Karnail Kaur And Another v. State Of Haryana






    
  





































  


 










!
"
#

$

$
% &! '

() $

*" 

 

 
 + ,
'-# $

$ % &! '

()

$

*" 


   
 + "
.
+ /"
'-#
.
+ 0" $$

% &! '

() $

*"      



 

 % 
0"
1) 2
3"4

#
*
2 
  
"

  


/
'

5 2
3"42 
#
*



 


'"*
&##2
*!)
3"4
1 2
()


34
!6
'"2
3"4

#
6* 

7
7
7
7
7


 

   

8#
0!"-6
#
"*

#
 /-
#
*


 ""
-
#
6
"
""



39!
% 
*"
:) "
3""
'
;!"-2
# 


















8#

"-


*-

#
6*!-"
"
6)
: )
:
" 
 /

 8#
!
*
6 )

!2
;
'-#2
+ , '-#
"
+ "
.
+ /"
'-#
.
+ 0"
 -/# 
8,
#"
/
:-
"
:)
#
!

'!:
4 ;!"
-2
1!# 


!"

< 2
< <
"
< 
"
/#

 +

=%
5# 
8,
#"

/
>!"
4"
0!"-6
""
?



39!
%2
# 6-
!"
 
#
*
/
!"
-! )
8# *
/
/""

#
!

#
;!" -2
4"
"
""



39!
% 2

6
 *4

'
 %2

#

!
*"
#
# !"
"4

*!#6
#-#
#
#

#

! ! "
 

 8#
!"@*
!*
:-
"

#
!

;2 64"

** 

;

"-
:,@6"-
# 

#

!



#


)
# -

!#
*"-
6 )

#
-!"
#

# "
'!:
4
;!"

-
#"
4! )

*" 

0!"-6


4
"
#
#
6
/

6 )
 "


"
#
#
6
/
-
#
*
 '
 %2

'
 %

>!
6
 
*
 )
:)
#

!

#

#

#-#
" 
*!#6
/! "
:
>!"

#


 8#
"
** 
/
#/4
"6"
:)
#
" ;
4"
"
""
 



39!
%<

4 8#
!"
# -"
#
"
"
""
 



*"
:)
;
"
 
"
""






*"
:)



"
';
:)
/)

 -

4
*

#
!
 '
(/42
#
"
!

3""
' ;!"-2
!*# "
:#
#
"
"
4"

"
"" 


/##
#
:
6*!-"
:)
/)

 -
# *

*



8#
*
/# 
 -
#
6*!-"
"
""
 


#4 !:6"
#

#
*!*

/"-
#
!"

#
!
 ;
!"
*4

'
 2
#
-

>!"
 ) 
6

*

#

#

#


!#
/#

#-#
"
 

>!"2
"
#
*-


0!"-6
:)
#
 -
"


/#
#
#6

#
'

<

=
#
!#
:
!:6"
#
#
4)

#
#
!"
/ >!"
4"
#
6
4)
0!"-6

/##
#
*
#4
: !"
-! )
  )
#/
#


!
 "-"
0!"-6
#
: *"
/# 
/"-
#
!"

;
/##

)

#
* 
#



?

=
#
 
:
!:6"
#

#
#6

#
"
4-
# #
;

! )
6*


#
/
 ")
96"

/ 

,
#
4"
"
#
*

0!"-6
/#!
:-
:!" :)
#
*

#

-
"


6*

*
 0!"-6
)

#
*

#

-2
#2

 
!  "-"
0!"-6

*"
:)
#
-
#

/! "
4! ) 6
#
#
;

-

** 2
/##
/
4
#


# "



8#
"
!
!#
!:6"
#
*4




#4

:
*"
#6! )
/#
*4


<
"
 < 


#
#
#6

#
"


"!:"
"
#
- 
9

*/



6
0!

*

"
"
 4
*

*

!  "-"
0!"-6

8#
"
'
! 2
/# 
!-
#

6"

:# 
 *2
#
!:6"
#
/# 
#
*/


;


!" /#
6

"

#6

6

'
 ?
 2
# -
/# 
/"-
#
!"


6

'

 

6* )



*

:!
#

** )
6"
"
**

# 6


#

"
/##

 )
:
"

6# -
# 
4"
"
:)
:

"
)
!#
*
6"
#

:
:) /)


/
"
*,-
"
"

/! "
:

66

6 !#

*


0!"-6

+
*"-

"
#
4
!:6
"""
:
# !2


**



*4

#

 2
/## "

 /

   !"#$%&!$  '($)  *+,-.!*.$  #*))".  /*--  -$).$)#$ -&00,#,$).12-$3$!$


5#4

-


*2

#-
# 4"

#
*!
"
#
!"2
#
# !"

-! )2
"
#
#
!-#

4

*!#6 "

,"
62

6
4
#2
#
/##
!# -

6*/"

 2
2
:-

-
 #
"
 2


*
#
#
!"
!-#

:



>!"

9!

:"
!"
'
 2
#
6) "
#
*
"
!:6
#
*"-2
"
/" #
!"2

#
#
;!"
-

/#6
#
 !:"


5#
6
!"
#


:-
"
-#2
" #
-
"

)

*"
!"
!: 
2

-"

)

!#
!"2
#
# /"

#
!"2
/#


#
*
-! )2

# #
;!"
-


8#
#
;!"
-

/#6
#
*"-
 !:6"
6)2

#
#,
2
96
#
*
" 
"
96
)
/
/#
#
 ")
-4 4"

#

"
6)


"
,
)
!# 4"2
"
#
*
!#
0!"-62


"
 #


#
#,
2
"


"-

/

8#
!

/"
   

    



 !

!"  

# 

  



$ !

 

!#  %% $

&  %%  

!# &

   

  !%'



!:'




'  2
#/
#
4

#
-
#,
#
!

#
!" !"
-! )
 )

"4
*!#6
#-#
#
/#
#

6* 
 2

#
!"
!"
-! )
/
#4

:
/""

;

8#
2
:-
*!! )
 

-"
#
!"
/#
 !"


-! )2
-

#/
#
#


#
"
/
4
 "4
#
*/

#
-

*
0!"-6

>!

* 
6

#
!"
-"-
/#6
#
-
/

# *
#
!#

#
!"
"4"
>!
=
#
/"2

 6* 

#
-!-


 ?



#
-




6*

--
#

"
#


 )
#
!"
 ;
-"-
/#6
#


#
*
#
#)

-! )
/#  *"-
#"

*
***
"@0!"-6

*

#
# !"
!"

-! )



(4-
# "
2
#
9
>!
:
#
!



/##
# -
#4-
*"

!
 "-"
0!"-6
>!-


#
 !"
/# 
# "-
#
*
-! )2
#
6

:
"

: 6 )

*

-! 
>!
#
*
"


/##
# **

#

:)
;
*!!

*-

!#
0!"-6
:) -
/! "

4! )
6!

#
;
-

**
4
# 0!"-6

-
/##

-
#
:
!!

#
" /#


#
!

'
/##

#
3** 
3!#)



=
#4
""
#
"
!:6
8#


#
"
:) -
'
 ?


/
 )


6,
;

**  !#)2
:!
/
 )

!
#


/#

#-#
"
 


:
6*"2
#
6
:
" 
/#
:)

6
9*" 

#
,

;
#
#

-
/#

6
6)
0!
: 
#
A"
#
#6

#
"2

*

 2
#
; #
:
4"
/#
4
*/

#
6



"6
#
4" "
4
"
/#
#
*

#

-
8#
*/

# #
;!"
-2
!*
!#

6

:
96"
 

 ()*

+

$ ,

-.

/ 0 *2
/#

6
#"

:
"

4
+#
* )

"
#
>!

 /##
#
;

/#6


#"
:
"

!"
*4




'

:)
#
-
/#
#"
6"

*
#
 #-#
"


/
/"2
! "
>!
#
!"
 /""

8#
4
+#

%
(-#
/"
#
>!
 *4
# "-
#

 /

B< 8#!2


# "
#

#
-
)-
#

 "-
#
4"

"
"
#-
#
* 6

#
 !
#
#
!"

-! )

 
#-"
/#
"
#
"4
*!#6
/##
 :)"
#
0!"
#
#
#

"
#
*
 -! 
"

#
6

#
#
;!"
- /#

*

"
/
"*

#
6
 ) #

#
:

6
"

#6

/
, !#
4"

4-"
!"
'
 ?



# "
3
#
6


"*

#
6
#
 #
 "

-!""
:)
#
"-

-! 
4" 
:)
#

-
(
#

6
#
/ *
"*" )

#
4"2

#
"
" 
"
#
0!"-6

"
/#
/
3 **

4"
"
#-
#
*
#
6) ,

4/

9*

*
"
6
#

# 
-
"
"

0!"-6

" /#
/
/##
6)
:
#
0!"-6

4
" 

>!


=
-
/#!
)-
#
#
-
/# 
/"-
#
!"
 #
;!"
-2
/#

6

*
#
#-#
"
 

>!"2


6 )




*

:!
#

! ) **
#


#


9

#
4"
"
:

"
 
 )
#
#

-

4 )
*
#
#


!# /#

#-#
"


/! "
:
0!"
3 #!-#
!#




9

6# -

4"
"
:

/! "
4! )
:
 9
 6
>!4 

*-


0!"-6
:!
!"
#6

# "2
#
;


6*

"6
#
4"
"
"
/# *

#
-
"
"*
#
6


:
"
#
#
 
**
4
0!"-6

-

#
9

-
/#  6-
*
 #!-#
,

*-
0!"-62



*  )

D/
6-
:,



#
*
2

*!

0!"-6@" ""
?


39!
%2
*"
:
*-

#

" ""



39!
% 
"
#/
#

#
:
""

# !
"
) 


0!"-6
'
6!#



#
!"
#
: >!"
4"
"
"@0!"-6
5# 
-

*4

  ?

 2

"!"
:4
#

 )

"!:
#
# -
/
! )
6*

>!

!"
/# 
/"- 6-
!"

;


-
/

#
*
#
4 

>!"

:
6*"

!"
!"
-! )

<

3
6/#
6 
!




*"

1 21 3)4 - ( 5 6.

+

.,.7.2
/#
#
!"
/# 
:-

>!"
 6

#
#-
#"
:
4"

*


#
6-
#- "
#"
:
/""

#
;


#
-
*"
##-# "




>!"

:
 "
8#
!"
# -"
#
"

"@0!"-6
:
#
!

'
/##
/
"6"
/#  # "-
#

#
"

4

/
B6* )

*C

:!
# -! 

#
!"
"
""

B6!


"

4C
8#
"



"

'
;!"-
/
# -"
:)
/)

 -

4
* :
 #
(-#
!

/##
/
"6"

/# 
# "-

 /
 B

5#2
#2

#

*E
8#
*!


 ?
/! "
-
 #/
#
/#4

-


*

#-
#
4" 
#
*!
"
#
!"2
#
#
!"

-! )2
#
6)
" !*
#
"
!"
/
!6
6 )F

#
*!#6

:  "
6!
:
"

,"
6
#
/##
#

6*/"
  2
"


#
*!#6
6!
:
6
4
#
#
/##
#
  
 )2


#
!6

#
"
!*
#
"
!" '!:



 ?

3
#
!:6

#
"2
#
 /! "
:

!

#
-

"
#
#
*  -
/! "
:
!"
#
6
: -

#
-!6
"
 /

0!"-6


)
")

"
 )
:)
#6
=

 !

#
#
* 
-

*
#
* ""
:)
#
-
6,-
#

(

#
>!"
 6
#
/
"*"
0!"-6
"
/

"-

# *4


?<

#
"
=

0!
*: 2
!*
#-
 #
4"

#
*!
"
#
!"2
#
#
# * 
-
6)
*
#
#
!"


-! )

/## 

/! "
:
*

#6

>!
#
!"

=
/

""
#
#
"
-
#"
>!"
# *


#-
:)
#
6
"
B"
#
#

 
/ !

#/
#

/

B0!"-6C
/#
#
6-

 ?<

#
"
=
6!

=
6




!""
#/

# * #
*

:! "-
!*
#

A"
!:



 ?

#
*"-

:
!:6"
:)

-
 )
/#
-"

# 

/##2

#
*2
#
!"

-! )

(
 /"
#

 -




/##2

#
*2
#
!" 

-! )
"2
:4! )2
/#
-"

#

#
#

:
 0!"-6

>! ?

8#
 )
"

#
:4
"


#
/# 

#
"
 #
!"
#"
:
>!"

*



#
#-
 )
"
#" :
4"

*

6-
#-
/#

#
*


 



#
!"
#
:
>!"


/# 
6-
#4
: 4"

3
 ")
"!"
:42


/
/
/#
# 0!"

#

-

>!
6

#
!"
" 
/"
#
6-
!"
/#
"-

#6
"4"

#-# "

2
#2
!#

*

/
:
6"
"!-
# !

0!"-6

>!

#
6-
!"


#
* 

=
!#

4! )
/#
6
#
!"

:- >!"
:)
#

-2
#

/! "
:

6-  *4
9

#
-

*
#
"
*,- "
-"-
-! 

#
!"
/#
#

6
#
 ") :
" 
/#
:)
#6

##-
#

4"
8#
*
 4 !

4"
#4-
:
!",
:)
#
-
/#  >!

-
#
!"
/! "
 
 !"
#
*

6
 *
-"-
-! 

#
#
!"
8#!2

!#

4! )2 #
0!"-6
 
/! "
#4

:
"


*
>!
#
!" /#

/""
:)
#
-

#
#
;!"
-
 6

'


8#
#
;!"
-
/! "
#
: >!"

**
#
4"
""
:)
#
-
"
 >!"
,
!#
4"
 !"-
 -

/
"
#
 
"*"
 !
-"-
-! 



#
!

3
-"
!:6
6"

:# 

*
/#

 *4


<
"
 <

 2

*!


<




#
#/
#
#
-
#
*""

!
/#
*4
 

"
<


'
<
 
"

!"

45 #6&,..*1"!#")3,#.,")



=2

)

!"
#
#*

/##

#-
# :
6"2
#
-
"
#
!"

-! )2
# #
"

"

>!


5#2

)

!"
#
#*2
#
-
" #
!"
-! )2
:!
"

*"

"
/# #
*4

'
 ?

'
 2
#
# 2
 #-
#
!"

#
>!

2
* 
!*
#6
"-

/



9

9

9

3
*!


<

#/
#
#
-
6)
#
>! #
!"
:!


#
"
#6
-! )2
#

6)
#
*"

!" 


!"

 

"


#
"
 #
#

#
"
/
*2
#
#
*"


#
#
!"
 >!!6


"
6*

"-

/
=
#
/"2 *4
!"


/! "
6

* )


"- -"-
-! 
#
:
""

=
!#
:6
4"
#
# *"-
:
*-
)
"

-

 

  -
#6

*:
!@
 


6*-

!*
# !"


#
6
!
"
,"
"
"
,"

*"- 

4! "

8#

/#
#
-
#
"

#
*
 /#
/# 
>!-


#
!"
#
#
""

"- -"-
-! 

#
#
!"



'
 <
*

*4
-"-
 -

**
- 4

8#
 4
*4
"

!"

74 //$*1-0!"8#")3,#.,")-



 3)
*
4"



# "
:)

(-#
!


9")
- 6
0!"
6)
**

#
'!*6
!

 3)
*
4"



# "
:)

'
;!"-


3""
' ;!"-




# "
:)
)
#
!

/##



6*6
 6
#
4
)
G#
:
*"
-
#6

-
)
#
* 4"

#
6
 H2
6)
**

#
(-#
!

 '4

#/
*4""

!:

2
)
*2



 4"



# "
:)

* 
-

3 '
;!"-

-

#

 2


#
"  2




: "
!"
'
 ?2




 
*

/#6

"
#
:
6"



#
: *"
!"
'
 
:)
)
-2
6)
**

# !

'

< 9

9

9

3
*!

"
*4
6* )
"
#

**

* 

"

6

*4

'
 
/! "
 )
: 6: 
!*
#
:-
"

9

*4

  
"


*

!#
-
=
#
/"

**
/! "

:
6: 
-
*

"-

#

- -"-
-! 

#
!"
"


 )

#
;2


9
 */
!"
 ?
 2

#6
#

**
/! "
: 6: 



3

!*#

"!
6"
:42
=
"

"
)
6)

" ""



39!
% 
*"
:)
"
-

/"-



#
!"

;

6



"

6"
:) "
3""
'
;!"-

#
"
""



39! % 
"
#
6

#:)
6"

8#
"
""




39!
%<

 
!*# "

=

#!
""
#

 #
6*!-"
0!"-6
""
?


39!
%



# 6
*

/"-
#
!"

#
!

;
#
: "

:

*

#
-
>!
#
*
4 #!-#
#
6
#
:
""

#
6
"
) 


0!"-6

 #
;

/#6
#
*
#4
:
/""
/! "
:
! ) 6*

"6
#
4"



)

#
/
 "6"
)
"
#
*

0!"-6

"6" ***
/#!
:-
 !"

:!"
:)
#
*

# -
"
/! "
 
:
/
/#

0!"

>!
# *


#

"
!6
/


 #
6
"
-"-
 

#
*

:
# 2 #/42
!

#
6

 )
"*"

:)
#
" ;
(/4



4 

)

#
6
"
" 
#
:
:"2
#
;
/
:
6*

,
)
* 
"
/#
/
8#

*
"
"6"
/#
#
"
 

9:99;95 &!3,)%$!,)+(,11 *,0   &%+$ 5##
*,-
@"

I
@
D 5##
*:  I
@
D