← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1580/2022dismissed

Union Of India v. Dharam Paul @Dharam Pal And Others

2023-07-28Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

1 2023:PHHC:096796 

         

 ! !"#$#%&'(    

! "#$ ! "#!

    

   

&'!!

 (   

    

!#( !

'!) &'!!

 )   ( 

   

&'!!

    ) 

   

*(" !

 *   

    

!

 

2 2023:PHHC:096796 '  * 

   

&'!!

   *+ 

   

!#( !

   &  ,-

 . /.    +  &#(" &! ",-./, !%  &*.0%,-./,1!  2 !0%,-./, %  3333  /.  0 -   4!  " !## 5."   % 1!  "# / / .

6 .#.7 /,

/ 2

"



8616 % %,/!##'! 5"     

-:

 ;< %

 56 ! =:/'  ;

/";-#  / >', #, 1! 56, 1

  /!"  % % 61 

' !% (  #6 ',!#156! 1 '! 5/? . /@ <A ,

 &/< )-/? -/ ! 

 B!-/C# , ##156  / &/@,1  &/ !-/1 %



9AA  8' 



, !  .2 &/     ! -/,5616 / 2'!/" /"%  /

#56

#1

1 /56! / .1

3 2023:PHHC:096796 

1 @ <AA  AA  < &## ''

., ! E#1

# 

 %%# 5 ! 1!/!/"5/  <AAA,1 ' "

    <, < ,AE; %  / ,   # 1

, 5  , '

' !  6 5       -%%# '  !  *'" 1

#! / E#1

1!/!/"5/



.)- AAA" '#/  1 " 2.#1 1  E#1

56!/' ! /"%    <,<,@@ E; %  /  5   '

   !  6 5    4!% ! %% /!!FG5#-%: ! "  1 ##6 //# . *'" 

< 1!#  "

'!#1#233!2$'()4'(*  # 2!5 %#% %5# 6$ 7/89:;<2.#%;<!5 <:8;<- $  :$ * 8 ! /  5'! # " " 2 .#E/"%   %E#;1

 1!/! '  " . *'"  

 %

 56 !   )-  AAA,#

 ".*'"

<%

56 !FG5#&% "  .#-%%# D9<;D9@

, #1

#! :/%%#/  ' %/6,! #   

! /   ! :/ % /'

 

 1

 /!"   ! % % 6 1 56 ! %  !  .  

 D 8616 % %,!   %

56 ! =:/'  ;/";-#  / >', #, !  5 "%'1!# 5"'! %/ /1   #"! . 5 #

!

,!6##

4 2023:PHHC:096796 # '

  #"1 A

#6! 1!!/ !/ .8%5!:6$ %#% %5#0'. 7 % , #/! # 5%#/%!/  FG5# &% "    8:3:!!  .#%;< 6$ %#%  %5#0 * .)' 1## / 

9%

56!   #%"$! %#% %5#6$<:%5$%5 <!:$  !! !# / # E#;

1

! %#/ #/%!*'" FG5#&% "  /  <%8$<%=: ;<5><# !<   >? - $ 1$ 87:  %58$ :#2!1!239!% :3: #%-#9# !5%5%:0(.'  -%5 "@8#$# #%

#"!: %5 $$#$ %  99#$$#%!: %5 % <!: 6$.<#133 2233#;28:%5 <!:$0.(' 1##  / 

9%

56! #1#2 !1#$#%)+' ( # 2!5$ %#% %5#6$7#>.#%;<%5 <!:$0/! / ! #  "   " 2 .#E/"%  1  " 

,% / .8%5!:A$"$!$83:0 ! '!  '    #" /#  !. 5 / 1 A

!:%  #1"56!FG5#&% "  / 8:3:!! .#%;<A$"$!$83:1 %%#/5# A !.! # / # !%  '!

'!! %% ;52-%

# / !1 !!% / ,! #  " ' !" " 2.#E/"% 1 " 

 56 !  . *'" 



 %

  )-   AAA 1!/! 1  #  %!# 56 FG5#&% " . *'"

<%

.# -%%#D9<;D9@

1!/!1 "/! !/ .8%5!:A$ "$!$83:!

,! / -1    #1

5 2023:PHHC:096796 1 A

 !#/ 8:3:!! .#%;<A$"$!$83:1  %%#/5#-# /

! %/! # 65"56!  .*'"

9%

#1#2 !1#$#%)+' ( # 2!5 $ %#%   %5# 6$ 7#> .#%;< %5  <!:$0 ! #. !   % /!  + B   

  

                 

        

  

 

       

            

   

    

    

                   

    

         

         

      

     

     

 

  

   

     

   



    

         

  

       

     

   

     

    

 

 

    

  

         

     

   

    

    

     !" #      

   

 $

        

   

      % 



  

        



   &      . ,!% / / /"

/ !/ ,! / "56!

9#1#2 !1#$#%  # 2!5$ %#% %5#6$<:%5$%5 <!:$, #6'%*'" %

#1#233!2)*(  # 2!5$!% :21!:%9!%  %5#6$ 7!1#2#$ 7/89:#%5 <!:$/5"%%#/5#  5!! / <:%5$A$"$!$83: 7!1#B 7 /89:# $83:, % .  /    56 FG5# &% "  

6 2023:PHHC:096796 /

6' #  /

  ! " %   #1  / <%8$<%=: ;<5><# !<  $83:  .<#133 2233 #;28:A$/ $83:1 ! 5 '!!/ !   ' !  4!  .  %% 

" ! /   FG5# -%: / C 9 96$.  ! 8%7>:!3: !5$++  .+,1!# #6'%!% . / .1:%

  <%8$<%=:A$ "$!

%   .<#133 2233 #;28:A$ /  $83: 4! , '  "    ! %  % ,

" !

, "

  7##6,!#!% / 1 /? 165/2! 6 A . !:% 6 96

,!

 5  '!' %6"  ?! "" !  56 !  16 5/2  ! 6

 =:/'   

?       ! :/ % /'

 1! : "!

" 6    /.      '( # H!! %2'E   + I E H!! % 5# + I E