Surinder Singh v. Mahru


    


  




  






  !

 
 
 



 





 


   
"

 #$ 
 
 
 



 
!

"
#





# 
   

 


%  $

%

 


 



&' 

() ($ $**+"
,

 
-  

.
# 
&' 


 
 
.

$/ (0 $**1

, 

 




 

'
 

  2




 

-

4

 # "
 



 "

 


 
  
  


 
.

5 



 





 

 
4 


' "




 
'







  
 

 
 
4,
6 +)"
4


6 $$$"
4 
6 /(11 $0"





# 
"
%  7 "
 
'
  

'
, 




  

%



 
&
'
   ,

 

8,#"


 



 




  


  
 
9 



"


 

 "




 

 

 

:

;
 


 


 "
 

 
  
,  ' "
 
 
 '


& 



  

"



"
'   


 

<
'  "




 

 






 
 
#


'
8

 







 



 

 
,
=

#
"
 

 
, 
 '

    
 







'


 
$/ 3(


<

#
#' "





 

 "

/

 
 
,

#  "
 
 
.
' , 



$ >



  

'


 
?
<77 >


#

 

 
   ?
<7 >

 

' 


 
'?

<7


:

 

%
 


#  "

 


&' 
  
 
.
;

' 
  


#  "
  
 
.


 


"
  


& 
 
 







& "
 

 

  
   



   

  

)













%
 



  





&' 

 
 
.

;
 


#  "

 -  

.
 

 
 
.
 

  


 

 


 #
 ' 


 

 

@
,

  
 '





 

'
 
 

' 
-"
 


 

 





' 

A



 

 
 &


 
 




   



 "
-  

.

 



  
."



 




 

+

5 
 #


&' 

# "



 





*


.






 

  

.




  

,
 
&' 
 
 
 
.
 
  
  

 
, 




 

.
 

  
 





"

&

=
# ,


 "


"



 





& 





=

 


 # 


 


 




 


 






, 
   "

 



 

,

 

'


 



  


 
 



 
 
.

$(










=
#


 





 
#
 


, 

#




$$

%
 





 
4,
6 +) 4
6 $$$
4 
6 /(1
1 $0"


# 
"


&  


 
   

,

 ,  
 

  





 

   

.

 
 


&' 
BA $2
BA
 $"



$*++ +*"



  

 





 
4 
6 /(1"
 

 


,

 

5
 
  

-
5 


.

&'()&* +,
'- '(*.

  $

!

 #

 
 
 





 "

 "

'
  
 

5 

 , "

 


 


& 
%
 



 


#  


  
 "

 

, 

C '
 
>3
 
 ' 
#  
'

>$2

>$2
4 
& BA
 3
 
! 
C ,
BA
 0"
 
 #"







 




& 


-"
 #





 



 
  
 



  





,
 

 




''  

 
.
,"
, 
 
 
  



$3










=
 #

' A"
,



 "


"





&
  "



  

 &


 

  

8

#  

  
 



&
B#


     
, 



"


, 

 







 '


& 
 "
, 
, 

&


& ' 
 
 '

  

 '  "


#
 



 

& 
, 


A #


, 

, 


&

& ' 


 '

  

=


 


 





 



& 
 

' 

, 
%"
'








4
  


& 

5




  

  

'
 


'




 "





 '
'
  
 

  
 





& 
 
 
'





 "




,

&

& ' 


 '

  

%
 





 
 



  
 
  

,

'

 

&  


$0

6

 



$:

-



'   "
=



 
 #  "





 
.
,"
, 

 


 
  


 
'  #  
6
 


 

'

'


##' 

   
9  


, $/

  "


' 



 "
 "

$1

 

'
 


 "
 
'

 

    "

 "

 
 

 

 


  !

 
/-.'01'*('2 3(3) Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No