← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9173/2019allowed

M/S Donalson India Filter Systems Pvt Ltd v. Union Of India And ORS

2019-11-04Mr Justice Jaswant Singh,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra3 pages

   

      

  !"##$%&%'() *

 



       

    ()  +,  ---  +,  -,,  ! " #  &    '()*+,-,$ *.,/0$*+,/1$**++-).+01 '()*,2$-20$/,*,$0+,02$0.,2*$0-.*0).+0,    3 &    "

&     '()0+5-$0015$0.*,$0.,,$02,/).+0, '(),/5$*./2$2,1-$/++1$1-+/$-/1,$-51.$2*,-).+0, '()2*,5$25+*$5+/+$0+.2.$,,01$0-/.,).+0,  6 #  % &    4 %   &  

'(7.,2*/.+01

'(705/5/$05+.$/,11$/,,2$5/2.$55,1$10..$10-.$ 1015$.2.1*  .52...+0, 6#

$% &    "

   '()-1-.$2,55$2,1*$/0.-).+0, % 8  &   

'()0,5/).+0,  9 :

$% &  

'(71*20.+0, %    "

& 



3  $% &   '(70,20/$.51,0$02./,$.1-+1$.1-/,$.55-+$.5,05$ .511-$.5,+*$.5112$.5,0,$.1+12$.5,/+$.10/2$.5-2+$ .5-./$-/-1$,05*$.0520$.0,+. 0.*/2.+0,    "

&  % #  &  ;< ;

'(7-225.+0,<

    6   $% & = 7

  $% &  ;<

'(7225-$/.+0$1,//$0,,/2$/*-0$/2,+.+0, %  9  &  3  $%    '()0+,15$,/.5$0+5*2).+0, !#

   '()02.1/$02251$02//2).+0, # =  "

   '().,2*/).+01$05+.).+0, 

! =  

$% &   7

 8 3  $% &   

'()12,-).+0,   8 9  $%    '()0/.+/).+0,  8 4 &  

'(7.-1+, .2*+*.+0,  > 3 "$% &  

'(7-225.+0,  8 8 $% & = %6 6 $% & 

%6  $% &   '(7.1.+*.+0,    &  

 #   $% &  ;< '(7*,50- -+0-.+0, %8

9  ""$% &   '(7,,10.+0, %6  

$% &   6  8 &   '(7.1-+1.+01    "

?

= $ % & 3 $ @     8 63  $%

 % & 3 $6 4  4 3  

"' =

 6 9    70* '()*.,/0$**++-).+01$ '()25+*$02//2$/.+0$/*-0$5+/+$/2,+$/,*,$0.,2*).+0,$ '()/++1$--01$0/.+/$-2--$2*,5$2*,-$-51.$-/1,).+0, '()0+.2.$*./2$12,-$0+,02$1-+/$*..*0$,*..).+0, '()0-/.,$02.1/$02251$05/.0$05/,,$0,,/2$.0+*1$ .5200$.2.1*$2-1-$.+/02).+0,.

     0* '(705/5/.+0,   0- '(7.0520 .0,+..+0,$   0* '(7.0,,.$.--1*  .--20 .+0,.   0* '(7.,12..+0,  #

 

"'    4 7  !

$% &   

'(),55$ 2,1*$*,50$-+0-$-/-1$-1-.$225-$1*20$/0.-$/,11$/,,2$ 5/2.$55,1$10..$10-.$1015$,05*$1,//$0+5*2$0+,02$ 0+,15$0.*/2$0.,2*$,/.5$,,01$02./,$0/+05$0,20/$ .5112$.1+12$.1-/,$.5,+*$.5,0,$-225$.0520$.0,+.$ .-1+,$.5-./$.5-2+$.5,05$.5,/+$.511-$.10/2$.55-+$ .51,0$.2*+* .1.+*.+0, 

&  % 3   7.  * '()*+,/1  *+,-,).+01 ? 6 !

&    '(7*,2$-20$--01$225-$/.+0$/*-0 /2,+.+0, AAA --/     $      * 

0   1#2"#$3'45%#& 6","1 '%''1%! 2&

--    ,,    6#78#2 */

  

  !

"  #$% "