High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20275/2021allowed

Kamlesh Devi And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2021-05-25Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!!M# #N4#O<L#<NJ<#$-I%O#-P#>I4K&Q#&41#<&%F&4&#&O# # # # # $<&41NJ&%<## # # ## # # # # # $%/'/'+"+RG#)*#+"+!## ## # # # # # 1&OL#-P#1L$N(N-4#S#+G9"G9+"+!# # T2@U;8B#1;7E#256#):B;=8# # # # # # # # # V>;:E:E)5;=8# ## # W;=8C8# # (:2:;#)*#<2=3252#256#):B;=8# # # # # # # # # V%;8X)56;5:8# # # $-%&/#S# <-4YQZL#/%9#KI(ON$L#&%I4##/-4J&# # !"#$#%&'('

)"*'+*'+*')4.@2'/1345,&#2'

64"'&0#'7#&@&@4%#"$*'

)"*'?,7,%'_I.,"2'Y/<2'=,">,%,*'

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`&0#' )@%@%A'/5&aW2'0,3#'X##%'1@$.@$$#1*''

C*'

[#,"%#1' 54I%$#-' 64"' &0#' 7#&@&@4%#"$' 3#0#.#%&->' ,"AI#1' &0,&' ,77-@5,&@4%$'0,3#'X##%'$I..,"@->'1@$.@$$#1'3@1#'%4%Z$7#,H@%A'5">7&@5'4"1#"'@%' 3@4-,&@4%'46'&0#'9I1A.#%&'"#%1#"#1'X>'&0@$':4I"&'@%'`!"#$%&'&$()*+,$'-.#/0+1$ '*234+5$6&$()4),$*7$84-54+4$4+9$4+*)/,-a'1#5@1#1'4%'DR*DC*CDCF'54%&,@%#1',&' /%%#BI"#'!ZN*'

P*'

M4&@5#'46'.4&@4%*'

R*''

\%' $#"3@5#' 46' ,13,%5#' 547>' 46' &0#' 7#&@&@4%2' )"*' ?,7,%' _I.,"2' Y/<2'=,">,%,2'94@%$'&0#'7"45##1@%A$',%1',55#7&$'%4&@5#'4%'X#0,-6'46'+&,&#'46' =,">,%,*''

N*''

[#,"%#1'+&,&#'54I%$#-'4774$#$'&0#'7#&@&@4%',147&@%A'&0#'$,.#'"#,$4%$',$' A@3#%' @%' &0#' @.7IA%#1' 4"1#"*' =#' 54%&#%1$' &0,&' &0#' 4"1#"' 1,&#1' FF*DN*CDCF' 54%&,@%#1',&'/%%#BI"#$'!ZF',%1'!ZC2'3@1#';0@50'&0#'466#%1@%A'3#0@5-#$';#"#' 54%6@$5,&#12',"#',77#,-,X-#'I%1#"'8I-#'FDQ'46''+&,&#')@%@%A'8I-#2'CDFC2'6",.#1' I%1#"'&0#')@%@%A'/5&*''

O*''

L' 0,3#' 0#,"1' "@3,-' 54%&#%&@4%$' 46' -#,"%#1' 54I%$#-$' ,%1' ;@&04I&' 54..#%&@%A'4%'&0#'.#"@&$'46'&0#'5,$#2'L',.'46'&0#'3@#;'&0,&'&0#',77-@5,&@4%$'46' &0#'7#&@&@4%#"$';#"#';"4%A->'1@$.@$$#1'4%'&0#'A"4I%1'46'.,@%&,@%,X@-@&>*'?0#' -,;'@%'&0@$',$7#5&'@$'%4'.4"#'-,#$0+),1-4&$'+,.#'0,$',-"#,1>'X##%'#-I5@1,&#1' &0"#,1X,"#' @%' &0#' 9I1A.#%&2' 0:09' X>' .>' -#,"%#1' X"4&0#"' <*' +*' <@--2' ]*2' ;04' $7#,H@%A'64"'&0@$':4I"&'0,$'4X$#"3#1',$'I%1#"2'(' ''

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

$0+$)/0#$-,14-9$0#$9*+,$@0)/0+$ )@*$@,,J#$7-*2$)*945$ C000D$ T3*+$ )/,$ -,#3*+9,+)$ 4.)/*-0)0,#$ ,0)/,-$ A/**#0+1$ )*$ ?*91,$ 4$ Q?G"A*23?40+)$*-$A/**#0+1$)*$2*6,$4+$433?0A4)0*+$.+9,-$-.?

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

S*''

\%',':4I"&'^I#">2'-#,"%#1'+&,&#'54I%$#-'14#$'%4&'54%&"43#"&'&0,&',&'&0@$' $&,A#'4%->'54%6@$5,&@4%'7"45##1@%A$'0,3#'X##%'@%@&@,&#1'I%1#"'8I-#'FDF'46'&0#' +&,&#')@%@%A'8I-#$2'CDFC*'/%>'4&0#"'6I"&0#"',5&@4%'46'#@&0#"'5044$@%A'&4'-41A#' GL8' 4"' 54.7-,@%&' @$' $&@--' I%1#"' 54%&#.7-,&@4%' 1#7#%1@%A' 4%' 04;' #3#%&$' ;@--' I%64-1',6&#"'&0#'7"#-@.@%,">'#%^I@">K@%3#$&@A,&@4%*'' E*''

L%'&0#'7"#.@$#2'54%5#1#1->'&0#'5,$#'46'7#&@&@4%#"$';4I-1'6,--'I%1#"'$IX' 7,",'P'bR'46'7,",'RN'46'&0#'9I1A.#%&2',$'"#7"41I5#1',X43#*'/554"1@%A->2'L',.' 46' &0#' 47@%@4%' &0,&' -#,"%#1' ]I1@5@,-' ),A@$&",&#' L$&' :-,$$2' :0,"H0@' Y,1"@2' 54..@&&#1','.,&#"@,-'@""#AI-,"@&>'@%'$I..,"@->'1@$.@$$@%A'&0#',77-@5,&@4%$*'?0#' $,.#' 4IA0&' &4' 0,3#' #%&#"&,@%#1' ,%1' 4"1#"$' ;#"#' "#^I@"#1' &4' X#' 7,$$#1' 4%' .#"@&$2'@%',554"1,%5#';@&0'-,;*''

Q*''

8#$I-&,%&->2' &0#' @%$&,%&' 7#&@&@4%' @$' ,--4;#1*' J4&0' &0#' @.7IA%#1' 4"1#"$'1,&#1'FF*DN*CDCF'54%&,@%#1',&'/%%#BI"#$'!ZF',%1'!ZC',"#'0#"#X>'$#&Z ,$@1#';@&0'-@X#"&>'&4'&0#'7#&@&@4%#"'&4',77"4,50'&0#',77"47"@,&#':4I"&'&4'$##H' "#-#,$#'46'X4&0'&0#'3#0@5-#$'4%'$I7#"1,"@'1I"@%A'&0#'7#%1#%5>'46'7"45##1@%A$' X#64"#'&0#')@%@%A'\66@5#"2':0,"H0@'Y,1"@'T"#$74%1#%&'M4*PW*' FD*''

M##1-#$$' &4' $,>' 4%' ,77"4,50@%A' &0#' 54.7#&#%&' :4I"&2' &0#' ,77-@5,&@4%' $0,--' X#' 1@$74$#1' 46' 4%' .#"@&$2' @%' ,554"1,%5#' ;@&0' -,;2' ,$' #B7#1@&@4I$->',$'74$$@X-#*''

,&%I4#/-4J&0# /&F#+GH#+"+!# # # # # # # KI1JL# +0,-@%@'

# [B;:B;=#8X;2AE5D\=;28)5;6#S# F;8\4)# [B;:B;=#=;X)=:2]U;#S# # F;8\4)'