← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/17795/2022disposed of

Sumedh Singh Saini v. State Of Punjab

2022-09-14Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan9 pages

      

 !"

!# !$!!

! !# !

### %&'

()*&)+,)-.



(/+)'

(01'

(00

22222 3( (

(&&)

/4, 22222(# 

(/+)'

(01'

(00

22222 3( (

(&&)

/4, 22222(# !% 5"6 2

( !3(  !2  

 



     

  



   







! "

### !3(  !.

!6 $

 

%$&' ())*+  ,-,,

   

  



.  

   



! "

   

  



 

 

%$&&/,0()  ,-,( 1    !

   

 

 

 (, 2 ,-,(

34$ ' (/

 , 2 ,-,(  

  (/5(656 

  (/5,6      %   (*22 7     %  5 6  ,-(28 

  (-* 

(,-&9 4% !

  

   9 &4    "

 

'!        ;; 

   

     

 

   !    

  $%& '  ( ) * ',-,"- .

+ ', - /  

 0 * (( /  

 ,0 -0 * )(+ )  ) 1/*

 /# +   #1 */ */2" 3# *

 +0+&

 

'       $%  

     #  4

!  &  '    5 ) ) 4

!.

  &  + *67  6  */8,193-     

  :0:

 

+

 + ; #   

  :0 :*

< 

=  ##=  

"

4

!. 





 

"!0 

.   .

 

."!0

 #!

!.   . !

. "  .

"#  %

>*()*))*)))?

* 7

   %

*(*))*)))?

  

!" %

* *))*)))?

*  %

)*))*))*)))?

   "    7

   

. 7 0  # # 88+6  

/ <  ,   

  :88+:- .

 # " . * .  #.  +

 + + ,@A$-   B +

  +   ; #  

     "    $%  &  *    5 )

) )* #  0   @ & ')>(*+   ) *  .

 !   88+ ##    

#

. #

  ##    7 0  #

*     . 

   $ 

 *          88+  

0 * )( + " * ) . C

>0  0 * 



     

#

.     D ) )(   .

#  

3 #!  . %

*D)*)))?

   

%

>)*))*)))?

!%

D*))*)))?

 .  

   .  7

>

)    #         *. # "# !"#  0       $%*  %

E*>)*))*)))?

 .   

  "!    

    

 

## 00   ##   ) )

  . #  

# 

   7  .  %

)* D*))*)))?

   

    %

>)*))*)))?

  %=+*      ##

 !%

D* *D)*)))?

" ' '

) )   

!

"# .  " "

  #

  7

  #.  " ) ) 

0   $%* %

5D*))*)))?



"  

##   

  %=+ + " * ) )

D .#" 

      $%&  5

) ) .

 88+  /# +  * #1 *$#!

+4/# +   3#   4

    E )  

 "

  

  =  

E 2  #* 

"  



   

53

3 #%  *#  #

"# 

"

   







 

  #1 " 

# .



"

 #

# 

 #

#  

"    "! #     $%* 

 $% 0

          ! 4

 *      #           "    $% 

 3#

( 

   ## $% * 

     

  07

 "

     #

# *

"     

$%

& 55 E ) )*  ') /.  " $% 



     #!# !

 $%"

&   5 ( )(.

 /#   +     !  B  *  

  $

  

  

#  !##   

 

"!  @   +  =  . 

  

 + # 



) 

$%. & ')   ) )D

 /# +  12 *

 $



  "!.!

 #  !##  D!



 $% 0 " #.  "! 



  

   



  

@

 

C F #     @      

#  

 ##  



"

 

     

  

.

       F #    *   #        .

 # 

    

  !! 

!        7 "

                    

   ##             #4

!  $% "



  #  7#     .  #   "

#

$ 7#* %

*DE*))*)))?

  

 "

# 3# 1 #.##

 / <  *&.

# # 



#  &.#

 ## .   .

% =# 



#  !  ##+  %

D*D)*))*)))?

 ! .   ! . %=+*&6$ "!.!4 + # #!* 

##  + ## 7 #    ! &.#   #!    %

>#

 3

%       

 #





/! D)G  #

   4

.  ""   . 7

!   

 #   #  #

*%

5D*))*)))?

.      ##

@    "  #  

  #*   " 

'  #.

  "

   # 4

! $%. .

  





 

 

.  0  

   

 

$%

#!"#     



   

>3

/  " *#  #

"#  +  /2"   !  

"  

    "! 

3  #

 ##"   ##

#

" # 

 

  !. %

)* D*))*)))?



 ### 

 

      

#   *+, 7   -.  "!



. #!

 #!

   



"# ! # " . !

 



4

!



 

0   " . 

0  

D<  #     #   %

DE " # #  & 5  ##  )5  "! 



"

  .

3# 1 #.## 

 / <    .   %

*(*(D*)))?

 



!    *   

     ## ( > ) 7.

 

  #     #

## 

E   2   !  #* "#! "! 

 0      "#



 H



 ' "

  "

 ' %

 ( ,/ -2 ,-(2 +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) /------<& , -) -* ,-(2 +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) /-----<& / -) -* ,-(2  +-(--(-,*))-0) ,-----<& -/ (- ,-(2 +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) +-----<& + (- (- ,-(2 +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) +-----<& = ,* (- ,-(2 +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) +-----<& ) (/ (( ,-(2 +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) (------<& -, -, ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) (------<& * -/ -, ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) (------<& (- -, -* ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) 0------<& (( ,0 -* ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) /------<& (, ,) -* ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) +------<& (/

(( (- ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) +------<& (0 (( (( ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) ,------<& (+

(= (( ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) +------<& (=

-= (, ,-(* +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) +------<& () -( -( ,-,- +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) /------<& (2 ,2 -( ,-,- +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) ,+-----<& (* () -, ,-,- +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) )+-----<& ,- (2 -/ ,-,- +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) )------<& ,( -2 -= ,-,- +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) (------<& ,, (- -) ,-,- +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) /------<& ,/ -/ -2 ,-,- +-(---2)(+2+2- +-(--(-,*))-0) /------<& E*>)*))*)))?

5  <     #   "

        

*00 .   .  "  

  

/! %

>D*))*)))?

,+

&

 D   "#-. 

  

  

7#  ! %

D*))*)))?

   +

&

E5   "#

(   

        #   

       



! "

           $%

 "

  00  "



<  #    ##      +    

"

     .

4

! 0  4

!*  " . 

0   

   

   )3

%  *#  #  

"    

"!#  #  +   "

  

 

    

 #!  *    

!   ## *. 

#

     ##   # 3  *  .   4 @ # # E   ## 

 )5.

 " #   "

    %

*(*(D*)))?

* 

 %

>)*))*)))?

 "  

    %

 *ED*)))?

 "   ;* )( 6

#    

 

#  *     #"#

4

!. .

  



 

0* 

#!

 .

     ##.

0 @ 

#

  

" "#0

 #!



  +           



!" #$%&&'()     

# .

 2  

      * 

       *      !""#"%  & #& " +  

#    #     , # %

4 "#.H 5  

    +    + #   3   ,  -   



  2  

 # .  

    

   "  

  . #  

  #    

#H I ##.

 

  

"     

. ## .

  #H

    !   7  #    "  #! "

J

   #       .       #!   

  "!   ! C"#J



"

! #   # 2

J



"

!  :

#

#    

#   

8   "#!.

 "2  2

  #  "!

 

    #

# #!  #     !# " #



 #  

 #"# 

#   ! ##!

  # # #!  7

#      .  

#   .

 #+ '>>   /#* 

#  

 .

                " 

#   

   .#  J

 8 #  

     !          !  " #*   "#  "

 " . . 

#!*  2

#"    *

##

  # "  

 * 2

     J

  

"# 

 

  .



 

     #  J $

# !  ##.!

"



#!  #  

   ## "

      " #     " "      

   *   #

 *   

 #  "

 '



#" #   #"

    7 # .

  

     

    

 >    ##!7  

 #"#   

# #! ## . " 

 #!

"       ## 

"  "!   

#

    I  0

1 +    

 -



  #.&/0  % 

 ! !#1%&&" # .   

 # # .

 #   >'(

/ 

 # 

4 "#.H

7 K(> @   "



*

#

   

#  ##.

  

 # * # .

#   >'(*

/ H ,-0 # + ""

*.

 

 

  #*

 

,

-*  " "    ,   ### - # "#    

# 

0#   " #  # 

# #   * .! #   "#!  



* .## 



 

     . 

#  * 7    "#

           

* 

   !  



  

 

!

  ! "

  

 

!

  #  #" #!  $%

#J " * #  #  

"#"

  

,"- *" . #   >'(*

#*   



    ,

-    *!

   "#    "   * . # #   



,-+ >'(

/  # "# 

   

#

#     *  $%*

    !.



*"! # *

4

!*  8 #.  

#  ,  #-    

    *  # 

* #

# 

#  



*    

  .

     ,    .



-*#

# # 2

,  #   !-* 



.#"2

     

# 

+ >'5,'-*

/"!

+ >'(, - 

! 

  



*.# ".  "! "

*   

#  "!   



!

+  #  



!

"      

 *"  # "   

 * ##

<

.

*

. #     #!"  *  ! 4

   !

   J. * #



! " 

"#!



,-

  " ##! "! 

     !  *  #

"   #  *     *. #

.      " #* 

8        

  

J 4##!.  *  *. 

  #

 "

 ,    -     * "2  

 

,-  0 !  " #      *            "   *        ## 

# 0# 

 # "I"#  I  

   # "#     

#  #    #"      *

.  



 * #      

             # 



,-

 #  ! #

  

   # 

!* 

        

.



 

"

,-"

 + ""

 I#  !I I  !I     4

  

 

!* .#"       # ##   

+ 5*     !

#* 

 ! *. 

# "#    

 ,



   !-   * 

4

, 

!-

       #!

  # " + ""

,  - "

  I . 



* !"

"#     #  " +  5 6 0

 

 !  

  

# "!

# " #"! 

 

 #  "!

  2   0 2 33 I ,- 

  #   

!  

 *.    #*  

*

  >'

, - 

  *    #     !   *      "

 *      

*

*     .



.

 .  #  



#*  

 7 

  .   #*  

*     

, -

 

 " #*"

"!  ##  

   "    

!*  

        

 

#   #

 

,+  4  56 6   7 - 85 # !""%+&&"9)J ; / + ,  -   &

  /   # !!1%9&& "% 

    I## I    + >'

, -*

/

,2-2  3 ,  

# 

-

 

 "   ##*     " #      "!  

#  <

.

*    

    +#   

"

4 

, B <  *&

#; B -. 

     

  

*      #

        #* 

   "!



# L &  ' 



#.  . ## .

 #     " #  #*#"  



 

#"

 # " 

  

    " 2 #!

 

 "

 > @  #    #, -    

  #   #

 .# " 

   

 #.

   

"!#  #    

#

#     

    ##  $%

! 

 "

    

 

     #4

! .

  0 



 

 

.   

4

!*     ##@ & ')>(*+   ) *

    

 $%

 "

 .    " . 

0



    

 $%   "

#

  "! 

 7#   !

 0

7#     "   %

5D*))*)))?

"! 

  ##

0  

* 

 7

   !     # 

 D  <     #      +   

    "  .

      

  ##    .  #   

70 * E"!  +. #

!  #!

   #  7 

   " #    ! # .#" "2  



 

#  ! 7#  



! 

!"    ##.#" 

#

 E

    

  *   

  

 F #       "!  

!  *    

    

 "

      

  

   

# "  "# !"

8   ##     "       !         "

$ 2 #  * !.

       "

* 



      #

 

  

  4



   

" "2  

2

.

.  !

  

* ##" # " "2  



4 " "   

  



@



  2  

 .##

@ ##"

"! 



 >'(, -

/      

 "# #  !*.

##

 



  # !



 5/ 5 ) ) 

 (1  7  * +   ## #   

::

4   5%$&&())*+  ,-,,6

 

 ,2 0 ,-,, 34$ ' ((

 () * ,-,-6         

!

 ! 

4    > &0     

   

  ::    

 

           . #++ + *   $%&   5

) )/+ #1 *$#!

+4 */2" 3#

#%3 >D >  )(,93- !

    

 

 $%  #1 

!   !

 +  /2"

0 



"  

* @:"# #  

       

$%.#"  

 "! + #

"!3

+ +

+

 0=/, ## -*/2"

#  

#  

* 

 > ) "!

  * 1 

*/2"

 + 

2  

     E ) .

# .

4



 .

"! 

D )  #!  4



" 

 ##   "  "! 



   +

  +  ; #   ) )

      

#! " "! 

     "#      

   > )    +     "   $

0#!

 $

+  <"   !*/2"



 

. 

 . ##  "  +4

 )

)  $ * 

 

        

 #     

::

3  

!

  

!

   !

    



 !  &     > 

         %

 !

     



 !    

 



  >  

   

  !

 

 (, 2 ,-,(  ,2 0 ,-,,    4      

34$ ' ((  () * ,-,-            !

>     

     4 ! !

?  .







 !       .  



 

   !  

  0/25,6 %  %

4

   

      

!

 ! 

       

"

  

!

    

   

!

  

 

  





            

!3(  ! &'

()*&)+,)-.



 8  

?

 M

8   "# &