← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1459/1999dismissed

Smt. Meera Devi Aand ORS. v. St.Haryana

2019-03-25Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan14 pages

 

     



 

 !"

##$$ % & ' (" 

#      ) 

 &# * +",!  "##$$

 -$,#&(!. $,' (

' /"*& ,!. $,' (

 1 $(," "#$"

  " &-""2

 !3"-"" 4 &-"    &    $     "    "  "(     2    #"&$& -/$ $5&$" , 2" 6

3 .&$42 #$ & -7/$7 $&!$$-1"&,+"$8"4 " ' 6   ' (" &-"

9$$ ,     '    2$$      6   3  "4$ # " &-"+"$ $,' "! " 2"

 "    :;

 :#4(6   2 -,  $$-$,  &$$    !  2"&  <&      "      $$#4(6 !&  =*    $$    ;

   & 6 7>  #  ?"6  7

:



+"#$$""(2 2 # "&$&!$$-1"&,+"$8"4 2  , " ' & -/$ $"!-#& "  "#" !$;  77 $   ,

>@"6

"#& "   $!$

 7 @""#    "#$ --"$" &$"A:7>

; " !&6  

 @""#" $ 2" -- @""#$2 # 2 "&$"A/$ $ "$ ( #  "" #   2 #@ ""6

2#"&$& -7 /$7 $ "$( #&$$(2"&(& 4 #  " ," #   "4#" $@"6 "##&-  ;

 :   :2""&$,2"" $4$4       "  &  $  2   --  2"  "  &$  " 6 !  #" #$ 6

"!42 4($&A@" 6

"# !&$($9!$&6 ::;,2""2 

  4(9!$=&-,5&$(6

2$ 2 

 $@"6 2  -"$ #   -"#$,"  $$#4( 6 2"$& -/$

 $!&  =* $$;

," &"4" 2$$ #  ?"  2 -$$-$,$4$4@"6  2  "#"#$6

2"""("! -" &"$--- !,"#$" 4 &-""&5& 

,6 ,,"## $ 2 -"&,2" 6

 ## # !,&"2# -A# 

6 $<2  - # $ (4<2" - <& "9!$9&        (  "  &  -  "  #$  "&$  "! ## """-" &" "# //- " "9!$9& @""&4 2& :

9)9@""#$"$&$"&@" "&24$@""&24 <-  (# @""&24 4($@""#$ ""$$-"    :"+"$  $ 3 &39$$ B. "#9& $2 &""&24 4("# #$

2$$&

 BB&$9)9   ,&"&4">"



"-" " #& " & -;:/$ $"2 ?  &/ "  <4    "  (  7;77  &4<    "  -"    " 9&>.! 2""$  "&6 ;;

  ,"  ,"(2 2 -$(   --  ?

 &/ --@"" 2 --2"&$>!& &"4 "# "& (" -",$  &$  !&    "  $  !    &  &$$(  4( # $2@""$2- 2""#  $"  "9&>.! 42 4( $&A        #  &"  4   "  $$-  $    " 2 "# -"4(" -- "#$@"" --  " -"$$""#$4&"4 2 > -- "$" -",$ " @" "#$"! -",$ "!&" " $,2"""$ (!

"&# @""$ 2# !   :4&"  24( "9!$9& !<&-   :"&$ 4( .&$4   " # -  #   " $  2  #$2"" "$2# !     :@"/$  $$2$$  =* #2$! " &-" - $$-,&"# ( $"&  B"2 $4(6 ,"$ /!

   $    "  A      /$     $     "  9& # ,2"""A"-2"< -" $ -"!<&-  :

< -" #"$ "$ ! $"&

6 "2 $4("$ ! &$-$4</-"/4( 6 "2  '$# ( $"&

+"  #$  "  $  #$   ! -  " $$-    "  2     2"    -  " ! "#$

  "  #$-    "  # ,  $$2-  &  2     C"" "#$6

 2 # ! "&$$$-"#$D ))

C""  "         :    ;

 :  #  4( 6 &$$!,-$2,2"& &" (2"& $4$4D ))

C"" "$$  $$ ;

 $4$4D ))

 C"" "&6 7>

  # 6  7

:

 $4$4D ))

 C"" "&4 2& : 9)9D

)

;

C"" "#$"!$&$"# &D

)

; C""  "  &    4    <    <    (# D )

:

C"" "#$"!&## " $" &D )

C"" "&4 D )



C"" " $ #$& 

9)9D )

 $&6

2 7  ,2"" & 

 C""  "  <&-             &("4&"<&-   2"&<& , &$,&$$!,4-" -""#$$4$4$$-D ))

 $&6   92  !    ,2"" &    C"" "&4$"#  D

)

 1 C"" "!$9& "<&  ("#  &D )

 9 C"" 6 4#& " "& $2" ,2"D ) 6 



$

B  # !" ,"#$A" -")C,.-"")C,"

" )$,)2 )C

7 "

)C

"" ","A"

' 9", +"$  $ C,"

* #$-"C,"

& "*& , 9!$"$C ,"

" ) /",*&-C,"

( *",)2 C,"

6E$C;,"

=4-",9$ / C7,  "

 ",  !    C:,  "

)  1"    C, "

"/*& ,*&-C ,"

=2-"C "

< -"C

 " -$ &$ "# ," $9&  &6 -"#$,&6

-" ,&6 -",&6 ;!& " ,&6 7 - "&6 : -" ,&6 !& ",&6  -" ,&6  !& ",&6  1 !& ",&6  9!& 6 

&$$(,&"#$22" +"2 !<&-   ;

 8$-  -- !  4(  "    <&-     ,  " #$"$##$"9&  =&-,' 2"" 2-$ =&-,' ,2"!<&-   

:"

8$--- !4("<&- #4( "9& 4$2,"#$"!//" "9& 4( 2($- -&$ ##$# (-""4#," #&-<&- #4("9& 4$24

:

  --      -&$    ##$,  " #>#$"!## 4 "9& " &-"&$

B"!" $ &$ "# 4-- " &-""  B"" 4$&$( " ##$

+"  9&   4$2  4(  # # $(  $(?-  "  ! & $( # -"$2"&$$ " "#$"! -4 #$&4$ $4$ B"44 !"#$ 6

"! 2""2 "##"&$ &"" 2(&-("4  #-#&-   +"   $-$!$" &"4"   ,"#$ "!$&4 -"& 8& "  ,"&4 4( $" --"4 2""# 

(  +"<& "9!$9& 2$&44  & ;" F!&,

 E 8 ##$$9& $2"" ! ( $ !- 8  (  " $!#   4- # && 

         

         

      

          

     

 

 



!" # !            



    $

    

%$            

  

    &%'

              (

  

                   &%)*    &%)"

  

  +,      $

 

             

                    

 !

" #-#          



      .   //      0

       

   

  

   

!

" #-#   



 

!-#                              /     2                           

        

   

      3   ,   +  ,

  ,     

                     &%)      &%)      ) 

     $        &%)! 

   .     

    

  * -   &  4               !

"#         

!-#           3 5  6                 , 

,7     "&%)

  

  

          1 



* -  &%'0         3   ,            $          /        $         3     

    /    &     

 

    

           

          !   8)98

:

   #-!';

!0* '



98 4  #-*';

 *       5  



  /    /   

5   

          

  



                  

8 <      !           

  

!

"-#    

  &%) #  

 

#"#0

    &%)!!$            

      

!    

       

         8 

=>=> 8 

=>=>

& 1  8

  #0                     

   

    ?                  .               

  0* # !  







        !- # !        



&%)*1      



         

5                            

    4  <

&%)   )-&    8  -= >  

 &  '                  

                8   9

53

1, #0"'

 0 #   5   

 ;      





              

 ((       

% % 

            

  &%)     <  5 98

:

  1, #- '   :

   !0*   

  )   9  ) 

(  < 1, #*!'  #  5    

0 ;       

  ((       ?                          8  *  

& '     

          '

5  ( 9(  1, #0#' *  (   &   '   9 

   2  1,  #*-  8 (  *#                    $     

   8 

   #0

  

     8         

 

          

   8  -  

$       

 

    5  (( 

*        

 

8 

4     %      

      

0   

#*#        0    

   #5   !  , 8)@  



 

 

               %   

5            

 , 8)@ $             (                   - "&"   4($ &$ "##$$   

            

   !, " # $ % &  '(   )%'# ((#( '%

%'*+* (' % ', -.+

'/( 0'/#  '(  !

  1, ( 2%  '(   (( ', $  '( 3 4!

 %.%# !

.%  2( .%  %)   &% '% 6# 1  ,

 "##$"# &   &"A2""&"4 !"4

6&4$5&$2 "##$

+"  ,B( "# ##$    (   & 4" $-$,!$  2$$   <&-#4("9& 4$2

+"##$ -$(



  1 <  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*   "&#

 '# !+,

  "&#