High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1667/2022dismissed

Pradeep Kumar v. Madan Lal And Another

2025-01-16Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal12 pages

!"##$!% "#%"% &

"#" $ %* 2

'()

* !

#& "#"

'()

'' "

( () ' '

' () *'

' $ 2

+ , - ( .( /0/$172 !

#& "#" $% *"2 2 '

"3##4*

###4* 536

% #9 "#" 8 #9 "#" #### #4*

()

' ( () :'' ;

() :< 1#"

'"(

+ <

' '

(

- :< 1#"

'"(

$ 2 -

():

: 1 )" !

* "

"# $! !! !!

+,+ 1

% & "

+,') : ''

? : (

#9 "#" $% *+2 () *'

#9 "#" '

#9 "#" $% *02 () > (

()

)

) 0+!34*

!'!

' 0+!34*

####4* ' ) (

> (

) ' (

' ' "

# "#"" $ % */2

' '

) &##"4* = ' (

) ' ( ' ( '

- ( ' '( '

() : 3& "

-& .

/0 , 1! $ % * #2 3"#

. % 1 "

/ /0,$%* 2 8 ' ' ( % (

() :'

) ####4*

#9 "#"

' '@

#9 "#" $%*02 ' (): ?

?: (

#9 "#" $% *32

() :''

- + #/ "#" ' '

' () ( ( *

() ):''( ''

!>!

' '( = ' '( ' ( -

(): 1% % "

)& ) )"(& "

// / 1! 1.!"

" ."# .!&

+0 1!

& <

( ()' '

(;

#& "#" $ %*"2

"9##4* # #& "# & +# #3 "#" '

"3##4*

###4*

''(

536

% #9 "

"#" 8 #9 "#" ####4*

( )

()

' ( ) *

)

() '

- '

() ( '

' () )

* A()* +,-*. /0 , ,1,(. (. ,2+*3 )/.45 6*66(7. ,6 ,00)(4,+(7. (6 879*: ;< : 4 47/.6*) 273 +5* 3*607.:*.+ 273 :*076(+(.1 +5* 3*6+ 72 +5* ,8 87/.+ =5(45 =,6 ,66*66*: 9(:* 73:*3 :,+*: "%$%" 7= *9*3 7. +5* 7+5*3 5,.: : 879*:,.,00)(4,+(7.2730,66(.1 47/.6*)273+5*0*+(+(7.*35,68

,. 73:*3 72 *9(4+(7. 7. ,447/.

.+ 72 :*2,/)+ 4788(++*: ;< +5* 3*607.:*.+5*470(*672+5*6 6,8*5,9*;**.6/00)(*:+7+5* 70076(+*47/.6*)2730,3+(*67 7= +5*4,6*6+,.:6,:?7/3.*:+7 "'%@%"2732()(.13*0)<+7+5* *70076(.1,00)(4,+(7.C '') / ,

)

) ') = :'' '

) ( '

' % '('

B A378 ,)) +5* ?/:18*.+ +6 4(+*: ;< )*,3.*: 47/.6*) 273 +5*,00)(4,.+,.:)*,3.*:47/.6 6*)273+5*3*607.:*.+(+(64)*,3 +5,++(8*2730,<8*.+ 720379 9(6(7.,)3*.+,66*66*:4,..7+;* *B+*.:*:,.:+5*0,<8*.+720 0379(6(7.,)3*.+,66*66*:5,6+7 ;*8,:*7.+5*9*3<2(36+:,+* 725*,3(.1,2+*3+5*0,66(.172 73:*3720379(6(7.,),66*668*.+ ++(6,)676*++)*:076(+(7.+5,+ (.4,6*722,()/3*72+5*+*.,.+ +70,<+5*3*.+,66*66*:;<+5*

7/3+*9(4+(7.73:*3657/):27 7))7=7=*9*3 +5*2,4+672+5* 03*6*.+ 4,6* 657=6 , ;7., 2(:

:* (.+*.+(7. 7. +5* 0,3+ 72 +5* 3*607.:*.+ +5,+ 5* =,6 ,)=,<6 6 3*,:< ,.: =())(.1 +7 0,< +5* *.+(3* 3*.+ ,66*66*: 7. +5* 9* *3< 2(36+ :,+* 72 5*,3(.1 ,2+*3 0,66(.172+5*73:*3720379(6(7 7.,),66*668*.+72+5*3*.+5* 3*607.:*.+ 657=*: 5(6 (.+*.+( (7. +7 0,< +5* 3*8,(.(.1 3*.+ (88*:(,+*)< ,2+*3 )*,3.*: 47/.

.6*) 273 +5* ,00)(4,.+ ,44*0+*: +5*3*.+/.:*3037+*6+;*(.165 73+,.:(.9,)(:7=5*.7.+5* 6,8*:,+*(*+5*2(36+:,+*72 2 5*,3(.1,2+*30,66(.17273:*3 ,66*66(.10379(6(7.,)3*.++5*3 3*607.:*.+657=*:5(6(.+*.+(7. ,.: =,6 3*,:< =(+5 +5* 3*8 8,(.(.1 ,87/.+ +7 8,-* 177: :*2(4(*.4< (+ =7/): 4*3+,(.)< .7+ ,87/.+ +7 *B+*.:(.1 +5* 0*3(7: 72 )(8(+,+(7. ,.: +5* 0,<8*.+ (2 8,:* =7/): ;* 47.6(:*3*:+75,9*;**.8,:*7 7.+5*9*3<2(36+:,+*725*,3(.1 ,2+*3 0,66(.1 72 +5* 73:*3 72 0 0379(6(7.,) ,66*668*.+ 72 3*.+ 73*79*3 +5* )*++*3 ,.: 60(3( (+ 72 +5* ?/:18*.+ 72 7.;)* /03*8* 7/3+0,66*:(. ,- -*65 ,:,=,.4,6*(6+70/.(65

!#!

+5*+*.,.+(.4,6*725(6=()2/) ):*2,/)+;<0,66(.1,.*9(4+(7. 73:*37..7.!0,<8*.+720379(6 6(7.,)3*.+7.:,+*2(B*:,.:.7+ +70/.(65+5*+*.,.+=57(63*,:

:<+78,-*0,<8*.+;/+2,()6+7 4780)<=(+573:*36:/*+7,8 8*3*8(6+,-*7+5(6 7/3+(672 +5* 47.6(:*3*: 70(.(7. +5,+ = =5*. +5* 3*607.:*.+ =,6 3*,:< ,.: =())(.1 +7 8,-* +5* 0,<8 8*.+ 7. +5* 9*3< 2(36+ :,+* 72 5*,3(.1(+=()).7+,87/.++7*B B+*.:(.1+5*0*3(7:,.:(.6/45 ,6(+/,+(7..773:*372*9(4+(7. 4,.;*0,66*:*.4* ;7+5+5* ,00)(4,+(7.6 ,3* :*4(:*: ,4473 3:(.1)< . 3*D/*6+ 72 )*,3.*: 47/.6*)273+5*,00)(4,.+ 4,6*6 6+,.:6,:?7/3.*:+7"%"% 2732()(.13*!?7(.:*3C # < : ''

() :''

' () '( % ' , '') (

< ) ) ''

< - ' () ' '

1#"

'"(

$ 2 ) ' ' (

' '' ' < ) '''

' ' () % : +$"2$ $2

:''

; *

!$!

: ''

)

) )

< < C (

()

- 1 "

%& "

2 )" !

" "# $! !! !! ! $ 2 ' 3& "

-& . $ 2 3"# . %1

$ 2

' ' ( - ( '

% '''

) < - 1%

" )&

)"(& " $ 2 ' *

'% (

5 ###4*

# "##&'' '"# # !##4* 536 8 % ++"###4*

()

() ' ' '

8 ) '

'()

)

' ( ')( '

()'

():'

' ()'

' -

!E!

'' () ) :'' : :* E ') '' ( ' :'' - (> ) . ):

; '

' :' < : C ')() ) '

- B A"" 5* 3*),+(7.65(0 72 2 ),.:)73: ,.: +*.,.+ ;*+=**. +5*0,3+(*6(6.7+:*.(*:5*), ,.:)73:64),(8*:,33*,36723*.+ =*2"""%%$+7%#E%%$,++ +5*3,+*72 6@%%%F!0*387.+5 ,.:=*2%$E%%$,++5*3,+* 72 6% %%%F!0*387.+55* +*.,.+6 57=*9*3 4),(8*:+75, ,9*0,(:+5*3*.+,++5*3,+*72

6 %%%F! 0*3 87.+5 /0 +7 '"'%%E 5* )*,3.*: *.+

7.+37))*3 57=*9*3 2(B*: +5* 0379(6(7.,) 3*.+ ,+ +5* 3,+* 72

6""

%%%F!0*387.+5=*2""

"%%$+())+5*87.+5720,66(.1 72+5*73:*3/0+703() %"% = =(+5476+72 6%%F!,.:(.+*3*6+ ,++5*3,+*72#G0*3,../8 "++5(66+,1* (+=7/) ):;*=73+5=5()*+7.7+(4*,6+7 =5*+5*3(6(+.7++5*:/+<72+5 5* *.+ 7.+37))*3+7,66*66+5* *B,4+,87/.+72,33*,36723*.+ +,.:,)674,)4/),+*+5*(.+*3*6+ ,443/*: +5*3*7. ,+ +5* 3,+* 7 72 #G 0*3 ,../8 ,6 0379(:*: /.:*3*4+(7."' ( 0379(6 67 72+5*4+78<8(.:

+5*

*.+ 7.+37))*3 (6 7;)(1*: /.:

:*3 +5* 4+ +7 ,66*66 +5* *B,4+ ,87/.+ 72 ,33*,36 72 3*.+ *B, ,4+ ,87/.+ 72 (.+*3*6+ ,443/*: +5*3*7.

476+72+5*0*+(+(7.,.:

:+5**B,4++7+,),87/.+=5(45(6 )(,;)*+7;*0,(:;<+5*+*.,.+6 6,6+5*0379(6(7.,)3*.+7.+5* :,+* 2(B*: ;< +5* 7/3+ (.4* * 47.6*D/*.4* 72 .7. +*.:*3(.1 +5**B,4+,87/.+720379(6(7., ,)3*.+7.+5*:,+*2(B*:(69*3< :3,6+(4 +5*3*273* 3*607.6(;()(+< <72+5* *.+ 7.+37))*3*D/,))< 9*3<5(15,.:(2+5*3*(6,.<8 8(6+,-*(.+5*4,)4/),+(7.72+5* ,87/.+ (2(+(6.7+0370*3)<,6 66*66*:;<+5* *.+ 7.+37))*3 +5*+*.,.+4,..7+;*5*):)(,;) )*7.+5*03(.4(0)*+5,+H4+72 +5* 7/3+657/)::7.75,38 +7+5*)(+(1,.+H.+5(63*1,3:

:*4(6(7. 72 +5* /03*8* 7/3+ + (. ,.1 (.156 ,6* /03, .**:6,3*2*3*.4*.+5*6,(: 4,6* ,03**80+(7.:*43**=,6

!@!

:3,=.,.:+5*:*43**57):*3=, ,6:(3*4+*:+7:*076(+ 6@"F! )*66 6"%%%F!,)3*,:<:*076(+* *:;<5(8;<,4*3+,(.:,+*,.: 7.2,()/3* +5*6/(+=,6+76+,.

::(68(66*:5*:*43**57):*3 ,0037,45*:+5* 7/3+;*273*+ +5*:,+*2738,-(.1+5*:*076(+ ,.: +5* 7/3+ )*3- 03*0,3*:

: , ;,.- 45,)),. 273 6 >@%F! (.6+*,:72 6>@"F!,.:+5*:*4 43**57):*38,:*+5*:*076(+;<

6 7.* )*66 2+*3 +5* :*076( (+ +5* :*43** 57):*3 7;+,(.*: 0766*66(7.,.:+5*?/:18*.+:

*;+73,00)(*:2733*)*,6*72+5* ,87/.+)<(.1=(+5+5* 7/3++ +=,627/.:+5,++5*:*076(+=,6 6573+;< 67.* "'5*?/:18*.+:*;+7 73+5*.,00)(*:273:(68(66,)72 +5* 6/(+ 2()*: ;< +5* 03*!*80+ +73 =5(45 =,6 ,))7=*: 7. +5* 137/.:+5,++5* 7/3+5,:.70 07=*3+7*B+*.:+(8*2(B*:(.+5* :*43**2730,<8*.+72+5*03(4* *,.:2,()/3*72+5*03*!*80+73 72 :*076(+(.1 72 *B,4+ ,87/.+ 5,: (.4/33*: :(68(66,) 72 +5* 6/(+ 7.6*D/*.+)< *,3)(*373:* *30,66*:(.2,97/372+5*:*43** 57):*3=,63*9*36*:,.:0766* *66(7.=,63*6+73*:;,4-+7+5* ?/:18*.+ :*;+73 00*,) 2()* *: ;< +5* :*43** 57):*3 =,6 ,))7=*:;<+5*)*,3.*:2(36+00 0*)),+* 7/3+ ;/++5*6,8*=,6 3*9*36*:;<+5*(15 7/3+ ">5*8,++*3=,6+5*.

.+,-*.+7+5*/03*8* 7/3+ =5*3*+5*,00*,)72+5*:*43** 57):*3=,6,))7=*:;<57):(.1 +5,++5*+(8*4,.;**B+*.:*:+7 78,-*+5*0,<8*.+72+5*03*!

*80+(7.87.*< ;*4,/6*273+5* **337372+5* 7/3+ +5*)(+(1,.+ 657/):.7+6/22*3 *)*9,.+7;6 6*39,+(7.72+5*/03*8* 7/3+ (6,6/.:*3! 4 " ! 1 ! # 5

(" !

# 6 " 5 6

" " " !

5 " 6!6!!

" 5!7

5 "

6 !1

" ! " ( 15

" " 55

6 6" 6

" !7

6 # #

" !7 6 " !

" "

! " 5

! " "

6 " ! 5 "

" 6"

6 " 6

5 "!

" ! 6 # ("5"

5 8" " " 5! 6 "

5 6 "

" " " 5 6 "!

" !

" 7 6 " 6

!"%!

" # 6 " " "!

" (!

"1 55 6 " # 8"

!7 " 9:

45 5

1 4

".+5*4,6*72 8*65 5 5,.: ,.:5(/03, +5*3* =,6 , :*2,/)+ (. :*076(+ 72 ,3 33*,36 72 3*.+ :/* +7 ;7.,2(:* 8(6+,-*724,)4/),+(7.+=,65 5*):+5,+.7*?*4+8*.+47/):;* 73:*3*: ,6 +5*3* =,6 , ;7.,2 2(:* 8(6+,-* (. 4780/+,+(7. 72 ,33*,36 !,B(8 H:* 8(.(8 (6 .7+ 4/3,+ )*BH=,6 ,00)(*: . +5*4,6*72 (.7:/8,3/03 3, (+=,65*):+5,+(.+*38672 *4+(7."' ( 72+5*4+ (+(6 6+5*:/+<72+5* *.+ 7.+37))*3 +7,66*66(.+*3(83*.+ (.+*3*6+ ,.:476++7;*:*076(+*:;<+5* +*.,.+ 7. +5* 2(36+ :,+* 72 2 5*,3(.1 )876+ , 6(8(),3 47.+379*36<4,8*/0;*273*+5( (6 7/3+(.+5*4,6*72,8;5*3 (.15/03, (.=5(45+5*),.

.:)73:5,:478*(.3*9(6(7.. +5,+4,6*,)67 +5*+*.,.+6-(00 0*:7.*<*,33*.+,++5*+(8*72 4,)4/),+(7.*2()*:+5*,00)(4, ,+(7.2738,-(.1:*2(4(*.4<177: ,.: 6(8/)+,.*7/6)< +5* ),.:)73 3: ,)67 2()*: ,. ,00)(4,+(7. (. 73:*3+76**-*?*4+8*.+5*6, ,(:,00)(4,+(7.72+5*+*.,.+=,6 ,))7=*:;<+5* *.+ 7.+37))*3 .+5*6,(:,00)(4,+(7.,)67 +5* 0379(6(7.,) 3*.+ =,6 ,66*66*: ;< +5* *.+ 7.+37))*3 273 , 0,3+(4/),30*3(7:,+,0,3+(4/), ,33,+*723*.+=(+57/+,66*66(.1 +5* *B,4+ ,87/.+ 72 3*.+ ,.: (.+*3*6+ ,443/*: +5*3*7.

,6 , 3*6/)+72=5(45 +5*+*.,.+6-(0 00*:,0*3(7:72" 87.+56(. ,66*66(.1 +5* ,33*,36 72 3*.+ ;/+ ,6 677. ,6 5* 3*,)(6*: 5(6 *3373 72 4,)4/),+(7.

,. ,00)(4, ,+(7. =,6 2()*: 273 8,-(.1 +5* :*2(4(*.4<177:,.:+5*6,(:03 3,<*3=,6,44*0+*:;<+5* *.+

7.+37))*3/.)(-*+5*03*6*.+4, ,6*(.=5(45+5*6,(:03,<*35,6 ;**.:*4)(.*:,.:+5*,00)(4,+ +(7.72+5*),.:)73:2730,66(.1 ,.73:*372*?*4+8*.+7.+5,+ 137/.:5,6;**.,))7=*:5(6

7/3+(.+5*4,6*72,8;5*3 (.15/03, :(64/66*: ,-*65

,:5,=,./03, (.*B+*.67, ,.:,)67,(9(6(7.*.4572+5(6

7/3+ 0,66*: (. %"%"

*.+ 'E# (9() *9(6(7. 7 '$$ 72 %%# +(+)*: ,6 ,?,.

. ,)(,6 ,? /8,3 9 ,-*65 /8,3 :*4(:*: 7. ,./,3< % %$ %"% ,.: 7;6*39*: +5,+ +5* 73:*3 72 +5* *.+ 7.+37))*3 13,.+(.1 0*38(66(7. +7 8,-* :*2(4(*.4<72+5*3*.++*.:*3*:6 6573++7;*8,:*177:

:7*6.7+ 6/22*32378,.<(.2(38(+<

!""!

" .+5*7+5*35,.:

+5*?/:18*.+63*)(*:/07.;< +5*)*,3.*:47/.6*)273+5*3*60 07.:*.+6F),.:)73:6(.+5*4,6*72 ,:,. ,) ,.: ,.7+5*3 /03 3, ,.: ,6(3/::(. ,.: 7+5*36 /03, ,3*,)+71*+5*37.:(22*3 3*.+2,4+6;*4,/6*(.+5*4,6*72 ,:,.,),.:,.7+5*3/03, , 0379(6(7.,)3*.+=,6,66*66*: (. ,4473:,.4* =(+5 ),= .,8 8*)< *B,4+ ,87/.+ 72 ,33*,36 ,87/.+72(.+*3*6+,.:*B,4+, ,87/.+0,<,;)*=,6.7+(2(*:;< +5* *.+ 47.+37))*3 +7 +5* +*., ,.+6 +7 ;* 0,(: 7. , 0,3+(4/),3 :,+* ;/++5*+*.,.+6:(:.7+0, ,<,+,))3,+5*3+5*<45,))*.1*: +5*73:*372,66*668*.+720379 9(6(7.,)3*.+2(36+ 7.6*D/*.+)< +5* *.+ 7.+37))*30,66*:+5* 73:*372*?*4+8*.+5(6(6.7+ +5* 076(+(7. (. +5* 03*6*.+ 4,6 6* ;*4,/6* (. +5(6 4,6* :/* +7 *3373724,)4/),+(7.

*.+(3*0,< <8*.+=,6.7++*.:*3*::/*+7 +5**33737.+5*0,3+72+5* 7/3+.+5*4,6*72,6(3/::(. ,.:7+5*36/03, +5*0379(6( (7.,)3*.+=,6.7+:*076(+*:7. +5* :,+* 2(B*: ,.: ,. ,00)(4 4,+(7. /.:*3 *4+(7. 72 +5* (8(+,+(7.4+ "@#'2736573+

+5*4+ =,62()*:273*B+*.6(7. 72 +(8* + =,6 5*): ;< +5* / /03*8* 7/3+ +5,+ ,00)(4,+(7. /.:*3 *4+(7. 72 +5* 4+ = =,6 .7+ 8,(.+,(.,;)* ,.: +(8* 4,..7+ ;* *B+*.:*: 5/6 +7 8< 8(.:

;7+5 +5* ?/:18*.+6 3*)(*: /07.;< )*,3.*: 47/.6*) ) 273 +5* 3*607.:*.+6F),.:)73:6 ,3*.7+,00)(4,;)*+7+5*2,4+6, ,.:4(34/86+,.4*672+5*03*6*.+ 4,6* "# *.4* (. 9(*= 72 +5* ,273*6,(: :(64/66(7.

+5* 03*6*.+ 3*9(6(7. 0*+(+(7. (6 27/ /.: +7 ;* 8*3(+73(7/6 ,.: +5* 6,8*(65*3*;<,))7=*: "$*273*0,3+(.1 (+(60 0*3+(.*.++78*.+(7.+5,+,)7+72 +(8*,.:*.*31<72+5* 7/3+6, ,3*;*(.1=,6+*:(.6/45+<0*72 )(+(1,+(7.=5(45(61*.*3,+*:;* *4,/6*726(80)*8(6+,-*7.+5* 0,3+72+5* *.+ 7.+37))*36 = =572,()+7:(645,31*+5*(3:/+(*6 72,66*66(.1+5*0379(6(7.,)3*.+ +(.,4473:,.4*=(+5),= "E *.4* , :(3*4+(7. (6 ,)67 1(9*. +7 ,)) +5* *.+

7.+37))*36 (. +5* +,+*6 72 /.?,;

,3<,., ,.: .(7. *33(+73< 5,.:(1,35 +7 ,6 66*66 +5* 0379(6(7.,) 3*.+ ;< 8/)+(0)<(.1+5*3,+*723*.+=(+5 5+5*0*3(7:273=5(45(+(6:/* 4,)4/),+* +5* *B,4+ ,87/.+ 7 72 (.+*3*6+ I #G ,.: ,2+*3 ,66*66(.1+5*476+ 1(9*,.,44/3 3,+*,87/.++7+5*+*.,.+=5(45 5*(66/0076*:+7+*.:*37.+5* :,+*2(B*:;<+5* 7/3+67+5,+ +5(6 -(.: 72 6(+/,+(7. 8,< .7 7+ ,3(6* (. 2/+/3* ;*4,/6* +5(6

!"!

7/3+ 5,6 *B0*3(*.4*: +5,+

*.+ 7.+37))*36 ,3* .*(+5*3 4,)4/),+(.1+5*,87/.+72(.+*3 3*6+.73,3*1(9(.1+5*,44/3,+* ,87/.+ < < )

') "#%"% :

D ; 4 F 4? D (' F 4?