← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1084/1999allowed

Bohti Etc. v. Bhateri Etc.

2016-10-2724 pages

 

   

 

 !"!#$%&%'

 

   

 

    ($ )*(  

( (    

   !"

#  

 $  !" #

 +++ 

( ( ,   !

  



  & 

 

'  ##( ) 

 **+,*---          #         .  "  $

   !   / "     # 

&

  ' (  / ""

   #  

"       01/     ##2 # "  /    !   

/" 3 " #  &

'  ##( #

   

#/   ## 0*1/

 "&

4/

 )   #  "   

 *1-5*,    

!

  #! 

 

 %  .  " /     #    "

   0*#   6    

   ##0*37 0* 3 ,8/

! 



" /

  ##0, 01/

! 



  

6/ " #  ## 0* #

#  ##0* 3 038

' "

 (/ /

   #  

/ "/   "

  9  ##0, 01/

   

#  ' "

 (/  

,+ .

0*/! 

  "

!   

  

 



  ## 031 

# 0*

4 

    / " !

/  



:#

# 0*

/6/#

 #   ## 0* 

!     

:  #

       :/ ##      *-;+   ##  31



#

  

  *4<

#  #        

     "

 #  #         ##    /        03    1  /

  " ! )   #  



!

 

 " !



  / #   ##

 "  5/       0*    ##

  " !

 

    #!  #

  "

  / &  = ##

" !

 33+,*-;3>?9,/

 #

   8;5;  #! #  087   ##

" !

 *-+,*-;8>?9@ 

 "#   8;5*  #! # 03 ,7    #

   ##

  

 " !

 

  33+;*-;@>?98 

 "#   @*5 "    #    "

   08#    #! # 0@; !

 

/

      !  /  )  " / 

##  



   038 0@; 0* A

 "  #

/ 

 



 "

 ! / "  

/

       ## 01      %  /   0*/#;1 # / / 5       

  %  /   "

   # 0*/ "

  " /"  #

     /     " 

 %  /

!

 " " 



#  ""

  "



#   " #   ##     /    , 6) /         

  03    8       0@    ;  5  

     ) "      ##" #    7  

   7   #  &) 

#" #" 7  ##/

 #    

/"""7 :

  ## "

  " !

 #     7  

# /    / 

! #   # #

)  " 



  /   0*/

/

   #    //! %   /     ##/

"&

4/

       /

  )    6 " "   /          08  /    /

       #  

 "   8;5;   03,/

/

#  8;5*  0@;

/

/

#  @85 /

 0*/ /

#

      9 0*# /    

6 /     # 0*/"

   #   ##  01



!   6 " "   / " # "

 #  0@;/

 ! /   0*/ 



' 08(  '  0,( //



!   5  .

0*/ # #  /

#   / /

 !

  

  !

      /

 

##

 0*# #

/ / 5 # 



%

/

   #  

 ""

% #   ##" 

/ 6/ #   :   

5"

   *-;+     # !

#  /

  8    #   #/   /

#     *<***-;;

& * B

" !  

 "  !   33+,*-;3    "!  *-+,*-;8 ) 

  "!  33+;*-;@

   !  / )  "   C 3 B

 "    #  

    C , B

  

   C 9.

8 B

  ##

 # #    

/" """: "

C 9.

1 B

      

# C 9.

@ B

  # &) 

#" #" C

9.

< B

 



! #   # #

)  "   # / ! C 9.

;   # #/     /

#       # **+-*--* & *'( B

 

!

 " "  

#  ""

 C6# / ## "C *'( B

  "

   # 

 0*C6# / ## "C 1    

" #    0*<  #! #   ##

  #   ##/ 

   "  /  

"      #      !

        0*'(*'(!  ) 

 *-+**--@ @  &

  ' (     

!

  #     ) 

     

  / "/""

     .  "$  / 

   #  #   

"   01           #      ##  !   )     

  **+,*--- <  &

  '  ##(  #

   

!

  #   

!

 ) 

#    .  "$

 

    #

    "

#/ "/  !



&

' (  " # 

 //

:     ;

   #         /

     "   /   

 / 

  "

 - 6 "  #   #"

 0*D  ' "

 (/ /

   #

    =  ?

    ##0*3  038  ' "

 (/

     0* 9  ##0,D 9 5 01.

! 

 

 " !

#  .

0@;

# 08D 6      

# 0*



   

 " !

 &

 /E % /  #  08 & / 

" 

   0@;  0,   



# 



  /  0*5 #

      %      0*D     " #   *+  #  D

'  ##(   " !

 )     

 >?93    >?9, 

 " !

   33,*-;3##

 #! #

0,D

' 08( " !

 )     

 >?98    >?91 

 " !

   33;*-;@##

 #! #

08@D

'  0@;(" !

) >?9<

>?9@ *-,*-;8

 " !

  ##

    #!  # 

  0*    3  D  

' 03,( 0*D /

!    

" 

##   



  "   0*  / "    / 6   #"  /         #   #  /    0*    = )  /  038@;" 

 #   ) /   /     #" !

& ) 

>?93>?9</

##  "    

  ##  /        ") /  !

&    #

  

?

6   /

/##

   

   

  "      /

    #    # "  #

 #  "    # "   !

#  

" 

 /:) 

>?93>?9<       



##   



  " "

  "

" "

   #  

      !

#  #

"  

#  "   **   ?  :    / "   ! !

  #   "   #  

) " #    /

   # !

&  

>?9, >?91>?9@/

:

 

"

 

!  #6     " *-+;'

#

 E "#*-+;E(=

  " #   "  ! 

       

 #! # 038@;'

0*,8@D

( :    /"

 # #    "

 '

( !



& ?     

      

  

%

/

  

# "  

" F

& ?   #

      6

    "    #

  #" ! 

 0* #

 /

        #! ##

   '

( 5  #

" " #

 

 " "#  

 

   #



"

 

!  #  " *<# "#*-+;/

:

 

5   

   " #

!

   

'

( !



& ?           / 

/

##

 0*D

    

#! A

    " #   0*/  !  ?

//



  / 

#   

 " !

 &/E   #  0@;/  0, 8



  /  0*   #    

  

"  "

 !     #  " !

    "  /   "

                 6     "        #   

"           /  

   #!

& 

 :  / 

:

#

   

!



" 

"

"   

   ## 6 # !

"     "  #  

"

 " / "  /



 !" # $

%&'(  6 " /  =E  ? #

 " 



/ 

 

   / &

   # " !

 / / ! " / 

 = 

/  =E  ?  

#    0*;#  " /

    

 

          !

 "             #              $%          $

%            #&$''()         #  #                        $

 

* %  #" )  

       + #"    ",         $

- %   #       .    

 

           $

/ %#   #  0 1       0  "     )  

     

   #2 3            + #"           

    #   $ ' ( !)

* + )

!), -.

 -)

$

'

 "   /  4 , " "   /

#/   " /6/ 

 :  # #    "  

 

/   

#   " 

/ / 

#

/5 

  

# # #

#

 "

G# H

  = I// !

      

G# H 

 

 "

/

 

   #  

 

# #  ' ( /*/ )) - )



 !%0 -&)  (  - )

$ %&,%,1*&  6 " /  " 

" ,35#/

"

 

/

3+5/ #":



#



/  

"

/   6/ 

##

 

 "#!

& "

  

:



    /



##

 

 "#!

  #":

  #

  #



:



   "  ' !( # 

3  *.

 - )

$ %&( 4 '

*-

 6 " /

/  

 #     !

   

 *-;89I$1@3 /

    /        "    

        " " /

  /   # 

 

  " "   / " " ""

!     "  

 "    "          !  

6   "" *;<3'#  J "#*;<3J( " #   5   



 #   !  



// "   "" " "

     ## " !

#  #

#   !



""

6# " 

 ## "# #

  /    

 

  

  / " 

:

  "  

     

/  !  B 

!

  " /  /  "

!

#  /

I*++4&  " K  /  #

  % )   " ?

" 

 

6/!

   #

" / ##

 ,++8*-;3 "

 

/  " "   !  # "#*-+;  /   #"  " # "

    #! #% )  # !

 ## "  #K   *3  

   " #

   !



"  # " #  

 / "/

!

  

#

D

' ( !

 "  

   #

  :  / 

:

#

   

/ #  

"   /: #"

            #/=

 

"  / !



"         # 0*/"

  " 

   / &"

 4 #":





 

  / /

# 

 #"  #

  

 #! #

  5 /  "    " "=   

 :   >?9, >?91>?9@/

##

 0* #! # #

   

  ' (         #    #   4

  

     

## #

!  " "   #

: 





  " #

 !  # " *<# " #*-+;/ "5 "

 

# #

" 

    #  " "  

5        #/A

    D

'  ##( !

       /  0*   #    "

 /   /

   "

 

    " 

" : 

   

) "  6

#  # !

"    "  "

 " /    /

 ' ( - 1.

 -  )



"

  - 

$ 

%&/(  % " // "  =E  ? / 

 /  

     6  " "      /     0*; " !

  0**# )  ' (  ##

3 4  $ %&,%,1*& 6 " /  / / =E  ? 6 " "   /5  " 

 6/ 

#   " /

/##

" 

""     ##  "  # &

    ' (  )

( 78  -)

$ %&/(

 6 " /  / 

   # "  

   ##       ' !( '

    

 5 9    -  )

$   %& /(  6 0*;# " /  /

!



66 " =E  ?  

/ / % 5 !.

   6 *-@@ 3-3 

!

#/

J*86% 5 !.

   6*-@@ 3-3 

   "#  " 

 !  #

# 

  :  //

 

:

  " 

 



 " *<%   / 

  &  # 

   

   /     # 

# # 

 

"

 /    "    /



"   "      

   

"   #  # 

     

   "       

 



#

# 

 

 



#   #

"  #  #  # # 5    6""

   # "

  ?     !



#

 #/  

 " ## " *<'3(#     "6/    ## 

  

/ " /  #         #    #    /      " 

   

#

 "    ! 

#  "

        #     #  #  # 

 / "/#    % 

!

//

    9 !  0   6*-@@ *;,@ /

 /  # 

 / 



    # "

  

  !

 

   #! #    

6" /

" 

 "

 

" /  !       &

 

/     " *<# "J '!( 3 - 

 !.

$ %&,%,1*& 6   /   " /

  #    

:

 " 

 

 *, 0/ 

# #  

>?9, >?91 >?9@"

 )  

# /

 '>?9, 919@(/

:



 

"   !

/# !  # " *<'3(# "#*-+; "   /  " /"   &

 ' ( .

'>?9,( % 

/   "

 ) >?93 / "/

5%                                      $            

    $ $)     #      $6 

# ) >?93  

#

>?9,/   #     D     /   %

   # #   4"   ?    

>?9, /

   " /

!

 "  #

"  "  

#

!

        

 /            #

  /   #   /   "

  # #   :       #! #   ###  /

0,    ' 08    (=  

   #

 "       /       E  "  ' (   

:

    

" 

 



!  # " *<'3(# "# *-+; #        

   /  %   

 /   

      



 "  ' ( .

'>?91( % 

#/  ) >?986 ) 

/ /  "   >? *   #

    /   0 #   

"   "   >? *5/ 

 

 "  6 "    /

08@D

' 0@;(//

 # " 

# 



/

  " >? *

"  / "  #  %      

08@/

#   # 

# D 0*

  #  # 

/

! 

&

?       %  

  #  ""  : / 



 #

/   # 0*D  :   /

 # #    

#! !   

" 

   /" 

:

5   

  

"  ' ( .

'>?9@( % 

/#/   #) >?9</ " /   # #   #!

 ## "  /

     "

       # 0* /"

  "

0*3D

'  03,(/

! 

& ?         %

  # : /""

  #

#

 D 0* "

 

#! :

/ "/) "

#  / "

>?9@/ /

     

 #!  #    #      !      

     "



   # 

/ 

:

  #      # 

/ *8



!

  

" F #    # !   /

  ""

       #

!     #

:

     6 "   !    #        #   ""

/" !



 !

      / "    "

 *-;; *1      / "         / #  "

&) "  ## " =

  / / =E  ?   1-

.!

 ! 

) ) 

! -)

$:



!

, ) #/  *@ 6  # !

 "    #  " #  

   #   

/

:

" 

!  # " *<'3(# "# *-+;   "

"



#  !

"  #  " #

  "   *<  ? #"   /

    B  >?.B14* 3,,*-;;  ?

"  0*D     #!  #     

       '   08(    ' 0,(

 &" 

) 

   9 5  ' 0@;(#  %  A      #

 "  !     : ?

" # B "  ""  B /

  !  ?

"  0* #! #!

&     #  

"      01B 

"      #! #

D

' (     A   ""

        #  D

'  ##(!    ) 

 **,*--- *;  " #  "  

#  

"   #     01

/ /   #

#"#  B  >?.B14*/ !

  /

  /   #   

/   #

   

" #  : B % 

# ! 

"  #

   : ?

" # B   " 5  " 

 # "   

    / ?         # 6  #

 "      "/"

   !

    6 # !

"     " #  "  #/ " /

' ( ) )  7 :-  -;



5< *$ %&  )

19

3-!

)   6 " / 

/     

#

!/!   ""#    "  "  ! "

#  #  "

## "

# 59    "               "   

?  

     

#

!# 

! "

>!

  /#   

 6/ 

  # !   / "/# /     "

5  6  #      

 

   "!

" 

 "  

" #  

 ' (  9 #     

 *!  " - *  =   $   %& ,%,1*&  6 " /  /  :   /



 #"    /    /

 #   "   B 

   

#   "

 #   "

 #  /    

   "

 #  #

" 

 "

 #  /   "

 #) "

 %   # !    # /     " 5   

 # A  "

  #

"!

#  #

EE

"   #

EE ' ( :! 1 !

) 

)  / ) *  )   )

-! ) ) >,  ! 

3 4-

.

$  % &,,,  6 " /    # !  #

@  3 #  / / !     " 5  *-  

  " #

D 

' ("    D

'  ##(  " "!

/ 

  ?

" #!

   B  >?.B14*/ 

D

' (  !  / 



    ?   ?

"   #     !

") #  

"  #  : B / 

"    01   # !     #

 

  

 6 #

 "    D

'  ##(     "      B   /

                #



#   A

 

 

    "        

    "

   "  /    "  /

' (  !4  -)



 7

.!

 -)

$2

/# 8( 4  )

$*(??:@ /    6 "   ##    # ) " #

"!

# /#   #     

%  /       .  "$      #  #  "#  

6 #

      $  !



 #

 /   /#     #  

!



/ 

/  

#      #     ##   !

    

   :    /""

  #   ##/

I 

9  #    ) #  

$ /    ' ( 4 

0 1-

 - )

$ % & ,%,1*& 6     "      ##  #         #

"!

  # * -- +++4&  "  #  )

##

      ""

 *-;*--16/  #

  " #   /  

 !

 ) >?9-       $   !  #

% "     # 

  

  ""





) "



"    /  6  "

  !

  ! 

 

# )

 :#"  6.# .

1 

""/* -)

$: ,  /  /

  

 /     " / 

#    /          &   ## "

    !       "  

#

   /

#    /

   " #   ##  

#" " # "  

 / 

    ""

 #  # ""

 

  

) "

 D  6 !4 " ' (  /"     

   ##/

5    #

     #   4

 /

  "    

 D

' (  

"   

5   /

 #

     #B  >?.B14*%  4 6 " ' (   /#  

  ###

"!

#   "   #  )

"      ""

    /

/ /

 ""

"

/ ""

      &   #    

  #"         #  

  ###"  "   /  " / "  "  "   #"#  /





 ##

#  #"# "  

 3+ I " #

D

' (  "    D

'  ##(     ) "   /    !   /  

       B   >?.B14*  /

"  #

  "/ 

 # 

  ) " : B /  ! 

  

/"""0   D

'  ##(     ) " / 

  B  !  "

 #

   !

  ?

"        

 /

"    /I/    

 "  9 0*;# )  

!

 /  #    "   / 



     "  #       D  

'  ##( #

     ) "  # #    "    

    D

'  ##(

##

#    3*        "   #  

  D  

' (#

  

' (" 5  # B   /    #

  #

 0*D   ?

"# B /  !

/  /      /#  6      / !

/   /#   / !

/ /        /   #  3,1*-;;    "#         / / "// 

"  /       /#  <;*--* ## 038@;6    " #  0*D  /  /       /#  <;*--*

 "

/  #   5  #  B   /   / "/#       <;*--* / " #  " "  # " #

D

' (  "   33 0/

 " !

/ 

  #" #   B >?.B14*/ !

5   /   

    ## "/#  %   

 #"# B " "!

 !

  

#   #      6 01#      /

57      8 9+6  # #      ## "  5   #   ?  /  

       #"  #  B  

?

    % !

 "  

   / 

 

    # !  " 5  " 

 

  / "



     "

#   

"          #           01 /

 "      #! #

D

' (

       #/        3, !

 "   0*##

)  

>?93>?9< #! #  ?"

  01   ?

" #   B >?.B14*I

   B /   ?

"  0* #! #    3,,*-;;% """  # 

  /

   / &    

 # 0*D 5 "

5 38  #  " #

D

' (          /  

&

                 #

" /5    /    #

    31 6  #!

 "     





      ""

   :     ) 

#    **,*---     ) 

     





# )    :

""

# #    " "

 3<*+3+*@ -

( (.

 )4 !    B

 5 4

 L 40 B

 

L 40