High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/30313/2017allowed

Kirandeep Kaur v. I D Steel Industries

2018-08-28Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

!"##$ % &&&#'

(!# )#*%* && '##+!"%*'

#*, && & - &&& #*$(!"#!'

.............................................................

!"##$ % &&&#'

(!# )#*%* && '##+!"%*'

#*, && & - &&& #*$(!"#!'

............................................................. /

!"##$ % &&&#'

(!# )#*%* && '##+!"%*'

#*, && & - &&& #*$(!"#!'

'#(0"#1 (!23&3&3 2 45 &

) 6

!"## $ !

!" %%%%%%%% ) 6,& &' ( )!# **!

#"+ !"## !, #

* "# - .!#/ ! #*#

#0 )!

!"##! +# $ #1 .!#/!*"

# 2

2 2 # +,3 4 $ 3#"!#/#5#"5"## $ #

!/#+ 3* "#/#!

## !#6# # /# ! #7!**#/" #!"##2

" " , #

"## # 9!# ! ! ""

# #&( # +, ! "##0 # !/ 9#*#+,!# : !"##+*#!!"## # ""

# #&(# !/#!# *" #!/ !##*##! *"

#&(! / # #! "##0 9 9#!!*-

!! !.##"9#! "" #/!#

* #" !#/

!# +,*##/!/##*+!# !# ! !. "

, +! ! *"

#0" 9# ! # ""

# #&( ! ! # #

!#*#!""

# #&(# !/"#*# ,! /!!!"9 #9#9**#/ !"## : !"##! #";/* +, <=+ $"* #

!"!

" # $ )!"# "!;/*

73& (8 '9# :(;# "

*1%** (! 0(++(< !- *$#1'* #8#-#2

00#!1# %!"# (! 3 (0 '9# 1' $ += 1 ;

+<(!-&%"#!(0$((0 *(!

11%*#" !;

#<$#*%8$'

(!%!"# (!> :%''9#*' !" "(0*%19$((0 *?$#$(!"# !1# (0$(: :

+ '

#*?&9#* 8#9 *'(:#!(8 ++= '

#" *%88 += * $# $(;

(!* (0 *%88 = '

+%!"#'9#&&&:%'< '9*%19;

(! * 8 =:# $$($ '#'($(1##"

!-*%!"#9 $'# @) (0 '9# 1'& 9%* # ", $ !1 $+# (0

(!A3&&&< ++ $$+= !"'9#(%'1 !

1+(*#'9#$(1##"

!-* !""

*19 -#'9# 11%*#"

(! * '

*0 1'

(! '9 ' '9# 19#B%# 8(%!' < '9 **#**#"1(*'* !" !'##*' *$ " !" 0'9## !(# *(!'($(1##"< '9'9#$%!

;# *$#1'&

9#(:C#1'(0'9# $(;

(!:# !- $ += 1(8$#!* '(=,$%!

;##+#8#!':# !-8 !+=< '9 '9#(:C#1'(0#!0(1 !-'9#1(8$#!* '(=#+#8#!', 1(8$(%!"

!- ' '9# !

+ *' -# 9 * '( :# #!1(% -#" :%' * !(' "#: #" ' + '# *' -# *%:C#1''( $$($ '#1(8$#!* '

(! *8 =:# 0(%!" 11#$' :+#'('9#$ '

#*('9#(%'&

9(%-91(8$(%!"

!-#B% #*1(!*#!'(0:('9 $ '

#*, #;#! ! :*#!1# (0 *%19 1(!*#!', '9# (%', !'9# !'##*'*(0C%*'

1#,(!:# !-* '

*0 #"

'9 ''9#1(8$+ ! !'9 *:##!"%+=1(8$#!* '#", 1 ! ! '* "

*1#'

(! 1+(*# '9# $(1##"

!-* !"

*19 -#'9# 11%*#"&

;(1#"%#0('

+ (0 1 *#* %!"#9 $'# @)(0'9#1'9 *!(8 ++='(:#*%88 =&9# "

*1#'

(!(0'9# - *' '#%!"#*#1(!"$(;

*( '( (!/,'(9(+"'9 ' '< *%!"#* :+#'( '='9#1 *#*%88 += **#!'#!1#(08(#'9 !

(!#=# 8 =9 ;#'(:#$ **#", *'(:##D#1 *#"

0'#1(!* "# !-'9#0%'9#0 1''9 ' $ '0(8 '9# *#!'#!1# (0 8$ *(!8#!', '9# (%' 9 * C% *"

(! %!"# (!A &&& '( < " *% ' :+# 1(8$#!* '

(! < '9 "#0 %+'

*#!'#!1#%!"# (!E/&&& !"< '90%'9# $(<#* (0 #1(;#= %!"# (!/&&& '9'9 * $$( 19,$ *(!*#!'#!1#(08(#'9 !

(!#=# 8 =!(':##B% #" ! ++1 *#*& ;

!1##;

"#!1#(0'9#1(8$+ !'1 !:#- ;#!(!

" ;

', *%:C#1' '( '9# (%' *%88(!

!- '9# $#*(!- ;

!- 00 " ;

' !"#D 8 !

!-9 8 !"'9# : !F4* *+ $ :# !- $ 8 0 1 # #;

"#!1# (0 '9# "

*9(!(% (0 19#B%#, ' * %!!#1#** = 0( '9# - *' '# '( #1(" != 0%'9# $#+ ! = #;

"#!1#& %19 00 " ;

'#;

"#!1#1 !:## " * #;

"#!1# ' ++*' -#*(0'

+(('9#$(1##"

!-*& 9#8 !!#(0#D 8 ! '

(!(0'9#$#*(!- ;

!- " ;

'1 !:# *$# (!E/&&&9# *19#8# *'(0(++(< *%88 =$(1#"%##D1#$'

<9###D#1 *#(0$(<#%!"#*#1(!"$(;

*('(

(!/:#1(8#*!#1#** =,<9##*#!'#!1#(0 (!# =# 8 = 9 ;# '( :# < "#" !" 1(8$#!* '

(!%!"# (!A *1(!* "##"

! "#B% '#,9 ;

!-#- "'('9# 8(%!'(0'9# 19#B%#,'9#0 ! !1 +1 $ 1 '= !"'9#1(!"%1'(0 '9# 11%*#"( !=('9#1 1%8*' !1#*& >&!;

#<(0'9# :(;#,<#9(+"'9 '<9##'9#19#B%# 8(%!'< '9 !'##*' !"1(*' * **#**#":='9#(%'

*$ ":= *$#1 #"" '#,'9#(%' *#!'

'+#"'(1+(*# '9#$(1##"

!-* !#D#1 *#(0 '*$(<#*%!"# (!

/(0'9#1'# "< '9 (!A3&&&* +# "= (:*#;#",!(8 +%+#0('

+(01 *#*%!"#9 $'# @)(0'9#1' *'(0(++(<'9#*%88 =$(1#"%# !"

> *%88(!* '

+ $(1#"%# 1 ! :# 0(++(<#" <9## *#!'#!1##D1##"

!-(!#=# 8 =:#!#1#** =' F !-

!'( 11(%!' '9# 0 1' '9 ' 1(8$#!* ' (! %!"#

(!A &&&< '9*#!'#!1#(0+#**'9 !(!# =# < ++!(':# "#B% '#,9 ;

!-#- "'('9# 8(%!'

(0 19#B%#, 1(!"%1' (0 '9# 11%*#" !" ('9# 1%8*' !1#*& &!#;#=1(8$+ !'%!"# (!3(0'9#1', '

8 =:#"#* :+#'9 ''9#1(8$+ ! !'- ;#*9 *: !F 11(%!' !%8:# !" 0 $(** :+# #8 + (0 '9# 11%*#"&0#8 + * ;

+ :+#< '9'9# !F<9## '9# 11%*#" 9 * ! 11(%!', *%19 !F, (! :# !- #B% #",*9(%+"0%!

*9*%19#8 +'('9#$ =##(0 '9#19#B%#&!#;#=*%88(!*, **%#"'('9# 11%*#", '

8 = :# !"

1 '#" '9 ' 0 '9# 11%*#" "#$(* '* '9# *$#1 #" 8(%!', <9 19 *9(%+" :# **#**#" := '9# (%' 9 ;

!- #- " '( '9# 19#B%# 8(%!' !"

!'##*'G1(*',:= *$#1 #"" '#,'9# 11%*#"!##"!('

$$# %!+#**#B% #" !"$(1##"

!-*8 =:#1+(*#"

*%:C#1''( !=; + "(:C#1'

(!(0'9#1(8$+ ! !'&0'9# 11%*#"1(8$+ #*< '9*%19*%88(!* !" !0(8*'9# (%' !"'9#1(8$+ ! !':=#8 +,'9#(%'1 !

*1#'

!'9#(:C#1'

(!, 0 !=,(0'9#1(8$+ ! !' !"

1+(*#'9#$(1##"

!-* %!+#** ':#1(8#* !#1#** = '( $(1##"< '9'9#1 *#&!*%19 * '% '

(!,'9# 11%*#"4* $#*#!1# 1 ! :# #B% #", %!+#** '9# $#*#!1# ('9#< *##D#8$'#"*%:C#1''(*%191(!"

(!* *8 = :#1(!* "##" $$($ '#&9# 11%*#",<9(< !'*'( 1(!'#*''9#1 *#,8%*':##B% #"'("

*1+(*#*$#1 "#0#!1#0(*%191(!'#*'&' *($#!'('9#(%''( *F *$#1 1B%#*'

(!*'('9# 11%*#" ''9 '*' -#&!1 *# '9#'

+ *'($(1##", '< ++:#($#!'('9#(%''( #D$+(#'9#$(** :

+ '=(0*#''+#8#!'&'< ++ +*(:#($#!

'( '9# (%' '( 1(!* "# '9# $(;

(!* (0 $+#

8 : - !

!-& %:C#1''('9 *,'9#'

+1 !:#(!" ='( " =: * * !"#!"# ;(%8%*':#'(1(!1+%"# '< '9 !

D8(!'9*&9#-% +'=8%*':#$%!

*9#" ''9## + #*'

*$#+ < !"'9#(!#<9((:#=*'9#+ <!##"!(':# 9#+"%$ !$(1##"

!-*0(+(!-%!!#1#** +=& &'< ++:#($#!'('9# -9(%'*'(1(!* "# !"

+ ="(<!1 '#-(=(01 *#*<9##$(1##"

!-*($ '

'9##(01 !:#1(!"%1'#"(!+ !#:="#* -! '#"1(%'*( ('9#< *#&9# -9(%'*8 = +*(1(!* "# **% !- !=0%'9#%$" '#""

(!*0("# + !-< '9 (!

31 *#* !'9#+ -9'(0C%"-8#!'*(0'9 *(%'& 9# $$# +* #"

*$(*#"(0& '< ++:#($#!'('9# $$#++ !'*'(8(;#'9# +(%'

0#*9 0( != 0%'9# ("# ! '9# + -9' (0 '9 C%"-8#!'&H 8$9 * **%$$+ #" : !"##!+*#!!# / !# !#/*!?!

& ? #

"##( #*##/!""

# #&(# !/ !# /!!# !"9 #9# # **#/ +## #9!;/*"+,<=+ $"* #

&"( : !"0 *"

#! +; #!*

#/ , 9#! **#/,!#/*#! ! "## " ,

9 #*"/

& ? #

"##( #*##/!""

# #&( # !/ !# /!#* #9#/!**#/ #!# ## "!!

# #&(# +,! "## # !/ "+ ,9#!# "#*!*, )!"#9#

+ #+,# !#" # * #""!# # 3!*#* " "" !"##0 + ! # !

*# ?*" +; !

9#/ ##

% % %-%*'3,3 ) 6

( ) &

( )