Raghuram K. Shetty v. State Of Punjab
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH CRM-M-31263 of 2016 (O&M) Date of Decision: 16.09.2022 Raghuram K.Shetty
...Petitioners
Versus
State of Punjab
...Respondent
Jagjeet Singh Dhaliwal
...Petitioners
Versus
State of Punjab
...Respondent
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMAN CHAUDHARY Present:- Mr. Rakesh Verma,
Mr. Manish Verma, Advocates for the petitioners in all the cases Mr. Manipal Singh Atwal, DAG, Punjab.
AMAN CHAUDHARY, J.
! "#$#
"#%$ %"& '( )"
"#%$ %"& '( ) * + ,
* - . /)) 0"
&0 %"& - /))0"
&0 %"& * /
1* 2
*- /))"$$#3 %"$ * 4 5 ) + 6 2
- 2-
, * 7 8
5 9 46
*
.
* * 5 ' "3& '
* * 46
*
* *
. 7
.* *'
: .* 5 5 4 , *
( *
%"
' %" *-
* * : 6 * 2 '
6 -
(
* 5 - 9 * '
"30&;
#;
5 9 * <
%"#;
#;'
"#%$ %"&'( )"
'( ) * -
- 3-
' 005 ' "3& = 00'>
?
2 4 5
*
*
*
@
* 5
6
/))"
%
) %"& "
%# % %
4 5
2 *8 8A- 5
% "
B9 #$0 2 * * * * * 5 00'
*
2
- 4- * *
*
8
2 4 5 * -
6
* 8A - 5 ! "
# $ = %"%>""
&3 = >
2
*
* * 5 ' *
8
2 4 5 = > $ % &' %"# ="> / / = >"& = > $( )
%"
= >/ /= >0% "*
%"
B9 C8 $
$
%"#
B C8"%
% +(
/)) %
) %"
%#"
%"
B
* * /
6
*8A-'( * $ % = %"$>"
%3 * ) $ , /))
0# % "
- 5- "&% % " $
- % ) &' , /))#0
# % " "%%" %
-
#..31263 of 2016 2 *
*
*
*
8
#.
./0012 34/0 . * *
**/
*)2 )+ 6 2 4 5 / * 8
* 2 4 5
*))
* *
*
9 6
56
%"#
B9 C8##&# * 2
* 0"3
* 5 . * *
* '
6
56
= > 6
* 8A -
- 6- 5 7 8 8
'
'( /) * *'
* ! 30$) ?
%"
?
)#% ) %"
5
,
*< *8A'(
6
5
6
%9# /))0$%
%"
%&% %
% (" /) ) 0##$ %"3 %&% %
2 ) )4 5 *
* * *
* !0) *9 00'
* * 2 4 5
- 75
* 6
8D- 5 "(!
, = %%3>
0$% (
# = %"&> "&
0%
* *
*
*
' '
6
* '
*
6
8D- 5 "(! = >
E) ?
"3$0 = G D>
* * 03$
"%5 8 * * 5
6 8 * 6 = 1
1 ="33$>
"5 '
/ +
H= %%> =$>
00 >I
* + , *8 1 + = > *
- 8- "0?
* , 5 / .
H= %%&>$
"
I 8 ( 6
E) J$K(
( - * 8 5* 5 6
* (
* => => => 6 5 * * ( ( 6 !
** - ( * * - (
* 8 ' *( *
6 J (
J =
* (> ?( 5 6 ( * * * ( 6 * *
5( ( 6 6
(' * (
6
* 6 5
6 6 5 ( 6 * 7
6? *
*(
- 9- ? .
*
J 5 ( 7 8, 8A - 5 E) F&5 (
8
? *
) E F!
8
.
* * * 6L ' ( 6 1 5* + F
( * ( A 6 - ) L ?
03$
* *
*
* * * M ' *
L - 6
* *
*
( 7 6 '
* 2 4 5 00'
*
*
*
- 105 ( 00'
E)
::. ;
' ) ="> ? '
* * *
* * * *
*E
) * * '
. (
= >! * )="> '
*
* * 2 * * 2 *
*
*L K( N< E) = > F *L * * @ =>F L L 5
*
*
' *
*
*
* *
*
* *
2 * *
- 11- -8D ! "
# $ %"%=0>/ /= >3"
00 ' "
#$ # "3 0=">/ /= >$0
&'% "33 = >/ /= >&% $ * ) = %%"> "%
"
$ 8 < = ! %% => / / = > #% #' #% '
%%&=>/ /= > 3& $$ 9$9 %%3=0>/ / = >#$" E) F- 2
* *AK *2 * 5
2 : )2
*
L 5
* 2 *
* 8A - 5 = = > E) F"5 " ' * ' ) 2 .
%" %"0
.
/ 4
* * *
"
%"
*
*
* ( .
* * (
* '<
- 12- . K
#"% )
* * * * ' ) 2 *
* " ' )
* 5 '
* ( * *
.
' ) 2 2 " ' ) *
* L "# 5 * ( *
*
.
/4* *
* ' .
%" %"0? . ( * * 6 ' ) 2 2 '
00'
. *
* *
% ' 7
*
' ) 2
L - $ %= >
E) B 00' * *7 5 ' 00' ' 00 ' *
* * * *
* = >
.
- 13- 2 * *
*<
*
3 < 0%#
*
* * *
* *
- * * !
*
*
. * - * - 00'
- * * *6
24
6 %"= >/ /= >3# "% 5 (
5
* 00' *
L - )/
* 2 F 2 L
*
6
56
= > . 6
= > 2
- 145 4 5 * * 7
. 4
*
2 2
O *
* 5 '"3& '
* /
* *
0"
%"% '( ) 0
0
E) F0- 5
P * 005 ' "3&
78 5 9 P *
* L -
* ! K
%"
%"
/
*) 2 /
* 4 5 . = >
4 5 8A- 5 9
- 152 . ( * * 6 2 2
00'
. * *
8A- 5 $ * %%=0>/ /= > %%
* *
. * * *
> 8A- "(!,
(= > $6 (' , '5/"3$$ " 3 )
* ,
= %%3>"
& 0
8
-
6
(' = >
E) F$Q
! #&")' "
E J! 8
.
* * *
6J5( 8
@ 6 - 8
D
- 16- * 30"
5
6
*
. 6* 8 6- 6
6
* - *
. :
6 . 8 6 6 6 J
"&"3 6
)
= >
E) F"&-( ) 6 8 ( 6
R "$ -
8
* 8 ( 6 - * 6
*
. 5 *8 * ( ( 6 6
( "
- * 6 8 - ( *
6 "3' , 9 D = > * *
( ) * ) ( *8 *
- 17- * (
* ( ( L - * 8A -
5
00 ' * * 7 * *
*
* 5 *
- * *
* * *
* 00' * *
* : -
6
$ ,# $,
"( !,
(
(' )
7 8
- 18-
6
,
* !"#$#
"#%$ %"& '( )"
"#%$ %"& '( ) ( &5"&#+) JUDGE 16.09.2022 gsv ? . 7 E S7! ? E S7!