$! /&(/&2 3/&2  / 23($3$?5 / 2$4!(+2 $3$4& $3/( 3(  $.4$ 4$ # ( '*2-(3 C++( ! "#$C"( (  ! "#$C"(C$+3$?5&

( #$/#$3$ !!(! $ $ $ +$&&  8$ &*( 2 $    +("*/-(3 C"00.4$$#$4!(   0 /  3$!+230#&(  3 8$04(++&! !  3?":<= )7$04(+4$ $(3+& +/(&2$$3/(*( :

8$/ 2$$+2(#0.4$$# (4!

; $(*( : !&2$#$3$+3 4$$ (&$$3(& &2$4$$$ 0&&:  /&/3$ 4(.3&2  ! "#$C"(C$+'*2-(3 C++(  .4+34$(+(& '*2-(3 C ++($3&$4$/23/(*(  $ 6*( 2$+ +($3! $ ! ( 2.$$ =$ (#$$& : 3$0 E$ #  ! "#$C"(C $+.4$3$?5.$$4$/( *( 4$+ 0& 0+& ( #$/#.

($!$+&4 &&($+ 0#& +&$+ /  3$!$(

8$(#$)E  ,( 3*$!$*( 26  

+4( 0!$+0 #$$$ $.(&+(+2+ 04 +&.+( $+&>(4$4$ $33 $            $  ?":  !   <= )7    $  !#($$ $ ?( $ .$! $ $*( 26  4($+0$ #$$*( 26  +4( #$  +3(&+(+2$3 4! 5$+$$+&4/ $4



$        4  /    3  $  !   3  !!&&  ! "#$$( $ & $ / ($!!&&H ! "#$(*( 2&&# +2$! (

8$  .( /43( 3$  $ ! "#$C"(C$+'*2-(3 C ++(4 &$ $!$3$2 $! !$3 5$+0!3$$  23#!!&$ #$ 44 !32! !+&$!!! 2 $( 

5$42.$! ($((&&2! / $ ##$("*/-(3 C"00 $ ( " 5)
 +2 $4 +&(+.

4$ (&4$ # ('*2-(3 C ++( ! "#$C"(C$+ 8$(.$!!&&+$&!!&&7( "*/-(3  C"00 3.4$  $3  &&4  >(  !!&&7(  '*2  -(3  C  ++(    ! "#$C"(C$+$2 >($ $ # 3#$3

"*/-(3 C"00!!&&H( ++&# $3+2$
( 4$&(!#$  +&&& 
$B(&# .3 



 ( 4 #$3 33&2 30$3( #$ 3#

 
   





     !"# E$$ !0#7 

I76 E$$ ! +& I76