High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/257/2003dismissed

Harpal Singh v. State Of Punjab

2019-10-17Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan,Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan22 pages

!"!

#$%"&'

!#( )

*"+ (#

!"!

#$%"&'

!#(

,-"./0

!"!

#$%"&'

!#(

! "!

# $

%&$ ' %&$ ' ' $

!!""

* - 1(2#3 $#

)

( "1(2#3 ( - ( 1(2#3 $#

% 41(( * 1%"&'

4( 1(2#3 $#

3#.

' $ (

$5! ($3!#$

)

#3 5

( ( '5 6! 3# . $#.%#3 # -#,1.!,!##("5 #,4-7. .!1 6! 3# .

$ $ ( # ! 8

62 !$$3 968 2 ($#.# (."( #$

! !!

33#(51

#3 5 , #

#"!

!!!-7. 1.!1,

#3 5 3.

3#!!3#..

;,$ #$ !!!1, ##

! .

3#( (,

61,

! !

# ,

"!'( !!!( ('

!( #"!

-7. 1.!

!!!"!

(#,#4

# #, !!# #(-".1, ,!'

( !5 #$"( #

( ("!

(#4 #$

#"($##(

(#4

33#"!#$

'"! !!

2 #$ 9

)

'#".( 1, !

(

(, !

#"!

!"(( 51!

,#4 "( $#"( 4 5#"

, , 4"&.(4#$

3##"# !

(1 ('#" 9<5 !#, 3 2 !#1 ('#" 9 5 !,

#"!

5#"

,!.

(, ( 93 "(

$!5!" ! !!(

$ 12 .( '#,!,

,!5#

4 5#"

( .( (4 5!#$

*#( &. $#.

3#.1, !

( (#2 #"#$$

$ 1

5#"

#34

' ##.1

1'#

"( ! . (

#"!

(3# (#(#.

!13!

3 #" 1

#,4( (

'"!

,!3#$ (

' ##.1

$# 1!

3#"(##

(###$

#"!

.#1

#,4(#, 3 #

!#!#

(###$

#"!

# (((###$' ##.,!!## (1

3 1!

$#"(

"( !9!!! (4 ,5!=#( ' !1!

93!

3 !3"(.# 3!

$#.

,##( .

6 ( ( ! (#!

#, !"3

! .

3#.(!

">#

#3 !#1#

'!! #$ , 1 $#. ?6 @#

( (

)

1 A= %9 $# #$$ !"( 3#!)< 1) 1 ()6%,! !

( %#3 # -#,1 .! 0

6 3 ( #"

(!, (#""( #$ !!!1

# ( ( ,#" !4 #$

3 #$#33"

(##4##!!

!!#'##(! ('

1$ 3#2 # !

(3 ('#(5#$ !!!,!!

$##!.# .

=.# $ !"3 =.# ,! #2 1 @.

#("3

!#$

( ('

61, ,!3#2 #3 (4 ##3 #!!

!!#

6 3#(

! .

!#$, !!

)

6, #

##$

( (( ##4##!!

!!#3 !

$#"

#("3 '!

133"!

(*"+ 1 4.& (!

,-".

# , ( !3!

3#"!

#$ ##1 #!

33"!

( ( !"$$ ( (!3#!" ! .

! ( #

3#2

$$ !

,-".33"!

(# 3#2

#('!3"!

(,!,3 1,

!133"!

4.& (# 3#2 $2 #('!3"!#$ #!1 #('!3"!#$ #! 3 1# #( 343 1,##(' !1,# !1# ,!,3 (3!

.#"#$!

1<1

9 33"!

(*"+ (# 3#2 ( #('!3"!, #! 3 1 #('!3"!, #!

3 13!

.#"#$!

9#, #$ !1,# #(' !1# 343 ((

3#2 (3 !,

( $ ('5 #(-".1!##$

( (( #!

, 4 # #3 #!!

!!#

1 33"!

( ( %2

( (,

5, 3#.3'

@# %

5, $#.5 ( !3!

(

3>"

!#,!

+ #

33"!

( , # ( (

5 !# !"$$ (!3#!" ! .

!1"!"3

#$1 # 3#2 #('!3"!#$ #! 3 ( C#('!3"!#$ #!1 ((##3!

.#"#$!

1C)1

91,

!133"!

(%2

# 3#2 ( #('!3"!, #! 3 1(5,!,3

3 !, 4 ##3 #!!

!!# C

16! 3#. , #

# @,!(#' (3#5#$

#$ # 6,!

+ (12( 3#2 5.

.# <

1- 2#("3

,# ## !#, 2 !1, , 4 ##!!

!!#

!#$, !!

!, 3#( $ 3#. ##$2 !#(#

$#. !1

33"!

( ,! ( ( $ (

#" #$ 7"(3! ! !!$#!

#87681.!1, #!" 3# !#$(#3".

! ("#

3 #

#$ 3#!!!#2( ("( 3#

% (

#$$ "( 3# )< ,! =3"!2 5 ' '5

#" #$ !!#!1 2(

( ( 3#...

#( ( (

3#..

#"#$ !!#!

3 ! #"1 ( !!#!

7"( 1.!1$ $( .$3 3 $##$$ !"( 3#!)< 1 1) ( 6%,!(!3#!

(1 !

.33#(51#, 1

5 ( (#"5( 3.

( "

3#"!

#$ #!

3"# 2( 1 =. !."3 ! , !!

!1! ( !'

#, %; :

;3#. #2( (

, !!

33#" #$

3( 1( #!3#!#3 ,

3"# !#5 %; @!' 1@ "5 $#.# @,!1.!! #

)

1,# !#! (3#.

# (##.@#

# ,!# (#

"3 ##.,!

'##4 (

#$ 1, # (! (!

!#! ( $

##.#

)

#2 (3#5#$ 5!488 %; *".& 1 :

3" 1 ?# !3 (3 (3# 1.!( #!

)

3#("3 (#!.# .#

( ('#(5#$ !!!($#"(

$##,&" !#

!##$( (D ((!

'"!

=C3.,! # $!( #$ 341 3.'

#,#'" #$

((!

'#,'!# =

3.,! #

!( #$$3

#$.('

3 3!

((!

#,'!#

,! # !( #$ 341 3.'

#,&"5@#

) 63!

(!',#"( =

)3. # $!( #$ '(#.

# !3 #13.'#2 ".'3"! 83#34#!# # ('##(,!

3.3!

(!',#"(,! # $!( #$ '(#.

1)3.'

#,".'3"! 83#34#!#

(

3"!

#$( 1

.# (!

#34! !"#$&" !@# ) 1, ,

!"$$3 #3"!

(

#(53#"!

#$"

33#(#

&" !, .# ." (#'' .

( !

&" !(

( ,!, $ ,."

( (#!.# .1,!'#" # ) #"!

%;) #( "

.#5

##$ #(-".1!##$

( (1!

.5#

.#5

!,#4

#3"(# !

,-".

( %

, 4.& 33"!

( "!

( # 3#.

# .

,-".33"!

(!"3 !#!, 4#,# .!#

'#")9 .1 (%

,3.

,-".33"!

5, 4( .

!!!$

#$ #(-".,!3#"

.# 5

3#" !

,-".#(%

,( # # #$

# !!! (!"$$3 .# 5, .(

!# !

! ( "3 #$ #(

$ 1 !

, -". 33"!

(4 (, (%

,#"!(

(( #

)

'#")9 .1 4.& ( (3#.

#( >" ('#"!

, 6,!"(5 (!

,-".#.5((#3#.

## (5#$

4'"# "(51!

,3.

#'#"<.

%; 7#!

4#,!!

,-".33"!

, #,! ,#4"( # !!

#(#!

3#((5#$

.# 1"(51

,-".33"!

(!(#"!(

#"!

1! (1 #"!

#$ !!!( ((

$#.#"!(

, !!(( !!!!#"!

#!"( # !!

#1-7. 1.! %;<!

." !.( #!

(# #

3 #$#33" (

!3 (!

#$A= %?"!

!3 EF $

%; - 2 ##

! ( #

)

( # #

3 #$ #33" ( 4

% ## !

!# (( #

2 !, #"5 #"3 #2 ( ## !A= %A= % ( 2 !A= %# A= % 1!

( ( (#2 #!

## !#,

2 !#6!

3#. # <

( #!

, 4 ##!!

!!#12( .

.#A= %*1 ('5 .(6>'

%;C# :1%;B@. (%; #!' + '

$#. , !!

! ( ( (

$$(2!A= %1A= %7(A= %- ! 32 5 %;@. 1A=3!

(0=#$$3 !

5 BBC1

,!#!

(!A0.! !!!1 %# # #$ $. 9! ! : ( #! ( ( $#

!##$

$.$# !0=".'

#C BBC($ ("

$3##$

!#(3 1@# < < ,!!!"

BBB"(

%"&'* !31B)C( 3# #$ !31B

3# !

#$, A= %:(A= % %; #(-".!##$

( !!!

!"#

3"#!#5#. ! 3!3"( #

)

(# #

#3 !#1,

, -".1 *"+ 1 4.& , # ( ( #( '!3"!1#(#.

!1,!,3

!13!

.#", # 3#2 '5 #!

(1"!"3 #$

(!3#!" ! .

!1, ,

( $ ('5 . !, !!(

( (2#"! 3#2 5 .

.#!

.51#

1 (%2 ,

((# ##1'5!"$$ ! .

5# 3#2

& #('!3"!13!

.#"(#(#.

!$#.

#!!

!!#1 , , !

+ (12( !

.#!1 ('5 !, !!

%; *"' 1 %# #1 # @,! *#( 0 . 1 .!1 #2 ( 5 ( (

)

A= %12( , (,!# (##.@#

!( # %;) 2( -".( #!

)

,! ! #"!

1$2 !#!.

51!

,-".1*"+ 1 1 4.& (%2 3.

# .( ! #

1#$

. ( ((3#! (##'

( 4 ! !!1 *"+ ( 4.& (

#"!

#$ !!!

4.& (3" #(#$

!!!$#. ! #(*"+ 2 ,#!',#"(!

(,$ #$ !!!,!3#$ (' ##.

*"+

.#2

4 5!$#."(

#,#$ !!!($#.

. 1<C#('!3"!1!

<1)

93!

!( #(#.

!, .#2 ((, "' #!

,!#3 41!#

5 . (

#"!

#$ !!!(, 34!

,#,(!'"!!((

33"!

( >"

.##("3

33#(# 2( -".1

(#3#.

# .#

=(5'"

5((#3#.

# .

$ %; 6! 3#. !3 #.# (!%, # 3 (#"

2 !# !3!

( #!

( (1#2

2#"!(#3".

;

2( #$

3"##3#3"( .

!#$

(, 3#( ("( 3# % 1,

3.33".!3 ! !

!"3 (, "#

.'"

13# (

5 #3 ( 2 '

52#2 ( !3!

33"!

,-".1 4.& (*"+ ($ (, ! .

!13# (

#!!

., $!

, 4 (

#($!

2( !'

3 (!

33"!

( ($ (!

, ! .

1 .

,! 2.'"!@# % B<< ,

!#( #

BBB $# !

9 # 4". !( #$ "10

! 1!3*"(!"( 2

3"!#(5#$2

3 #

"3 !"3 ($"

, (#"3 "34,

! #3

(!#$

!('"!

, .#",!5 ! #"!

2 !##$

#3 ",$"5 3#2 .#"(#"#$

!( .#"1 !". #$ !

1C)1

9 ,! !

#, # '

3#2 ( $#.

#!!

!!##$ , 2 ,#3 2( ! .

(!. #$$31# 3#2 5 ('

$$ =. (; 1, #!

("3 (.'"!@# % B<<$#.

33"!

($#!

915

#$# ,#

1B 1

9# )

BBB! A= ;9 (

..#"#$!

BBB! A= ;9

(2 "( 4# ( 5.

#$'3 .#"# .

( ($#!$ #$

'"!

#$# 4". !3

.,! !.

(

'"!,!#'

# (#

'!!#$#"

.G #

(#3".

! #

!$ #$

'"!

#$$3 #$!3 0!#$$3 1*"(!" ; "( # :"

1 # #0*"(!" #!

.!#$

#$$3 3#(1 "!@# %@ B<< , ,! 2#"!5#, ('5 ,!!$ (

#$ 4". # )

#2 ( 3#5 #$ #!

(#3".

(!A= ; 9 $

!1 ( !!#!7"( 1.!1 2( &"(.

( )

13#23 ((!

$##,!D

(

) *

+(! ( ,

+ , "

)" 0(

) )/ +

$ ( -)".

-)".

# + +

$ (

(

) *

+(! ( ,

5 # + , "

)" 0(

) )/ +

$ (

1 (2

/ "4 #

1 (2

/ "4

# + +

$ (

5 + , "

)" 0(

) )/ +

$ ( "

$ "

#5 + +

$ (

5 + , "

)" 0(

) )/ +

$ ( 4

7)( % 4

7)(

#5 + +

$ ( &

5 + , "

)" 0(

) )/ +

$ (

#5 + +

$ ( 6,!#( '#

"3#3" 5

6,!$"

#'!

2 !3

("( 3#! 1 9)1 9) (, 3# 6%1

$# 1# !

,!'

( ! 3#$#$$ "( 3#

)< 6%

$2 ($ ('5&"(.

3#23#(!

( 2 #3

!#"'5,5#$$ !

33"!

( !$ ( @#

133"!

(*"+ 1 4.& /%

,(%2 ($ (&# '

@# )

!1 33"!

,-"./0 !$ ( @#

1 #3 ! #$ , , !!"

( #

1 , ! " 3 #" 3#"!

! 2 !

#"#$

&"(.

1 #!

2 '

4 "#

$#(!#! ;

( (3#"!

!( !#

3#(

6 !3!

3"3, !!$#

3"#1 !

%;:

;1,(#,#$( !!!1, ##2(

, !!33#"#$

3( 1!"#

3"#!#5# . ! 3!

( $ ( 33"!

( *"+ ( 4.& 1, #,

#"1##"#,(!*"+

!4 5#"

( 4.& !("5#"

! #" #'!

2#1*"+ ( ('",!# 2#

("' *"+ ,!# 2# ("'!# #$."3 !$33 '

3"!

( 51

3#"( 2 3"

!# ((!3(

"'1, 2'

( %; :

;1 ,! !"'& ( # 5 3#!!

=.#1'"!

!"34#

"!(3#"(#'

(#5

# . #

( #!

("(3#23. ( 33#"#$

3( 2 '5

! !3#$(

!"(#'' '

3"!

3 #$ 3( !

!( #"!

3"#!#51

(#, !,$ :

;3#. , !!"!

(# !(

33#(#:

(!!! (3#$

##.

(( >" ##"5#!

!!! 33"!

(1, # ("( (( !!!

( #"!

(

$# 1

( $3# #$ !"3 33"!

(!!!

#" 3#'

!(#'

$!.

1!5(!"

.( '#"

( 5 #" (3#"!

! (34

3"# !#5! !3 # !( $3#( ,!

('5

3"#!#!#

(*"+ (

4.& ( $ ($#.:

; , !!1 2 ! .&#3"

3"#!#5.4

( 5#$!"3 (#"'$"('

$#$!.

#"('

2 #

(1'5

.3>" #, 1 ( 3#"!

!3#"

1 ! %;:

; (. ##"5##'!

2 (!

33"!

(*"+ ( 4.& 2.!#

.( , (#

( 5(

( $5'#

(

#"3#"(3 5# .

(#'

$!.

3"# ((#$

!!5#$5 !( $3#(

2 ,

$3! ( 33".!3 ! #$

(

3"#!#53#'

.( #!"$$ $# !# !$"

3# ( $

(!#( ! (1

53#"( 2 >"

($#

#(#$ !( $3#( !#!#

!!!( $ $#.

, !!'"

5((#.4 5!"3 $$# $

(3#"!

!1, $(

# #(#$ !( $3#( !3!

!#.

= ".

(23 ( '5 ( 3#"!

!,!

(*"+ ( 4.& (# .#2 # 3#..

."( #$ ! !! ( $

3"#!#5!4 !$3 2"

."#!

33"!

(,! (#''

5(#."( #$ !!!(

#$ !!!. 2 4 3 ("

3#"!

#$ (#''

!1#$$ "( 3#)< 6%!(!3#!

(##$."( .!#$ 3# 6% ;

!1 ( 3#"!

!3#" ".

!#1! !

3"#!#51, ,!("5!"# '5%;:

;1( $5

!!!

#"!

33"!

(1 *"+ 2( 93 " ! ( #,

4.& 1 ( !!!

(

#"!

9 .( (, 4.& !# !#$ !!!1 *"+ !" !!!, # ( !!!

4!1

2 ( '#,!# .

*"+ ( !4 !, !!$#

4 5!(!

# .#"#$

$ $ "!

3#("3#$,##$

51*"+ (

4.& !!! #"!

( ( #"!

, *"+ 2( ! ((#2 #"!

( (1'#

(5#!" !!!(

*"+ 2( '#,!# .13 5# (#" # #$ !"3 ( ,! # 3#.. ."( #$ ! !!

." #"!51

5 ( (#3#..#''

5!# ! (!1

3# #!

('5 (3#"!

! !"3 H!!! (#.#2 #3#..

."( #$ !!!1

!##$."3 2"

!3 3!

#$( 3 2( 1.#2 #!$33

.# 1.#2 ! ((

.(#$ 3.(!2 5($$3"#(#"

3.!. 2 5 !# # 3#.. ."( #$ ! !!1 , .5 # '

$# 3#.#

3#( #, 1# !(!#2 *"+ ( 4.& (3#.. (."( #$ !!!1 3#..# #(3#..##'& ?"

.# 1$#.

! .

#$%;:

;1!"3

33"!

23#.. (#''

5!#1!(! !'!

(1!."3

!1!

! ,

(###$

##.,!# ((!

#"'5 .

"!'( (( ((!

$#"( !=#( ' !1!

93!

, .!!$#.

. ('34 ',!!#$#"(.!! #" 1 (3#"!

(3# (

3#2 5$#.

$#.#$#( '!3"!1 & , 5 ( 3!

.#"1 ! ."3 .# 2 '5

3#.:

! .

#3 (,

! .

3#( (("

!3$ (

! .

, !%; #,

3 ( 3.

$#"( ) #( '!3"!, # 3 1 C#( '!3"!

, #! 3 1#( !

#( 3 !#, ,# 887 ".4(!

3!3!

(,# !,!,3

!(#

( ! ,3 1 , !# $#"( .!! $#.

#"!

(

!" .

5! .

3#( # 5( !,

#'& 3#!

('53#"!

( .# ".

(23 (#'

$#$

!,!

!!!,!#$#( (

3#"(# 2 #!!'5( , '"! !!#$#!(5#(( (!. #$$3

!!# #(-". (#'

#(!." (# + !

#!!

!!##$ " >"5#$# #((3!

.#"1

3#2 ! 2 '

("#

((!. #$$31

33"!

(#!"$$ (5(!3#!" ! .

!( (##5 3#2 5 $$ :

( 3#"!

5##!

#! !# ;

# #" (# # $( !"3 ".

! # '

3#23#"!'

!# '$# !##! !

'"! !!

.# 1, "' #$(5.

#(-".!##$

( (,!#(!." 2 "

.#"#$"33#" (#((3!

.#"1#!!

!!##$,

#,,!# + '5,5#$!

#, 3#2 !$#.

#( '!3"!1#( & , 5( " 3!

.#"!(##

% + (!"3 . .# #'

2 $ (# #,

3#. (5 !##2#2

. !3!

5 @# 2#"! .5'

3#.(33"!

(#'

#2 (1#. ('5, !

. 2 ( 3( (# (

( #"! #$$!

.3#1!4

$ #!

(1$$!5#$

#!3.

#"#'

#,# 2 !"'. (5, # #

#3 #$$3! 3#. !

( $!

.3# !3!

6$"(

33".!3 !

# (,#51

5,#"(# 2 4 >" ,

(.#3 !,#(#$3#23# #2

! (3#

. # !#!

5 (# #!5

. (

#$$!

.3#34!.

!"'.!!# .( '5 ( 3#"!

!,!

,!# 2( 2' , (## .

#$.('

((

2 3

(5 3#!35#3#..."( (#''

#"!

(

3#2 ! !###2 (! ,

2( (

2.( =&"(33#$ !!#(!!

2( 1 # 3#23 ( !!$3#5 0 #"

33"!

( ( # '

3>" ( 51

.#!

53'

3#23 ($# #$$ "( 3#)#$6%1 !$#(!

# !5 2!# # 5 ;

3#"!

53##2 (!"3

& 3# #!3# (

3"# !!"33 !!$"5#2

(3#! (#

(

#$$ !, 3#.. "!"3 #$ 3#!35 (

2( (("3 ( '5

3"#, (# 3#2 51 =&"(33#$ !!#(!

( 2 !#'

33 ((,! 5 ("#'5

#" $

3# #!1, $(

3"#

!!"33 !!$"5#2 (!3 !

5#(!

(#, #$ !#' (#"'

#!35!,5!!

#"( ('5!

3 35(!

5($$3"# ( 3 2(

3#!35 !#'

$ ($#.

$3!(33".!3 !#$

(

! 3!

!'"(53

(3#! (#3#..

#$$

( 32#2 .

#$33"!

(1*"+ ( 4.& !3!

!#2 ('5%;:

; #

.# , !! !3!

(#'

%;) #( "

.#5

#$"( # !#"!

1-7. 1.!1, !

# #!

3#3 #$ #(-".1!##$

( ( #!

,-".33"!

.#5

#( (% , 4.& 3#.#!

.(#

1 (% , 4.& 3#.#

##.

,-".'#")9 % 14, 3 #

1 ,

!!!,!3#".# 5

3#" !

,-".

(!(#% ,( !!! (!"$$3 .# 5, . (

!#(

! ("3 #$#(

$ !

, -". ( 4 , ( % ,

4.& #"!(

#($"

.# # )

'#"

)9 .

% , 4.& ( 3.

# ( >" ( '#" !

, -". 6 ,! "(51 # , (5 #.5!

,-".((#3#.

# #, 1# (51

'#"<

3( (4 3 #

)

$# 1( #!##$ !, !!#2(

2#"!4!!

#,2#2 .

#$!

,-".1 ( % , 4.&

3( %; 7#1#

.#5

##$ #(-".!##$

( (1! !

, -".33"!

(,!!#,#4

(# ( (5#$

.# "(51

,-".!(#"!(

#"!

!!!(

$#.#"!(

!##2( ( 3"34

!#5 %; #(-".*.'

(( #!

( (

33"!

( !"$$

(!3#!" ! .

33"!

( !

, -".1 4.& ( *"+ # )

( 33"!

(%2 #

(

3#2

$$ ( !

;

(##!

5 !##(!'

!.#5

$# 1 3#2 !!(("5#2

! !.#5#$ %; 6! 3#.

"1!3 #.# (!%1, # ( 3##'#

2( (

3#2 5

#( -". *.'

( ( $ (

3#2 5 3

$# 1 #!

3 !4 ,5$#.

#"!

(

("#''

51!(#2 ((!!# !'!

((!'"

'##5.#

2 0

2 .!

'5 $ (#33#"$#

#!!

!!##$!"3 #''

(3 !1##"

#,(!

2#2 .

3( %;) 2( -".1 ( ( #!

( ( 33"!

23#.

# .(.( =&"(33#$ !!#, (#

2#2 .

6 !3#!! =.#1

!* 3 5#$!3# !!#..

(

!# 5 1!#3,#4 ( "2!##

%#3 #!9%#3

( .

,#4#$

"'3 (#

(3#.

# .#C )

.43#$ !!# '

$# .1!4 .#

#3#.

=(51'"

5((#" (# !##3#.

$#,(#( #!

!$!

, !!(, (##!

5 !## (!3( ! !.#5 #"!

! ( $ (#2#"!&"(.

" #$%& # "'

( ) *

+++ ,

- "./

/ "-

( )

(

#* 0 '

* -

2 )-

$&32-$#*

2 ) -

/+ '

4 5$

(

- ".

+( 6 - 7

'(7

" #

*/ #, 1 #!

# 3' #

1("

#($$ $3!(33".!3 (

3# =, !"3 #'!

2#! ('

( 3#"!

( $ (#&"(.

# '5

=#"!"##$ !".

"( !.33".!3 !3#23##$

(

3"# !!"33 !!$"5#2 (!3 !

(3#3"!2 5($$.2 5

&"(.

#$3#23# ( !

3#( ( '5

#" (# ! # !"$$ $#. 5 5#$.5

!, !# ;

(##!

5 !## $ ,

1!!"3

! $#"(#'

, #"5.

!!"3

." &"(.

((

( 2#(#$5.

(!.!!

9 ! /5 :

' 9 ! ;" : '