Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited And Others v. Rakesh Kumar And Another

 











 

 





































 


































 !"
#
$"%&'&(
)
* 



+  !
 (%+ 
&, -
.!$
($
!+"'



















































/
"!&!&("'


0"'+
12- 
($
!+"'











"'3($"(!'

 4
)

 5.
4 
 
 1
.


 5.
4 
 
 1
4

"'"(!


4 (6""7
1 2'+&08
$7% !"8
#
!+"
3"!&!&("'






9
9
9
9
9
 1
.8

:  ;<


+"
3"'"(!
3"!&!&(
&'
$&"%!"$
, &('!
!+"
$"
$ !"$
  

8
3 ''"$
=>
!+"
"(! ;
$-&(&'! !&7"
&=2( ;8
+ ($&, +
"(%+8
+ ($&, +
:#
'+!8
!+"
&=2( ;<
$&'3'&(,
#
"'3($"(!
?'
&,&( ;
33;&% !&(
:#
'+!8
<
@&!+

$&"%!&(
!
!+"
3"!&!&("'
!
%('&$"
"'3($"(!
?'
"3"'"(! !&(8
#
33&(!-"(!
(
%-3 ''&( !"
= '&'8
@&!+&(
!@
-(!+'
#-
!+"
$ !"
#
"%"&3!
#

%"!&#&"$
%3>
#
!+"
$"

;'
2($"
%+ ;;"(,"
&'
!+"
$"
#
!+"
&=2( ;
$ !"$
 

$&'-&''&(,
!+"
"7&"@
33;&% !&(
#&;"$
=>
!+"
3"!&!&("'
'""0&(,
!+""&(
"7&"@
#
!+"
#"' &$
$"
#
!+"
&=2( ;
$ !"$
  





"'3($"(!

+ $
0(%0"$
!+"
$'
#
!+"
&=2( ;
'""0&(,
!+""&(
&''2 (%"
#
$&"%!&('
!
!+"
3"!&!&("'
!
, (!
+&-
33&(!-"(!
(
%-3 ''&( !"
= '&'

(
"'3('"
!
"'3($"(!
?'

!+"
3"!&!&("'
'! !"$
="#"
!+"
&=2( ;
!+ !
!+2,+
;"!!"
#
!+"
3"!&!&("'
$ !"$
A 

*
!+"
3;&%>
#
33&(!-"(!
(
%-3 ''&( !"
= '&'
+ $
=""(
0"3!
&(
="> (%"
#

3"&$
#
!+""
>" '
($
!+ !
'&(%"
(
!+"
$ >
#
!+"
3 ''&(,
#
!+"
&-32,("$
$"
$ !"$
  

!+"
' &$
3"&$
#
!+""
>" '
+ $
"; 3'"$8
"'3($"(!
?'
% '"8
#
33&(!-"(!
(
%-3 ''&( !"
,2($'8
@2;$
="
(@
%('&$""$
=>
!+"
3"!&!&("'

(
!+"
;&,+!
#
'2%+
%(%"''&(8
!+"
&=2( ;
$&'3'"$
#
"'3($"(!
?'

=>
$&"%!&(,
!+"
3"!&!&("'
!
%('&$"
+&'
% '"
#
33&(!-"(!
(
%-3 ''&( !"
,2($'
@&!+&(
!@
-(!+'
#-
!+"
$ !"
SHAMSHER SINGH 2024.04.25 12:40 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Chandigarh

  







































 



#
"%"&3!
#

%"!&#&"$
%3>
#
!+"
$"


+"
3"!&!&("'
!+"(
#&;"$
(
33;&% !&(
'""0&(,
"7&"@
#
!+"
$"
#
!+"
&=2( ;
(
!+"
,2($
!+ !
!+2,+
(!+"
$"%&'&(
! 0"(
=>
!+"
3"!&!&("'
(

B



8
!+"
3"!&!&("'
+ $
$"%&$"$
!
0""3
&(
="> (%"
!+"
33&(!-"(!'
(
%-3 ''&( !"
,2($
!&;;
#2!+"
$"'

+"
&=2( ;
#2($
!+ !
!+"
$"%&'&(
#
!+"
3"!&!&("'
$ !"$
B



@ '
7">
-2%+
&(
"C&'!"(%"
!
!+"
!&-"
@+"(
!+"
&=2( ;
+ $
3 ''"$
&!'
$"
$ !"$
  

($
!+""#"8
#&($&(,
(
"
&(
&!'
$"8
$&'-&''"$
!+"
3"!&!&("'?
"7&"@
33;&% !&(

#!"
+" &(,
!+"
;" ("$
%2('";
#
!+"
3"!&!&("'
($
,&(,
!+2,+
!+"
&-32,("$
$"'8
@"
#&($
!+ !
!+"
&(&!& ;
$"
#
!+"
&=2( ;
$ !"$
  

@ '
3 ''"$
(
!+"
= '&'
#
%('"(!
=>
!+"
;" ("$
%2('";
#
!+"
3"!&!&("'
($
!+"
(;>
$&"%!&(
,&7"(
!+2,+
'2%+
$"
&'
!
"C3"$&!&2';>
%('&$"
"'3($"(!
?'
33;&% !&(
- $"
=>
+&-
'""0&(,
!+""&(
%-3 ''&( !"
33&(!-"(!

33;&% !&('
#
33&(!-"(!
(
%-3 ''&( !"
= '&'
'+2;$
="
$"%&$"$
!
!+"
" ;&"'!

"; >
&(
!+"&
$&'3' ;
$"#" !'
!+"
7">
=6"%!
="+&($
'2%+
33&(!-"(!'

+""#"8
!+"
&=2( ;
&'
#2($
!
+ 7"
%--&!!"$
(
"
&(
&''2&(,
!+"
#"
$&"%!&('
"'3"%& ;;>
@+"(
!+"'"
$&"%!&('
"
= '"$
(
!+"
%('"(!
=>
;" ("$
%2('";
#
!+"
3"!&!&("'
33" &(,
="#"
!+"
&=2( ;


















A
+"
"7&"@
33;&% !&(
#
!+"
3"!&!&("'
&'
;'
#2($
!
+ 7"
=""(
&,+!;>
$&'-&''"$
'
!+"
&=2( ;
$&$
(!
&,+!;>
#&($
(>
33 "(!
"
&(
&!'
#"' &$
$"
$ !"$
  


D
(
7&"@
#
!+"
=7"8
!+"
3"'"(!
3"!&!&(
&'
$&'-&''"$






























E 1
.F





























 

* 












































E 1
4F
























































 








+"!+"
'3" 0&(,G" '("$

)

"'
G

+"!+"
"3! =;"

)

"'
G
 SHAMSHER SINGH 2024.04.25 12:40 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Chandigarh