High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/31334/2016disposed of

Jinder @ Jatinder & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS.

2017-02-17Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal25 pages

! " #$% & ''

! " #$% &

!()*+, -

& .

/ 0&*+, -

& . /

& .

/ '&*$1# +,,2+ #$%

5 ! ''

* ! "#"$ %&'

(

! " * )) #"

$ %&'

( %0 & % &- # ' 5

6 & 7#0 89:;

0 # " +

+ :

9 *"<+ * .,=# / - # " + :+ 9

0 - %

'& ' 4 5 >#0 - # " 9 + ** % & ' * & *' 60? 0-%

& #?%=' 5 9-? & ' * ?%6 #

$*! ! "#"+$ %&'

(

! ,-./01 0

2+1/3+' %

7#0 89% '& ' 4:5 >89? 0 ' ''

**?0

# $%!& '

(

) *

+ '

) ,

) , & -) -,) ./012 ') ) )3

- 2 ) 2

)

( )2' )

- 4) - 5

5 )

3 *).,0

3) 2 5

5 2

3) ) ) .*)0 -

) ) ) 2

()' )2 2 )) 2 , 6 * 3)( 2 ))2 2, ) ) ) 2( 2 ))2

( (, ) , ,)1 7122 / 8 )

)2 (22

2 2 * 1 9

2 83) )2

3 42 ,23 / 8 , )) ( , , *' , 4,)1 712) ( :

, ) ) 9 ( 22

(

: 2/ ,

- 3

- 2

)( )

, 2 (( 2/ ,

(

2 22

, ( 2 )2 2 2 ; 9 < )9' & # &+$% = 45 "'* *6+ - ?

' ' *( **?0

9)2 , 2( 9'< )4 $"> 3? 2 $+ + -

2 <

:54 !$$")2 ?;'-

2 < " '

(

) '(" @ & # &+$%) ?

+ ' ) 5 < 74&

) ) ,

) ) ) 3 -

75 )

) )

3-) )

) ' :( ) ))) ) ) )' :( ) ) ) ) ( ) , )' : )2 2)

2 2

(2 (:

2 2

,3 ) ) ( : ,

39 2) 2 3

2 ) ) :

,3 * - ,, 3

,2 , ) 2 ) (

( 2 /

2 ( 2

2 2 ;

/ - 9 < ) 9'

# &+$% = 45 > ?# '#

) & - '%*6 *- &# %6 ?6

0'%**' 4;5 !

+%& ?

&& % 9**70 @ *#

0 &-' =

'& '

; 45 9&# #

+ % & && % "#%-*# *0 +(

-' &-'> 0 * & '& '7# -*# 6

'6# #& # 5 >= ?& &? A0 # # " ;

+ 7#0 '* & #' ?**% '& ' %? # -' ' 7#

& *0 > AB%* ,&= # # $# 0' !& 4) 5 #"+ $ % !

,.673$&8 ) & /7,!

4 2#"+ $ %

! ",.66$&8 ) & -/

$ %9

#"+4+&";

)5 ! ", .677$&8 ) & ./36,#'' #& - 6 $ !

&*!$8< 2 22,;2!#"+ #' $ !&

%"!

& & ! ",--=01 0

2+13-0$ 1+ > *0*&#'' #& $# 0' **?0

' *

) 92 &&# '( : , )

,2 (2 )262 / 2 * / 2 2 92 *

,( / 2 6 ,

) ) *, ) 92 &&#)2

2 *2

( ) 2 : )(, )

92&&# 2 , )

2 :

2 , )): , , 62

2 2 , ) ' ) , ) / 2

92&&#

62 , ,

2 )

2 2 A )

62 ( , ) ) B (62, 22 2 ) 2 92 &&# ' 2 , )

,2) 22 (

) ' )/ 2

92&&#2 62 C 2 ,, 2 "!&

2 )) C4 C *

/ 2

: 2 "!&

2 262 () 2 ># , ( 2 : )( 4 D 2 .

,0 , ) 2 62 2 '

2 22 )2 2 2 2 62 ( , ) ,,, ) :

62 , ) *, )

2 )

, 2

) 2 2

2 /

2 *, )

62 ( , 2 )2B 2) ) ) * 2 2 )/ 2

62 ) 2 , 2 B B 2

) / 2 2 ( 2 '

, ) ,2 2, ( 2

(2 ( , * , )

62 6,

) , ( 2 * , )2 62 6,

2 =

5 8#**) # 9&2; $*! ! "#"+$ %&'

( ! ,--70=1 0

2+1

.- & &? # " ;

+ * A0 # &? 7# & #

- $# & - %# & *? > &? *' ' '* &#*+ &? #*' A?- &? %= - 6& 0*6

?#' #> # 6% ?

&? A0# # " ;

> &? # " ;

+ % = C=%+ $#& - %# &

5 9 = &? # " ;

+ '*& 0 %7# ?

## 0*6%7#

? #- ?*'0*6 & '*6 -* & * 0# '' *+ *+' * -*

' '*# 9?6 &#'6-*-?

0? %**6& - & * # & -

'%6 0'& ' 9 $*! #"+ $ %&'

( !

-.0/1 0

2+1/=+AB%*"#& '#

6'& **& -#& % - **?0' # *, (

?, )

: B 2, 2 A'- 2 , 62 / 2 2

, ) ( 2 2 2 ,

2 2 &+ ' , ) ) , ) 62 22 )

2, )(EF.0

2 /

2 .0 ,(

, 2

')2 , ) B 2, 2 2 , A ' -62 )

(2( , ) , 2 22 2 22 2 2 , 2 : )(

2, ):

( ( 2 :

2 ,(

2 ,2 2 2 B ( (2 (2G

( , 2

2 ,( (

,2 2 2 , )(2

2 ,2

( , 92

2 , 2 ( )) 2,2 2F 2 , ( 2 , 2 ( (

2 2 2 ( (),; 2( (

, ,

2 2 2 222(, ,

2 2

, ) ) 2 ,( , , ( ( , ' 2

: 2 : B 2 , 2 () 2

2 , )

(2 ,

2 (2 2 22 ) , 22

,/ 26 /

2) 2

B 2 2 ,

2 ,

2 , ) (2 ' ) :

2 ) ) 2 /

2 2 ) 2 , 2 2 2 , 2)

, 2

) , 2 , )(2) )

2 /

2 ,, , 22 , ) (B .

(: )) / 2 B 2, 2 = 5 >7#0 '*& 0

# " 9 '#& * #%

AB%*"#& '#

$*! ! "#"+ $ %&'

( ! ,-./01 0

2+1/3,

# AB%*,&=# '* # '&# 0

# " 9 6

06 '&# %*+%# A0# ?#* %0# 0- 7# '*'%?& =

&? # " ;

8**?0& &* ? * ?& $# 0' 9-? #+?#'#& *6 ? **?0& &*%6?A0# ?#* %0# 0-0 7# '*' %?& = 0&? # " ;

?*&0*' 7#0 & 0 #0&*'? #? '*& 0 .'0 )2 2 "!& , ))2

2 ,

2 2

&+ 4 2 "!& : , ) B 2, 2 ( 2 )2 2 , ) , (

) ( : )(

, ) 62 ,)2 .''0 8 , ( 2

, B 2 , 2 2

22 ) 2 ? .0 /

2 .0 ,(

, 2

862 , ):

, ) /2( .'''0 2, ) 62 , 2 )2 ( (

2 ,(

2 ,2 2 2

2 ,( (

,2 2

2 ( 2 ,2 (

, 92

2 2

; ( )) 2,2 2 , ) (2

.'10@ 22 ( () ,; 2( 22 ,2 2 2 2 , , B ) , ( ( , ( .10862 , ) : 6 ) ,

2 (2 2

2 2 ) , 22

,/ 2 6 /

2 ) 2

B 2 2 .1'0@

2 2 +#'

) 2

2 2 2 ( : )(: ) 2 2

2 +# '

A'- 2

, ( ' ) , : 6 )2 , 2 +# '

, 2

2 2

2(2)2 , () , (2 2 +#'

A , , ) , : /

)

2 / 2 ( , ),

2 2, ,2 /

(2 2 2 @

, 2 : 26

) ,

2 (2 22 2 (2 ' 2 2

22, B 2, 2 ) 2 ) ,

: 22,,2 ,

2 2 , ), 9

2 ) 2 ),

))2, (

, .1''0 8 2 ) 62

, ) 2 "!&

,2 2 * 2 ) ( 2

( : 22, B 2 , 2

( ' 2

( ( 2 ) 2 )2 (2

(2 2 : 2 )( 262

, ) ( , 2

22 2

( @ ), 2 (2

2 , 2 2

(2 : 62 , ) 2 "!&

22 2 ) , 22 2 2 2

)

2 2

+#'

2 2

)2 (2 2

,, : 2 , ) , ) 22,

) 2 (2 2 : 2

, ( 2 +# '

2 (2

2 B ,2 (2

22 =

5 9#**% ? ' E* = 0 &? + A0 # =' ? &%*6 - %*(

# & 0 ?#* &# # 0 && & $# ?#* #* #*6F

# " 9 ** # 0 6 #

0 **6%

0 "@6 - #*

,'' A0# ?#* % ' *6%#

# " 9 ' 89 0 9**&% # ?

# " 9 % - $# ( & 89 9?6+# '&? *(# $# 6# %6-'+? #$# 6 *

-*& % 6+# ?&# '+' *- % #0

& $# # %6-'+&* #

0 *- ?# =' ? 0&%*6 - - %*( '9 7#0 '*& # 0#

# " 9 + **?0 6%

-0 *# .0 8

2 )

2 2 ),

), .0 2 ) 22 2 ,2 , 26, 62 , 2

.02 ,

2() ,

2) +#'

.(0

2 2 2 ), & &*0*0 0# *

' -*# ?0#*&%*6 **0 %0 0 '?&#%*-? ?=% &#%* -?? *6?& ' *- * % &+ - 0*00 &&0

&&0 & #* -

# " 9 % '&# 0%

'& ' :5 "&**# -0+ + $## + * & % '

? ' * ** 0 ?#* *

- # & ,$## +# *6%?6 %6 *'%?

& ?#* '# '& %? & '& - ## *&>& ' *6 ?#* % -# #

& 0& #* *6?'&*& 60- #&0 -0# %6?6 '& '9 -? + % 6 0 &%*6

- # & 5 "'0 #

&*6- 6 #*

*& 0-%

-? 0# * * ? %6 #

$*!>"< "0"&8

1,% 7#0 '*& 0?* *0 -? *'

- %?& 5 >(0 *6

#'+# -?% 7#0 89 *0 ? #%7# & 0 0

' % '& ' 7#*6+ '*& **? 89:;

0 # " +

+ :

9 *"<+ * .,=# / - # " + :+ 9

0 - #%7#& 0 0

' %67# .7+-+-.7 0 $ 1 / H

?!! " @$8 :* "@ ?!! 8

(2 "@