← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1060/2024dismissed

Sanjeev Kumar v. The Oriental Insurance Company And Others

2024-04-30Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal,Mr. Justice Deepak Manchanda3 pages

  



        

    !"#!$%&%'()

'*!!+,-.  /00!11'   2! %!' 1'&-'$!.0'3 #  2'#%42'# 2!&  !&0'#!' &  5(  65   ,  65   ,5  

!&!'  5 7!&2,-'#18#+$ !8" 2!00!11'  99999  ,8: 1;  2-42 2!%'& ' %' $- 00!1$211!'4!%&.#!  2!*-#4.!'  # !# < 

 0&&!# =3  1!'!# %'41! -#4! " 2%& -  11>%'4 2! >%  0! % %' "%1!# =3 2! !&0'#!' %'&-'$! $.0'3 2-42 >2%$2 0! % %' 2! !&0'#!' %'&-'$! $.0'3 2# $211!'4!# 2! ># 0&&!# =3 2! !.'!'  7#1 8 -=1%$ %1% 3!+%$!&8,--7&2! :"&2 8 2!7#1 ;

2!00!11' >'!#$=!%'4!4%&  %' ?@) 2! $>&%'&-!#>% 2 2!!&0'#!' %'&-'$!$.0'3 ' <

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

      

"- %1! 2!00!11' B&$1%.>&#*-#%$ !#-0'=3 2!7#1 !&-1 %'4%' 2! %&&-'$! " #%!$ %'&  2! !&0'#!' %'&-'$! $.0'3  03  2! 00!11' 

&D8

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

!'!#$-'&!1" 2!00!11' 2&=!!'2!# D ' 2!$1%..#!=3 2!00!11' 2!2#&  !# 2   2! %.!" 2! $$%#!'  2! $ %' A-!& %' >& =!%'4 #%+!' =3 52+% %'42 >2!!&    1 ! & 4!%'2%&""%#+% # !# )

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

 #%+! " 2! $   2! %.! " 2! $$%#!' 8 >2%$2 $' #%$ %'& !.%' -'!&1+!#!+!'=!"!-&' 2!1%42 " 2!&!$' #%$ %'&% %&+% -113%.0&&%=1! "%'#- %" 2!#%+!" 2!$  2! %.!" 2!$$%#!' >&' 21#!" +1%# #%+%'4 1%$!'$!  2!! >& 1& !'-42 !+%#!'$! =!"! 2! 7 #1  $' #%$ %'4 2! $-&! " 2! $$%#!'  & 2# =!!' 0*!$ !# =3 2! 00!11'  >!+!8 >% 2-  #+! %'4  2!&! %&&-!& 2! 7 #1  >!'  '  $$!0  2! 00!11' B&$1%.2!1!'!#%'41!-#4!%&"-'# 2+!!F !'&%+!13!"!#  2!"%'#%'4&" 2!7#1 '# 2!!+%#!'$!%' 2%&!4#'#%42 13&! &%#! 2! 7#1 B&>#  < ' 2!1%42 " 2!"!#%&$-&&%'8>!"%'#'!%' 2!#!" 2! 1!'!#%'41!-#4!

   %&.%&&!

  H ,5I 

       C2! 2!&0!7%'4E!&'!# ( !&E C2! 2!!0 =1! ( !&E