High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2329/1998allowed

(O&M) State Of Haryana Etc. v. Azad Singh

2024-04-23Mr. Justice Namit Kumar10 pages

! " # $$%% & ' ()# $ ) *" *# # +,-+! " ("

#-(%%+

+

#$ .#( ) %

$$ % ( ( ) ( # / )0 1$ *"#2

% (( % 2((% 3 ) ( ,((( + # 4+ 5#*" (

% ( (% *" # $ $% ((

5 5%% ) (#/ )0 6 1+$ *"#2

% ,(( 3 )+ # 4+ 5#*" $$ % (% *" # $$%% ) ( # / )0 1+# *(0(

( # $$ % *() $#( *

#( %2

7(

# # $% ((

(%# (

% ( #

# 0( ( 18 ( *" ( (%%) %+ %% ( 5(#

/ (( # 0(%( *% * (9($% # #(

(% *( (( % )5(# %%* 45 ).#

#$% ((

(# #5 $$ (*" ( 5(#

0 1 #/ (#( ( # 0 "( #

( # #( 5 4

( )

, # (%%) %%" 0( #( ( 5 18 5(#

()() " # )

# ) % (# * $$ ( ) (#$

(9(

# %%) # # )#5 $ #$% ((

*

# 0( ( 5 $ ) ( #(0 + #

+ 0( ( ( (%%) % *( " 9 ( # # $% ((

5 $$ (#

)#:0$% "0:;

# )+#

+## "()#

) % ( (

#(( ($%

5 $$ (9(

# %%) # # $% ((

5 $$ ( *" + #

+ # ()# 0( #(( + ) ( # % .# $% ((

< # 0( #( ( (%%) %%"* ( (! +# ( =$ +

# ( *" (%() 5( 05#(#" # #$% ((

5 ) )*" ( % 11

# 0 # # / ( #( ( 1 + + #

# ;( 5 )( $ 9( # $$ (0%5 ( $% ((

*

# $% ((

5 ) ) (%" 5 ) .#$% ((

5 ) () ) 0 */ # $$ %

,$ " 2 00(( + # 4 ! 5 %( # ;$("

9 ( # ( 5

" ( " # )# # $% ((

+ #

+#0( ( (%) %9((# #$% ((

# ()#

) % ( (

#( ( 9 ( % # # $ # * $$ ( ( $%

# $% ((

# $0 0$% " 5 0 #

,$ " 00(( + # 4+ (%% $#$ .#$% ((

(#($%( # (#$

# 5( 0 #

(0#$

#$% ( 8 # $% ()

# $ (+

%% 5() ( 5

0 >## #

0( ( 18 + $ *" # ( (%%) %+ %% (?

>### (( 0 ( ( *%? , >###2((%2

# / (( " (#( (? , >### (( $ $%" % +(

? , 8 %( 6 # () %

%

# $ ( $$ ( () # (

+ ( % 2

( / )0 1 # (

#$% ((

1 ))( ) ( # / )0 1 $$%% $ $$ %+5#( ## *(0( *" # % 5 $$%% 2

( / )0 6 1

@

%

# $$%%

# / )0

* ##2

*% 5

0( (0(" ( 0

# * ##2

*% 5 (% $$ ( # $ $% ((

5 5 4() (%"5 ) * (+ #

+ 5 < ( * $ #(0*

0( (

#(( !

#

# / )0

* ##2

*% 5*()*

0(

/

%( *% * (9 $$

#(

( +%

%%( $ #/ )0

#!

A*% $02

(

! " # $ % $$$ & &'()"

# * +,* - .#/ "

## 0 1 $$$ & 2 / )0

#(2

()",*+* 3 4 ( ( 55## " "

#6 $$$ * 3 # # # + %

%

# $ $$ # / )0

* # # 2

*% 5 *"

() # (

# $ $% ((

5 0( (%%) %%" 5(#

()() " !

#

# $ 5 $$ (#

)#0$% "0;

# )+#

+# # "()#

( (( +#

+#(0$ ) 5 ()#%" (*"#2

*% 5!

#

# #(2

( 5#(% "()# $ (

#/ )0B

#2

*% 5 % "#0( (

#$

8

9 # # %

%

# $ ( $ #

9

0$%(

# 6+$ *" #( 2

+

( (

, %*( ()#+ * ,((( %

2+ # 0+ (%(2

( 4

=($ %"+#$ 5 $$ ( ( (%"5 ) * ( *" # $$%% ( % 11

#0 # #(( 50( *"# *,((( % )( +# 0+(% 18 +5#( ## *#% (%%) %*"#2

*% 5 !

A*% $02

(#

7#

$ # #%

! " " # $

#!

$ % % &

'

( )*+,

%

- %

.

/ '

0 )*+

,

% 1

%

6

.

/

%

%

2 0

,

$

$3"

"

-4 5 2 6

&

%

%

,

% ,

,

" "#"

"

8

!

$

#

1

,

,

$

9 %

1

,

%

%

,

1

#

!

,

%

7 :

, ; 1

6

9

,

%

<

%

,

+

< %

5

3"

6

"

= #+#!

A*% $02

(- .#/ 7#

$ # #% : $

" $ 3 "

;

>?( 0? ?1

; @

1 9 #

@

, 6 +@ ;

" 1 $ 3 "

"

AB$

$

$ AB

*

$ 1 <'$! 90? :

0? : , 0? ? , 1 9 # ; $

; , $

/

,5

$ 1 <'$!

= 8 $ + 5# 5 $$ ( (%"5 ) * (

#0 #+5 < ( *( " #(( 5 < (

#*

) % (

0*# / ( # ($ :) )0

#$ (%"5 )5 (

5(# " ) % $

;(

( B

0$% "

* ( * 5 $ #(0 ()#

( ( ( 9

+ $ 5 0( 0 ( + # # 5 ) ;( *" # ,$ " 2 00((

/ (()

) % (+ #

+ #( ( 5 ($ 5(# < ( D 5 %

;( (%"5 )* ( * ( * 0( ( (0( % 0( .# (()

#2

*% 5 # (

#$ 50( *"# *,((( %

)( + 5# 5

0$ # 5 # $$ (() # ("(5 )( 0

# $ 5 $$ (

)

*"#,$ "2 00(( #( ( 5;5(##

#,$ "2 00(( (

#$ 5($5(#*"# *,((( % )(

($

0 # ,$ " 00((

;(

(%"5 )$( + #(( 5 % ) < ( 9 ( % % 5 # 0$% " $$ (

B (%"5 ) * ( # %) % ()# ; #( ( $( 6 9 (5

# * + $$ % ( %% 5 90$ ) / )0

#2

*% 5 (9(0

% #

" # %% * 0 0 # $ #

( (( (%%1+(#%()#

((0 1

() $$%( + ( "+ ($

()%"

>##$ 4()B EBD >##$ *% EBD