High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AS/59/2022dismissed

M/S Ncubate India Service Pvt Ltd v. M/S Fast Track Communication And ANR

2022-04-26Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj38 pages

!"#$%$ &' ( ($)$ $$$

)) ( &' * && $ +$ &" ,)& $ ( $ - ...

/ !"

! " # #$# %& '! () *!!

" " " +, -! ( . / , 0 )""!

- 23# #$$# 4!

53, 6$ - ( !" & " " " 7! 8 ! ! ! " $ 9 &!"":

!" ! !"

8" " & "

! ! ;< !( 8! ! ;<"

8" " & !

8" "!

;$6#3=2,8!

! "& 8!

$ ( " & 7!

#=3 $=$6

$# = 9 ( !" ;$6#3=2,8 ! & -$8! - 8" &> 7! " !""$%

$# = " ?!

! @ !& ! 2 $$# =

! 8! 7!"!

! !

" 7! ! $$ A 8! ! ! "

!" B

CD !" -

CD)E ! & $ CD)E$ ) 7! 5 CD)E5 ;! " 6 CD)E6 / - 2 CD)E2 . ; = CD)E= . & 4 CD)E4 " $5

)E$8 F!"

!" B

CD !" -

CD)E$, / !

$ CD)E$,$ D( 5 CD)E$,5 ) !

=289 ( C 34$

$6 . 8! " !

5 5 ))" .! %45G + ).)1H "

" ! " 7! 7! & " ; G" &

8" " &H!&

! " $2 (! ! & & " ! 8!C & 8! !" !!

CD !" -

CDE , ; $ CDE ,9 ) 7! & 5 8 !

!""& " & 8" $= A !& !" )!!

8" !

! 8! & ! !7! 8! ! 5

&" 6 / !

! )! ""

! > ! " !

& &

> "! ! 7! 7!

! ! !& 8! !

& !" !

3 - ( !"

8!(! CD)E$ G

D! 8 # 8

H & !

& 7! 7! !

& D

& > !

" 8! " !

& ! " & ( !"

8! !

& "!

> ! E5 G

D!8 =H !!

! " !

$%&'# ( )%* + " !

! +#

,! ( )%*

$%&- + # ! +

" "

. 6 > ! " & 8!

7! !

8" " & & ! 7! " D

& 8! " &" ! & "!

7! !

- ( !" 6$ >! ! &" 7! !

! CD)E$, G

D!8%H 2 ( !

! " & )! ) 3 ( " ! ! " & )! & '! () *!!

" & !

D!8 #GCD)E$,$H 5 $$# 2 ( & 8! 7! 7! !& 7! " & E8 ; !

8" " & ( ! & '! =;< ! ! & $$# $# = . < " !

&.< 7!& !

8" ! &. " &

8" " & ( !& " G

D!8 #H & 8!

" !

!" &

& ! ; " D D" B

/ 0- $" )%1 2

3 , " ! 4'

$ "5&6 ! $" )%1 "%* #/ 5& ! "!%* #/

! 5 - -

+ %* #/

7 5& 6 ! ' 5 - - " %* #/ 4 %* #/ " 8 9' : + %* #/ ,! $ +8 9' :' )% )%*$%&- " +

( %* " "

$%&- ))% )%* 5!;-

0 < 8+ 8

! )*=% *

+ 5& 6 ! >" 8 2 . + 5

- - " ! .

" !

$%&' -

?%1

#/- % )@%= 0&; # !"

#$"$% & $'"(

5& 6 5& >" "

AAAAAAAA ) &* +

, #+ - . # / # 0' / 0- 0

$&%- " $ )%%*+0 # 4

"!%* #/>" 8 2 "

0 0 < 8 "

AAAAAA 1

2 0 "0' 0 - )%1 # B 2 B ! " +

" ;C + " - )%1

!?;1

! " !

$%&'# ( )%* + " !

! +#

,! ( )%*

$%&- + # ! +

" "

. %

& )" &

& &

! " & & . !

! & " &

8" 9 & 8!!

! !

, ! &

D! 8% !

;$6#3=2,8 "!

7! (

&& 8!

!"" & 8! D! 7! 0! " !

8" " 7! 7! !!& 7! " " ! ! ! 8 D

& & 8! ! !

! !

8" " & D 8D

& ! 7! 7! " ! & 8! ! !

! & !

8 "

" ! &" !" !

3 - ( !" )01

! 0/2!0 / 345 !3!2/0 61! /34! " %

!" !

5% - ( !" ! ! !" !!

!" "" ! ! ! D! 7! ( !" ! ! !

" 8D" ! ! !

! ! " 7! !

& 7! < ! ! & ! ! !

! " 7! D! 8D

& CD

& 87! ! 7!

# ( !" !

5% - ( !" !"

! " !" ! !" ! !" 7!"& " ! " > I !")! " 0

# 2 !)33( 4 .. 4 E

!" " 5% - ( !" > I !")!!

B8 D %

D " D

" " D "

" ' ! 0 %C@ > " - E " +

+ 0 %C= + +

" " E "

' !

" '" 0 %C= %C@ E E "

+ 0 5-, -#%@1=0 *%+

- .' *'&* 5- "

+ $ "'

$ $ *'&* # # E " E9": 0 + " "

E E 8

+""

" "" " "

' ""'# ##'" 5#" + * - $ 6 %"$*'&#$ " C + " +

" +"

" - " +E " + " + "" + +

E/$ ' # 5 ""'5- # ''"5#"&' ##'"# $.''**$#$" .'&' 5#$"%"# %" - * # # $ - $7*'#& 7 ? ( " '# 8

& 5 .'# 95 "'0*- & - :4.14

0 %%=> " - "" + +"

0 %%? - " " " .' " 5 + 5 $

:4; . <=< 0

# 5 #- - !'* ( " !

+" " " " "

E " "

E /

E " " + *'&* #'#;$95#" " #"

# #" # &- - $ $ " %* $$# - ""'# # * &'$' + %* ' / +# 7' " - *5#7 +" ""' *5& , " *'&* '# -7*$7 # - %* +"&-* ' $ " # *5#+ %"#"- #+'*& $.'$#%" * & +'# "'** % >$%* '**# -*$ *'&* " # - *5 "

# '#E GC" ! H ( ! ! "& !" !

! !

& 8D !" ! 7!" !"

D )! ! !& ! J ! " ! " !" " !

& ! ! & !! "!! ! )!"! D D & J &

I! " I

; & " ! " > I !" )! " '& 9%* & .

* !)33:()..<1 D "!

D%C

" + 0 %%= - " 0 + "

! " "+

+ +

" 0 %%= -

" 9: +9: +9: +9: + 9: +9:

" %?0 %C@ - " + + 0 %C= + +

" " %1 8 "

3 - - + +9%:E E9" ":+ 9 : E E 9" ": 9C: E

E9" ": F D + + E E "

< " + "

"" + < " "

" 8 E ! E %*0 ? - ; F D F G;

E9:F D; "

+ +

9":F D; "

+ E

+ " +

" + %H 0 %%= - "

+ + " 0 %C@ - + " + + +

" " %=-

F D 0 C

- 0 %%= %C@

- + " 0 %C=

- "

" " "

" - "

+ + "

+ 0 %%= %C@ - "

+ "

+ +

" " - +"

! " %@

E E 0 %%= - E E 0 %C@ - E E E E 0 ? - + !

" " " " " "+ +

)/ ""'# '#"1?$ " +* "

+ "# ## ##% '#* "'

""'& "$ "

6%" $ "# # # * *'# & '

'** "# # # %# / ' '- *'&* ""'#%*"#*5#$" -# #' %*"#$"&* "& / ""'#& - ##'"#"5#" *5 @' + '**# - "# # + # - #" # - & +5 "' # 5- "

""'# '# #*5 6 %" $ "# # # - # #" 5#" "

' %" $

5 5#" * "&* # - + " " +

& +"* '

"# $ '# $ *$ $# "&* / #*5 *'&* ""'# '# "#'"$ " #""'& "'* "# $+""'& - 5

"# ## ##%6%" + * *'# & +'# '# ""'& "$"

"'** -## %-

" " + + " !

+ + 0 %%? - " 0 %%= %C@ - % ; " " "

+ "

+ + + "

/ " "

"" + " "! + + 0 %%= %C@ -

DD GC" ! H

! !& !" ! D & ! D " " ! "& ! 7! !& & & " )! & ! !

D &

! D " " "

D !

! ! !" ! !

! !" ! )!"& D 8D ! " !

!" ! & D

5 ( "

** !)33(..;; > I !")! "!" !

5% - ( !" !

B8 ID * +

; "

0 %C@ - "" " + " 4

( '

9 : " B+

" "

- +

" " " " " " B+ " "

H0 %C@ - " "< "

" 0 %C= - + " " 0 %C@ B+ ""

0 %C= "" " "

= " < + " " 4 +

0 %C@+ F "" D + " "" " " " " " + - +

" "

& D

6 ( " & & . & #

!)3;()..)14 > I !")! !" !

3 5% - ( !" ! " GH 7!!

!"" &, 7! ! GH ! 7! & ! ! &" " & ! GH !!

" &" !

7! ! "

" ! "!

& " ! ! ! !" !

" & ! ! "

! &

" " ! " D !

D* ; < "

" +

; 0 "

(5 G :/'

*# 0 6#*# ""'# "5#&- ' # ## && # + #'&$ <33336+ * #& ": - #%+1)+)))&;+

+ #1)+)))&;+ "

; /'

*# # $ .' + +'# **#'" #"'&'**$ # #+ # #"'&+* "# $.' + : ; +

+ #%+1)+)))&; : - +

9 : : "

@ # ## +*'&* '# " ? # + 1: $ '& " '# + 5- '*

"&* 5+ #@'#$'#$ 5 #5 "#&- ""'#A '

" $"@''**$ #* -& #5 "#+ ' # ""'#+ '#& ,* -& #

#+' "@'$ 5'$ "&* %)4 + "

; + "

(+ " #%+1)+)))&; "

+ + !

- + 8%"

;

%% + "

H < + " "

0 + ! 0 %C=+ " "

(+ " "

B < + "

+ ( B + + <

" D GC" ! H

2 ( "

** '# ** !)3:(<..;?

!" !

- ( !" > I !")! !

B8 D%?( 0'0 50> 5 -5 , 0 4 - + 9 ))*: * 0

C@ 0 %%=9:+%C= %C@ - +%==% " 0 %%=9: %C@" "

. . < +

> =G; ? = "

.+ I . . " "

3 8J + 9 ))1: % 0

%+ G 90

C);C%+

1 : ?

I " 7 I " 7 0 ?

8 <" 2 # -

" J ;K; " " "

" I

7 "

I 7 I 7 "

0 ? - + %=H +

+ +

I 7

" "

I 7. %1

" "

# . . 0 C - +

>C)G

?C)-

. . " 0 %%=9: - + " " " + 5 "# #%"# 6%" $ "# * *'# & '

'# ""'& " $ * "'

" '* '** "# #%6" + "" + " " . %*/.'# + ## * #$" $ +" " - $ ""'# #*5 %" $ "# - + - $ #" 5#" # 5 5#" ##'"# $ $ "&* "

# '* $

+ "

>C G; ?C

"" "" " " "

. %H 4

( '

, $ J B+ 9 ))=: ? 0

1?+ " B " " " 6 8

>C G; ?C ""'#$#" '#$*$* "# '*&'# '#% &&$ & - #" '# $& #- '

"# ""'# "' & " # # $ *$ * $

""'# # $ *"' "& "

#$$. %=

" "" +

"" .

>C?+ G; ?C?6 + " "" + "" . "" " " "

" "

. 1 "

" 0 %%=9: %C@+ L

G; 9:/ 0 %C@ -

" " 9: / *'&* '# " 1: ' *'&* # ' ""'# * #$" / # # $ *$ $ ' *'&* $**# "$* 9:/ '*'&**$ ""'# -5#"# -& ""'#"

- & ' &# -"&* # * #$" $" $ **# " $ * "

# + - $& & '

"# -* ' -$" ""'& "'*+"-- 9: "

+0 %C@ " " *-

+ " + " 0 %C@ " " "!

"" "

;

8%+

# 1+)))&; ! "

8% "8% %@@H " #=!

+ "

)%)+ #?+1)+)))&; ' J 8 #?+1)+)))&; " )%) #1)+)))&; >%%@ )% "

$ + "

)%); )%%+ + #%=!

$ ; + #* !

+ "

+ + "" " + " D GC" ! H ! " ! " & & "!

! " & " &

!" D ! 7!

)! & " " & 7! > I !" )! ! " !& ! ( ! " & & " ! 7! ! ))

)7 )

= " & )!

7! > I !" )! " B

+ 5' $

:41.)33 D!

B ?9%*: 0 ? C9%: "

" 9: 9":

9":

+ + " B D

+ B M

+ " " " " B -

B "

+ "

" + B

+ ;

0 + ;

L+ +

L+

B "

+ " "

" "

8 + '* 5 / 9&* # ' && # 5 9&* :;<0.< 9%H:0 + +

+ "

+E " " EG0< 0 , 0 0 -< 0 ,0 8 <"+ " B

" < E " D: + " " E E E E

" + " " " " B

+ "

; 9: 0 ? C 9%: - "

" "2#" 0 0 +

E ! "

" E + "

E" E

" "

+ + 0 0 0 #< B" 0 0 8 <"M +

" < + B L + !

+ B <

" " ;" " + ! "

+ + + " + "

B ' - %C* " "

4 0! > I !" )! "

' 5 $ , !)3)(<..))!

B ?=)'

" 0 CH= 8 "

" =) '"0 49 )%):@0

%=@+

0 CH= 8

% %@+ " G % B < "

< "+

" "" < +

+ "

+ ! " & ! " 0 + "

""< ;

9,'!#0 389%@H1: C0

%@+0 "

50 ' 9%@@):?

%H+ 0 8 0 38 9 ))C: %

H*%+ > 0 0 58 9 ))?: %)

*@@+' 0 0 389 ))*:@0

HC%+ 0 38#,0 9 ))H:%C0

%) +0 #0## 9 ))=:10

1C1+- 0 9 ))@:%)0

)*+80!

# 0 -89 ))@:%*0

@= #0 0 B89 )%): 0

??1: %C 0 0 4 -#%@C?8 H+

8 " G9- ?)?:

B 9%: ( " M9 :

+ ! "

" M9C: "

" M 9?:

" "

( . %? " "

904 0 -#

%@1?0 %+'"0 0 8 <"-#%@1H %*+ 5J - 0 5 -# %@*C0 ))+4 5 0 ' 9%@H):

?1)+0" 0 49%@@=:10

?% +'

0 0 589 )) :?0

=1 0 J0 < ! 9 ))H:C0

H11: %1

0 4 !9 ))H:?0

?%1+ G

?C + ? :9%:-

9 : 8+ %@HC +

" +" 9C: ,

+ + I" 7+ I 7+ I 7+ I 7+ I !7+

I 7

9?:-

+ + " + " 6 +

< " "

0 + +

+ "

91: " " " +

" "

. %* J 20 389 ))=:%)0

?1)+

+ " 7 "

+ " " %H 0 #< > 9 ))@:@0

C*=+

G90

CH?+ ): ) " " . %= 0 38'

9 ))@:?0

H%+

" < < "

B G90

=*+ =:9: B 7 " "

M 9: B 7 M 9:

B < M 9: B 7< < "" M

9: B M 9: " " 0 B . - " "

0 9 ))@:%)0

?)% %@ + " + <

" +

7 "

" " + .9

: =)) "

" "

) + G ? ) "

" " "

! & " " "

.+ 9, #< 4 4 $ - 9%@=?:?0

*C1+

;- - J > N 0 %@@ 0

9 :0

C% + #""N8

%@@?0

9C:0

**1+J $ B 8 9 ))%:%0

1)%+-0 9 ))@:%)0

)* J '4 #0 -89 ))@: %)0

*C*:.9

=)1 "+

4 0 8 9%@@@: 0

%)+ "

" " + "

' " " + " " =1 ,< 5 0 0 4 !+ 9 )%@: 1 0

?C*+ 0 CH= 8 "

%@1

C%+ " G ?C%- " "

9%@H=:%0

= " + B "

;

B+ B + + "

< B + " %) G90

CC: %) /

+ B ;

/ + B 0 (

" 0 (

" .

C%% 0" 0 4 9%@@=: 1 0

?% + B

;

+ + B

" "

+ " "

+ "

B "

+ " = G90

?%*: = <

B B

# '"$ 0 J< 9%@@*:@0

"+ < B ;

< " ' ; < <

!+ + +

+ "

" " <

< + "

7 < " "'

" "

< M <

" +

B " + < . C% 4#!

0 49%@@@: C 0

C)@+ " "

" B "

( + "

0 ( "

0 ( " " 0 (

< & + B + + ;

L "

" "

0 ( C%C - 0 38-#%@110 =)H+ 1+

" G9-#

=)@;%): ?1 " "

< " + B

< ( +

0 ?%H 8

" "

++! ; "

! " "

" "

+ "<

+ + <

" " 90

'+ +0< 0 0 -#%@1 0 1 M 4 0

38 -# %@1C 0 % : + " "

B <

C%? 4J # 0 -89%@H@:%0

C11+

" "" " +<

! " " "+ " B < +

< "" . 9

3 ! " " ! & > I !")! !

! " "

7! !"":!

B8 H . >

" 7!

& 7! H (

7! >

)! " !"

)! >

& !

& )!!

! )!

" ! H >

)! 7! !

& K& ! "

@ H

! !

& ! " 7! !

!"& "

H!D ! +! "

1 + ! !

1+&

!" 1+ ! 1+

" 1 ! D

! 7!

! " !+ !

! 1 " : !

! 7! ! ! " !

D !

" &

, " "

"& ?

! ! & !" & )

% 0! " ! " 7! !"

7! !

& " !"

& ! !" ! !" !

8" "

8" & !

! ," ! !

!! !" !

& )!

! & <

& )!

! !! !! & )!

! " & ! & (

&& "&" & )!

& " ! " # #$# %& )!! 8( $ -9 5/1#: 2#

! & P&>

" P&>