← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9399/2019allowed

Karishma v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-11-12Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu21 pages



      

 !""#$%$&'( 





   '  )*

 +  ++

     

    

!

 " 

    

   

#  #$

%& ' !%( ) * (   # &   (  %  (  !

(  +

    (  %    

  ' !

 (  ,,,,

 ++ ,

 "  

  #

   % !  --. ( % "    "  -1-

  

               

   ! ! "# $%& '

 (

  (         &

)   ( 

                  *  +  ) ,  -& .

'  / !01 "2& +   / !

  "3! %! "2 $"&

 ) / !"4      

    

  

               

 

            

 &(



 5 ) +           



       !

  +'

        (  /    +   0 %   1 23-456

5. 47 -456/ 50  !%  % 

!

'

 !%5578  9  ( # /

'% 0/   0   #   # &%        ! %

  %  







  

  !! " #$%# &!'%#(#&#)%*+#,-.#)!#- ,672&8+6 3&9+.6"3"&9+96#&:8$,:/62 & :8$8+60&:8$9+.60&:8$9+960%; -2-

 

! 

  "

  %!  :%!    

"

 %

%  /-*0 &%*%"0 &!"

)#1 )#!  2'

.#3,

  



'

 " <   '

    = :

 9 1>        !



?     

 

  4

 #14 4#! %# "@  +  ,  +   20 +  $ A

    2@ + A

  "32 +     )

' +        A   , '

'

   2" +  $ A

    27 + A

 

#$%# "72 +  ,  +   />B "73 +     )

' +        , '

'

  

 )       .

' 1+   

   )!

/>B #3,    

)      ! 1#3, "2$7   C    

       (

  

   '

       +  ) !!  "! %! "2! #3,

)5, #).0#$#&D ) ? '

)( 

 



  )(   "

        !!  "! %! "2  (

        & 

   -3-

A      "!%"> E )   & "#0%! #3, *  

)    8   + &9 ?( + +    

    7 

 ) '  , '!>      ! + 0%#3

!"@ $3#" !

###%!3

)  #1 )+

"6 ! (#&#)%

78 0&--#! " )+& #

&%+ %#

#$%# & #!-#&

" )+&

#$%#

" )+& )#!-#&

&%+ %#

#$%# ₹" 1$ ₹7 1$ ₹71$ ₹"01$

 + ! / ! "& F0 ₹"7 1$ ₹@71$ ₹071$ ₹"21$

 + ! / ! % F7 2 :A$ 8'

 5  / +

       :8  -**      

       , & 8+  9+. F 9+9 +

        )! * 

 



         )   

)1

E )!   )      /) ?

  $+

 )  8 9 ? >

&E )/ 9 ? >-9> 9 ? ! '

 ) 

  ! +

 

'

        

 !!/) ?

 $+

 (



   ! GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG -4-

#   

 ) ((

'    ) 5  8  8  +    5        9 &  ? H$

)  $# "4# !

%-   "!  +  ) , - #9  

%--.  " "1 "@ " ! *  +  ) , - "1 "@ 0!  +  ) , - " 71 "@ " %! *  +  ) , - 71 "@ 7! >

'    5  8   +  ) 0 01 "0 3!

8)>    % 21 "7 .

.

' / !21 "7&+ !/ !7&.

'!/ !"1 "@&+ !/ ! "F .

'!/ !71 "@&+ !/ !"F      )

   (  ) 5  8 8 +   &  ?  '

 +   /  

  %! 7! "@ F 3! %! "2!.

.

'!/ !01 "0   (   ) 5      9 )   )  

   (    )   5  8  8  +   &  ? '

+  /  

 "7!@! "7! 

(

    '

(

 

' / !01 "0(    ) ) 



 $

'  ! , '!

 

    '            

 (

     '

(

   .

'  / ! 01 "0   )      9         

'  (         )        )   



       !8 

 ( )A    

 

  (

 

.

'!/ !21 "7&+ !/ !7&.

'!/ !"1 "@&+ !/ ! "F&.

'!/ !71 "@+ !/ !"F .

'!/ !01 "0!5 ('&  

( 

' 

   '



  

 (       

  !   

  :9, +   (

   

 

 :9, +   ( 

 ) )

, +   $.

'  F





' 

 )  !5 ('& 

 (   

'  

   (       

 !      

 $+

  (   -5-



   (  )     $+

    1' !

  ;%%!

 1 23-456

    9   ( #  /

 '% 0 #  '

 )<  !

! % (

/:8$8+0 =:% ;'1 745>65 

 ! %#



 1 53-458 

(   "%  1 256-5-5--4/ 20#      "

<  / "  ?

0      :%   ? <  " !

%!

 24 5- -456@  %

 " !  48 4- -45>    % :%   "  ?

 % )((

 

- 

  !  #

  %  :%  !

 "

!  !!

?

/ ?0"!"  58 4- -45>

56 4- -45>    

"

  %!!

% !

 "

 &

"    ( "

  57 4- -45>  ?   "

#

(    """ !

 

  "    (@

   ? 56 4- -45> %:% 

.  ? 

 

    ! % ?

/ ?0"!

%!

# -4 4- -45>@#%

" ! :%    

-4 4- -45>/ 70     " # 5A7 2!   :%   5A.!  % )((

  -6-

/ 



     !

 (  -5 4- -45>     

       %    (    

. !&%@"    !*!

 %   5.-!   *%  '

 (

-5 4- -45> 

0  ? 

     

     %    !      

 -5 !&%  "    "  5.5!   *%   

-5 4- -45> 

  '



  "

  /0

!

 ! % 

 :%  

  "  

   ( +

1 A777 -45>"!" # (



B !   

-6 4- -45>"  

 ! "  

 "

&   /0 "

 

  "   



? 

 ; !

!

     

 

( %   " C

 ? ":%

 #

       

 #

    %  #   /0    %



   !

# @#%

"   !

 "

 

   + *    '1

  ;

!

#  ( % 



!!    9  # /

'% 0% -7-

)( (

  

    1 53-458 

-6 45 -458@#%  !%  "!!

 "#  %#!1

!



-7 4A -458 

  9%  !

 (



 B !    

-A 4A -4-- 

 

      #

  ! ( 

     

 2- ( /,+50  %       ; !

!

       %   #  !B  (   " %

# 5A. -!    

24 4A -4-- 

 

 !

 54 4> -4-7    

 ( %   % ! 

"# !

 !!

!

"  ""   "

"

& B%  " /0  $

 !" 

 "   

   :%   %  

 

  

  %!

 

!  9  %#

  

  1 453-458  ! <   # 

(  9% !

#  

 

@  !

# %#@  "

 ! 

% & " "

&

&  #

 

#%  #  # (   < " %     

-   !

!

 "   "%!"  #  !   %$% !

-8-

   ! 57 5. % ;@ !

#

# :% 

 

(   + *  + +'1

(     

 ( %  "   %%  "   

!

    

 

 %    %

# 5A. -! #  !B 

(@#%   #  :% # 

 

(  9% %#    1 23-456!

:%  %# #

"

56

-A   !%   

 1

/0   A   <  #

! % (

!

/0  % %#    ! 9 / -0 

#  47 42 5>68@

!%  

  !&   "< 45 47 -456#   

  25 -6 

( 

  %#    %  "     #  !

/0 "        ( #   



  1 53-458 #%  

  

  %!

   !

  

   453-458 

(( 

 %#     #   

 !

% #  

  <  <%  A   #   ! %  (

 !

@ #% -9-

 #

 # !%  

@ !

 ! %  #

 $

#  

(- 

%#  =:% ;'1 745>65 #

    !    "   !% E  #  1 

!  "   

/5I+B0@#%   %

#  F

!

G 3    3

!

  % (  ? '% ?

  ' !

 " %  B(  (

   

  1 A3-458  ?

%    

%  

 ! 9  /&HIJ0 /F

!

G0

(.   %#     

-> 48 -4--  $ % ;



!

   

!

  :%



. !&% 9  # /

'% 0 # @

% !

%  "

#

#   

-    ( %    %  "   !

!  "

( 

.

+ + 2 +3

.  ;



%

 F  G  # /

'% 0

 1 23-456/  -10-

  0% )((

 "%  1 256-5-5--4   "

< / " ?

0 

. 

 

%

:%  " ?

  #  (  24 5- -456  =   !   %  " ?

48 4- -45>

"!  ?"!"   58 4- -45>

56 4- -45> 

. 

:% ?

     ? "  " ! :%   "  

-4 4- -45> / 70           " 5A7 2 !    % :% 5A.! 

.( 

 #

& 

   <     -5 4- -45>   

       %    (     

 .

!&%" '

!

    5.-! 

.-       -5 4- -45>   

     %    

       !      

 -5

!&%'

!

    5.5! 

..  ;  " #

"

 

 :%

!

  ! :% @#% "  

./   "  

 ( +

1 A777 -45>"!" # (



B !   

-6 4- -45>"  

#  " 

 

?  !

   %  -11-

   

' 

 "3! %! "2& 

 



        *  +  ) ,  -   :8 8+ +  !    

   ( A  (       8  & '

 

  @! ! "#!      :88+  ( "73           

    !     (                )

 "7%!0   !   '

     

 ( .   5 

&8 "& ? + '

5 

  

     

)  "3"

"3  '&  .A$7 $3! >     ! C ?

    + & ! I    8  & ..,&        )

    8 ! B       



         8  )

 ! >'

(    ) '    &     

  (

     

 



    +   (



   (? 

  

) ('

 

      ! -   !;

.0  ; %%!

     

 

( %   "  

 ":%

 #   

#

  % # !!

!

    % -12-

   !

# #%

   !



   "

 

.  * -A 4A -4--  (



 B ! 

     %  

J    # ( %#$

     -A4443" #  %       (  

    

   ) 5  8 8 +   ! >    

   

       * +  )  '   8   + $ - 

  :A$8'

 &      

'  / !01 "2&+ !/ !&

 "3! %! "2!8     (     0 !"! "2   & (    

    ! 8  (   

    

   &   )

 "7%!0  (  "73   (     '   :88+! *   ' &     $   .   5 

&  ?       + '

 5 

&  ? &(

     "3" "3   '! +     ) 

       ) $  ) , '5 

      )  (           

   )   ) +   !5 ) 

 

 

 

    

 

 !7& 1$  

    $        )       

 ) +   ! . 

&     

       !7& 1$(      

+ )   (     &     (    )    -13-

, ' 

 + 

5 

& 8  0& +

&  @! 7! & (   9   -   (  )             ! !.  &8 8

+  J&+

 ( !/

>

&.

'  &

) ?  E  

 

 

 !5         

,+5&8 0&+

    9  -  

             @! 7!  ) 

 

)

    8 8   8  5    &+K/ !02@7  "3& 

   "!""! "3 )       ' 

+   A

   ! >   

     !7& 1$)   

 ) )E      

 

          

     )  

    &    ( )  ) ?       

 &     

 )            K  * ,+5&8 0&+

! *  (

 &   "$ 3$ !;

. ; !

!

     

   #

 !B  (@"    "!



# 5A. -!  B%  

 ! 

"

!!

@  #   !

% %# 

<

 

.

       -2 46 -4-7 ( %

#    

%:%  :% !

"  #

 !   

%  % 

 %!

 

  -14-

.

 54 4> -4-7$ % " % # 

 ( %    !

   !  

  !!

!

 "  "@#%   ! " & #  

. ?  -. 4> -4-7  

%  %     ! 

 

.( = %

 

        !

  "    !

%

"  "  !% 





"

  :%  ?    %!

!

 )

57 54 -4-7/&HKJ0   (

 =:% ;'1 745>65! #

"    !  9     1 23-456    :%  #  

   F

 !

G    3    4 56"%789 %!$#" %! :;8,$!<7 & $: 6:;8,"7%$6

$%!8$#! "= 8$,;&>"8 !"?8< ? $&%!>@"8!$%"5"&!-9/

.- ;  " #

  & # ("



#     1 A   

5. 54 -4-7   "

 

  %!

    

      (    =:%  ;' 1 745>65 

 

 #  

@  

 F

!

G 

.. ;

"

    & # "

 (



  9  # /

 -15-

'% 0

 1 53-458@  

#

< 

     # :%  

./ ;



%

"#  47 42 5>68 !% 



  !&   "< 45 47 -456@ %!!



 !%  

 

  25 -6 @ !

 ! #

 $

!

% 

.0  "

    ( %     &  # "  # !

@ %%!!

#   "  

$ ; ! % 

" $

#

 %  

% !

    5A.! @

!!



  1 23-456 %   ! % (

  !

" :%   5A. ! @ "      % %!

 # !  (       " %

# 5A7 2!  ;

!

   

  %!



  

#

% :% 5A.! "! %  (    !&%  5.-!  -16-

!      5.5! 

(

2-( 5A. -! @

$$  ;

     ! 9 

 !  =:% ;'1 745>65   %! %#



  1 53-458 

$$$  ?  

  #$

  =:%  ;' 1 745>65 

 

 #  

@     " %    1 256-5-5--4  !    " ?

"

 ?% 

 1%#  

$@  )  "  !

%!

 ?  " 

#$

"

  

 

  1 53-458  =:% ;' 1%# 

 ! 

@  "  

  !

 % =:% ;'1 745>65#  



 !

G  !  9  /& HIJ0

F

!

G %!

#    %  -17-

9   %    < !

    "  !

#  =:%  ;' 1 745>65  

 F

 !

G@    !  F

 !

G    3     4 56"%7 #  

-18-

  !"?8<3      %! $#" %! :;8, $!<7 & $: 6:;8,"7%$6 $%!8$#! "= 8$@" 

#  

)((

   *(%!&"?

 ' !

L$$ 

@$ 

  

F

!

G 

 1 A3-458@" 

!   

  53-458 

@$$  )   %   /&HIJ0 % # (  " !

# F

!

G "   =:%  ;' 1 745>65    

 1 53-458 

. .    ! 

!   



  " ?

 ? ?  

:% @#%  "  # 

    (    $

   ! %    "

 !%  

 45 47 -456"!

 ( % "   

.

   "

  < !%  

 " 

  %  %  56  

!

 /1

E

* &0  !

% -458"! %  K  , '   



     A 

     &   & )  &        ) -19-

   ( & A     '

   (           ; ;  " #

 < !%  



"

 !

 

  $  ! 

!!

% # 

  %

      

   !

 

 #  !



%  @#%  

  #  %

 !

E  

 # 

&  !

& 3         % 

  !#  

. 

   "  !

  !!% !

 !% #

   # !

!% "

%#  (   $

 "% !  

 " %   $% !  





" #  

)((

 ?

  "  "

 !    <   !

   

# #$  #



  % # "@ !

 

#   !

 "

 

. ( :%  "  

   "

@ % ?  

 -4 4- -45> / 70  :%    /0   

% # %:%  :% % ) ((

    

 1 23-456



 "" % %    -20-

. !

!

 /0 %

# "  

  #       #         <  @

 

  

    #% " 

< !

 2&"!# 

 

.( ?      #  !

  "  #  ( "   

/420   

  !

 !



   

! /0     !7@"5A"8,(

 ++ 

    K    ?

1  

L K     ) L  -21-