High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1501/1998dismissed

Bir Singh (Veer Singh) & ORS. v. Dharambir & ORS.

2025-08-21Mr. Justice Amarinder Singh Grewal6 pages

!"##

!###

$$ %

%()*+,+%+,-+../)+

!!"" #$ %&

! '''''

'$0 (!)*" !!"+ ," +- !!"" +,)")"!, $,,)".%/ ,), ")%, ,",)&* )0

,,"3,,4*

$,%, %+-!!"! +-!!""%

,0,)&* )0

*+4* ,0,,)*, !0,&*, ," +-!!"" !",, 7 (+, !",, $,,)

,,* *, !0,&*,),! 30+, .,),0 0, ,)%,

# ! *" !, !",, *, " 0*,) 78 9 ," ,!",(!",, "

" , ,!* !",, 7 ! , , !",, 2:

"*+", ,

), " 2 8 :15% *"")

, !",, +,*", ,) ,** !-,"!, *,"

," %, 0 - - ,) ,+"-

,!!",, 0 %,- "% *"*,-

7 ;!, !! ," ,%, 0 ,)*,)* !",,

0,,0<*,%0,,+"< !, *," +0

77 5*% 0 "%6*( !",, =0, 0- %,,*!! , ! " :1%""" * ( ",0 !",, ""

>0,0- ?%, ,0) "*)", , *,!!-% :

"- *0

%,"0,,)0* ₹7

%!, ,0 ),, "

A*"- !, *,!!-% !",,

" 72 (" *!!!,, " +-!, *, !",, &* )0

( !",, !

!!" + "

,," 3,, 4* $,%,

""),) , &* )0 <% !",, ),0, ** *"

!!"% 1

2 B *" !!"" + 6*+"% ,"

,)!, ! %! ," 0%"

- - +0 %+-%-

!,5,*) , , ,) +-6*+"%%""-* ,0*,

,",0- ,)"%, +",! +0%+-%-

!, 8 5, **+0, " C= *"-! +-,)%, D 8!"

,)5,"*) "*)!

. !"+ " 6*+"%"", ,% :

* %,"-

%!, ,

+" 0*%!, ,0 ),, "

- 0," ," ,", 5, **+0, ,0 =*, "

!, *,!!-%"

!!""

1 5,"*+0, ," :1, ), *0 ,!*0!,,"%,

*0% "-=* 5,)

" *" !!""!" ",*!&* )0 E?+"*!0 6* 5 ,, 7

12 66, ,"2 (* ,, ,", , :

*"-!, ! + !0, , !" +" , , ₹7

+!, 0 1 5,)* 6*+"% ,"

,) 0,,), , 7

%!, !

5, **+0, !!"" +,"

!, !!- *!=*, "

,!, ! ,)"- &* )0 6*+"%

)5 6" 1

,,"

3,,4* +,)+ *0, &* ",+"+, !!" +""% : ( - " *" !

*+0, !!"" ," +", , !, *,!!-,+, *

%, * *""", +!,

! 5, " 6*+"%

*! *!!,,

,)"- *, %""!!" ," +-!!""

5 " *" !, !* !! +.

,), "*+0,, *!!!," ,0)"*)" :1C= %!" + " D !",) ,,)%, %=0,

-,, =0,, * +- " *" !

+ ,"6* D 8),""- 0, *, " %+,)*", +- E%= 0,,) !, *, " !",,

, %% (!

"=0, ,) %," :1C= 0"- 3D 7,

% ", ,,! D 8!",) !,+,),)%,=0,

+" !",, 0, , , =0,, , ,%!, ,,! 5,*0 %+,)%, !

", ,,!,0 ),, "

!",, " ," =0, *+ ),+",+"", , 7

, +!, " 6*+"%,)"- "* *""", +!, !

"-"

2 7 (* &* )0 E?+"*!06*", *! +-" *" !!"", *!, ""- ,,)*,+" *)"

:1C= %!" + "

$,%, ,* + 0% "

,0* !-0 *"" " , ,

% ! 2 >* *, ,,* +- !",, % !0,&*,(! ,+*"

! * !,

- ::C=3

7C=3 7

7C=3 2 %""!, 9 C=3 8

C= 3 "" , , * +",

%," !, *,"

% , *", ,)*,!!- 8 5 ,% ,

,6* , .

,% , 0 6*+"% % , ,)+ !!,, +" *0- >*0

*+,"A*, "%, , ,,!!!" ,)"- )* , ,0 * ! )*" !!", ,)0,""*!!",, , - """

#0##

'$ ,, D!.,) F D!+"