High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5209/2002dismissed

(O&M) Nanak Chand & Ros. v. Nanak Chand

2015-01-14Mr. Justice Dr. Bharat Bhushan Parsoon9 pages

"#$%&$&$ "'("

()!

&&&&& ")!

*)!+!

"'("

&&&&& !, "

-# .)&-( /0+1)2 /

)(, ")!& .)& ("

) 2 /

)()!, "& ( "!")/ !

"(!3" 4 +"

)- "$567

( )8" )3"5 4

/ "72$9:5() " ) ) )) ! ;( ;7& ( , ")4"

! 4 1 ( (

1 ! ,<!)" + ()!, """= 6>,) "(&(, ")!!

+?(/ "(?) !25 7( ()!, "( "

, )"

) ()" 1$&9&$: +482 $6@5 7(( 1 ! ,)1 !! !)A+ ) 38(, ")!

)( )

<"" "

"!! 8@"

5 7()!, "( ("?

(+!)

1 ! ,)1 !!

)(,+), ()("

)<( (

<!4 +& & ( "!")/ !

" ! " "48 (4)?)

/ ""

"? (, ")4"

!2()!, "<!

? /"(!( , "A+! ")"

)(,+),

84), )< )'

3+ ( (! !) 1"+ +) "? !( ! "

( ! (! )!+4 "

1 " !( "?(/4+"

+ 4 8

1 ! ,&183!

( "( ) ? "4,,4

)/ 4 "(8)$62( ?) ()!, "( ("? (+!)

1 ! ,)1 !!

)( ,+), ()(" <!4 +<!"

,4 & :& ()!, " "(<) "!1" " (?) !

/ ""

! (( 4! "!!

"4< )'2!

1 1!()+"!

(84), )!( ,"

1 1! 4! "!( !"

() 1 "

)") 4!<( (/) !1 ),)

34& ) 4 "?

(<) "

!1" ) ? "448 38 ( )!, "2 ( , ")! 1"

( / ",,4 " "

), )(?)

("?

+!)

(

1 ! ,)1 !!

)(,+), ()("

)<( ( <!4&( )!, "4!

,4 ((!( , "A+! "<!'" ")"38 ( 1 "(8)$9% "1 "(48)"

$><( (<! ")!

$9>,)1 "( "(8)$B& C )<!4!

4 38( , ")!& %& D)" 44) )1

< "? !!+! (,4 "?!

(,) !# E$& F( !()

)"G

& F(()("

) !!( )"

"/4 G

:& F(())!, " !4 34 3/

( 1 ! ,)1 !! "(?) !1" "

"(1"

,4 "!, 448 "(?)

("?(+!) 1!( ,

84< )'!

(1"+ +) "?

< )'!G

%& F(() ( , ")! )A+ ) ( !( , "

A+! "

) ( ) <" +!2 +, " "

"!! 8 "

( )!, " ! 4 34 3 / 1(!( , "( !?) G

& F(()(, ")!(/"

4 +!!"

4(,)!", "G

6& F(()(, ")!(/"

4(, "G

9& F(()(, ")!)! ,, 1 4 "?

( !, "38( ) <""

4 &H & (4)" 44)"

(,,44+( ) 8 (/? /"( "+))" "?!(()

)"<!$9>,) "("

)

)"1 "( )!

() "?<!4?4 "

/4 & ( ?)

,)!

"4 " "

+, "

( , ")!4"

<! 4!

)C & ( 4)" " 44)2 ( </)2 (4 ( (, ")! (/3" 34 ,) / ( ( )!, "( ("? (+!)

(,)1 !! "A+!

)( ,+), ! () (" <! )" +& "? 4)" " 44)2(,)1 !!<!)"

)84), )< )'3+( )!, "( ("? !+!)2 "!1+(!((!!) 3+! "!!

1"+ +) "?"

38, "?( !?) !+,38 (, ")!2(/ )&$&$<!,!! &",,42( 4)" ,,44+( ) 82 !?) < (( "?!

4)" " 44) "(3 / !!+"

38, "?(,,4/ C+ ?1"

B&B&2!!

( )

/ &$&$,!! 38 (4)" 44)& 6& (/() 4)" +"!4

)(,) !"

) +448 ,)+! )!,!! 38( +)!34 <"

() !& 9& D)" +"!4

)(, ")! " ( !)?+1"!

"48< ()?) ( !!+

("?

+!)

(,)1 !!

) ,+), ()("

)<( ( <!4 +& B& (,)!" !!<()()<!"

)"?)1" "

<) "?I+ 38()!, " " ) !8((,)1 !!<!

))!) ,+), !!

))8 "? +84), )!( ,&( )!, "?

) 448! ! F$((

1"+ +)( !( !3+ "48!44!() 81 !( !38,+)(! "? 1(1)'& "? ()!, "2()) "(84), )!( ,

)$ 8)! " 448"

! 4 "? "(!4

)(,!3 +B 8)!& ()!, "<!I1 " "(8)$& F , ("

<!I1 " 38(, ")! "!+,, )

( , ("

)" +( !!( , 1(,) !!

(, ")!& ") !!I1 " "2(! (()!, "!44!(!( !38 1"+ +) "?(!( !( 1!4 "

38,+)(! "?) 81 !( !

1(1)'& , ("

2( </)2""

334 / "( /)!

"()!, " !4!

1"+ +) "?(!( !3+!( !

< "!!) !+,, )( "

))/)!

(, ")!(( ,)1 !!<!)" + ()!, " "(8)$B=6>,) "(&( !/)!

"(!3" !34 / 383 (( +)!34 <& +

(, ")!2 "480)1("

, ") &,,) "( < "!!3 I! F:"

") !!I1 " "2(! ((""

!8! "<("()!, "!) (!( ,

! "( !( , "A+! "3+/ 4+") ( <!!) )( 4 "?

"!" , "

) / "& ! 4) 8 3!)/ 2 ( , " <!

) ? "448 4 "(8)$6&(/ "4 "(!!<44!

(,4 "?!< +4 )()!+??!(( !?) <!(1 "?)

!'/

()!, "( +?( (!!!+1 ! ?"

" 3+!

(,"

,438(4)" 44)2( +?( ()<!"

!+3!" 4/ " "!+,, )

(,4& & D)" ,,44+( ) 8 3!)/ ( 1() "?

/ "

(, ")! ,,)!((8(/ 4 !34 !(

") ((!( , "A+! "<!? /"

)!, ,+), !& D)" ,,44+( ) 8 +)() 3!)/ !+"

)# E$& &&&&&&&&&( "+! ! "(4"

!34 !(!

<(<!(,+),

)<( ((,) ,)8(

3"4"

(, ")!(/1 !)348 4

,) /((,)1 !! " !,+<) "484

(,+),

84< )'!&"(,)!"!2( !

/ " ! 1 !! "? <(" "

!, ,+), ! !

,) / 1)48 ("?

+!)

) " 11) 4 ,+), ! ( () < 44 "

1' ( ?)

/ " / 434& ()

)2 "? ( ,,44" ( ,+), !

( +!) ! 44 )1 "!

11) 4"

()<!"

4+!,) ( 3 "?( ,,44" ("? "8 ()3+! "!! "(!( , !,+&(!3"(4 38( ";34-+,)1 +) " E.

(" D4 *!& " (?<"H $:%2 && &$BB""!< ( "? /) "

()3+! "!!

(" "

) <( ( ""8 <! ) &

, !! 3 4 8

"81 !( ) ) 1" 1 !

,)1 !!2!

("" !"

4 34 3/ &"

( "!"!"

1) 4("?(!3"

38(,,44"!,)/ +!48(+! < )'!84 ), )!<()!"

<((!!) < )'!!44 "?

!( !&H ()4/"!4<(!3" !+!! 38(,,44+( ) 8

1 " "?& $& (4)" ,,44+( ) 8) ?(48,4 )4 "+, C+ ?1" "

<( (( !<)((!( ,<!4

))+"" "?(4 A+ 3+! "!!3+(""("? (3+! "!! ?")41)("

<!(4 3"

("?

+!)& D)" , ")!; +"!4 1 "48,4 )4 "+, "4)C+ ?1"

( ";34-+,)1 +) " # $%& '# " () )% (* %)(% ( !

(! !<)(""<!? /"( ,)1 !! ))8 "(3+! "!!

3+(!) )!+)"

+ "

"( )+1!"!2 <!(4 3("?

+!)&(<! ! " <( ( () <! )" " I+ 38 ( "" <( ( ! ,+4 ((,)1 !!<!)"

)(3+! "!!

J5")4.)("7 81 4 (.)("K&( !

( !2()

)2<)A+

)"<()3+! "!!

)!+)"<!

!) ",4

?")41)(""

4 (1)("3+! "!!&(

"" "3(4

<!(( !!(

3+! "!!<! "

!4 !) +!"+ !" " +"

+)"<( (<! ?"

1' "? ) 3 4 "? 1 4' ) ,),) "? () 34!2 "4+ "?

!<1"

2()

)2()1

4! ((!( , +4 "

3+!

) (),+), !!!

/ 4 ? / "? (4"

)!' "?,,44";!/ "&( ";34-+,)1 +) (4 !+"

)# !" # $

& & '() * +, -

/ $

$ .$

. /

# $

$ $ $

$ .

$. .$

$ .$

$12234

52234 6 $$& ",-%#)%./-&% " !

! 1 4),) / !

"+"

)- "$:575 7537

(! +"C3 )3"

" !) "2$%1 3 "!

) &(!( ,<!4 +

)84"

) '!(<), ) "?3+! "!!23+(""!) ( 4/ !

"3+! "!!&(A+! "<( () ! "(!<!<(() (,)1 !!( 3"+!

),+), ()("(

)<( ( <!

4 +&( ";34-+,)1 +)(4 ( "( )+1!"!

( !2E(3+! "!!

!44 "?4/ !

"!!H<( (<!!) 38( "" "(!( ,""

3! 3,+), ()("(

<( ((!( ,<!4 +& $& D)" , ")!; +"!4)4 +, " -0. '((%./-&% "() )% (* %)(% C+ ?1"

( !

+)2 "!+,, )

( ! "" "& (<!! "<( ((

,)1 !!<!4

)!34 !( "?(4< !( ,2')8""

?")4 1)("!3+(""!) 3+! "!!

! ) "?"

!44 "?1"& ( ! +)

)1 (/ <'"38(4)" 44)"

(,,44+( ) 8(( !1 +" (("?

+!)

( ,)1 !!&<!

"(!!1)

((("?

3+! "!!<!"

1)48 "/ 4

()1!

")3+4!

<!3) "? "?3 + 11"1"

"< / 8( +4

,)C+ (4"

&()<! " / "4 384"

(/",) 11"2()<!4!

!' +!

3+ 4 "? 1) 4! ( 3" ,4 +!

( !( , !4 & ,)C+ <!4)48!( <"() +?(/ "3) +?(2<( (<!"

"! !"< ((,4(("?

/ 8(!)!+4 "!

,)C+ (4"

&( !

(!<)(+!A+

)""

+4 "

(4, +4 (, ")4"

& $:& "/ <

(

)! !+!!

"2 ((4)"

,,44+( ) 8(!'" " +"(,) " ,4!,,4 34

!+(1)! "() ?(,)!, /"

() !"

") )" "I) !

)/ !

"4C+) !

"& $%& () !"

1) "( "!", ""

(!1 !

!1 !! &